A lack of constraints on the cold opaque HI mass: HI spectra in M31 and M33 prefer multi-component models over a single cold opaque component

Abstract

Previous work has argued that atomic gas mass estimates of galaxies from 21 cm HI emission are systematically low due to a cold opaque atomic gas component. If true, this opaque component necessitates a ~35% correction factor relative to the mass from assuming optically-thin HI emission. These mass corrections are based on fitting HI spectra with a single opaque component model that produces a distinct "top-hat" shaped line profile. Here, we investigate this issue using deep, high spectral resolution HI VLA observations of M31 and M33 to test if these top-hat profiles are instead superpositions of multiple HI components along the line-of-sight. We fit both models and find that >80% of the spectra strongly prefer a multi-component Gaussian model while <2% prefer the single opacity-corrected component model. This strong preference for multiple components argues against previous findings of lines-of-sight dominated by only cold HI. Our findings are enabled by the improved spectral resolution (0.42 km/s), whereas coarser spectral resolution blends multiple components together. We also show that the inferred opaque atomic ISM mass strongly depends on the goodness-of-fit definition and is highly uncertain when the inferred spin temperature has a large uncertainty. Finally, we find that the relation of the HI surface density with the dust surface density and extinction has significantly more scatter when the inferred HI opacity correction is applied. These variations are difficult to explain without additionally requiring large variations in the dust properties. Based on these findings, we suggest that the opaque HI mass is best constrained by HI absorption studies.

arXiv commentAccepted in MNRAS. 25 pg, 13 figures

References in corpus (59)

• SciPy 1.0--Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python
• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
• The Neutral Atomic Phases of the ISM in the Galaxy
• The Interstellar Environment of our Galaxy
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor and Dust-to-Gas Ratio on Kiloparsec Scales in Nearby Galaxies
• The Millennium Arecibo 21-CM Absorption Line Survey. II. Properties of the Warm and Cold Neutral Media
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor From Infrared Dust Emission Across the Local Group
• xCOLD GASS: the complete IRAM-30m legacy survey of molecular gas for galaxy evolution studies
• Multi-Scale CLEAN deconvolution of radio synthesis images
• The Star Formation Law in Atomic and Molecular Gas
• The Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury
• Molecular gas kinematics within the central 250 pc of the Milky Way
• The Effelsberg-Bonn HI Survey: Milky Way gas. First data release
• A wide-field HI mosaic of Messier 31. II.The disk warp, rotation and the dark matter halo
• Tracing the total molecular gas in galaxies: [CII] and the CO-dark gas
• Molecular gas in the Andromeda galaxy
• Dust and Gas in the Magellanic Clouds from the HERITAGE Herschel Key Project. I. Dust Properties and Insights into the Origin of the Submm Excess Emission
• Molecular and Atomic Gas in the Local Group Galaxy M33
• A Wide-field High Resolution HI Mosaic of Messier 31: I. Opaque Atomic Gas and Star Formation Rate Density
• Cosmological evolution of atomic gas and implications for 21 cm HI absorption
• Dust and Gas in the Magellanic Clouds from the HERITAGE Herschel Key Project. II. Gas-to-Dust Ratio Variations across ISM Phases
• Giant Molecular Clouds in the Local Group Galaxy M33
• The Temperature and Opacity of Atomic Hydrogen in Spiral Galaxies
• The 21-SPONGE HI Absorption Line Survey II: The temperature of Galactic HI
• The distance to the Andromeda Galaxy from eclipsing binaries
• The Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury VIII: A Wide-Area, High-Resolution Map of Dust Extinction in M31
• Fitting Together the HI Absorption and Emission in the SGPS
• A Self-Absorption Census of Cold HI Clouds in the Canadian Galactic Plane Survey
• Autonomous Gaussian Decomposition
• Cold and Warm Atomic Gas around the Perseus Molecular Cloud. II. The Impact of High Optical Depth on the HI Column Density Distribution and Its Implication for the HI-to-H2 Transition
• ROHSA: Regularized Optimization for Hyper-Spectral Analysis - Application to phase separation of 21 cm data
• The Local Leo Cold Cloud and New Limits on a Local Hot Bubble
• Cold and warm atomic gas around the Perseus molecular cloud I: Basic Properties
• THOR - The HI, OH, Recombination Line Survey of the Milky Way - The pilot study: HI observations of the giant molecular cloud W43
• The HI/OH/Recombination line survey of the inner Milky Way (THOR): data release 2 and HI overview
• Kinematics of the Atomic ISM in M33 on 80 pc scales
• The Resolved Distributions of Dust Mass and Temperature in Local Group Galaxies
• The Spatially Resolved Dust-to-Metals Ratio in M101
• Optically thick HI does not dominate dark gas in the local ISM
• Molecular Gas Velocity Dispersions in the Andromeda Galaxy
• DHIGLS: DRAO H I Intermediate Galactic Latitude Survey
• The Neutral Hydrogen Bridge between M31 and M33
• Cloud formation in the atomic and molecular phase: HI self absorption (HISA) towards a Giant Molecular Filament
• Excitation temperature of the warm neutral medium as a new probe of the Lyman-α radiation field
• Effect of the heating rate on the stability of the three-phase interstellar medium
• Recovering interstellar gas properties with HI spectral lines: A comparison between synthetic spectra and 21-SPONGE
• The Dust in M31
• Simulating the atomic and molecular content of molecular clouds using probability distributions of physical parameters
• Autonomous Gaussian decomposition of the Galactic Ring Survey. I. Global statistics and properties of the 13CO emission data
• The Metallicity Dependence of the HI Shielding Layers in Nearby Galaxies
• The molecular gas mass of M33
• Probabilistic detection of spectral line components
• An ATCA Survey of HI Absorption in the Magellanic Clouds I: HI Gas Temperature Measurements in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Relationship between the Line Width of the Atomic and Molecular ISM in M33
• A High-Resolution, Dust-Selected Molecular Cloud Catalogue of M33, the Triangulum Galaxy
• Tracing the Formation of Molecular Clouds in a Low-Metallicity Galaxy: A HI Narrow Self-Absorption Survey of the Large Magellanic Cloud
• CLOVER: Convnet Line-fitting Of Velocities in Emission-line Regions

Cited by in corpus (12)

• PHANGS-JWST First Results: Tracing the Diffuse ISM with JWST Imaging of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Emission in Nearby Galaxies
• The atomic-to-molecular hydrogen transition in the TNG50 simulation: Using realistic UV fields to create spatially resolved HI maps
• Stellar feedback in M83 as observed with MUSE -- I. Overview, an unprecedented view of the stellar and gas kinematics and evidence of outflowing gas
• The dynamic centres of infrared-dark clouds and the formation of cores
• Kinematic analysis of the super-extended HI disk of the nearby spiral galaxy M83
• The Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array Local Group L-band Survey (LGLBS)
• Dust around massive stars is agnostic to galactic environment: New insights from PHAT/BEAST
• Testing the Momentum-driven Supernova Feedback Paradigm in M31
• The HASHTAG project: The First Submillimeter Images of the Andromeda Galaxy from the Ground
• Investigating variations in the dust emissivity index in the Andromeda galaxy
• FEASTS and MHONGOOSE: HI Column Density Distribution at $z=0$ for $N_{\mathrm{HI}}>10^{17.8}{\mathrm{cm}}^{-2}$
• Supernova origin of galactic turbulence revealed by superbubbles