Challenges in designing appropriate scaffolding to improve students' representational consistency: The case of a Gauss's law problem

Abstract

Prior research suggest that introductory physics students have difficulty with graphing and interpreting graphs. Here, we discuss an investigation of student difficulties in translating between mathematical and graphical representations for a problem in electrostatics and the effect of increasing levels of scaffolding on students' representational consistency. Students in calculus-based introductory physics were given a typical problem that can be solved using Gauss's law involving a spherically symmetric charge distribution in which they were asked to write a mathematical expression for the electric field in various regions and then plot the electric field. In study 1, we found that students had great difficulty in plotting the electric field as a function of the distance from the center of the sphere consistent with the mathematical expressions in various regions, and interviews with students suggested possible reasons which may account for this difficulty. Therefore, in study 2, we designed two scaffolding interventions with levels of support which built on each other (i.e., the second scaffolding level built on the first) in order to help students plot their expressions consistently and compared the performance of students provided with scaffolding with a comparison group which was not given any scaffolding support. Analysis of student performance with different levels of scaffolding reveals that scaffolding from an expert perspective beyond a certain level may sometimes hinder student performance and students may not even discern the relevance of the additional support. We provide possible interpretations for these findings based on in-depth, think-aloud interviews.

arXiv comment14 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (20)

• Students' Understanding of Direct Current Resistive Electrical Circuits
• When physical intuition fails
• Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part II: Effect of Some Potential Factors on Problem Solving and Transfer
• Impact of peer interaction on conceptual test performance
• Categorization of Quantum Mechanics Problems by Professors and Students
• Student understanding of symmetry and Gauss's law of electricity
• Assessing Expertise in Introductory Physics Using Categorization Task
• Using Isomorphic Problems to Learn Introductory Physics
• Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part I: Performance on Non-intuitive Problem Pair from Introductory Physics
• Using an Isomorphic Problem Pair to Learn Introductory Physics: Transferring from a Two-step Problem to a Three-step Problem
• Improving performance in quantum mechanics with explicit incentives to correct mistakes
• Using Categorization of Problems as an Instructional Tool to Help Introductory Students Learn Physics
• Categorization of problems to assess and improve proficiency as teachers and learners
• Challenges in Analogical Reasoning
• To use or no to use diagrams: The effect of drawing a diagram in solving introductory physics problems
• Students' Difficulties with Equations involving Circuit Elements
• Developing a Magnetism Conceptual Survey and Assessing Gender Differences in Student Understanding of Magnetism
• Improving Students' Conceptual Understanding of Conductors and Insulators
• Improving Student Understanding of Coulomb's Law and Gauss's Law
• Should Students be Provided Diagrams or Asked to Draw Them While Solving Introductory Physics Problems?

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Helping students become proficient problem solvers Part I: A brief review
• Do students benefit from drawing productive diagrams themselves while solving introductory physics problems? The case of two electrostatic problems
• Development and Validation of a conceptual survey instrument to evaluate introductory physics students' understanding of thermodynamics
• Holistic framework to help students learn effectively from research-validated self-paced learning tools
• Development and validation of a conceptual multiple-choice survey instrument to assess student understanding of introductory thermodynamics
• Using the Conceptual Survey of Electricity and Magnetism to investigate progression in student understanding from introductory to advanced levels
• Using multiple representations to improve student understanding of quantum states
• Impact of Guided Inquiry with Simulations on Knowledge of Electricity and Wave Phenomena
• Case study examining graduate student sensemaking using the epistemic game framework for Laplace's equation in upper-level electrostatics
• Using the Energy and Momentum Conceptual Survey to investigate progression in student understanding from introductory to advanced levels
• Perspectives of Women and Men Students and Faculty on Conceptual and Quantitative Problem-Solving in Physics from Introductory to Graduate Levels
• Instructor Framing and Incentives Shape Physics Students' Engagement and Learning Gains from an Inquiry-Based Electrostatics Tutorial on the Method of Images
• What does it mean to think like a physicist? Insights from physics graduate students