On the AGB stars of M 4: A robust disagreement between spectroscopic observations and theory

Abstract

Several recent spectroscopic investigations have presented conflicting results on the existence of Na-rich asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars in the Galactic globular cluster M4 (NGC6121). The studies disagree on whether or not Na-rich red giant branch (RGB) stars evolve to the AGB. For a sample of previously published HER- MES/AAT AGB and RGB stellar spectra we present a re-analysis of O, Na, and Fe abundances, and a new analysis of Mg and Al abundances; we also present CN band strengths for this sample, derived from low-resolution AAOmega spectra. Following a detailed literature comparison, we find that the AGB samples of all studies consistently show lower abundances of Na and Al, and are weaker in CN, than RGB stars in the cluster. This is similar to recent observations of AGB stars in NGC 6752 and M 62. In an attempt to explain this result, we present new theoretical stellar evolutionary models for M 4; however, these predict that all stars, including Na-rich RGB stars, evolve onto the AGB. We test the robustness of our abundance results using a variety of atmospheric models and spectroscopic methods; however, we do not find evidence that systematic modelling uncertainties can explain the apparent lack of Na- rich AGB stars in M4. We conclude that an unexplained, but robust, discordance between observations and theory remains for the AGB stars in M 4.

arXiv comment25 pages, 21 figures, 15 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (60)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• Extragalactic Globular Clusters and Galaxy Formation
• Multiple populations in globular clusters. Lessons learned from the Milky Way globular clusters
• Na-O Anticorrelation and HB. VII. The chemical composition of first and second-generation stars in 15 globular clusters from GIRAFFE spectra
• An absolutely calibrated effective temperature scale from the InfraRed Flux Method
• The effective temperature scale of FGK stars. II. Teff : color : [Fe/H] calibrations
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. VII. Relative Ages
• Ultraviolet Radiation from Evolved Stellar Populations -- I. Models
• A new implementation of the infrared flux method using the 2MASS catalogue
• Non-LTE calculations for neutral Na in late-type stars using improved atomic data
• Spectroscopic and Photometric evidence of two stellar populations in the Galactic Globular Cluster NGC6121 (M4)
• The Anglo-Australian Observatory's 2dF Facility
• Horizontal Branch Stars: The Interplay between Observations and Theory, and Insights into the Formation of the Galaxy
• A helium spread among the main sequence stars in NGC 2808
• Early Disc Accretion as the Origin of Abundance Anomalies in Globular Clusters
• Helium variation due to self-pollution among Globular Cluster stars: consequences on the horizontal branch morphology
• Star-to-Star Abundance Variations among Bright Giants in the Mildly Metal-Poor Globular Cluster M4
• Multiple stellar populations in 47 Tucanae
• The White Dwarf Cooling Sequence of the Globular Cluster Messier 4
• ARES v2 - new features and improved performance
• Performance of AAOmega: the AAT multi-purpose fibre-fed spectrograph
• Low-temperature gas opacity - AESOPUS: a versatile and quick computational tool
• Non-LTE line formation of Fe in late-type stars - III. 3D non-LTE analysis of metal-poor stars
• Evolution and Nucleosynthesis of Extremely Metal Poor & Metal-Free Low- and Intermediate-Mass Stars I: Stellar Yield Tables and the CEMPs
• The SUMO project I. A survey of multiple populations in globular clusters
• Non-LTE aluminium abundances in late-type stars
• Non-LTE oxygen line formation in 3D hydrodynamic model stellar atmospheres
• Sodium-Oxygen anticorrelation among Horizontal Branch Stars in the Globular Cluster M4
• Mass loss on the red giant branch: the value and metallicity dependence of Reimers' η in globular clusters
• Towards stellar effective temperatures and diameters at one per cent accuracy for future surveys
• High Precision Differential Abundance Measurements in Globular Clusters: Chemical Inhomogeneities in NGC 6752
• Systematic NLTE study of the -2.6 < [Fe/H] < 0.2 F and G dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood. I. Stellar atmosphere parameters
• Effective temperature determinations of late-type stars based on 3D non-LTE Balmer line formation
• Sodium content as a predictor of the advanced evolution of globular cluster stars
• Detection of solar-like oscillations in relics of the Milky Way: asteroseismology of K giants in M4 using data from the NASA K2 mission
• Inelastic O+H collisions and the OI 777nm solar centre-to-limb variation
• The helium content of globular clusters: NGC6121 (M4)
• A New Reddening Law for M4
• Direct Evidence for an Enhancement of Helium in Giant Stars in Omega Centauri
• The Stagger-grid: A Grid of 3D Stellar Atmosphere Models - II. Horizontal and Temporal Averaging and Spectral Line Formation
• Photometry and spectroscopy of multiple populations along the AGB of NGC2808 and NGC6121 (M4)
• Evolution of long-lived globular cluster stars III. Effect of the initial helium spread on the position of stars in a synthetic Hertzsprung-Russell diagram
• Lithium abundances in red giants of M4: evidence for asymptotic giant branch star pollution in globular clusters?
• The treatment of mixing in core helium burning models -- III. Suppressing core breathing pulses with a new constraint on overshoot
• Observing multiple stellar populations with FORS2@VLT - Main sequence photometry in outer regions of NGC 6752, NGC 6397, and NGC 6121 (M 4)
• Why Hot Horizontal Branch Stars Can Appear Redder Than Red Giants
• Clear evidence for the presence of second-generation asymptotic giant branch stars in metal-poor Galactic globular clusters
• On the missing second generation AGB stars in NGC6752
• Chemical analysis of Asymptotic Giant Branch stars in M62
• Sodium abundances of AGB and RGB stars in Galactic globular clusters II. Analysis and results of NGC 104, NGC 6121 and NGC 6809
• An extreme paucity of second population AGB stars in the normal globular cluster M4
• On the necessity of composition-dependent low-temperature opacity in metal-poor AGB stars
• A phenomenological modification of thermohaline mixing in globular cluster red giants
• Lost and found: evidence of Second Generation stars along the Asymptotic Giant Branch of the globular cluster NGC 6752
• The growth of helium burning cores
• Multiple populations along the asymptotic giant branch of the globular cluster M 4
• Cyanogen in NGC 1851 RGB and AGB Stars: Quadrimodal Distributions
• Constraints on Helium Enhancement in the Globular Cluster M4 (NGC 6121): The Horizontal Branch Test
• NGC 6752 AGB Stars Revisited: I. Improved AGB temperatures remove apparent overionisation of Fe I
• AGB subpopulations in the nearby globular cluster NGC 6397

Cited by in corpus (7)

• What is a globular cluster? An observational perspective
• Integrated Mass Loss of Evolved Stars in M4 using Asteroseismology
• The GALAH Survey: Chemically tagging the Fimbulthul stream to the globular cluster $\omega$ Centauri
• Fluorine Abundances in the Globular Cluster M 4
• Confirming the presence of second population stars and the iron discrepancy along the AGB of the globular cluster NGC 6752
• Nonlinear Color-Metallicity Relations of Globular Clusters. X. Subaru/FOCAS Multi-object Spectroscopy of M87 Globular Clusters
• Matching seismic masses for RR Lyrae-type and oscillating red horizontal-branch stars in M4