Revisiting Hardy's Paradox: Counterfactual Statements, Real Measurements, Entanglement and Weak Values

Abstract

Classical-realistic analysis of entangled systems have lead to retrodiction paradoxes, which ordinarily have been dismissed on the grounds of counter-factuality. Instead, we claim that such paradoxes point to a deeper logical structure inherent to quantum mechanics, which is naturally described in the language of weak values, and which is accessible experimentally via weak measurements. Using as an illustration, a gedanken-experiment due to Hardy\cite{hardy}, we show that there is in fact an exact numerical coincidence between a) a pair of classically contradictory assertions about the locations of an electron and a positron, and b) the results of weak measurements of their location. The internal consistency of these results is due to the novel way by which quantum mechanics "resolves" the paradox: first, by allowing for two distinguishable manifestations of how the electron and positron can be at the same location: either as single particles or as a pair; and secondly, by allowing these properties to take either sign. In particular, we discuss the experimental meaning of a {\em negative} number of electron-positron pairs.

7 pages, 1 figure

Cited by in corpus (153)

• Ultrasensitive Beam Deflection Measurement via Interferometric Weak Value Amplification
• Colloquium: Understanding Quantum Weak Values: Basics and Applications
• Measuring small longitudinal phase shifts: weak measurements or standard interferometry?
• Experimental joint weak measurement on a photon pair as a probe of Hardy's Paradox
• Quantum weak values
• Complex weak values in quantum measurement
• Nonperturbative theory of weak pre- and post-selected measurements
• Anomalous Weak Values Are Proofs of Contextuality
• Direct observation of Hardy's paradox by joint weak measurement with an entangled photon pair
• Amplification of Angular Rotations Using Weak Measurements
• Experimental Realization of the Quantum Box Problem
• Quantum Cheshire Cats
• Observation of a quantum Cheshire Cat in a matter wave interferometer experiment
• The significance of the imaginary part of the weak value
• A double-slit `which-way' experiment on the complementarity--uncertainty debate
• Quantum Averages of Weak Values
• Contextual Values of Observables in Quantum Measurements
• Quantum measurements with preselection and postselection
• Weak Measurements Beyond the Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman Formalism
• New wine in old bottles: Quantum measurement - direct, indirect, weak - with some applications
• Extracting joint weak values with local, single-particle measurements
• State tomography via weak measurements
• Measuring incompatible observables of a single photon
• Quantum Non-demolition Measurements on Qubits
• Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements II: Past and future measurement effects within a double Mach-Zehnder-interferometer setting
• Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements I: A single particle accurately measured yet left superposed
• Weak-to-strong transition of quantum measurement in a trapped-ion system
• Practical measurement of joint weak values and their connection to the annihilation operator
• Modular values and weak values of quantum observables
• All-order evaluation of weak measurements: --- The cases of an operator $\mathbf{A}$ which satisfies the property ${\mathbf{A}}^2=1$ ---
• Strange Weak Values
• Ultra-sensitive phase estimation with white light
• Quantum interference experiments, modular variables and weak measurements
• Complete characterization of post-selected quantum statistics using weak measurement tomography
• On Amplification by Weak Measurement
• Pre- and post-selection, weak values, and contextuality
• On the role of complex phases in the quantum statistics of weak measurements
• Weak measurements with a qubit meter
• Pre- and post-selected quantum states: density matrices, tomography, and Kraus operators
• What is the value of an observable between pre- and postselection?
• Negative Conditional Entropy of Post-Selected States
• Tests of Fundamental Quantum Mechanics and Dark Interactions with Low Energy Neutrons -- Extended Version
• Optimal waveform estimation for classical and quantum systems via time-symmetric smoothing. II. Applications to atomic magnetometry and Hardy's paradox
• Post-selected von Neumann measurement with Hermite-Gaussian and Laguerre-Gaussian pointer states
• Toward Ultra-high Sensitivity in Weak Value Amplification
• Experimental realization of post-selected weak measurements on an NMR quantum processor
• Simulating broken $\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}$-symmetric Hamiltonian systems by weak measurement
• Observation of the quantum paradox of separation of a single photon from one of its properties
• A Completely Top-Down Hierarchical Structure in Quantum Mechanics
• Nonlocal Measurements via Quantum Erasure
• Experimental demonstration of separating the waveparticle duality of a single photon with the quantum Cheshire cat
• General complex Spin Weak Values obtained in Matter-Wave Interferometer Experiments
• Weak measurements measure probability amplitudes (and very little else)
• Weak and semiweak values in non-ideal spin measurements: an exact treatment beyond the asymptotic regime
• Extracting joint weak values from two-dimensional spatial displacements
• Measuring Which-Path Information with Coupled Electronic Mach-Zehnder Interferometers
• Experimental Realization of Sequential Weak Measurements of Arbitrary Non-commuting Pauli Observables
• Advantages of nonclassical pointer states in postselected weak measurements
• Fock-state view of weak-value measurements and implementation with photons and atomic ensembles
• How quantum paradoxes originate from the non-classical statistics of physical properties related to each other by half-periodic transformations
• Feasible optical weak measurements of complementary observables via a single Hamiltonian
• Counterfactual Statements and Weak Measurements: an Experimental Proposal
• Reconstructing weak values without weak measurements
• Realism and causality I: Pilot wave and retrocausal models as possible facilitators
• Narratives of Quantum Theory in the Age of Quantum Technologies
• What is a quantum-mechanical 'weak value' the value of?
• Quantum Oblivion: A Master Key for Many Quantum Riddles
• Observing the "quantum Cheshire cat" effect with noninvasive weak measurement
• Experimental simultaneous read out of the real and imaginary parts of the weak value
• Increased success probability in Hardy's nonlocality: Theory and demonstration
• Demystifying weak measurements
• Linear optics implementation of weak values in Hardy's paradox
• Investigating the Effects of the Interaction Intensity in a Weak Measurement
• Hardy's paradox as a demonstration of quantum irrealism
• Single-pair measurement of the Bell parameter
• Weak Measurement of the Arrival Times of Single Photons and Pairs of Entangled Photons
• Sufficient conditions for uniqueness of the weak value
• Measurements of nonlocal variables and demonstration of the failure of the product rule for a pre- and postselected pair of photons
• Interaction-Free Effects Between Distant Atoms
• Full characterization of modular values for two-dimensional systems
• Graph-theoretic strengths of contextuality
• Path probabilities for consecutive measurements, and certain "quantum paradoxes"
• Past of a particle in an entangled state
• Voices of Silence, Novelties of Noise: Oblivion and Hesitation as Origins of Quantum Mysteries
• Realism and Causality II: Retrocausality in Energetic Causal Sets
• The Salecker-Wigner-Peres clock, Feynman paths, and a tunnelling time that should not exist
• Progress and Perspectives on Weak-value Amplification
• Weak value amplification of photon number operators in the optomechanical interaction
• Weak values in a classical theory with an epistemic restriction
• Estimation of Spin-Spin Interaction by Weak Measurement Scheme
• Experimental probe of weak value amplification and geometric phase through the complex zeroes of the response function
• Do weak values capture the complete truth about the past of a quantum particle?
• Peculiar Features of Entangled States with Post-Selection
• Anomalous Weak Values Without Post-Selection
• What weak measurements and weak values really mean - Reply to Kastner
• Anomalous energy exchanges and Wigner function negativities in a single qubit gate
• Estimating Pre- and Post-Selected Ensembles
• Non-representative quantum mechanical weak values
• Quantum uncertainty as classical uncertainty of real-deterministic variables constructed from complex weak values and a global random variable
• Quantum weak values and logic, an uneasy couple
• How a single particle modifies the physical reality of two distant others simultaneously: a quantum nonlocality and weak value study
• Feynman-path analysis of Hardy's paradox: measurements and the uncertainty principle
• Disembodiment of arbitrary number of properties in quantum Cheshire cat experiment
• A Scheme for Performing Strong and Weak Sequential Measurements of Non-commuting Observables
• Robust Weak Measurements on Finite Samples
• Dimension-independent weak value estimation via controlled SWAP operations
• Comment on "A linear optics implementation of weak values in Hardy's paradox"
• Joint weak value for all order coupling using continuous variable and qubit probe
• Cat state, sub-Planck structure and weak measurement
• On the Validity of Weak Measurement Applied for Precision Measurement
• What do quantum "weak" measurements actually measure?
• Decoherence effects on weak value measurements in double quantum dots
• Weak Values and Modular Variables From a Quantum Phase Space Perspective
• Observation of Nonlocality Sharing among Three Observers with One Entangled Pair via Optimal Weak Measurement
• Experimenting quantum phenomena on NISQ computers using high level quantum programming
• Exploring postselection-induced quantum phenomena with time-bidirectional state formalism
• The negative probabilities and information gain in weak measurements
• On relativistic elements of reality
• Reply to "Comment on 'A linear optics implementation of weak values in Hardy's paradox'"
• Quantum tomography via Non-orthogonal basis and weak values
• A strange weak value in spontaneous pair productions via a supercritical step potential
• Weak Values and Relational Generalisations
• Sensing electrons during an adiabatic coherent transport passage
• Revisiting weak values through non-normality
• Speakable and unspeakable in quantum measurements
• Entanglement measures for two-particle quantum histories
• On the Power of Weak Measurements in Separating Quantum States
• A weak-value model for virtual particles supplying the electric current in graphene: the minimal conductivity and the Schwinger mechanism
• Theoretical investigation of the relations between quantum decoherence and weak-to-strong measurement transition
• Weak value as an indicator of back-action
• Strong reactions in quantum super PDEs. III: Exotic quantum supergravity
• Failed attempt to escape from the quantum pigeon conundrum
• Uncertainty Relations in Pre- and Post-Selected Systems
• No contextual advantage in non-paradoxical scenarios of two state vector formalism
• Optimal waveform estimation for classical and quantum systems via time-symmetric smoothing
• On Interchangeability of Probe-Object Roles in Quantum-Quantum Interaction-Free Measurement
• Can parallel lives provide a solution to Hardy's paradox?
• Cumulants and the moment algebra: tools for analysing weak measurements
• Implementation of weak measurement amplification with the weak coherent light and optomechanical system
• Re-interpretations of an experiment on the back-action in a weak measurement
• Hardy's paradox according to non-classical semantics
• Hardy's Paradox and Measurement-disturbance Relations
• Extraction of Product and Higher Moment Weak Values: Applications in Quantum State Reconstruction and Entanglement Detection
• The real and imaginary parts of a weak value appearing as back-actions via a post-selection
• Amplification of mechanical quadratures using weak values
• A brief overview and some comments on the weak measurement protocol
• Measure the temperature of the spin via weak measurement
• PT and Anti-PT Symmetry Arising in Time Dependent Weak Value Measurements
• The solution to the Hardy's paradox
• Why physical understanding should precede the mathematical formalism - conditional quantum probabilities as a case-study
• Counterfactual quantum measurements
• Nonlocal Generalized Quantum Measurements of Spin Products Without Maximal Entanglement
• Interplay between strong and weak measurement: Comparison of three experimental approaches to weak value estimation