The Milky Way's stellar streams and globular clusters do not align in a Vast Polar Structure

Abstract

There is increasing evidence that a substantial fraction of Milky Way satellite galaxies align in a rotationally-supported plane of satellites, a rare configuration in cosmological simulations of galaxy formation. It has been suggested that other Milky Way substructures (namely young halo globular clusters and stellar/gaseous streams) similarly tend to align with this plane, accordingly dubbed the Vast Polar Structure (VPOS). Using systemic proper motions inferred from Gaia data, we find that globular cluster orbital poles are not clustered in the VPOS direction, though the population with the highest VPOS membership fraction is the young halo clusters (~30%). We additionally provide a current census of stellar streams, including new streams discovered using the Dark Energy Survey and Gaia datasets, and find that stellar stream normals are also not clustered in the direction of the VPOS normal. We also find that, based on orbit modeling, there is a likely association between NGC 3201 and the Gjöll stellar stream and that, based on its orbital pole, NGC 4147 is likely not a Sagittarius globular cluster. That the Milky Way's accreted globular clusters and streams do not align in the same planar configuration as its satellites suggests that the plane of satellites is either a particularly stable orbital configuration or a population of recently accreted satellites. Neither of these explanations is particularly likely in light of other recent studies, leaving the plane of satellites problem as one of the more consequential open problems in galaxy formation and cosmology.

10+8 pages, 4 figures, 4+5 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (110)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• galpy: A Python Library for Galactic Dynamics
• Small-Scale Challenges to the $\Lambda$CDM Paradigm
• A 2MASS All-Sky View of the Sagittarius Dwarf Galaxy: I. Morphology of the Sagittarius Core and Tidal Arms
• Detection of the gravitational redshift in the orbit of the star S2 near the Galactic centre massive black hole
• The Proper Motion of Sgr A*: II. The Mass of Sgr A*
• Gaia Data Release 2: Kinematics of globular clusters and dwarf galaxies around the Milky Way
• Are the Magellanic Clouds on their First Passage about the Milky Way?
• The Faintest Dwarf Galaxies
• The Sagittarius Dwarf Galaxy: a Model for Evolution in a Triaxial Milky Way Halo
• A Vast Thin Plane of Co-rotating Dwarf Galaxies Orbiting the Andromeda Galaxy
• Detection of massive tidal tails around the globular cluster Pal 5 with SDSS commissioning data
• Mean proper motions, space orbits and velocity dispersion profiles of Galactic globular clusters derived from Gaia DR2 data
• Vertical waves in the solar neighbourhood in Gaia DR2
• Origin of the system of globular clusters in the Milky Way
• The great disk of Milky-Way satellites and cosmological sub-structures
• The total mass of the Large Magellanic Cloud from its perturbation on the Orphan stream
• The VPOS: a vast polar structure of satellite galaxies, globular clusters and streams around the Milky Way
• The extended tails of Palomar 5: A ten degree arc of globular cluster tidal debris
• The Anisotropic Distribution of Galactic Satellites
• Proper motions and dynamics of the Milky Way globular cluster system from Gaia DR2
• The properties of Galactic globular cluster sub-systems
• Stellar Streams Discovered in the Dark Energy Survey
• The Origin of the Magellanic Stream and Its Leading Arm
• Gaia DR2 Proper Motions of Dwarf Galaxies within 420 kpc: Orbits, Milky Way Mass, Tidal Influences, Planar Alignments, and Group Infall
• Four New Stellar Debris Streams in the Galactic Halo
• Probing the Outer Galactic halo with RR Lyrae from the Catalina Surveys
• The Parkes HI Survey of the Magellanic System
• The Origin of the Bifurcation in the Sagittarius Stream
• The spatial distribution of the Milky Way and Andromeda satellite galaxies
• Ghostly Tributaries to the Milky Way: Charting the Halo's Stellar Streams with the Gaia DR2 catalogue
• A whirling plane of satellite galaxies around Centaurus A challenges cold dark matter cosmology
• Small Dwarf Galaxies Within Larger Dwarfs: Why Some Are Luminous While Most Go Dark
• The 200 Degree-Long Magellanic Stream System
• The rotationally stabilized VPOS and predicted proper motions of the Milky Way satellite galaxies
• The Streams of the Gaping Abyss: A population of entangled stellar streams surrounding the Inner Galaxy
• Co-orbiting satellite galaxy structures are still in conflict with the distribution of primordial dwarf galaxies
• The orbital poles of Milky Way satellite galaxies: a rotationally supported disc-of-satellites
• Detection of a 45 Degree Tidal Stream Associated with the Globular Cluster NGC 5466
• The Three-Dimensional Structure of the M31 Satellite System; Strong Evidence for an Inhomogeneous Distribution of Satellites
• Substructure in Tidal Streams; Tributaries in the Anticenter Ring
• Discovery of a New, Polar-Orbiting Debris Stream in the Milky Way Stellar Halo
• A 22 Degree Tidal Tail for Palomar 5
• The Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem, Suggested Solutions, and Open Questions
• The preferred direction of infalling satellite galaxies in the Local Group
• Tracing Sagittarius Structure with SDSS and SEGUE Imaging and Spectroscopy
• The Southern Stellar Stream Spectroscopic Survey ($S^5$): Overview, Target Selection, Data Reduction, Validation, and Early Science
• A Synoptic Map of Halo Substructures from the Pan-STARRS1 3π Survey
• The Milky Way's Disk of Classical Satellite Galaxies in Light of Gaia DR2
• Velocity anti-correlation of diametrically opposed galaxy satellites in the low redshift universe
• Discovery of $\sim$ 9,000 new RR Lyrae in the Southern Catalina Surveys
• Evidence for a Milky Way Tidal Stream Reaching Beyond 100 kpc
• A thousand shadows of Andromeda: rotating planes of satellites in the Millennium-II cosmological simulation
• Stellar Streams and Clouds in the Galactic Halo
• Planes of satellite galaxies: when exceptions are the rule
• Discs of Satellites: the new dwarf spheroidals
• Did the Milky Way dwarf satellites enter the halo as a group?
• The PAndAS Field of Streams: stellar structures in the Milky Way halo toward Andromeda and Triangulum
• Absolute HST Proper Motion (HSTPROMO) of Distant Milky Way Globular Clusters: Galactocentric Space Velocities and the Milky Way Mass
• A Cold Milky Way Stellar Stream in the Direction of Triangulum
• The Link between Galactic Satellite Orbits and Subhalo Accretion
• The new Milky Way satellites: alignment with the VPOS and predictions for proper motions and velocity dispersions
• Fourteen candidate RR Lyrae star streams in the inner Galaxy
• On the persistence of two small-scale problems in ΛCDM
• The Spatial Distribution of Galactic Satellites in the LCDM Cosmology
• Proper Motions of Stellar Streams Discovered in the Dark Energy Survey
• The multiplicity and anisotropy of galactic satellite accretion
• Stray, swing and scatter: angular momentum evolution of orbits and streams in aspherical potentials
• Serendipitous Discovery of a Thin Stellar Stream near the Galactic Bulge in the Pan-STARRS1 3Pi Survey
• A new spin on disks of satellite galaxies
• Tidal tails around the outer halo globular clusters Eridanus and Palomar 15
• TriAnd and its Siblings: Satellites of Satellites in the Milky Way Halo
• Phlegethon, a nearby $75°$-long retrograde stellar stream
• Chemo-dynamical properties of the Anticenter Stream: a surviving disc fossil from a past satellite interaction
• Evolution of galactic planes of satellites in the EAGLE simulation
• Are rotating planes of satellite galaxies ubiquitous?
• The Vast Polar Structure of the Milky Way Attains New Members
• The Role of Baryons in Creating Statistically Significant Planes of Satellites around Milky Way-Mass Galaxies
• A Disk Origin for the Monoceros Ring and A13 Stellar Overdensities
• Detection of a 50 degree-long Trailing Tidal Tail for the Globular Cluster M5
• Discovery of a Stellar Overdensity in Eridanus-Phoenix in the Dark Energy Survey
• Evidence for Early Filamentary Accretion from the Andromeda Galaxy's Thin Plane of Satellites
• The velocity anisotropy of the Milky Way satellite system
• Another Look at the EBS: A Stellar Debris Stream and a Possible Progenitor
• Eppur si muove: Positional and kinematic correlations of satellite pairs in the low Z universe
• Co-orbiting planes of sub-halos are similarly unlikely around paired and isolated hosts
• An extended Pal 5 stream in Gaia DR2
• A spectroscopic study of the Globular Cluster NGC 4147
• Exploring the outskirts of globular clusters: the peculiar kinematics of NGC 3201
• On the Stability of Satellite Planes I: Effects of Mass, Velocity, Halo Shape and Alignment
• Phase-space correlation in stellar streams of the Milky Way halo: The clash of Kshir and GD-1
• Characterizing the Infall Times and Quenching Timescales of Milky Way Satellites with $Gaia$ Proper Motions
• Two New Halo Debris Streams in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Detection of a Nearby Halo Debris Stream in the WISE and 2MASS Surveys
• At a Crossroads: Stellar Streams in the South Galactic Cap
• Quasar Lenses and Galactic Streams: Outlier Selection and GAIA Multiplet Detection
• Do halos that form early, have high concentration, are part of a pair, or contain a central galaxy potential host more pronounced planes of satellite galaxies?
• Update on the Cetus Polar Stream and its Progenitor
• Cresting the wave: Proper motions of the Eastern Banded Structure
• Spatial Distribution of Globular Clusters in the Galaxy
• Discovery of a thin stellar stream in the SLAMS survey
• Stability of Satellite Planes in M31 II: Effects of the Dark Subhalo Population
• Tails from the Orphanage
• A Cold Stellar Stream in Pegasus
• GCN: a gaseous Galactic halo stream?
• A Magellanic origin for the Virgo substructure
• An analysis of satellite planar configurations around the MW and M31: singling out new high quality planes

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Selecting accreted populations: metallicity, elemental abundances, and ages of the Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus and Sequoia populations
• $S^5$: The Orbital and Chemical Properties of One Dozen Stellar Streams
• A Low-Mass Stellar-Debris Stream Associated with a Globular Cluster Pair in the Halo
• Orbital Clustering Identifies the Origins of Galactic Stellar Streams
• Planes of satellites around Milky Way/M31-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations and comparisons with the Local Group
• Broken into Pieces: ATLAS and Aliqa Uma as One Single Stream
• Six More Ultra-Faint Milky Way Companions Discovered in the DECam Local Volume Exploration Survey
• The Clustering of Orbital Poles Induced by the LMC: Hints for the Origin of Planes of Satellites
• The Pristine Dwarf-Galaxy survey -- III. Revealing the nature of the Milky Way globular cluster Sagittarius II
• Purveyors of fine halos. II. Chemodynamical association of halo stars with Milky Way globular clusters
• Shapes of Milky-Way-Mass Galaxies with Self-Interacting Dark Matter
• Phase-space Properties and Chemistry of the Sagittarius Stellar Stream Down to the Extremely Metal-poor ($[Fe/H]\lesssim -3$) Regime
• Discovery of a new nearby globular cluster with extreme kinematics located in the extension of a halo stream
• A chemo-dynamical link between the Gjöll stream and NGC 3201
• The e-TidalGCs Project: Modeling the extra-tidal features generated by Galactic globular clusters
• An updated detailed characterization of planes of satellites in the MW and M31
• Planes of satellites around simulated disc galaxies: I.- Finding high-quality planar configurations from positional information and their comparison to MW/M31 data
• $S^5$: The destruction of a bright dwarf galaxy as revealed by the chemistry of the Indus stellar stream
• ED-2: a cold but not so narrow stellar stream crossing the Solar neighbourhood
• Charting Galactic Accelerations with Stellar Streams and Machine Learning
• Classifying the satellite plane membership of Centaurus A's dwarf galaxies using orbital alignment constraints
• Efficient and accurate force replay in cosmological-baryonic simulations
• Galaxy archaeology for wet mergers: Globular cluster age distributions in the Milky Way and nearby galaxies
• Identifying substructure associations in the Milky Way halo using chemo-kinematic tagging
• Discovery of rotation axis alignments in Milky Way globular clusters
• Identification of a dwarf galaxy stream in Gaia, and its possible association with the VPOS structure
• From the Fire: A Deeper Look at the Phoenix Stream
• Investigating the origin of the Milky Way streams. A revised look at their orbital pole distribution in light of precession effects