What You Don't Know Can Hurt You: Use and Abuse of Astrophysical Models in Gravitational-wave Population Analyses

Abstract

One of the goals of gravitational-wave astrophysics is to infer the number and properties of the formation channels of binary black holes (BBHs); to do so, one must be able to connect various models with the data. We explore benefits and potential issues with analyses using models informed by population synthesis. We consider 5 possible formation channels of BBHs, as in Zevin et al. (2021b). First, we confirm with the GWTC-3 catalog what Zevin et al. (2021b) found in the GWTC-2 catalog, i.e. that the data are not consistent with the totality of observed BBHs forming in any single channel. Next, using simulated detections, we show that the uncertainties in the estimation of the branching ratios can shrink by up to a factor of $\sim 1.7$ as the catalog size increases from $50$ to $250$, within the expected number of BBH detections in LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA's fourth observing run. Finally, we show that this type of analysis is prone to significant biases. By simulating universes where all sources originate from a single channel, we show that the influence of the Bayesian prior can make it challenging to conclude that one channel produces all signals. Furthermore, by simulating universes where all 5 channels contribute but only a subset of channels are used in the analysis, we show that biases in the branching ratios can be as large as $\sim 50\%$ with $250$ detections. This suggests that caution should be used when interpreting the results of analyses based on strongly modeled astrophysical sub-populations.

arXiv comment24 pages, 14 figures, comments are welcome

References in corpus (71)

• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
• Advanced LIGO
• Evolution of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
• Bilby: A user-friendly Bayesian inference library for gravitational-wave astronomy
• Common Envelope Evolution: Where we stand and how we can move forward
• A Comprehensive Study of Binary Compact Objects as Gravitational Wave Sources: Evolutionary Channels, Rates, and Physical Properties
• Double Compact Objects I: The Significance Of The Common Envelope On Merger Rates
• Black hole mergers in the universe
• A new route towards merging massive black holes
• Computationally efficient models for the dominant and sub-dominant harmonic modes of precessing binary black holes
• Binary Black Hole Mergers from Globular Clusters: Masses, Merger Rates, and the Impact of Stellar Evolution
• Merging binary black holes formed through chemically homogeneous evolution in short-period stellar binaries
• Gravitational waves from scattering of stellar-mass black holes in galactic nuclei
• Total recoil: the maximum kick from nonspinning black-hole binary inspiral
• An introduction to Bayesian inference in gravitational-wave astronomy: parameter estimation, model selection, and hierarchical models
• Extracting distribution parameters from multiple uncertain observations with selection biases
• Binary Black Hole Mergers from Globular Clusters: Implications for Advanced LIGO
• The chemically homogeneous evolutionary channel for binary black hole mergers: rates and properties of gravitational-wave events detectable by advanced LIGO
• Merging black hole binaries in galactic nuclei: implications for advanced-LIGO detections
• Formation of the first three gravitational-wave observations through isolated binary evolution
• The progenitors of compact-object binaries: impact of metallicity, common envelope and natal kicks
• MOCCA-SURVEY Database I: Coalescing Binary Black Holes Originating From Globular Clusters
• The Formation of Eccentric Compact Binary Inspirals and the Role of Gravitational Wave Emission in Binary-Single Stellar Encounters
• Binary Mergers and Growth of Black Holes in Dense Star Clusters
• One Channel to Rule Them All? Constraining the Origins of Binary Black Holes using Multiple Formation Pathways
• Evolution of Binary Compact Objects Which Merge
• The effect of the metallicity-specific star formation history on double compact object mergers
• BPASS predictions for Binary Black-Hole Mergers
• Dynamics of stellar black holes in young star clusters with different metallicities - II. Black hole-black hole binaries
• Measuring the binary black hole mass spectrum with an astrophysically motivated parameterization
• Four-Body Effects in Globular Cluster Black Hole Coalescence
• 4-OGC: Catalog of gravitational waves from compact-binary mergers
• The spin of the second-born black hole in coalescing binary black holes
• Compact Binary Merger Rates: Comparison with LIGO/Virgo Upper Limits
• Estimating the final spin of a binary black hole coalescence
• Forming short-period Wolf-Rayet X-ray binaries and double black holes through stable mass transfer
• Modeling Dense Star Clusters in the Milky Way and Beyond with the $\text{CMC}$ Cluster Catalog
• Compact Binaries in Star Clusters I - Black Hole Binaries Inside Globular Clusters
• GWTC-2.1: Deep Extended Catalog of Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
• Determining the population properties of spinning black holes
• Degeneracy between mass and spin in black-hole-binary waveforms
• Mergers of Stellar-Mass Black Holes in Nuclear Star Clusters
• New binary black hole mergers in the LIGO--Virgo O3a data
• Searching for a subpopulation of primordial black holes in LIGO/Virgo gravitational-wave data
• Use of gravitational waves to probe the formation channels of compact binaries
• The impact of mass-transfer physics on the observable properties of field binary black hole populations
• Monte Carlo Simulations of Globular Cluster Evolution. IV. Direct Integration of Strong Interactions
• Measuring the spin of black holes in binary systems using gravitational waves
• Three-Body Dynamics with Gravitational Wave Emission
• On the Assembly Rate of Highly Eccentric Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Research Note: The Expected Spins of Gravitational Wave Sources With Isolated Field Binary Progenitors
• Measuring the star formation rate with gravitational waves from binary black holes
• Counting And Confusion: Bayesian Rate Estimation With Multiple Populations
• Distribution of Effective Spins and Masses of Binary Black Holes from the LIGO and Virgo O1-O3a Observing Runs
• Can we measure individual black-hole spins from gravitational-wave observations?
• Parameter estimation for heavy binary-black holes with networks of second-generation gravitational-wave detectors
• Model-independent inference on compact-binary observations
• Cover Your Basis: Comprehensive Data-Driven Characterization of the Binary Black Hole Population
• Building better spin models for merging binary black holes: Evidence for non-spinning and rapidly spinning nearly aligned sub-populations
• No peaks without valleys: The stable mass transfer channel for gravitational-wave sources in light of the neutron star-black hole mass gap
• Exploring Features in the Binary Black Hole Population
• Ain't No Mountain High Enough: Semi-Parametric Modeling of LIGO-Virgos Binary Black Hole Mass Distribution
• Black Hole Binaries in Galactic Nuclei and Gravitational Wave Sources
• Do unequal-mass binary black hole systems have larger ${\chi }_{\text{eff}}$? Probing correlations with copulas in gravitational-wave astronomy
• VAMANA: Modeling Binary Black Hole Population with Minimal Assumptions
• The Observed Rate of Binary Black Hole Mergers can be Entirely Explained by Globular Clusters
• Spin it as you like: the (lack of a) measurement of the spin tilt distribution with LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA binary black holes
• What GW170729's exceptional mass and spin tells us about its family tree
• Characterizing the observation bias in gravitational-wave detections and finding structured population properties
• Dropping Anchor: Understanding the Populations of Binary Black Holes with Random and Aligned Spin Orientations

Cited by in corpus (23)

• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• Evidence for a correlation between binary black hole mass ratio and black-hole spins
• Systematic biases due to waveform mismodeling in parametrized post-Einsteinian tests of general relativity: The impact of neglecting spin precession and higher modes
• The Redshift Evolution of the Binary Black Hole Mass Distribution from Dense Star Clusters
• PixelPop: High Resolution Nonparameteric Inference of Gravitational-Wave Populations in Multiple Dimensions
• Nonparametric analysis of correlations in the binary black hole population with LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA data
• Residual eccentricity as a systematic uncertainty on the formation channels of binary black holes
• McFacts III: Compact binary mergers from AGN disks over an entire synthetic universe
• Exploring the evolution of gravitational-wave emitters with efficient emulation: Constraining the origins of binary black holes using normalising flows
• Spin Doctors: How to diagnose a hierarchical merger origin
• Consistent eccentricities for gravitational wave astronomy: Resolving discrepancies between astrophysical simulations and waveform models
• Exploring field-evolution and dynamical-capture coalescing binary black holes in GWTC-3
• An upper limit on the spins of merging binary black holes formed through binary evolution
• Multi-spectral Sirens: Gravitational-wave Cosmology with (Multi-) Sub-populations of Binary Black Holes
• The origin channels of hierarchical binary black hole mergers in the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA O1, O2, and O3 runs
• Seeking Spinning Subpopulations of Black Hole Binaries via Iterative Density Estimation
• On the Astrophysical Origin of Binary Black Hole Subpopulations: A Tale of Three Channels?
• Reassessing the Spin of Second-born Black Holes in Coalescing Binary Black Holes and Its Connection to the chi_eff-q Correlation
• Comparing astrophysical models to gravitational-wave data in the observable space
• Population Synthesis of Gravitational Wave Sources
• Can Big Black Holes Merge with the Smallest Black Holes?
• Characterizing Binary Black Hole Subpopulations in GWTC-4 with Binned Gaussian Processes: On the Origins of the $35M_{\odot }$ Peak
• Inferring host environment properties and gravitational-wave decay time from the eccentricity measurement of dynamically captured binaries