Null energy condition and superluminal propagation

Abstract

We study whether a violation of the null energy condition necessarily implies the presence of instabilities. We prove that this is the case in a large class of situations, including isotropic solids and fluids relevant for cosmology. On the other hand we present several counter-examples of consistent effective field theories possessing a stable background where the null energy condition is violated. Two necessary features of these counter-examples are the lack of isotropy of the background and the presence of superluminal modes. We argue that many of the properties of massive gravity can be understood by associating it to a solid at the edge of violating the null energy condition. We briefly analyze the difficulties of mimicking $\dot{H}>0$ in scalar tensor theories of gravity.

46 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (18)

• Type Ia Supernova Discoveries at z>1 From the Hubble Space Telescope: Evidence for Past Deceleration and Constraints on Dark Energy Evolution
• The holographic principle
• Chameleon Cosmology
• Can the dark energy equation-of-state parameter w be less than -1?
• Ghost Condensation and a Consistent Infrared Modification of Gravity
• Effective Field Theory for Massive Gravitons and Gravity in Theory Space
• Braneworld models of dark energy
• The phantom menaced: constraints on low-energy effective ghosts
• Classical and Quantum Consistency of the DGP Model
• Phases of massive gravity
• Massive graviton as a testable cold dark matter candidate
• Perfect Fluid Theory and its Extensions
• How a brane cosmological constant can trick us into thinking that w < -1
• Gradient instability for w < -1
• Effective Lagrangian and Topological Interactions in Supersolids
• Instabilities and the null energy condition
• Cosmological attractors in massive gravity
• Holes in the ghost condensate

Cited by in corpus (262)

• The galileon as a local modification of gravity
• Beyond the Cosmological Standard Model
• Massive Gravity
• The Effective Field Theory of Inflation
• Causality, Analyticity and an IR Obstruction to UV Completion
• Cosmology and Fundamental Physics with the Euclid Satellite
• Imperfect Dark Energy from Kinetic Gravity Braiding
• Cosmological Non-Linearities as an Effective Fluid
• Holographic c-theorems in arbitrary dimensions
• Starting the Universe: Stable Violation of the Null Energy Condition and Non-standard Cosmologies
• Ultra-Light Dark Matter
• Seeing a c-theorem with holography
• Bouncing Cosmologies: Progress and Problems
• Crossing the Phantom Divide: Theoretical Implications and Observational Status
• A Critical Review of Classical Bouncing Cosmologies
• New Ekpyrotic Cosmology
• Galilean Genesis: an alternative to inflation
• On the Extra Mode and Inconsistency of Horava Gravity
• Towards hydrodynamics without an entropy current
• G-Bounce
• Bouncing Universe with Quintom Matter
• Solid Inflation
• Effective field theory for hydrodynamics: thermodynamics, and the derivative expansion
• Averaged Null Energy Condition from Causality
• Features and New Physical Scales in Primordial Observables: Theory and Observation
• Energy's and amplitudes' positivity
• A Primer on Energy Conditions
• The Imperfect Fluid behind Kinetic Gravity Braiding
• Bouncing Galileon Cosmologies
• A quantum hydrodynamical description for scrambling and many-body chaos
• Comments on Holographic Entanglement Entropy and RG Flows
• A Measure of de Sitter Entropy and Eternal Inflation
• Relativistic Fluids, Superfluids, Solids and Supersolids from a Coset Construction
• Viscosity and dissipative hydrodynamics from effective field theory
• Adiabatic hydrodynamics: The eightfold way to dissipation
• Inflation and primordial non-Gaussianities of "generalized Galileons"
• The ideal relativistic fluid limit for a medium with polarization
• The quantum mechanics of perfect fluids
• Effective field theory for dissipative fluids (II): classical limit, dynamical KMS symmetry and entropy current
• Holographic Complexity in Vaidya Spacetimes I
• Constructing higher-order hydrodynamics: The third order
• Bouncing and Accelerating Solutions in Nonlocal Stringy Models
• Observational constraints on phantom-like braneworld cosmologies
• A non-local theory of massive gravity
• The Viability of Phantom Dark Energy: A Brief Review
• Subluminal Galilean Genesis
• Weakly Broken Galileon Symmetry
• Matter Bounce Scenario and the Dynamical aspects in f(Q,T) Gravity
• Superluminality and UV Completion
• Dissipative hydrodynamics in superspace
• Second-order transport, quasinormal modes and zero-viscosity limit in the Gauss-Bonnet holographic fluid
• Deconstructing holographic liquids
• Chronology Protection in Galileon Models and Massive Gravity
• A Unified Approach to Cosmic Acceleration
• Bouncing cosmologies with dark matter and dark energy
• Lorentz Breaking Massive Gravity in Curved Space
• Relativistic fluid dynamics: physics for many different scales
• The Speed of Gravity
• Supersymmetric Galileons
• Supersymmetric P(X,phi) and the Ghost Condensate
• Dark Energy, Inflation and Extra Dimensions
• Effective actions for anomalous hydrodynamics
• Dissipation in the effective field theory for hydrodynamics: First order effects
• Hidden Negative Energies in Strongly Accelerated Universes
• The null energy condition and instability
• A New Perspective on DGP Gravity
• Hall viscosity, topological states and effective theories
• DBI Genesis: An Improved Violation of the Null Energy Condition
• Traversable wormholes in $f(R)$ gravity with constant and variable redshift functions
• Cosmological perturbations in mimetic matter model
• Primordial fluctuations and non-Gaussianities from multifield DBI Galileon inflation
• On the Initial Conditions in New Ekpyrotic Cosmology
• Spectral Sum Rules and Magneto-Roton as Emergent Graviton in Fractional Quantum Hall Effect
• Non-dissipative hydrodynamics: Effective actions versus entropy current
• When Matter Matters
• Global Anomalies, Discrete Symmetries, and Hydrodynamic Effective Actions
• Challenges for String Cosmology
• General Relativity solutions in modified gravity
• Slow-roll Inflation with the Gauss-Bonnet and Chern-Simons Corrections
• Sound waves and vortices in a polarized relativistic fluid
• The squeezed limit of the solid inflation three-point function
• Defrosting in an Emergent Galileon Cosmology
• Action approach to cosmological perturbations: the 2nd order metric in matter dominance
• Phenomenology of dark energy: general features of large-scale perturbations
• Spherically symmetric static solutions in a non-local infrared modification of General Relativity
• On the Null Energy Condition and Cosmology
• Aspects of Galileon Non-Renormalization
• Cuscuton Bounce
• Soft-Pion Theorems for Large Scale Structure
• Bigravity and Lorentz-violating Massive Gravity
• Cheng-Weyl Vector Field and its Cosmological Application
• From Satisfying to Violating the Null Energy Condition
• Inflation from Minkowski Space
• Absence of a local rest frame in far from equilibrium quantum matter
• Testing Lorentz invariance of dark matter
• Hairy planar black holes in higher dimensions
• Phantom without UV pathology
• Cosmological constraints on deviations from Lorentz invariance in gravity and dark matter
• Black holes in $\omega$-defomed gauged $N=8$ supergravity
• Off-shell hydrodynamics from holography
• Unitary null energy condition violation in $P(X)$ cosmologies
• UV stable, Lorentz-violating dark energy with transient phantom era
• The Effective Theory of Shift-Symmetric Cosmologies
• The Hunt for Primordial Interactions in the Large Scale Structures of the Universe
• Derrick's theorem beyond a potential
• Effective actions for relativistic fluids from holography
• Cosmology and perturbations in massive gravity
• Wess-Zumino Terms for Relativistic Fluids, Superfluids, Solids, and Supersolids
• Using dark energy to suppress power at small scales
• $c$-Theorem for Anisotropic RG Flows from Holographic Entanglement Entropy
• Black Hole Thermodynamics and Massive Gravity
• Screened Fifth Forces Mediated by Dark Matter-Baryon Interactions: Theory and Astrophysical Probes
• Cosmological perturbations in an effective and genuinely phantom dark energy Universe
• UV completion without symmetry restoration
• Effective perfect fluids in cosmology
• Bumpy black holes from spontaneous Lorentz violation
• Fluctuating relativistic dissipative hydrodynamics as a gauge theory
• Quantum Field Theory of Fluids
• Stable wormholes in scalar-tensor theories
• Massive and modified gravity as self-gravitating media
• A Universe Without Dark Energy: Cosmic Acceleration from Dark Matter-Baryon Interactions
• Cosmology of the Spinor Emergent Universe and Scale-invariant Perturbations
• Black Hole in the Expanding Universe with Arbitrary Power-Law Expansion
• Sound-induced vortex interactions in a zero-temperature two-dimensional superfluid
• Thermodynamics of perfect fluids from scalar field theory
• Conformal solids and holography
• Aether Unleashed
• Cosmological Perturbations Across an S-brane
• Disorder in the Early Universe
• The gravitational mass carried by sound waves
• A Lagrangian formulation of relativistic Israel-Stewart hydrodynamics
• Dynamics of the generalized unimodular gravity theory
• No static sphericaly symmetric wormholes in Horndeski theory
• Gaugid inflation
• Cross-correlations as a Diagnostic Tool for Primordial Gravitational Waves
• Spontaneous Breaking of Lorentz Symmetry with an antisymmetric tensor
• Scalar field as a perfect fluid: thermodynamics of minimally coupled scalars and Einstein frame scalar-tensor gravity
• Effective Field Theory of Broken Spatial Diffeomorphisms
• Stability of the aether
• Elasticity bounds from Effective Field Theory
• Variations on an aethereal theme
• Anisotropic massive Brans-Dicke gravity extension of the standard $\Lambda$CDM model
• Generating enhanced parity-violating gravitational waves during inflation with violation of the null energy condition
• Fluid Inflation
• The structure of correlation functions in single field inflation
• Fluids, Superfluids and Supersolids: Dynamics and Cosmology of Self Gravitating Media
• On dark energy models of single scalar field
• Viscosity of an ideal relativistic quantum fluid: A perturbative study
• The effective theory of fluids at NLO and implications for dark energy
• Oxidised cosmic acceleration
• Reconstructing the History of Energy Condition Violation from Observational Data
• Solid Soft Theorems
• Higher derivative scalar-tensor theory through a non-dynamical scalar field
• A Gauge Theory for Shallow Water
• Black hole thermodynamics, conformal couplings, and R^2 terms
• Scale invariant solids
• Baryon chemical potential and in-medium properties of BPS skyrmions
• Effective field theory for fluids: Hall viscosity from a Wess-Zumino-Witten term
• Spectrum of Cuscuton Bounce
• Isocurvature Perturbations of Dark Energy and Dark Matter from the Swampland Conjecture
• Dynamics of the electric current in an ideal electron gas: a sound mode inside the quasi-particles
• The effective field theory of multi-component fluids
• Can Galileons support Lorentzian wormholes?
• Completing Lorentz violating massive gravity at high energies
• Perturbative unitarity and NEC violation in genesis cosmology
• Note on scalars, perfect fluids, constrained field theories, and all that
• Comments on Hall transport from effective actions
• Variational principle for theories with dissipation from analytic continuation
• Boosting GWs in Supersolid Inflation
• Massive mimetic cosmology
• Platonic solids back in the sky: Icosahedral inflation
• Effective Field Theory for Spontaneously Broken Symmetry
• Reduced Massive Gravity with Two Stückelberg Fields
• Non-minimally coupled gravity constraints from DESI DR2 data
• Linear response hydrodynamics of a relativistic dissipative fluid with spin
• A no-go for no-go theorems prohibiting cosmic acceleration in extra dimensional models
• Time warps
• Wormhole modeling in $R^2$ gravity with linear trace term
• A minimal self tuning model to solve the cosmological constant problem
• Effective Field Theory of Gravitating Continuum: Solids, Fluids, and Aether Unified
• Soft theorems for boosts and other time symmetries
• Intrinsic Entropy Perturbations from the Dark Sector
• Electric hyperscaling violating solutions in Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton gravity with R^2 corrections
• Holographic phonons by gauge-axion coupling
• Indications of a non-trivial vacuum in the effective theory of perfect fluids
• Bouncing behavior in $f(R,L_m)$ gravity: Phantom crossing and energy conditions
• On Coupling NEC-Violating Matter to Gravity
• Zoology of Graviton non-Gaussianities
• Some disquisitions on cosmological 2-form dualities
• Massive spin-2 particle from a rank-2 tensor
• Phantom dark energy with tachyonic instability: metric perturbations
• Self-gravitating $\Lambda$-media
• Entanglement inside the cosmological apparent horizon
• Rotating cosmologies: classical and quantum
• Dark matter and baryogenesis in the Fermi-bounce curvaton mechanism
• Eternal Universes
• Generalized unimodular gravity as a form of k-essence
• Are we seeing the beginnings of Inflation?
• On the 6th Mode in Massive Gravity
• Banks-Zaks Cosmology, Inflation, and the Big Bang Singularity
• Ponderable aether
• Multi-field Cuscuton Cosmology
• Dark energy with a shift-symmetric scalar field: obstacles, loophole hunting and dead ends
• Null energy condition violation and beyond Horndeski physics in light of DESI DR2 data
• Hairy Lovelock black holes and Stueckelberg mechanism for Weyl symmetry
• Cuscuton Bounce Beyond the Linear Regime: Bispectrum and Strong Coupling Constraints
• Massive graviton dark matter searches with long-baseline atom interferometers
• Causality and Stability from Acoustic Geometry
• On Causality Conditions in de Sitter Spacetime
• The Quantum Perfect Fluid in 2D
• Evolution of black holes through a nonsingular cosmological bounce
• Stability of nonsingular cosmologies in Galileon models with torsion. A no-go theorem for eternal subluminality
• Solidity without inhomogeneity: Perfectly homogeneous, weakly coupled, UV-complete solids
• Adiabatic Media Inflation
• Phantom Dirac-Born-Infeld Dark Energy
• Unitarity constraints on the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density in higher derivative gravity
• A multipole-expanded effective field theory for vortex ring-sound interactions
• Disformal invariance of continuous media with linear equation of state
• Subadditive Average Distances and Quantum Promptness
• How Much NEC Breaking Can the Universe Endure?
• Healthy Horndeski cosmologies with torsion
• In hot pursuit of a stable wormhole in beyond Horndeski theory
• Classical and Quantum Dynamics of Gyroscopic Systems and Dark Energy
• Deriving the Gibbons-Maldacena-Nunez no-go theorem from the Raychaudhuri equation
• Glimmers of a post-geometric perspective
• Apparent Fine Tunings for Field Theories with Broken Space-Time Symmetries
• Reissner-Nordstrom and charged gas spheres
• Geodesic completeness, cosmological bounces and inflation
• Hitchhiker's Guide to the Swampland: The Cosmologist's Handbook to the string-theoretical Swampland Programme
• Effective field theory of coupled dark energy and dark matter
• Flows into de Sitter space from anisotropic initial conditions: An effective field theory approach
• Resolving Puzzles of Massive Gravity with and without violation of Lorentz symmetry
• A Note on the Field-Theoretical Description of Superfluids
• Slow Burgers Vortices in Hot Conformal Fluids
• Evolution of perturbations in a universe with exotic solid-like matter
• Revisiting Holographic Dark Energy in Cyclic Cosmology
• Sound waves move matter
• Characteristic analysis for integrable soliton models on two-dimensional target spaces
• Moving holographic boundaries
• Inclusion of a perfect fluid term into the Einstein-Hilbert action
• The need for a nonlocal expansion in general relativity
• Higher Derivative Terms in Three Dimensional Supersymmetric Theories
• Boundary Conformal Field Theory at Large Charge
• Primordial gravitational waves and perturbations during an inhomogeneous inflation
• Spacetime Instability and Quantum Gravity as Low Energy Effective Field Theory
• A Heuristic Approach to the Far-Future State of a Universe Dominated by Phantom Energy
• Horndeski in motion
• Apparent $w<-1$ and a Lower $S_8$ from Dark Axion and Dark Baryons Interactions
• The energy conditions and model selection in the local Universe
• An Effective Field Theory of Magneto-Elasticity
• Accelerated expansion in the effective field theory of a radiation dominated universe
• Decoupling Inflation From the String Scale
• Quantum dynamics of perfect fluids
• Collective dynamics in holographic fractonic solids
• A complex scalar field theory for charged fluids, superfluids, and fracton fluids
• Quadrupole-conserving dynamics in the non-commutative plane
• Classification of quantum states based on the null energy condition
• Effective field theory for the superfluid vortex lattice from coset construction
• Time as a test-field: the no-boundary universe in motion and a smooth radiation bounce
• Spontaneous Breaking of (2+1)-dimensional Lorentz Symmetry by an antisymmetric tensor
• Effect of bulk Lorentz violation on anisotropic brane cosmologies
• Medium Generated Gap in Gravity and a 3d Gauge Theory