Quantum weak values and logic, an uneasy couple
arXiv:1605.03023 · doi:10.1007/s10701-017-0068-5
Abstract
Quantum mechanical weak values of projection operators have been used to answer which-way questions, e.g. to trace which arms in a multiple Mach-Zehnder setup a particle may have traversed from a given initial to a prescribed final state. I show that this procedure might lead to logical inconsistencies in the sense that different methods used to answer composite questions, like Has the particle traversed the way X or the way Y? , may result in different answers depending on which methods are used to find the answer. I illustrate the problem by considering some examples: the quantum pigeonhole framework of Aharonov et al, the three-box problem, and Hardys paradox. To prepare the ground for my main conclusion on the incompatibility in certain cases of weak values and logic, I study the corresponding situation for strong/projective measurements. In this case, no logical inconsistencies occur provided one is always careful in specifying exactly to which ensemble or sample space one refers. My results cast doubts on the utility of quantum weak values in treating cases like the examples mentioned.
References in corpus (11)
- Colloquium: Understanding Quantum Weak Values: Basics and Applications
- Nonperturbative theory of weak pre- and post-selected measurements
- Revisiting Hardy's Paradox: Counterfactual Statements, Real Measurements, Entanglement and Weak Values
- The past of a quantum particle
- New wine in old bottles: Quantum measurement - direct, indirect, weak - with some applications
- Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements I: A single particle accurately measured yet left superposed
- Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements II: Past and future measurement effects within a double Mach-Zehnder-interferometer setting
- How quantum paradoxes originate from the non-classical statistics of physical properties related to each other by half-periodic transformations
- What is a quantum-mechanical 'weak value' the value of?
- Non-representative quantum mechanical weak values
- What the complex joint probabilities observed in weak measurements can tell us about quantum physics
Cited by in corpus (6)
- A Completely Top-Down Hierarchical Structure in Quantum Mechanics
- Understanding quantum mechanics: a review and synthesis in precise language
- Probing finite coarse-grained virtual Feynman histories with sequential weak values
- Past of a particle in an entangled state
- Apparent quantum paradoxes as simple interference: Quantum violation of the pigeonhole principle and exchange of properties between quantum particles
- Hardy's paradox according to non-classical semantics