What weak measurements and weak values really mean - Reply to Kastner
arXiv:1704.00958 · doi:10.1007/s10701-017-0107-2
Abstract
Despite their important applications in metrology and in spite of numerous experimental demonstrations, weak measurements are still confusing for part of the community. This sometimes leads to unjustified criticism. Recent papers have experimentally clarified the meaning and practical significance of weak measurements, yet in [R.E. Kastner, Found. Phys. 47, 697-707 (2017)], Kastner seems to take us many years backwards in the debate, casting doubt on the very term "weak value" and the meaning of weak measurements. Kastner appears to ignore both the basics and frontiers of weak measurements and misinterprets the weak measurement process and its outcomes. In addition, she accuses the authors of [Y. Aharonov et al., Ann. Phys. 355, 258-268 (2015)] in statements completely opposite to the ones they have actually made. There are many points of disagreement between Kastner and us, but in this short reply I will leave aside the ontology (which is indeed interpretational and far more complex than that described by Kastner) and focus mainly on the injustice in her criticism. I shall add some general comments regarding the broader theory of weak measurements and the Two-State-Vector Formalism (TSVF), as well as supporting experimental results. Finally, I will point out some recent promising results, which can be proven by (strong) projective measurements, without the need of employing weak measurements.
arXiv commentReply to arXiv:1702.04021 which criticizes our [Ann. Phys. 355, 258-268 (2015)]. Slightly revised version, Found. Phys. (2017)
References in corpus (14)
- Colloquium: Understanding Quantum Weak Values: Basics and Applications
- Revisiting Hardy's Paradox: Counterfactual Statements, Real Measurements, Entanglement and Weak Values
- Amplifying Single-Photon Nonlinearity Using Weak Measurement
- Experimentally quantifying the advantages of weak-value-based metrology
- Measuring incompatible observables of a single photon
- Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements I: A single particle accurately measured yet left superposed
- Broadening the scope of weak quantum measurements II: Past and future measurement effects within a double Mach-Zehnder-interferometer setting
- Charge sensing amplification via weak values measurement
- Experiment Investigating the Connection between Weak Values and Contextuality
- Can a Future Choice Affect a Past Measurement's Outcome?
- The Case of the Disappearing (and Re-Appearing) Particle
- Measurement and Collapse within the Two-State-Vector Formalism
- Demystifying weak measurements
- Quantum to Classical Transitions via Weak Measurements and Post-Selection
Cited by in corpus (8)
- Determination of weak values of quantum operators using only strong measurements
- Weak values and quantum properties
- The Weak Reality that Makes Quantum Phenomena more Natural: Novel Insights and Experiments
- Interaction-Free Effects Between Distant Atoms
- Anomalous weak values are caused by disturbance
- Analysis of single-particle nonlocality through the prism of weak measurements
- Time Derivatives of Weak Values
- How weak values illuminate the role of "hidden"-variables as predictive tools