When physical intuition fails

Abstract

We analyze the problem solving strategies of physics professors in a case where their physical intuition fails. A non-intuitive introductory-level problem was identified and posed to twenty physics professors. The problem placed the professors in a situation often encountered by students, and their response highlights the importance of intuition and experience in problem solving. While professors had difficulty in solving the problem under the time constraint, they initially employed a systematic approach, e.g., visualizing the problem, considering various conservation laws, and examining limiting cases. After finding that familiar techniques were not fruitful, they made incorrect predictions based on one of two equally important factors. By contrast, other more familiar problems that require the consideration of two important principles (e.g., conservation of both energy and momentum for a ballistic pendulum) are quickly solved by the same professors. The responses of students who were given the same problem reflected no overarching strategies or systematic approaches, and a much wider variety of incorrect responses were given. This investigation highlights the importance of teaching effective problem solving heuristics, and suggests that instructors assess the difficulty of a problem from the perspective of beginning students.

7 pages, PACS: 01.40Fk,01.40.gb,01.40G-,1.30.Rr; keywords: physics education research, expertise, intuition, problem solving, expert-novice differences, non-intuitive problem

Cited by in corpus (27)

• Multiple-choice test of energy and momentum concepts
• A Framework for Understanding the Patterns of Student Reasoning Difficulties in Quantum Mechanics
• Helping students learn effective problem solving strategies by reflecting with peers
• Assessing Expertise in Introductory Physics Using Categorization Task
• Do evidence-based active-engagement courses reduce the gender gap in introductory physics?
• Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part I: Performance on Non-intuitive Problem Pair from Introductory Physics
• Challenges in designing appropriate scaffolding to improve students' representational consistency: The case of a Gauss's law problem
• Improving performance in quantum mechanics with explicit incentives to correct mistakes
• Helping students become proficient problem solvers Part I: A brief review
• Categorization of problems to assess and improve proficiency as teachers and learners
• Surveying college introductory physics students' attitudes and approaches to problem solving
• Development and Validation of a conceptual survey instrument to evaluate introductory physics students' understanding of thermodynamics
• Surveying Turkish high school and university student attitudes and approaches to physics problem solving
• Holistic framework to help students learn effectively from research-validated self-paced learning tools
• Case of two electrostatics problems: Can providing a diagram adversely impact introductory physics students' problem solving performance?
• Improving student understanding of quantum mechanics underlying the Stern-Gerlach experiment using a research-validated multiple-choice question sequence
• The challenges of changing teaching assistants' grading practices: Requiring students to show evidence of understanding
• Development and validation of a conceptual multiple-choice survey instrument to assess student understanding of introductory thermodynamics
• Teaching assistants' beliefs regarding example solutions in introductory physics
• Evaluating GPT- and Reasoning-based Large Language Models on Physics Olympiad Problems: Surpassing Human Performance and Implications for Educational Assessment
• Impact of evidence-based flipped or active-engagement non-flipped courses on student performance in introductory physics
• Instructional Strategies that Foster Effective Problem-Solving
• A Framework for Understanding the Impact of Integrating Conceptual and Quantitative Reasoning in a Quantum Optics Tutorial on Students' Conceptual Understanding
• Centripetal Acceleration: Often Forgotten or Misinterpreted
• Case study examining graduate student sensemaking using the epistemic game framework for Laplace's equation in upper-level electrostatics
• An impulse to the ground to end rolling with slipping
• What does it mean to think like a physicist? Insights from physics graduate students