Spin it as you like: the (lack of a) measurement of the spin tilt distribution with LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA binary black holes

Abstract

While much has been learned about black holes by analyzing the latest LVK catalog, GWTC-3, a measurement of the astrophysical distribution of the black hole spin orientations remains elusive. This is usually probed by measuring the cosine of the tilt angle ($\cos \tau$) between each black hole spin and the orbital angular momentum, $\cos \tau =+1$ being perfect alignment. Abbott et al. has modeled the $\cos \tau$ distribution as a mixture of an isotropic component and a Gaussian component with mean fixed at +1 and width measured from the data. We want to verify if the data require the existence of such a peak at $\cos \tau =+1$. We use various alternative models for the astrophysical tilt distribution and measure their parameters using the LVK GWTC-3 catalog. We find that a) Augmenting the LVK model such that the mean $\mu$ of the Gaussian is not fixed at +1 returns results that strongly depend on priors. If we allow $\mu >+1$ then the resulting astrophysical $\cos \tau$ distribution peaks at +1 and looks linear, rather than Gaussian. If we constrain $-1\le \mu \le +1$ the Gaussian component peaks at $\mu =0.48_{-0.99}^{+0.46}$ (median and 90% symmetric credible interval). Two other 2-component mixture models yield $\cos \tau$ distributions that either have a broad peak centered at $0.19_{-0.18}^{+0.22}$ or a plateau that spans the range [-0.5, +1], without a clear peak at +1. b) All of the models we considered agree on the fact that there is no excess of black hole tilts at around -1. c) While yielding quite different posteriors, the models considered in this work have Bayesian evidences that are the same within error bars. We conclude that the current dataset is not sufficiently informative to draw any model-independent conclusions on the astrophysical distribution of spin tilts, except that there is no excess of spins with negatively aligned tilts.

arXiv comment6 pages body + 10 pages appendices. Following Ref suggestion, now includes differential rate plots per unit costilt. Data release on Zenodo linked from Data availability section. Note: the abstract in the metadata is shorter than the paper's due to Arxiv restriction to 1920 characters

References in corpus (62)

• Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
• dynesty: A Dynamic Nested Sampling Package for Estimating Bayesian Posteriors and Evidences
• Evolution of binary stars and the effect of tides on binary populations
• Characterization of the LIGO detectors during their sixth science run
• Bilby: A user-friendly Bayesian inference library for gravitational-wave astronomy
• Double Compact Objects I: The Significance Of The Common Envelope On Merger Rates
• The runaway growth of intermediate-mass black holes in dense star clusters
• Coalescence of Two Spinning Black Holes: An Effective One-Body Approach
• Bayesian inference for compact binary coalescences with BILBY: Validation and application to the first LIGO--Virgo gravitational-wave transient catalogue
• Extracting distribution parameters from multiple uncertain observations with selection biases
• Merging black hole binaries in galactic nuclei: implications for advanced-LIGO detections
• Formation of the first three gravitational-wave observations through isolated binary evolution
• The evolutionary roads leading to low effective spins, high black hole masses, and O1/O2 rates of LIGO/Virgo binary black holes
• Pulsar Recoil and Gravitational Radiation due to Asymmetrical Stellar Collapse and Explosion
• Black Holes: The Next Generation -- Repeated Mergers in Dense Star Clusters and their Gravitational-Wave Properties
• Eccentric Black Hole Mergers Forming in Globular Clusters
• One Channel to Rule Them All? Constraining the Origins of Binary Black Holes using Multiple Formation Pathways
• Distinguishing Spin-Aligned and Isotropic Black Hole Populations With Gravitational Waves
• The Dynamical Evolution of Stellar Black Holes in Globular Clusters
• Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Formation, Masses, and Merger Rates of Highly-Eccentric Black Hole Binaries
• Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Highly-Eccentric, Highly-Spinning, and Repeated Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Does the Black Hole Merger Rate Evolve with Redshift?
• Hierarchical mergers of stellar-mass black holes and their gravitational-wave signatures
• Measuring the binary black hole mass spectrum with an astrophysically motivated parameterization
• Spin orientations of merging black holes formed from the evolution of stellar binaries
• Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Close Binaries with Two Compact Objects
• Investigating stellar-mass black hole kicks
• The cosmic merger rate of neutron stars and black holes
• Where are LIGO's Big Black Holes?
• Determining the population properties of spinning black holes
• Reconstructing phenomenological distributions of compact binaries via gravitational wave observations
• New binary black hole mergers in the LIGO--Virgo O3a data
• Use of gravitational waves to probe the formation channels of compact binaries
• A high-velocity black hole on a Galactic-halo orbit in the solar neighborhood
• Constraining Formation Models of Binary Black Holes with Gravitational-Wave Observations
• Using spin to understand the formation of LIGO's black holes
• Circularization and Final Spin in Eccentric Binary Black Hole Inspirals
• Constraints on Binary Black Hole Populations from LIGO-Virgo Detections
• Research Note: The Expected Spins of Gravitational Wave Sources With Isolated Field Binary Progenitors
• Joint constraints on the field-cluster mixing fraction, common envelope efficiency, and globular cluster radii from a population of binary hole mergers via deep learning
• Measuring the star formation rate with gravitational waves from binary black holes
• Distribution of Effective Spins and Masses of Binary Black Holes from the LIGO and Virgo O1-O3a Observing Runs
• Parallelized Inference for Gravitational-Wave Astronomy
• Revising natal kick prescriptions in population synthesis simulations
• The Low Effective Spin of Binary Black Holes and Implications for Individual Gravitational-Wave Events
• Model-independent inference on compact-binary observations
• Building better spin models for merging binary black holes: Evidence for non-spinning and rapidly spinning nearly aligned sub-populations
• Black Hole Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Galactic X-ray Binaries
• The runaway black hole GRO J1655-40
• Picky Partners: The Pairing of Component Masses in Binary Black Hole Mergers
• The binary black hole spin distribution likely broadens with redshift
• Measurement Accuracy of Inspiraling Eccentric Neutron Star and Black Hole Binaries Using Gravitational Waves
• No evidence that the majority of black holes in binaries have zero spin
• Ain't No Mountain High Enough: Semi-Parametric Modeling of LIGO-Virgos Binary Black Hole Mass Distribution
• Understanding Compact Object Formation and Natal Kicks. IV. The case of IC 10 X-1
• A new spin on LIGO-Virgo binary black holes
• Do unequal-mass binary black hole systems have larger ${\chi }_{\text{eff}}$? Probing correlations with copulas in gravitational-wave astronomy
• A trend in the effective spin distribution of LIGO binary black holes with mass
• VAMANA: Modeling Binary Black Hole Population with Minimal Assumptions
• Searching for mass-spin correlations in the population of gravitational-wave events: the GWTC-3 case study
• (H)DPGMM: A Hierarchy of Dirichlet Process Gaussian Mixture Models for the inference of the black hole mass function
• Gravitational-wave population inference at past time infinity

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Cover Your Basis: Comprehensive Data-Driven Characterization of the Binary Black Hole Population
• A Parameter-Free Tour of the Binary Black Hole Population
• Resolving the Stellar-Collapse and Hierarchical-Merger origins of the Coalescing Black Holes
• Potential Subpopulations and Assembling Tendency of the Merging Black Holes
• What You Don't Know Can Hurt You: Use and Abuse of Astrophysical Models in Gravitational-wave Population Analyses
• Evidence for a correlation between binary black hole mass ratio and black-hole spins
• GW241011 and GW241110: Exploring Binary Formation and Fundamental Physics with Asymmetric, High-Spin Black Hole Coalescence
• Which black hole is spinning? Probing the origin of black-hole spin with gravitational waves
• Nonparametric analysis of correlations in the binary black hole population with LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA data
• Gravitational waves carry information beyond effective spin parameters but it is hard to extract
• Merging binary black holes formed through double-core evolution
• Exploring field-evolution and dynamical-capture coalescing binary black holes in GWTC-3
• Gravitational-wave Observations Suggest Most Black Hole Mergers Form in Triples
• Rarity of precession and higher-order multipoles in gravitational waves from merging binary black holes
• Structure and Skewness of the Effective Inspiral Spin Distribution of Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Searching for candidates of coalescing binary black holes formed through chemically homogeneous evolution in GWTC-3
• The steep redshift evolution of the hierarchical binary black hole merger rate may cause the $z$-${\chi }_{\mathrm{eff}}$ correlation
• Signatures of a subpopulation of hierarchical mergers in the GWTC-4 gravitational-wave dataset
• Inferring small neutron star spins with neutron star-black hole mergers
• Mapping Parameter Correlations in Spinning Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Probing Spin-Orbit Resonances with the Binary Black Hole Population
• Evidence for Three Subpopulations of Merging Binary Black Holes at Different Primary Masses
• Analysis and simulations of binary black hole merger spins -- the question of spin-axis tossing at black hole formation
• Reducing systematic uncertainties in gravitational-wave population analyses by increasing the detection threshold
• Measurement prospects for the pair-instability mass cutoff with gravitational waves
• No model-independent evidence for a peak in binary black hole spin (mis)alignments