On the origin of the BAOtr-DESI tension

Abstract

The fiducial-independent angular/transverse BAO dataset, obtained from two-point angular correlation functions in thin redshift shells (hereafter BAOtr), systematically prefers smaller comoving distance ratios $D_{\mathrm{M}}/r_{\mathrm{d}}$ than the DESI DR2 three-dimensional BAO measurements at $z\lesssim 0.65$, driving dataset-dependent CPL dark-energy inferences and conflicting conclusions about the Hubble tension. We investigate whether this disagreement can be attributed to the $\Lambda$CDM fiducial assumed in the 3D BAO pipeline, or resolved within the CPL parametrisation. We show that the published 3D BAO distances are fiducial-independent by construction, with residual effects at $\lesssim 0.3\%$ -- negligible against the 10--18\% BAOtr uncertainties. We then scan the CPL parameter space with ${\Omega }_m$ and $H_0$ jointly determined at each $(w_0,w_a)$ by the Planck ${\theta }_{\ast }$ constraint and optimisation against the DESI data. Two complementary tests are performed: a direct comparison of each DESI-optimized model with the BAOtr data, and an $\alpha$-interpolation test that anchors the prediction to the DESI measurements. Both reveal an inescapable trade-off: models that fit DESI well (${\chi }_{\mathrm{DESI}}^2\lesssim 5$) yield ${\chi }_{\mathrm{BAOtr}}^2\gtrsim 42$, while reducing the BAOtr tension to ${\chi }_{\mathrm{BAOtr}}^2\sim 37$ requires ${\chi }_{\mathrm{DESI}}^2\gtrsim 8$. No CMB-consistent CPL model fits both datasets simultaneously. The direct comparison at $z=0.510$ -- where BAOtr and DESI disagree by $3.7\sigma$ (data-versus-data) -- sets an irreducible tension floor that no smooth modification of $D_{\mathrm{M}}(z)$ can remove. These conclusions are robust across analysis methods, extrapolation schemes, and substitution of SDSS for DESI. The remaining explanations are observational systematics -- most plausibly in the BAOtr measurements -- or new physics beyond CPL.

arXiv comment40 pages, 5 figures, 8 tables

References in corpus (68)

• Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation Function of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies
• LSST: from Science Drivers to Reference Design and Anticipated Data Products
• The clustering of galaxies in the completed SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: cosmological analysis of the DR12 galaxy sample
• Exploring the Expansion History of the Universe
• Accelerating Universes with Scaling Dark Matter
• A Comprehensive Measurement of the Local Value of the Hubble Constant with 1 km/s/Mpc Uncertainty from the Hubble Space Telescope and the SH0ES Team
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Power-spectrum analysis of the final dataset and cosmological implications
• The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in the Data Release 10 and 11 galaxy samples
• The Clustering of the SDSS DR7 Main Galaxy Sample I: A 4 per cent Distance Measure at z=0.15
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Cosmological Implications from two Decades of Spectroscopic Surveys at the Apache Point observatory
• The Pantheon+ Analysis: Cosmological Constraints
• DESI 2024 VI: Cosmological Constraints from the Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• Early Dark Energy Can Resolve The Hubble Tension
• The Pantheon+ Analysis: The Full Dataset and Light-Curve Release
• Challenges for $\Lambda$CDM: An update
• Probing Dark Energy with Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations from Future Large Galaxy Redshift Surveys
• Braneworld models of dark energy
• A 2% Distance to z=0.35 by Reconstructing Baryon Acoustic Oscillations - I : Methods and Application to the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Probing dark energy using baryonic oscillations in the galaxy power spectrum as a cosmological ruler
• Improving Cosmological Distance Measurements by Reconstruction of the Baryon Acoustic Peak
• Overview of the Instrumentation for the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument
• Early dark energy, the Hubble-parameter tension, and the string axiverse
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Baryon acoustic oscillations with Lyman-$\alpha$ forests
• The Clustering of Luminous Red Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Imaging Data
• Seven hints that early-time new physics alone is not sufficient to solve the Hubble tension
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: BAO and RSD measurements from anisotropic clustering analysis of the Quasar Sample in configuration space between redshift 0.8 and 2.2
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: measurement of the BAO and growth rate of structure of the luminous red galaxy sample from the anisotropic correlation function between redshifts 0.6 and 1
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: measurement of the BAO and growth rate of structure of the luminous red galaxy sample from the anisotropic power spectrum between redshifts 0.6 and 1.0
• The clustering of galaxies in the completed SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Observational systematics and baryon acoustic oscillations in the correlation function
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: BAO and RSD measurements from the anisotropic power spectrum of the Quasar sample between redshift 0.8 and 2.2
• The clustering of galaxies in the completed SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in Fourier-space
• DESI 2024 III: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations from Galaxies and Quasars
• Cosmic Complementarity: H_0 and Omega_m from Combining CMB Experiments and Redshift Surveys
• Baryonic Signatures in Large-Scale Structure
• Ameliorating Systematic Uncertainties in the Angular Clustering of Galaxies: A Study using SDSS-III
• $H_0$ Tension, Phantom Dark Energy and Cosmological Parameter Degeneracies
• Graduated dark energy: Observational hints of a spontaneous sign switch in the cosmological constant
• Dark Energy with Phantom Crossing and the $H_0$ tension
• Robust Preference for Dynamical Dark Energy in DESI BAO and SN Measurements
• Clustering of Sloan Digital Sky Survey III Photometric Luminous Galaxies: The Measurement, Systematics and Cosmological Implications
• A 2% Distance to z=0.35 by Reconstructing Baryon Acoustic Oscillations - II: Fitting Techniques
• Relaxing cosmological tensions with a sign switching cosmological constant
• A rapid transition of $G_{\mathrm{eff}}$ at $z_t\simeq 0.01$ as a solution of the Hubble and growth tensions
• Interpreting DESI's evidence for evolving dark energy
• Scant evidence for thawing quintessence
• Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: A 2.7% measurement of Baryon Acoustic Oscillation distance scale at redshift 0.835
• Relaxing cosmological tensions with a sign switching cosmological constant: Improved results with Planck, BAO, and Pantheon data
• Cosmological parameter analyses using transversal BAO data
• Modeling the angular correlation function and its full covariance in Photometric Galaxy Surveys
• Tracing The Sound Horizon Scale With Photometric Redshift Surveys
• Angular Baryon Acoustic Oscillation measure at z=2.225 from the SDSS quasar survey
• Baryon Acoustic Oscillations from the SDSS DR10 galaxies angular correlation function
• Late time approaches to the Hubble tension deforming $H(z)$, worsen the growth tension
• Model-independent reconstruction of the Interacting Dark Energy Kernel: Binned and Gaussian process
• Omnipotent dark energy: A phenomenological answer to the Hubble tension
• Negative cosmological constant in the dark energy sector: tests from JWST photometric and spectroscopic observations of high-redshift galaxies
• BAO angular scale at z_eff = 0.11 with the SDSS blue galaxies
• Dynamical Dark Energy Beyond Planck? Constraints from multiple CMB probes, DESI BAO and Type-Ia Supernovae
• Exploiting the full potential of photometric quasar surveys: Optimal power spectra through blind mitigation of systematics
• Measuring the transverse baryonic acoustic scale from the SDSS DR11 galaxies
• Clustering of Photometric Luminous Red Galaxies II: Cosmological Implications from the Baryon Acoustic Scale
• Multidimensionality of the Hubble tension: the roles of ${\Omega }_m$ and ${\omega }_c$
• Constraining scalar-tensor theories by neutron star-balck hole gravitational wave events
• Composite Dark Energy and the Cosmological Tensions
• Comprehensive analysis of the tidal effect in gravitational waves and implication for cosmology
• Characteristic Scales of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations from Perturbation Theory: Non-linearity and Redshift-Space Distortion Effects
• Precise Measurement of the Radial Baryon Acoustic Oscillation Scales in Galaxy Redshift Surveys
• Status of the $S_8$ Tension: A 2026 Review of Probe Discrepancies

Cited by in corpus (1)

• Dark Energy in the DESI Era: A Brief Review of Evidence, Beyond-$\Lambda$CDM Interpretations, and Tensions