Where Are We With Light Sterile Neutrinos?

Abstract

We review the status of searches for sterile neutrinos in the $\sim 1$ eV range, with an emphasis on the latest results from short baseline oscillation experiments and how they fit within sterile neutrino oscillation models. We present global fit results to a three-active-flavor plus one-sterile-flavor model (3+1), where we find an improvement of $\Delta {\chi }^2=35$ for 3 additional parameters compared to a model with no sterile neutrino. This is a 5$\sigma$ improvement, indicating that an effect that is like that of a sterile neutrino is highly preferred by the data. However we note that separate fits to the appearance and disappearance oscillation data sets within a 3+1 model do not show the expected overlapping allowed regions in parameter space. This "tension" leads us to explore two options: 3+2, where a second additional mass state is introduced, and a 3+1+decay model, where the ${\nu }_4$ state can decay to invisible particles. The 3+1+decay model, which is also motivated by improving compatibility with cosmological observations, yields the larger improvement, with a $\Delta {\chi }^2=8$ for 1 additional parameter beyond the 3+1 model, which is a $2.6\sigma$ improvement. Moreover the tension between appearance and disappearance experiments is reduced compared to 3+1, although disagreement remains. In these studies, we use a frequentist approach and also a Bayesean method of finding credible regions. With respect to this tension, we review possible problems with the global fitting method. We note multiple issues, including problems with reproducing the experimental results, especially in the case of experiments that do not provide adequate data releases. We discuss an unexpected 5 MeV excess, observed in the reactor flux energy spectrum, that may be affecting the oscillation interpretation of the short baseline reactor data. We emphasize the care that must be taken in mapping to the true neutrino energy in the case of oscillation experiments that are subject to multiple interaction modes and nuclear effects. We point to problems with the "Parameter-Goodness-of-Fit test" that is used to quantify the tension. Lastly, we point out that analyses presenting limits often receive less scrutiny that signals. While we provide a snapshot of the status of sterile neutrino searches today and global fits to their interpretation, we emphasize that this is a fast-moving field. We briefly review experiments that are expected to report new data in the immediate future. Lastly, we consider the 5-year horizon, where we propose that decay-at-rest neutrino sources are the best method of finally resolving the confusing situation.

arXiv comment52 pages, 36 figures. Corrected typos in Fig 12 and Table III, plus other minor corrections

References in corpus (128)

• emcee: The MCMC Hammer
• Evidence for oscillation of atmospheric neutrinos
• First Results from KamLAND: Evidence for Reactor Anti-Neutrino Disappearance
• A 2.4% Determination of the Local Value of the Hubble Constant
• The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly
• Parallel Tempering: Theory, Applications, and New Perspectives
• Improved Predictions of Reactor Antineutrino Spectra
• On the determination of anti-neutrino spectra from nuclear reactors
• The IceCube Neutrino Observatory: Instrumentation and Online Systems
• First observation of PeV-energy neutrinos with IceCube
• Measurements of the Solar Neutrino Flux from Super-Kamiokande's First 300 Days
• Global analysis of three-flavour neutrino oscillations: synergies and tensions in the determination of theta_23, delta_CP, and the mass ordering
• The trouble with $H_0$
• From eV to EeV: Neutrino Cross Sections Across Energy Scales
• Measurement of the solar neutrino capture rate with gallium metal. III: Results for the 2002--2007 data-taking period
• Measurement of the solar neutrino capture rate with gallium metal
• Neutrinos in cosmology
• Improved Search for ${\bar{\nu }}_{\mu }\to {\bar{\nu }}_e$ Oscillations in the MiniBooNE Experiment
• Observation and Characterization of a Cosmic Muon Neutrino Flux from the Northern Hemisphere using six years of IceCube data
• Sterile Neutrino Oscillations: The Global Picture
• A Search for Electron Neutrino Appearance at the Delta m**2 ~ 1 eV**2 Scale
• The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory
• Reanalysis of the GALLEX solar neutrino flux and source experiments
• Significant Excess of ElectronLike Events in the MiniBooNE Short-Baseline Neutrino Experiment
• The angular distribution of the reaction ${\bar{\nu }}_e+p\to e^{+}+n$
• Design and Construction of the MicroBooNE Detector
• Non-adiabatic Level Crossing in Resonant Neutrino Oscillations
• Updated global analysis of neutrino oscillations in the presence of eV-scale sterile neutrinos
• Sterile neutrino search at NEOS Experiment
• The Neutrino Flux prediction at MiniBooNE
• Upper limits for neutrino oscillations muon-antineutrino to electron-antineutrino from muon decay at rest
• Prompt neutrino fluxes from atmospheric charm
• Observation of Energy and Baseline Dependent Reactor Antineutrino Disappearance in the RENO Experiment
• Measurement of the Reactor Antineutrino Flux and Spectrum at Daya Bay
• A ménage à trois of eV-scale sterile neutrinos, cosmology, and structure formation
• Searches for Sterile Neutrinos with the IceCube Detector
• Search for nu(mu)-->nu(e) Oscillations in the NOMAD Experiment
• Search for sterile neutrinos at the DANSS experiment
• Evolution of the Reactor Antineutrino Flux and Spectrum at Daya Bay
• Observation of Two-Neutrino Double-Beta Decay in Xe-136 with EXO-200
• Sterile neutrinos with eV masses in cosmology -- how disfavoured exactly?
• Measurement of Muon Neutrino Quasi-Elastic Scattering on Carbon
• Low reheating temperature and the visible sterile neutrino
• How secret interactions can reconcile sterile neutrinos with cosmology
• Search for sterile neutrinos in MINOS and MINOS+ using a two-detector fit
• Dipole portal to heavy neutral leptons
• The Short-Baseline Neutrino Program at Fermilab
• Status of Light Sterile Neutrino Searches
• Search for sterile neutrino mixing using three years of IceCube DeepCore data
• Limits on sterile neutrino mixing using atmospheric neutrinos in Super-Kamiokande
• Active to sterile neutrino mixing limits from neutral-current interactions in MINOS
• Constraints on Galactic Neutrino Emission with Seven Years of IceCube Data
• Final NOMAD results on nu_mu->nu_tau and nu_e->nu_tau oscillations including a new search for nu_tau appearance using hadronic tau decays
• Neutrinos And Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
• The hadronic interaction model Sibyll-2.3c and inclusive lepton fluxes
• Testing the statistical compatibility of independent data sets
• Ruling out four-neutrino oscillation interpretations of the LSND anomaly?
• First search for short-baseline neutrino oscillations at HFIR with PROSPECT
• New Physics in Astrophysical Neutrino Flavor
• DUNE as the Next-Generation Solar Neutrino Experiment
• Precision Measurements with High Energy Neutrino Beams
• The Detector System of The Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment
• Calibration of Super-Kamiokande Using an Electron Linac
• Convolutional Neural Networks Applied to Neutrino Events in a Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber
• Explaining LSND by a decaying sterile neutrino
• Solar neutrinos and neutrino physics
• Dark Matter Search in a Proton Beam Dump with MiniBooNE
• Sterile Neutrino Constraints from the STEREO Experiment with 66 days of Reactor-on Data
• Dual baseline search for muon neutrino disappearance at 0.5 eV^2 < Δm^2 < 40 eV^2
• Lorentz- and CPT-violating models for neutrino oscillations
• Probing the LSND scale and four neutrino scenarios with a neutrino telescope
• Sterile Neutrinos: Cosmology vs Short-BaseLine Experiments
• An improved measurement of muon antineutrino disappearance in MINOS
• Probing Non-Standard Interaction of Neutrinos with IceCube and DeepCore
• On The Vacuum Oscillation Solution of The Solar Neutrino Problem
• Search for Sterile Neutrinos Mixing with Muon Neutrinos in MINOS
• A Deep Neural Network for Pixel-Level Electromagnetic Particle Identification in the MicroBooNE Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber
• First Constraints on the Complete Neutrino Mixing Matrix with a Sterile Neutrino
• Sterile Neutrinos in Light of Recent Cosmological and Oscillation Data: a Multi-Flavor Scheme Approach
• Dual baseline search for muon antineutrino disappearance at 0.1 eV^2 < Δm^2 < 100 eV^2
• Toward precision measurements in solar neutrinos
• Sterile Neutrinos with Secret Interactions -- Cosmological Discord?
• Measurement of ${\theta }_{13}$ in Double Chooz using neutron captures on hydrogen with novel background rejection techniques
• Search for anomalies in the νe appearance from a νμ beam
• Collisional production of sterile neutrinos via secret interactions and cosmological implications
• The 5 MeV bump - a nuclear whodunit mystery
• Large scale Gd-beta-diketonate based organic liquid scintillator production for antineutrino detection
• Astrophysical neutrinos flavored with Beyond the Standard Model physics
• Constraining Sterile Neutrinos with AMANDA and IceCube Atmospheric Neutrino Data
• Sterile Neutrino Fits to Short Baseline Data
• Improved Constraints on Sterile Neutrinos in the MeV to GeV Mass Range
• Radiative corrections to low energy neutrino reactions
• First Observation of Low Energy Electron Neutrinos in a Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber
• Impact of nonstandard interactions on sterile neutrino searches at IceCube
• Limits on Electron Neutrino Disappearance from the KARMEN and LSND electron neutrino - Carbon Cross Section Data
• Neutrino oscillations in low density medium
• Activating the 4th Neutrino of the 3+1 Scheme
• Mapping systematic errors in helium abundance determinations using Markov Chain Monte Carlo
• Measurement of the Antineutrino Spectrum from ${}^{235}$U Fission at HFIR with PROSPECT
• A Sterile Neutrino Origin for the Upward Directed Cosmic Ray Showers Detected by ANITA
• Cosmological constraints with self-interacting sterile neutrinos
• Exploring a Non-Minimal Sterile Neutrino Model Involving Decay at IceCube and Beyond
• New limits on heavy sterile neutrino mixing in ${}^8\mathrm{B}$-decay obtained with the Borexino detector
• First Measurement of Monoenergetic Muon Neutrino Charged Current Interactions
• Sterile Neutrinos and Flavor Ratios in IceCube
• Diagnosing the Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly with Global Antineutrino Flux Data
• First Measurement of the Ar$(e,e^{\prime })X$ Cross Section at Jefferson Lab
• Unitarity Bounds of Astrophysical Neutrinos
• Cosmic tau neutrino detection via Cherenkov signals from air showers from Earth-emerging taus
• First Measurement of ${\nu }_{\mu }$ and ${\nu }_e$ Events in an Off-Axis Horn-Focused Neutrino Beam
• Non-Unitary Neutrino Propagation From Neutrino Decay
• Searches for new physics at the Hyper-Kamiokande experiment
• MiniBooNE, MINOS+ and IceCube data imply a baroque neutrino sector
• Observing EeV neutrinos through the Earth: GZK and the anomalous ANITA events
• High intensity cyclotrons for neutrino physics
• Search for the disappearance of muon antineutrinos in the NuMI neutrino beam
• On the robustness of IceCube's bound on sterile neutrinos in the presence of non-standard interactions
• Assessing the role of nuclear effects in the interpretation of the MiniBooNE low-energy anomaly
• The Not-So-Sterile 4th Neutrino: Constraints on New Gauge Interactions from Neutrino Oscillation Experiments
• Active-sterile neutrino oscillations at INO-ICAL over a wide mass-squared range
• Optimizing the ${}^8$Li yield for the IsoDAR Neutrino Experiment
• Describing neutrino oscillations in matter with Magnus expansion
• A Decisive Disappearance Search at High-$\Delta m^2$ with Monoenergetic Muon Neutrinos
• IceCube bounds on sterile neutrinos above 10 eV
• Results of a search for 2$\beta$-decay of ${}^{136}$Xe with high-pressure copper proportional counters in Baksan Neutrino Observatory
• On the IceCube Result on ${\bar{\nu }}_{\mu }\to {\bar{\nu }}_s$ Oscillations
• Revisiting constraints on 3+1 active-sterile neutrino mixing using IceCube data
• Neutral Current ${\pi }^0$ Production in MiniBooNE

Cited by in corpus (82)

• 2020 Global reassessment of the neutrino oscillation picture
• Updated MiniBooNE Neutrino Oscillation Results with Increased Data and New Background Studies
• Sterile Neutrinos
• Results from the Baksan Experiment on Sterile Transitions (BEST)
• Improved Short-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Search and Energy Spectrum Measurement with the PROSPECT Experiment at HFIR
• A Search for Electron Neutrino Transitions to Sterile States in the BEST Experiment
• Reactor antineutrino anomaly in light of recent flux model refinements
• An eV-scale sterile neutrino search using eight years of atmospheric muon neutrino data from the IceCube Neutrino Observatory
• Relaxing Cosmological Neutrino Mass Bounds with Unstable Neutrinos
• Event Generators for High-Energy Physics Experiments
• Neutrino Flavor Conversions in High-Density Astrophysical and Cosmological Environments
• Bounds on light sterile neutrino mass and mixing from cosmology and laboratory searches
• The Future of High-Energy Astrophysical Neutrino Flavor Measurements
• Non-Reversible Parallel Tempering: a Scalable Highly Parallel MCMC Scheme
• The Future of Solar Neutrinos
• Flavor-dependent radiative corrections in coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering
• MicroBooNE and the ${\nu }_e$ Interpretation of the MiniBooNE Low-Energy Excess
• Sterile neutrino self-interactions: $H_0$ tension and short-baseline anomalies
• The physics potential of a reactor neutrino experiment with Skipper CCDs: Measuring the weak mixing angle
• Sterile Neutrinos and the Global Reactor Antineutrino Dataset
• Understanding the MiniBooNE and the muon and electron $g-2$ anomalies with a light $Z^{\prime }$ and a second Higgs doublet
• Non-unitary neutrino mixing in short and long-baseline experiments
• Large Extra Dimensions and neutrino experiments
• Search for an anomalous excess of charged-current quasi-elastic ${\nu }_e$ interactions with the MicroBooNE experiment using Deep-Learning-based reconstruction
• Explaining the MiniBooNE Excess Through a Mixed Model of Oscillation and Decay
• Two-Higgs doublet solution to the LSND, MiniBooNE and muon $g-2$ anomalies
• Neutrino-4 anomaly: oscillations or fluctuations?
• How to Identify Different New Neutrino Oscillation Physics Scenarios at DUNE
• Minimal dark energy: key to sterile neutrino and Hubble constant tensions?
• Cosmology-friendly time-varying neutrino masses via the sterile neutrino portal
• Neutrino Physics Opportunities with the IsoDAR Source at Yemilab
• Sterile Neutrino Searches with MicroBooNE: Electron Neutrino Disappearance
• Sterile Neutrino Shape-shifting Caused by Dark Matter
• Solutions to the MiniBooNE Anomaly from New Physics in Charged Meson Decays
• Leptonic Unitarity Triangles
• Explaining the MiniBooNE Anomalous Excess via Leptophilic ALP-Sterile Neutrino Coupling
• Gallium Anomaly: Critical View from the Global Picture of ${\nu }_e$ and ${\bar{\nu }}_e$ Disappearance
• Searching for Sterile Neutrino with X-ray Intensity Mapping
• Shedding New Light on Sterile Neutrinos from XENON1T Experiment
• Constraints on Decaying Sterile Neutrinos from Solar Antineutrinos
• Two sides of the same coin: sterile neutrinos and dark radiation. Status and perspectives
• Cosmological search for sterile neutrinos after Planck 2018
• Inspection of the detection cross section dependence of the Gallium Anomaly
• Pseudoscalar sterile neutrino self-interactions in light of Planck, SPT and ACT data
• Impact of Wave Packet Separation in Low-Energy Sterile Neutrino Searches
• Dark sectors in neutron-shining-through-a-wall and nuclear absorption signals
• Order-of-Magnitude Beam Current Improvement in Compact Cyclotrons
• A search for an eV-scale sterile neutrino using improved high-energy ${\nu }_{\mu }$ event reconstruction in IceCube
• Flavors of Astrophysical Neutrinos with Active-Sterile Mixing
• Addressing the Short-Baseline Neutrino Anomalies with Energy-Dependent Mixing Parameters
• Neutrinos from Primordial Black Holes in Theories with Extra Dimensions
• Requirements on common solutions to the LSND and MiniBooNE excesses: a post-MicroBooNE study
• Constraining super-light sterile neutrinos at Borexino and KamLAND
• A new analysis of the MiniBooNE low-energy excess
• Improved sensitivities of ESS$\nu$SB from a two-detector fit
• $B-L$ model with $A_4\times Z_3\times Z_4$ symmetry for $3+1$ active$-$sterile neutrino mixing
• Search for an Anomalous Production of Charged-Current ${\nu }_e$ Interactions Without Visible Pions Across Multiple Kinematic Observables in MicroBooNE
• A 17 MeV pseudoscalar and the LSND, MiniBooNE and ATOMKI anomalies
• First Search for Unstable Sterile Neutrinos with the IceCube Neutrino Observatory
• Cascade Appearance Signatures of Sterile Neutrinos at 1-100 TeV
• Methods and stability tests associated with the sterile neutrino search using improved high-energy ${\nu }_{\mu }$ event reconstruction in IceCube
• Light Sterile Neutrinos
• Signal processing and spectral modeling for the BeEST experiment
• The implication of $J/\psi \to (\gamma +)\mathrm{invisible}$ for the effective field theories of neutrino and dark matter
• Search for a light sterile neutrino with 7.5 years of IceCube DeepCore data
• Exploring the new physics phases in 3+1 scenario in neutrino oscillation experiments
• Search for Hidden Neutrinos at the European Spallation Source: the SHiNESS experiment
• Lepton masses and mixings, and muon anomalous magnetic moment in an extended $B-L$ model with type I seesaw mechanism
• Neutrino Energy Estimation in Neutral Current Interactions and Prospects for Sterile Neutrino Searches
• New physics at nuSTORM
• Quasi-Sterile Neutrinos from Dark Sectors I. BSM matter effects in neutrino oscillations and the short-baseline anomalies
• Neutrino interactions in liquid scintillators including active-sterile neutrino mixing
• Wilks's Theorem, Global Fits, and Neutrino Oscillations
• A Frequentist Simulation-Based Inference Treatment of Sterile Neutrino Global Fits
• Exploration of mass splitting and muon/tau mixing parameters for an eV-scale sterile neutrino with IceCube
• Invisible neutron decay and light BSM particles
• Sterile sector impacting the correlations and degeneracies among mixing parameters at the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment
• Closing the Neutrino "BSM Gap": Physics Potential of Atmospheric Through-Going Muons at DUNE
• A chiral model for sterile neutrino
• Status and Perspectives of Neutrino Physics
• νOscillation: a software package for computation and simulation of neutrino propagation and interaction
• Dirac CP phases in a 3+1 neutrino scenario with $\mu -\tau$ symmetry