A Challenge to the Standard Cosmological Model

Abstract

We present the first joint analysis of catalogs of radio galaxies and quasars to determine if their sky distribution is consistent with the standard $\Lambda$CDM model of cosmology. This model is based on the cosmological principle, which asserts that the universe is statistically isotropic and homogeneous on large scales, so the observed dipole anisotropy in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) must be attributed to our local peculiar motion. We test the null hypothesis that there is a dipole anisotropy in the sky distribution of radio galaxies and quasars consistent with the motion inferred from the CMB, as is expected for cosmologically distant sources. Our two samples, constructed respectively from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey and the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer, are systematically independent and have no shared objects. Using a completely general statistic that accounts for correlation between the found dipole amplitude and its directional offset from the CMB dipole, the null hypothesis is independently rejected by the radio galaxy and quasar samples with $p$-value of $8.9\times 10^{-3}$ and $1.2\times 10^{-5}$, respectively, corresponding to $2.6\sigma$ and $4.4\sigma$ significance. The joint significance, using sample size-weighted $Z$-scores, is $5.1\sigma$. We show that the radio galaxy and quasar dipoles are consistent with each other and find no evidence for any frequency dependence of the amplitude. The consistency of the two dipoles improves if we boost to the CMB frame assuming its dipole to be fully kinematic, suggesting that cosmologically distant radio galaxies and quasars may have an intrinsic anisotropy in this frame.

arXiv comment11 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ Letters. Code and data available at https://zenodo.org/record/6784602

References in corpus (36)

• SciPy 1.0--Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python
• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
• HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
• Binary companions of evolved stars in APOGEE DR14: Search method and catalog of ~5,000 companions
• Planck 2018 results. I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck
• Preliminary Results from NEOWISE: An Enhancement to the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer for Solar System Science
• The GMRT 150 MHz All-sky Radio Survey: First Alternative Data Release TGSS ADR1
• SUMSS: A Wide-Field Radio Imaging Survey of the Southern Sky. II. The Source Catalogue
• Planck 2013 results. XI. All-sky model of thermal dust emission
• Mid-Infrared Selection of AGN with the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer. I. Characterizing WISE-Selected AGN in COSMOS
• Initial Performance of the NEOWISE Reactivation Mission
• Radio-Loudness of Active Galactic Nuclei: Observational Facts and Theoretical Implications
• Host galaxies, clustering, Eddington ratios, and evolution of radio, X-ray, and infrared-selected AGNs
• The unWISE Catalog: Two Billion Infrared Sources from Five Years of WISE Imaging
• The CatWISE2020 Catalog
• The Rapid ASKAP Continuum Survey I: Design and First Results
• A Test of the Cosmological Principle with Quasars
• Cosmic radio dipole from NVSS and WENSS
• Detection of the velocity dipole in the radio galaxies of the NRAO VLA Sky Survey
• Identification of 1.4 Million AGNs in the Mid-Infrared using WISE Data
• Large peculiar motion of the solar system from the dipole anisotropy in sky brightness due to distant radio sources
• Dipoles in the Sky
• High redshift radio galaxies and divergence from the CMB dipole
• Probing the Cosmological Principle in the counts of radio galaxies at different frequencies
• A radio spectral index map and catalogue at 147-1400 MHz covering 80 per cent of the sky
• Revisiting the NVSS number count dipole
• The Cosmic Radio Dipole: Estimators and Frequency Dependence
• Dipole anisotropy in sky brightness and source count distribution in radio NVSS data
• On the kinematic cosmic dipole tension
• Dipole Anisotropy in Integrated Linearly Polarized Flux Density in NVSS Data
• A new way to test the Cosmological Principle: measuring our peculiar velocity and the large scale anisotropy independently
• Is the evidence for dark energy secure?
• Radio spectral index from NVSS and TGSS
• The galaxy power spectrum from TGSS ADR1 and the effect of flux calibration systematics
• The effects of lensing by local structures on the dipole of radio source counts

Cited by in corpus (95)

• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
• Analyzing the Large-Scale Bulk Flow using CosmicFlows4: Increasing Tension with the Standard Cosmological Model
• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• Assessing cosmological evidence for non-minimal coupling
• $\Lambda$CDM Tensions: Localising Missing Physics through Consistency Checks
• A simultaneous solution to the Hubble tension and observed bulk flow within 250 $h^{-1}$ Mpc
• The cosmic radio dipole: Bayesian estimators on new and old radio surveys
• An effective description of Laniakea: impact on cosmology and the local determination of the Hubble constant
• Dipole Cosmology: The Copernican Paradigm Beyond FLRW
• Theoretical systematics in testing the Cosmological Principle with the kinematic quasar dipole
• The Cosmic Dipole in the Quaia Sample of Quasars: A Bayesian Analysis
• The expected kinematic matter dipole is robust against source evolution
• Hydrodynamical structure formation in Milgromian cosmology
• Cosmological foundations revisited with Pantheon+
• Discordance of dipole asymmetries seen in recent large radio surveys with the Cosmological Principle
• Anisotropy in Pantheon+ supernovae
• The cosmological star formation history from the Local Cosmological Volume of galaxies and constraints on the matter homogeneity
• Testing anisotropic Hubble expansion
• Measuring kinematic anisotropies with pulsar timing arrays
• Torsion at different scales: from materials to the Universe
• Reassessment of the dipole in the distribution of quasars on the sky
• Tomographic redshift dipole: Testing the cosmological principle
• Minkowski Tensors in Redshift Space -- Beyond the Plane Parallel Approximation
• asevolution: a relativistic N-body implementation of the (a)symmetron
• The low multipoles in the Pantheon+SH0ES data
• The kinematic contribution to the cosmic number count dipole
• Some disquisitions on cosmological 2-form dualities
• A study of Dipolar Signal in distant Quasars with various observables
• Discord in Concordance Cosmology and Anomalously Massive Early Galaxies
• Aether scalar tensor theory: Hamiltonian Formalism
• Tracking the validity of the quasi-static and sub-horizon approximations in modified gravity
• Solution of the dark matter riddle within standard model physics: From black holes, galaxies and clusters to cosmology
• Testing the Cosmological Principle: On the Time Dilation of Distant Sources
• Cosmic dipoles of active galactic nuclei at optical and radio wavelengths display much larger amplitudes than the cosmic microwave background dipole
• Resolution of the incongruency of dipole asymmetries within various large radio surveys -- implications for the Cosmological Principle
• Anisotropic Cosmology in the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity
• Examining the local Universe isotropy with galaxy cluster velocity dispersion scaling relations
• Spatially Homogeneous Universes with Late-Time Anisotropy
• Cosmic dipole tensions: confronting the cosmic microwave background with infrared and radio populations of cosmological sources
• The MeerKAT Absorption Line Survey: Homogeneous continuum catalogues towards a measurement of the cosmic radio dipole
• asimulation: Domain formation and impact on observables in resolved cosmological simulations of the (a)symmetron
• Resilience and implications of adiabatic CMB cooling
• An Independent Measure of the Kinematic Dipole from SDSS
• Forty years of the Ellis-Baldwin test
• Redshift drift in a universe with structure III: Numerical relativity
• Combining chirp mass, luminosity distance and sky localisation from gravitational wave events to detect the cosmic dipole
• Clustering properties of the CatWISE2020 quasar catalogue and their impact on the cosmic dipole anomaly
• Testing inhomogeneous cosmography in our cosmic neighborhood using CosmicFlows-4
• QCD axion dark matter and the cosmic dipole problem
• Cosmological inference from within the peculiar local universe
• No evidence for anisotropy in galaxy spin directions
• Using relativistic effects in large-scale structure to constrain astrophysical properties of galaxy populations
• Peculiar velocity effects on the Hubble constant from time-delay cosmography
• Anisotropy in the cosmic acceleration inferred from supernovae
• Matter Dipole and Hubble Tension due to Large Wavelength Perturbations
• Primordial gravitational waves from spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking
• Measuring our peculiar velocity from spectroscopic redshift surveys
• The impact of large-scale galaxy clustering on the variance of the Hellings-Downs correlation: numerical results
• Testing General Relativity through the $E_G$ Statistic Using the Weyl Potential and Galaxy Velocities
• Statistical effects of the observer's peculiar velocity on source number counts
• Linear Relativistic Corrections in the Spherical Fourier-Bessel Power Spectrum
• Reconciling cosmic dipolar tensions with a gigaparsec void
• No evidence for local $H_0$ anisotropy from Tully--Fisher or supernova distances
• Fast and spurious: a robust determination of our peculiar velocity with future galaxy surveys
• Doppler bias: impact of peculiar velocities on color selection and the large scale structure of galaxy surveys
• CMB low multipole alignments across WMAP and \emph{Planck} data releases
• A mechanism to generate varying speed of light via Higgs-dilaton coupling: Theory and cosmological applications
• Inferred Hubble Parameter from Gravitational Waves in a Perturbative Bianchi I Background
• On the anisotropic distribution of clusters in the local Universe
• Homology reveals significant anisotropy in the cosmic microwave background
• Numerical evolution of Maxwell's equations for wavefronts propagating through a spherical gravitational potential
• Measuring cosmic dipole with the GRB luminosity-time relation
• Gravitational waves from dark domain walls
• Solar peculiar motion inferred from dipole anisotropy in redshift distribution of quasars appears to lie along the Galactic Centre direction
• Gas of thin tubes of massless scalar field as a possible model of unified dark fluid
• The kinematic cosmic dipole beyond Ellis and Baldwin
• The Cosmological Dipole in Tilted Anisotropic Universes
• Cosmological perturbations on an averaged background
• Weak Lensing Low Multipoles
• Galaxy number-count dipole and superhorizon fluctuations
• The Ellis and Baldwin test of the Cosmic Dipole: Exploring the impact of multiple flux density cuts
• Testing the cosmological principle with quasars
• Testing the cosmological principle on gigaparsec scales
• Constraints on the gravitational potential from DESI DR2 BAO and its implications for the local void scenario
• Probing dipole and quadrupole anisotropy in Gamma-ray bursts from Swift dataset
• Symmetry in Hyper Suprime-Cam galaxy spin directions
• Measuring peculiar velocity and tomographic redshift dipole with DESI DR1 catalogs
• Bouncing Cosmologies in modified gravity with space time torsion
• Addressing Dipole Tension via Clustering in $\Lambda$CDM and beyond
• Evolution of superhorizon perturbations in early Universe with anisotropic solid remnant
• $S_8$ from peculiar velocities: agreement with Planck for Tully--Fisher and supernovae, tension for the fundamental plane
• Superhorizon isocurvature fluctuations relax tensions
• Detector induced anisotropies on the angular distribution of gravitational wave sources and opportunities of constraining horizon scale anisotropies
• An effective $\mathbf{\Lambda }$-Szekeres modelling of the local Universe with Cosmicflows-4