Optically thick HI does not dominate dark gas in the local ISM

Abstract

The local interstellar medium (ISM) is suffused with "dark" gas, identified by excess infrared and gamma ray emission, yet undetected by standard ISM tracers such as neutral hydrogen (HI) or carbon monoxide emission. Based on observed dust properties from Planck, recent studies have argued that HI mixed with dust is strongly saturated and that dark gas is dominated by optically-thick HI. We test this hypothesis by reproducing this model using data from Planck and new 21 cm emission maps from GALFA-HI -- the first large-area 21cm emission survey with comparable angular resolution to Planck. We compare the results with those from a large sample of HI column densities based on direct observations of HI optical depth, and find that the inferred column density corrections are significantly lower than those inferred by the Planck-based model. Further, we rule out the hypothesis that the pencil-beam HI absorption sight lines preferentially miss opaque "blobs" with small covering fraction, as these structures require densities and pressures which are incompatible with ISM conditions. Our results support the picture that excess dust emission in the local ISM is not dominated by optically-thick HI, but is rather a combination of intrinsic changes in dust grain emissivities and H2 missed by CO observations.

arXiv comment10 pages, 7 figures; ApJ accepted

References in corpus (42)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
• The Leiden/Argentine/Bonn (LAB) Survey of Galactic HI: Final data release of the combined LDS and IAR surveys with improved stray-radiation corrections
• The Milky Way in Molecular Clouds: A New Complete CO Survey
• Planck 2013 results. XI. All-sky model of thermal dust emission
• The Dark Molecular Gas
• The Millennium Arecibo 21-CM Absorption Line Survey. II. Properties of the Warm and Cold Neutral Media
• A Full-Sky H-alpha Template for Microwave Foreground Prediction
• Planck Early Results: All sky temperature and dust optical depth from Planck and IRAS: Constraints on the "dark gas" in our galaxy
• Ultraviolet Survey of CO and H_2 in Diffuse Molecular Clouds: The Reflection of Two Photochemistry Regimes in Abundance Relationships
• The GALFA-HI Survey: Data Release 1
• The Millennium Arecibo 21-cm Absorption Line Survey. I. Techniques and Gaussian Fits
• Planck intermediate results. XVII. Emission of dust in the diffuse interstellar medium from the far-infrared to microwave frequencies
• A Herschel [C II] Galactic plane survey II: CO-dark H2 in clouds
• Abundances and Behavior of 12CO, 13CO, and C2 in Translucent Sight Lines
• Planck intermediate results. XXIX. All-sky dust modelling with Planck, IRAS, and WISE observations
• Changes Of Dust Opacity With Density in the Orion A Molecular Cloud
• The CO luminosity and CO-H2 conversion factor of diffuse ISM: does CO emission trace dense molecular gas?
• Dust variations in the diffuse interstellar medium: constraints on Milky Way dust from Planck-HFI observations
• Dark gas in the solar neighnorhood from extinction data
• The 21-SPONGE HI Absorption Survey I: Techniques and Initial Results
• Fitting Together the HI Absorption and Emission in the SGPS
• Cold and Warm Atomic Gas around the Perseus Molecular Cloud. II. The Impact of High Optical Depth on the HI Column Density Distribution and Its Implication for the HI-to-H2 Transition
• Optically thick HI dominant in the local interstellar medium; an alternative interpretation to "dark gas"
• Cosmic rays, gas and dust in nearby anticentre clouds : I -- CO-to-H2 conversion factors and dust opacities
• The Local Leo Cold Cloud and New Limits on a Local Hot Bubble
• Cold and warm atomic gas around the Perseus molecular cloud I: Basic Properties
• E(B-V), N(H I) and N(H_2)
• Imaging diffuse clouds: Bright and dark gas mapped in CO
• HI, CO, and Planck/IRAS dust properties in the high-latitude-cloud complex, MBM 53, 54, 55 and HLCG 92-35; Possible evidence for an optically thick HI envelope around the CO clouds
• Dust models post-Planck: constraining the far-infrared opacity of dust in the diffuse interstellar medium
• The temperature of the diffuse HI in the Milky Way I: High resolution HI 21 cm absorption studies
• Spatial and Temporal Variations in Small-Scale Galactic HI Structure Toward 3C~138
• Variations between Dust and Gas in the Diffuse Interstellar Medium
• Accurate measurement of the HI column density from HI 21cm absorption-emission spectroscopy
• Recovering interstellar gas properties with HI spectral lines: A comparison between synthetic spectra and 21-SPONGE
• Synthetic Observations of 21cm HI Line Profiles from Inhomogeneous Turbulent Interstellar HI Gas with Magnetic Field
• Spatial Variations in Galactic H I Structure on AU-Scales Toward 3C 147 Observed with the Very Long Baseline Array
• A High Galactic Latitude HI 21cm-line Absorption Survey using the GMRT: II. Results and Interpretation
• Variations between Dust and Gas in the Diffuse Interstellar Medium. 3. Changes in Dust Properties
• Variations between Dust and Gas in the Diffuse Interstellar Medium. 2. Search for Cold Gas

Cited by in corpus (32)

• Tracing the total molecular gas in galaxies: [CII] and the CO-dark gas
• Photodissociation and X-Ray Dominated Regions
• Mapping the Magnetic Interstellar Medium in Three Dimensions Over the Full Sky with Neutral Hydrogen
• On the Three-Dimensional Structure of Local Molecular Clouds
• The Physical Nature of Neutral Hydrogen Intensity Structure
• ROHSA: Regularized Optimization for Hyper-Spectral Analysis - Application to phase separation of 21 cm data
• The HI/OH/Recombination line survey of the inner Milky Way (THOR): data release 2 and HI overview
• THEMIS 2.0: A self-consistent model for dust extinction, emission, and polarisation
• HI filaments are cold and associated with dark molecular gas. HI4PI based estimates of the local diffuse CO-dark H2 distribution
• Demonstration of magnetic field tomography with starlight polarization towards a diffuse sightline of the ISM
• The Quest for the Missing Dust: II -- Two Orders of Magnitude of Evolution in the Dust-to-Gas Ratio Resolved Within Local Group Galaxies
• Extracting the cold neutral medium from HI emission with deep learning: Implications for Galactic foregrounds at high latitude
• Exploring the properties of warm and cold atomic hydrogen in the Taurus and Gemini regions
• The essential elements of dust evolution: A viable solution to the interstellar oxygen depletion problem?
• On the accuracy of HI observations in molecular clouds -- More cold HI than thought?
• A lack of constraints on the cold opaque HI mass: HI spectra in M31 and M33 prefer multi-component models over a single cold opaque component
• Small-Scale HI Channel Map Structure is Cold: Evidence from Na I Absorption at High Galactic Latitudes
• An Unbiased CO Survey Toward the Northern Region of the Small Magellanic Cloud with the Atacama Compact Array. I. Overview: CO Cloud Distributions
• Observational Evidence for a Thick Disk of Dark Molecular Gas in the Outer Galaxy
• Fermi-LAT gamma-ray study of the interstellar medium and cosmic rays in the Chamaeleon Molecular-Cloud Complex: A look at the dark gas as optically thick HI
• Turbulent power distribution in the local interstellar medium
• Kinetic tomography of the Galactic plane within 1.25 kiloparsecs from the Sun. The interstellar flows revealed by HI and CO line emission and 3D dust
• Giant Molecular Cloud Formation at the Interface of Colliding Supershells in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Gas and Cosmic-Ray Properties in the MBM 53, 54, and 55 Molecular Clouds and the Pegasus Loop as Revealed by HI Line Profiles, Dust, and Gamma-Ray Data
• Probing local cosmic rays using Fermi-LAT observation of a mid-latitude region in the third Galactic quadrant
• "Dust Giant": Extended and Clumpy Star-Formation in a Massive Dusty Galaxy at $z=1.38$
• The MeerKAT Absorption Line Survey (MALS) data release 3: Cold atomic gas associated with the Milky Way
• Shocks and Molecules in Diffuse Interstellar Cloud Pairs
• Dust evolution: going beyond the empirical
• Description of turbulent dynamics in the interstellar medium: Multifractal microcanonical analysis: II. Sparse filtering of Herschel observation maps and visualization of filamentary structures at different length scales
• The MACH HI absorption survey I: Physical conditions of cold atomic gas outside of the Galactic plane
• Tidal disruption of "snow clouds" by unassociated stars