On the inconsistency of [C/Fe] abundances and the fractions of carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars among various stellar surveys

Abstract

Carbon-enhanced metal-poor (CEMP) stars are a unique resource for Galactic archaeology because they probe the properties of the First Stars, early chemical evolution and binary interactions at very low metallicity. Comparing the fractions and properties of CEMP stars in different Galactic environments can provide us with unique insights into the formation and evolution of the Milky Way halo and its building blocks. In this work, we investigate whether directly comparing fractions of CEMP stars from different literature samples of very metal-poor ([Fe/H] < -2.0) stars is valid. We compiled published CEMP fractions and samples of Galactic halo stars from the past 25 years, and find that they are not all consistent with each other. Focusing on giant stars, we find significant differences between various surveys when comparing their trends of [Fe/H] versus [C/Fe] and their distributions of CEMP stars. To test the role of the analysis pipelines for low-resolution spectroscopic samples, we re-analysed giant stars from various surveys with the SSPP and FERRE pipelines. We found systematic differences in [C/Fe] of ~0.1-0.4 dex, partly independent of degeneracies with the stellar atmospheric parameters. These systematics are likely due to the different pipeline approaches, different assumptions in the employed synthetic grids, and/or the comparison of different evolutionary phases. We conclude that current biases in (the analysis of) very metal-poor samples limit the conclusions one can draw from comparing different surveys. We provide some recommendations and suggestions that will hopefully aid the community to unlock the full potential of CEMP stars for Galactic archaeology.

arXiv commentPublished in MNRAS, only very minor changes compared to submitted version

References in corpus (97)

• Array Programming with NumPy
• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Technical Summary
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): first data release
• Nucleosynthesis and Evolution of Massive Metal-Free Stars
• SkyMapper and the Southern Sky Survey
• Near-Field Cosmology with Metal-Poor Stars
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. I. Description and Initial Validation Tests
• Carbon Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars. I. Chemical Compositions of 26 Stars
• The Hamburg/ESO R-process Enhanced Star survey (HERES) II. Spectroscopic analysis of the survey sample
• The Stellar Abundances for Galactic Archeology (SAGA) Database - Compilation of the Characteristics of Known Extremely Metal-Poor Stars
• A Spectroscopic Study of the Ancient Milky Way: F- and G-Type Stars in the Third Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• First-generation black-hole-forming supernovae and the metal abundance pattern of a very iron-poor star
• The early star generations: the dominant effect of rotation on the CNO yields
• SkyMapper Southern Survey: First Data Release (DR1)
• The Binary Frequency Among Carbon-Enhanced, s-Process Rich, Metal-Poor Stars
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Star Frequencies in the Galaxy: Corrections for the Effect of Evolutionary Status on Carbon Abundances
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. II. Validation with Galactic Globular and Open Clusters
• 4MOST: Project overview and information for the First Call for Proposals
• CH in stellar atmospheres: an extensive linelist
• The Pristine survey I: Mining the Galaxy for the most metal-poor stars
• New ATLAS9 And MARCS Model Atmosphere Grids for the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• The Most Metal-Poor Stars. IV. The Two Populations With [Fe/H] < -3.0
• A strong case for fast stellar rotation at very low metallicities
• The Frequency of Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars in the Galaxy from the HERES sample
• Normal and Outlying Populations of the Milky Way Stellar Halo at [Fe/H] < -2
• Observational Constraints on First-Star Nucleosynthesis. I. Evidence for Multiple Progenitors of CEMP-no Stars
• The stellar content of the Hamburg/ESO survey. IV. Selection of candidate metal-poor stars
• Bright Metal-Poor Stars from the Hamburg/ESO Survey. I. Selection and Follow-up Observations from 329 Fields
• TOPoS: II. On the bimodality of carbon abundance in CEMP stars. Implications on the early chemical evolution of galaxies
• Binarity in Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor stars
• High-Resolution Spectroscopy of Extremely Metal-Poor Stars from SDSS/SEGUE: I. Atmospheric Parameters and Chemical Compositions
• Carbon-enhanced Metal-poor Stars in SDSS/SEGUE. I. Carbon Abundance Estimation and Frequency of CEMP Stars
• The role of binaries in the enrichment of the early Galactic halo. III. Carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars -- CEMP-s stars
• Carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars: the most pristine objects?
• Abundance Profiling of Extremely Metal-Poor Stars and Supernova Properties in the Early Universe
• Dynamical Relics of the Ancient Galactic Halo
• The stellar content of the Hamburg/ESO survey. II. A large, homogeneously-selected sample of high latitude carbon stars
• s-Process in Low Metallicity Stars. I. Theoretical Predictions
• Stellar Archaeology -- Exploring the Universe with Metal-Poor Stars
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars in the Inner and Outer Halo Components of the Milky Way
• The stellar content of the Hamburg/ESO survey. V. The metallicity distribution function of the Galactic halo
• The Most Metal-Poor Stars. III. The Metallicity Distribution Function and CEMP Fraction
• Extremely metal-poor stars from the cosmic dawn in the bulge of the Milky Way
• Four-hundred Very Metal-Poor Stars Studied with LAMOST and Subaru. II. Elemental abundances
• Center-to-Limb Variation of Solar 3-D Hydrodynamical Simulations
• The Best and Brightest Metal-Poor Stars
• The role of binaries in the enrichment of the early Galactic halo. II. Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars - CEMP-no stars
• The EMBLA Survey -- Metal-poor stars in the Galactic bulge
• Carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars in dwarf galaxies
• The extremely low-metallicity tail of the Sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• The Frequency of Carbon Stars Among Extremely Metal-Poor Stars
• Population Studies. XIII. A New Analysis of the Bidelman-MacConnell "Weak-Metal" Stars - Confirmation of Metal-Poor Stars in the Thick Disk of the Galaxy
• A high-resolution spectral analysis of three carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars
• Ba stars and other binaries in first and second generation stars in globular clusters
• Binarity among CEMP-no stars: an indication of multiple formation pathways?
• Deep SDSS optical spectroscopy of distant halo stars I. Atmospheric parameters and stellar metallicity distribution
• The Most Metal-Poor Stars. I. Discovery, Data, and Atmospheric Parameters
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars: CEMP-s and CEMP-no Sub-Classes in the Halo System of the Milky Way
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: the most metal-poor stars in the Galactic bulge
• Carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars: a window on AGB nucleosynthesis and binary evolution. I. Detailed analysis of 15 binary stars with known orbital periods
• The Pristine Survey -- VI. The first three years of medium-resolution follow-up spectroscopy of Pristine EMP star candidates
• Estimation of Carbon Abundances in Metal-Poor Stars. I. Application to the "Strong G-band" stars of Beers, Preston, & Shectman
• Galactic Archeology with the AEGIS Survey: The Evolution of Carbon and Iron in the Galactic Halo
• Detailed Abundances in the Ultra-faint Magellanic Satellites Carina II and III
• The SkyMapper DR1.1 Search for Extremely Metal-Poor Stars
• Bright Metal-Poor Stars from the Hamburg/ESO Survey. II. A Chemodynamical Analysis
• The Pristine Inner Galaxy Survey (PIGS) II: Uncovering the most metal-poor populations in the inner Milky Way
• Carbon and oxygen in metal-poor halo stars
• The Photometric Metallicity and Carbon Distributions of the Milky Way's Halo and Solar Neighborhood from S-PLUS Observations of SDSS Stripe 82
• Detection of a population of carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars in the Sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• The Most Metal-Poor Stars. V. The CEMP-no Stars in 3D and Non-LTE
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars in the Early Galaxy
• Chemical Cartography. I. A Carbonicity Map of the Galactic Halo
• Spectroscopic Validation of Low-Metallicity Stars from RAVE
• Searches for Metal-Poor Stars from the Hamburg/ESO Survey using the CH G-band
• The stellar content of the Hamburg/ESO survey VI. The metallicity distribution of main-sequence turnoff stars in the Galactic halo
• WHT follow-up observations of extremely metal-poor stars identified from SDSS and LAMOST
• The S2 Stream: the shreds of a primitive dwarf galaxy
• Dynamically Tagged Groups of Metal-Poor Stars from the Best \& Brightest Survey
• High resolution spectroscopic follow-up of the most metal-poor candidates from SkyMapper DR1.1
• Stellar metallicities from SkyMapper photometry I: A study of the Tucana II ultra-faint dwarf galaxy
• Origin of the CEMP-no Group Morphology in the Milky Way
• The R-Process Alliance: Spectroscopic Follow-up of Low-Metallicity Star Candidates from the Best & Brightest Survey
• The Pristine Inner Galaxy Survey (PIGS) III: carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars in the bulge
• Chemical Cartography. II. The Assembly History of the Galactic Stellar Halo Traced by Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars
• Four-hundred Very Metal-poor Stars studied with LAMOST and Subaru. I. Survey Design, Follow-up Program, and Binary Frequency
• An in-depth spectroscopic examination of molecular bands from 3D hydrodynamical model atmospheres. II. Carbon-enhanced metal-poor 3D model atmospheres
• Identification of a Group III CEMP-no Star in the Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy Canes Venatici I
• Carbon-enhanced Metal-poor Stars in SDSS/SEGUE. II. Comparison of CEMP Star Frequencies with Binary Population Synthesis Models
• Targeting Bright Metal-poor Stars in the Disk and Halo Systems of the Galaxy
• A Search for Unrecognized Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars in the Galaxy
• The Pristine survey -- XV. A CFHT ESPaDOnS view on the Milky Way halo and disc populations
• Metal-Poor Stars Observed with the Southern African Large Telescope II. An Extended Sample
• Carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars in the SDSS-APOGEE database

Cited by in corpus (6)

• The Pristine Inner Galaxy Survey (PIGS) V: a chemo-dynamical investigation of the early assembly of the Milky Way with the most metal-poor stars in the bulge
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor star candidates from BP/RP Spectra in $Gaia$ DR3
• Phase-space Properties and Chemistry of the Sagittarius Stellar Stream Down to the Extremely Metal-poor ($[Fe/H]\lesssim -3$) Regime
• Mining S-PLUS for Metal-Poor Stars in the Milky Way
• The Pristine survey -- XX: GTC follow-up observations of extremely metal-poor stars identified from Pristine and LAMOST
• Four-hundred Very Metal-poor Stars Studied with LAMOST and Subaru. IV. Heavy Element Enhanced Stars