Neutrino-4 anomaly: oscillations or fluctuations?

Abstract

We present a deep study of the Neutrino-4 data aimed at finding the statistical significance of the large-mixing short-baseline neutrino oscillation signal claimed by the Neutrino-4 collaboration at more than $3\sigma$. We found that the results of the Neutrino-4 collaboration can be reproduced approximately only by neglecting the effects of the energy resolution of the detector. Including these effects, we found that the best fit is obtained for a mixing that is even larger, close to maximal, but the statistical significance of the short-baseline neutrino oscillation signal is only about $2.7\sigma$ if evaluated with the usual method based on Wilks' theorem. We show that the large Neutrino-4 mixing is in strong tension with the KATRIN, PROSPECT, STEREO, and solar ${\nu }_e$ bounds. Using a more reliable Monte Carlo simulation of a large set of Neutrino-4-like data, we found that the statistical significance of the Neutrino-4 short-baseline neutrino oscillation signal decreases to about $2.2\sigma$. We also show that it is not unlikely to find a best-fit point that has a large mixing, even maximal, in the absence of oscillations. Therefore, we conclude that the claimed Neutrino-4 indication in favor of short-baseline neutrino oscillations with very large mixing is rather doubtful.

arXiv comment12 pages. Final version to be published in Physics Letters B

References in corpus (25)

• Evidence for Neutrino Oscillations from the Observation of Electron Anti-neutrinos in a Muon Anti-Neutrino Beam
• The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly
• Significant Excess of ElectronLike Events in the MiniBooNE Short-Baseline Neutrino Experiment
• Measurement of electron antineutrino oscillation with 1958 days of operation at Daya Bay
• Measurement of Reactor Antineutrino Oscillation Amplitude and Frequency at RENO
• First Double Chooz ${\theta }_{13}$ Measurement via Total Neutron Capture Detection
• Status of Light Sterile Neutrino Searches
• Update of Short-Baseline Electron Neutrino and Antineutrino Disappearance
• eV-scale Sterile Neutrinos
• Reactor Neutrino Spectra
• Where Are We With Light Sterile Neutrinos?
• Short-Baseline Active-Sterile Neutrino Oscillations?
• Improved Sterile Neutrino Constraints from the STEREO Experiment with 179 Days of Reactor-On Data
• Addendum to: Global constraints on absolute neutrino masses and their ordering
• Phenomenology of light sterile neutrinos: a brief review
• Testing the very-short-baseline neutrino anomalies at the solar sector
• Reactor antineutrino fluxes - status and challenges
• An estimate of theta_14 independent of the reactor antineutrino flux determinations
• Matter Effects in Active-Sterile Solar Neutrino Oscillations
• Statistical Significance of Reactor Antineutrino Active-Sterile Oscillations
• Statistical interpretation of sterile neutrino oscillation searches at reactors
• Searches for sterile neutrinos at very short baseline reactor experiments
• Statistical Methods Applied to the Search of Sterile Neutrinos
• A Comment on the note arXiv:2006.13147 on arXiv:2005.05301, "Preparation of the Neutrino-4 experiment on search for sterile neutrino and the obtained results of measurements"
• Note on arXiv:2005.05301, 'Preparation of the Neutrino-4 experiment on search for sterile neutrino and the obtained results of measurements'

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Results from the Baksan Experiment on Sterile Transitions (BEST)
• Experiment Neutrino-4 search for sterile neutrino and results of measurements
• A Search for Electron Neutrino Transitions to Sterile States in the BEST Experiment
• Reactor antineutrino anomaly in light of recent flux model refinements
• Statistical significance of the sterile-neutrino hypothesis in the context of reactor and gallium data
• First constraints on light sterile neutrino oscillations from combined appearance and disappearance searches with the MicroBooNE detector
• Non-unitary neutrino mixing in short and long-baseline experiments
• Search for sterile neutrino oscillation using RENO and NEOS data
• Testing sterile neutrino mixing with present and future solar neutrino data
• BEST Impact on Sterile Neutrino Hypothesis
• Sterile Neutrino Searches with MicroBooNE: Electron Neutrino Disappearance
• Gallium Anomaly: Critical View from the Global Picture of ${\nu }_e$ and ${\bar{\nu }}_e$ Disappearance
• Two sides of the same coin: sterile neutrinos and dark radiation. Status and perspectives
• Inspection of the detection cross section dependence of the Gallium Anomaly
• Reactor antineutrino flux and anomaly
• Review of sterile neutrino searches at very short-baseline reactor experiments
• Improved sensitivities of ESS$\nu$SB from a two-detector fit
• Light Sterile Neutrinos
• Exploring the new physics phases in 3+1 scenario in neutrino oscillation experiments
• Baseline and other effects for a sterile neutrino at DUNE
• Status and Perspectives of Neutrino Physics
• Low-energy neutrino responses for 71Ga by electron capture rates, charge exchange reactions and shell model calculations
• Significance of classically forbidden regions for short baseline neutrino experiments