Are the Milky Way and Andromeda unusual? A comparison with Milky Way and Andromeda Analogs

Abstract

Our Milky Way provides a unique test case for galaxy evolution models, thanks to our privileged position within the Milky Way's disc. This position also complicates comparisons between the Milky Way and external galaxies, due to our inability to observe the Milky Way from an external point of view. Milky Way analog galaxies offer us a chance to bridge this divide by providing the external perspective that we otherwise lack. However, over-precise definitions of "analog" yield little-to-no galaxies, so it is vital to understand which selection criteria produce the most meaningful analog samples. To address this, we compare the properties of complementary samples of Milky Way analogs selected using different criteria. We find the Milky Way to be within 1$\sigma$ of its analogs in terms of star-formation rate and bulge-to-total ratio in most cases, but we find larger offsets between the Milky Way and its analogs in terms of disc scale length; this suggests that scale length must be included in analog selections in addition to other criteria if the most accurate analogs are to be selected. We also apply our methodology to the neighbouring Andromeda galaxy. We find analogs selected on the basis of strong morphological features to display much higher star-formation rates than Andromeda, and we also find analogs selected on Andromeda's star-formation rate to over-predict Andromeda's bulge extent. This suggests both structure and star-formation rate should be considered when selecting the most stringent Andromeda analogs.

arXiv comment13 pages, 11 figures. Accepted by MNRAS

References in corpus (113)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Technical Summary
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Galaxy Evolution Explorer: A Space Ultraviolet Survey Mission
• The Formation of Galactic Disks
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• Overview of the SDSS-IV MaNGA Survey: Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory
• UV Star Formation Rates in the Local Universe
• The Galaxy in Context: Structural, Kinematic and Integrated Properties
• The reversal of the star formation-density relation in the distant universe
• Color Separation of Galaxy Types in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Imaging Data
• Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV: Mapping the Milky Way, Nearby Galaxies, and the Distant Universe
• Quantifying the bimodal color-magnitude distribution of galaxies
• The Eighth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Data from SDSS-III
• CIGALE: a python Code Investigating GALaxy Emission
• The merger that led to the formation of the Milky Way's inner stellar halo and thick disk
• Nearly 5000 Distant Early-Type Galaxies in COMBO-17: a Red Sequence and its Evolution since z~1
• Galaxy Luminosity Functions to z~1: DEEP2 vs. COMBO-17 and Implications for Red Galaxy Formation
• Co-formation of the Galactic disc and the stellar halo
• The Tenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the SDSS-III Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• Analysis of galaxy SEDs from far-UV to far-IR with CIGALE: Studying a SINGS test sample
• The Chemical Evolution of the Galaxy: the two-infall model
• The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): first data release
• The GALAH Survey: Scientific Motivation
• The Green Valley is a Red Herring: Galaxy Zoo reveals two evolutionary pathways towards quenching of star formation in early- and late-type galaxies
• Galaxy Zoo 2: detailed morphological classifications for 304,122 galaxies from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• A Catalog of Bulge+Disk Decompositions and Updated Photometry for 1.12 Million Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Chemical Cartography with APOGEE: Metallicity Distribution Functions and the Chemical Structure of the Milky Way Disk
• Dust Attenuation Curves in the Local Universe: Demographics and New Laws for Star-forming Galaxies and High-redshift Analogs
• Improved background subtraction for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey images
• LAMOST Experiment for Galactic Understanding and Exploration (LEGUE) The survey science plan
• The age structure of stellar populations in the solar vicinity. Clues of a two-phase formation history of the Milky Way disk
• Structure and Kinematics of Early-Type Galaxies from Integral-Field Spectroscopy
• The Arecibo Legacy Fast ALFA Survey: The ALFALFA Extragalactic HI Source Catalog
• Improved Estimates of the Milky Way's Stellar Mass and Star Formation Rate from Hierarchical Bayesian Meta-Analysis
• A direct dynamical measurement of the Milky Way's disk surface density profile, disk scale length, and dark matter profile at 4 kpc < R < 9 kpc
• GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Star Formation Rates, Stellar Masses and Dust Attenuations of 700,000 Low-redshift Galaxies
• First GLIMPSE Results on the Stellar Structure of the Galaxy
• Mapping the Three-Dimensional Density of the Galactic Bulge with VVV Red Clump Stars
• The formation and assembly history of the Milky Way revealed by its globular cluster population
• Homogeneous Velocity-Distance Data for Peculiar Velocity Analysis. III. The Mark III Catalog of Galaxy Peculiar Velocities
• Toward a Unification of Star Formation Rate Determinations in the Milky Way and Other Galaxies
• Two Red Clumps and the X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge
• The Milky Way has no thick disk
• The Milky Way: An Exceptionally Quiet Galaxy; Implications for the formation of spiral galaxies
• Multicomponent Decompositions for a Sample of S0 galaxies
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: the Galactic Thick to Thin Disc transition
• The long bar as seen by the VVV survey: I. Colour-magnitude diagrams
• Chemodynamics of the Milky Way. I. The first year of APOGEE data
• Chemodynamical history of the Galactic Bulge
• Stellar mass map and dark matter distribution in M31
• Dynamical Blueprints for Galaxies
• Tracing chemical evolution over the extent of the Milky Way's Disk with APOGEE Red Clump Stars
• The Luminosity Profile and Structural Parameters of the Andromeda Galaxy
• On the Formation of Galactic Thick Disks
• The age-metallicity structure of the Milky Way disk
• On the origin of the chemical bimodality of disk stars: A tale of merger and migration
• From the bulge to the outer disc: StarHorse stellar parameters, distances, and extinctions for stars in APOGEE DR16 and other spectroscopic surveys
• A Census of Oxygen in Star-Forming Galaxies: An Empirical Model Linking Metallicities, Star Formation Rates and Outflows
• Investigating the Andromeda Stream: I. Simple Analytic Bulge-Disk-Halo Model for M31
• Dusty waves on a starry sea: the mid-infrared view of M31
• VVV Survey Near-Infrared Photometry of Known Bulge RR Lyrae stars: the Distance to the Galactic Center and Absence of a Barred Distribution of the Metal-Poor Population
• Extended HI Rotation Curve and Mass Distribution of M31
• A 2-3 billion year old major merger paradigm for the Andromeda galaxy and its outskirts
• Origin of chemically distinct discs in the Auriga cosmological simulations
• The Andromeda galaxy's most important merger about 2 billion years ago as M32's likely progenitor
• Galaxy Zoo: comparing the demographics of spiral arm number and a new method for correcting redshift bias
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: the chemical structure of the Galactic discs from the first internal data release
• Galaxy Zoo: Evidence for Diverse Star Formation Histories through the Green Valley
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: Global stellar population and gradients for about 2000 early-type and spiral galaxies on the mass-size plane
• Milky Way vs Andromeda: a tale of two disks
• The GALAH survey: An abundance, age, and kinematic inventory of the solar neighbourhood made with TGAS
• Galaxy Zoo: Secular evolution of barred galaxies from structural decomposition of multi-band images
• The origin of diverse $\alpha$-element abundances in galaxy discs
• The Near-infrared S0 Survey III: Morphology of 15 Southern Early-type Disk Galaxies
• SDSS IV MaNGA - The spatially resolved transition from star formation to quiescence
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Global stellar populations on the size-mass plane
• A radial age gradient in the geometrically thick disk of the Milky Way
• Unveiling the Boxy Bulge and Bar of the Andromeda Spiral Galaxy
• A panoramic view of the Milky Way analogue NGC 891
• The Formation Times and Building Blocks of Milky Way-mass Galaxies in the FIRE Simulations
• The Nature and Origin of Substructure in the Outskirts of M31 -- II. Detailed Star Formation Histories
• The mid-life crisis of the Milky Way and M31
• Ages and masses of million Galactic disk main sequence turn-off and sub-giant stars from the LAMOST Galactic spectroscopic surveys
• Unveiling the Milky Way: A New Technique for Determining the Optical Color and Luminosity of our Galaxy
• A resolved analysis of cold dust and gas in the nearby edge-on spiral NGC 891
• Ages and Masses of 0.64 million Red Giant Branch stars from the LAMOST Galactic Spectroscopic Survey
• An Ultraviolet Study of Star-Forming Regions in M31
• Age Demographics of the Milky Way Disk and Bulge
• The Information Of The Milky Way From 2MASS Whole Sky Star Count: The Structure Parameters
• The bimodal [Mg/Fe] versus [Fe/H] bulge sequence as revealed by APOGEE DR14
• Box/Peanut and Bar structures in edge-on and face-on SDSS nearby galaxies I. Catalogue
• A Global Star Forming Episode in M31 2-4 Gyr Ago
• Scalelength of disc galaxies
• The Tully-Fisher Relation for 25,000 SDSS Galaxies as Function of Environment
• Forming Lenticular Galaxies via Violent Disk Instability
• Galaxy Zoo: star-formation versus spiral arm number
• Milky Way Analogues in MaNGA: Multi-Parameter Homogeneity and Comparison to the Milky Way
• Does the Milky Way Obey Spiral Galaxy Scaling Relations?
• Cosmological insights into the assembly of the radial and compact stellar halo of the Milky Way
• Sizing Up the Milky Way: A Bayesian Mixture Model Meta-Analysis of Photometric Scale Length Measurements
• From the Outside Looking in: What can Milky Way Analogues Tell us About the Star Formation Rate of Our Own Galaxy?
• The scaling relation between baryonic mass and stellar disc size of morphologically late-type galaxies
• Structural Analogs of the Milky Way Galaxy: Stellar Populations in the Boxy Bulges of NGC 4565 and NGC 5746
• The Milky Way and Andromeda galaxies in a constrained hydrodynamical simulation: morphological evolution
• The Effect of Bars on the Ionized ISM: Optical Emission Lines from Milky Way Analogs
• On the Mass Assembly History of the Local Group
• Gas accretion in Milky Way-like galaxies: temporal and radial dependencies
• Probing Galactic Structure with the Spatial Correlation Function of SEGUE G-dwarf Stars

Cited by in corpus (19)

• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: the third and final data release
• Dark Matter Constraints from a Unified Analysis of Strong Gravitational Lenses and Milky Way Satellite Galaxies
• The Star Formation Rate of the Milky Way as seen by Herschel
• The abundance of satellites around Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with the TNG50 simulation: a matter of diversity
• Mapping the Galactic Metallicity Gradient with Open Clusters: The State-of-the-Art and Future Challenges
• The merger and assembly histories of Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with TNG50: disk survival through mergers
• The Milky Way tomography with APOGEE: intrinsic density distribution and structure of mono-abundance populations
• SDSS IV MaNGA: Bar pattern speed in Milky Way Analogue galaxies
• Cold and Hot gas distribution around the Milky-Way-M31 system in the HESTIA simulations
• Searching for Milky Way twins: Radial abundance distribution as a strict criterion
• Constraining the Milky Way's Ultraviolet to Infrared SED with Gaussian Process Regression
• Time evolution of the galactic $B-\rho$ relation: the impact of the magnetic field morphology
• A Galactic Self-Portrait: Density Structure and Integrated Properties of the Milky Way Disk
• Dark Matter Velocity Distributions for Direct Detection: Astrophysical Uncertainties are Smaller Than They Appear
• Simulations of the accreted stellar halos of low-mass field galaxies
• Interrelations between Astrochemistry and Galactic Dynamics
• NGC 3521 as the Milky Way near twin: spectral energy distribution from UV to radio decameter ranges
• High and low Sérsic index bulges in Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies: origin and connection to the bar with TNG50
• How to Build an Empirical Speed Distribution for Dark Matter in the Solar Neighborhood