NGC 6752 AGB Stars Revisited: I. Improved AGB temperatures remove apparent overionisation of Fe I

Abstract

A recent study reported a strong apparent depression of Fe I, relative to Fe II, in the AGB stars of NGC 6752. This depression is much greater than that expected from the neglect of non-local thermodynamic equilibrium effects, in particular the dominant effect of overionisation. Here we attempt to reproduce the apparent Fe discrepancy, and investigate differences in reported sodium abundances. We compare in detail the methods and results of the recent study with those of an earlier study of NGC 6752 AGB stars. Iron and sodium abundances are derived using Fe I, Fe II, and Na I lines. Various uncertainties are explored. We reproduce the large Fe I depression found by the recent study, using different observational data and computational tools. Further investigation shows that the degree of the apparent Fe I depression is strongly dependent on the adopted stellar effective temperature. To minimise uncertainties in Fe I we derive temperatures for each star individually using the infrared flux method (IRFM). We find that the $T_{\mathrm{eff}}$ scales used by both the previous studies are cooler, by up to 100 K; such underestimated temperatures amplify the apparent Fe I depression. Our IRFM temperatures result in negligible apparent depression, consistent with theory. We also re-derived sodium abundances and, remarkably, found them to be unaffected by the new temperature scale. [Na/H] in the AGB stars is consistent between all studies. Since Fe is constant, it follows that [Na/Fe] is also consistent between studies, apart from any systematic offsets in Fe. We recommend the use of $(V-K)$ relations for AGB stars. We plan to investigate the effect of the improved temperature scale on other elements, and re-evaluate the subpopulation distributions on the AGB, in the next paper of this series. [abridged]

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (54)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• Multiple populations in globular clusters. Lessons learned from the Milky Way globular clusters
• An absolutely calibrated effective temperature scale from the InfraRed Flux Method
• An Analysis of the Shapes of Interstellar Extinction Curves. V. The IR-Through-UV Curve Morphology
• A Triple Main Sequence in the Globular Cluster NGC 2808
• Intrinsic iron spread and a new metallicity scale for Globular Clusters
• Homogeneous Photometry for Star Clusters and Resolved Galaxies. II. Photometric Standard Stars
• The effective temperature scale of FGK stars. II. Teff : color : [Fe/H] calibrations
• Properties of stellar generations in Globular Clusters and relations with global parameters
• Ultraviolet Radiation from Evolved Stellar Populations -- I. Models
• A new implementation of the infrared flux method using the 2MASS catalogue
• Non-LTE calculations for neutral Na in late-type stars using improved atomic data
• NLTE line formation of Fe in late-type stars II: 1D spectroscopic stellar parameters
• Distances and ages of NGC 6397, NGC 6752 and 47 Tuc
• A helium spread among the main sequence stars in NGC 2808
• Helium variation due to self-pollution among Globular Cluster stars: consequences on the horizontal branch morphology
• The second and third parameters of the Horizontal Branch in Globular Clusters
• Hot Horizontal-Branch Stars: The Ubiquitous Nature of the "Jump" in Stromgren u, Low Gravities, and the Role of Radiative Levitation of Metals
• New Analyses of Star-to-Star Abundance Variations Among Bright Giants in the Mildly Metal-Poor Globular Cluster M5
• Both accurate and precise gf-values for FeII lines
• Abundances in giant stars of the globular cluster NGC 6752
• Sodium-Oxygen anticorrelation among Horizontal Branch Stars in the Globular Cluster M4
• Fe I Oscillator Strengths for the Gaia-ESO Survey
• Na-O Anticorrelation and HB. II. The Na-O anticorrelation in the globular cluster NGC 6752
• CNO abundances in the globular clusters NGC 1851 and NGC 6752
• Sodium content as a predictor of the advanced evolution of globular cluster stars
• Chemical tagging of three distinct populations of red giants in the globular cluster NGC 6752
• A Comparison of Stellar Elemental Abundance Techniques and Measurements
• Helium and Multiple Populations in the Massive Globular Cluster NGC6266 (M62)
• The Stagger-grid: A Grid of 3D Stellar Atmosphere Models - II. Horizontal and Temporal Averaging and Spectral Line Formation
• The treatment of mixing in core helium burning models -- II. Constraints from cluster star counts
• A New Feature Along the Extended Blue Horizontal Branch of NGC 6752
• AGB Sodium Abundances in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae (NGC 104)
• O and Na abundance patterns in open clusters of the Galactic disk
• The origin of the spurious iron spread in the globular cluster NGC 3201
• Evolution of long-lived globular cluster stars III. Effect of the initial helium spread on the position of stars in a synthetic Hertzsprung-Russell diagram
• O, Na, Ba and Eu abundance patterns in open clusters
• On the red giant branch mass loss in 47 Tucanae: Constraints from the horizontal branch morphology
• Influence of departures from LTE on calcium, titanium, and iron abundance determinations in cool giants of different metallicities
• Clear evidence for the presence of second-generation asymptotic giant branch stars in metal-poor Galactic globular clusters
• Nucleosynthesis in helium-enriched asymptotic giant branch models: Implications for Heavy Element Enrichment in Omega Centauri
• The Na-O anticorrelation in horizontal branch stars. V. NGC 6723
• On the missing second generation AGB stars in NGC6752
• Precise reddening and metallicity of NGC6752 from FLAMES spectra
• Chemical analysis of Asymptotic Giant Branch stars in M62
• An extreme paucity of second population AGB stars in the normal globular cluster M4
• Sodium abundances of AGB and RGB stars in galactic globular clusters I. Analysis and results of NGC 2808
• Microturbulent velocity from stellar spectra: a comparison between different approaches (Research Note)
• Lost and found: evidence of Second Generation stars along the Asymptotic Giant Branch of the globular cluster NGC 6752
• Multiple populations along the asymptotic giant branch of the globular cluster M 4
• Level of helium enhancement among M3's horizontal-branch stars
• First evidence of multiple populations along the AGB from Strömgren photometry
• Towards 21st Century Stellar Models: Star Clusters, Supercomputing, and Asteroseismology

Cited by in corpus (12)

• What is a globular cluster? An observational perspective
• Integrated Mass Loss of Evolved Stars in M4 using Asteroseismology
• The Hubble Space Telescope UV Legacy Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters - XIV. Multiple stellar populations within M 15 and their radial distribution
• Sodium abundances of AGB and RGB stars in Galactic globular clusters II. Analysis and results of NGC 104, NGC 6121 and NGC 6809
• The GALAH Survey: Chemically tagging the Fimbulthul stream to the globular cluster $\omega$ Centauri
• Multiple stellar populations in Asymptotic Giant Branch stars of Galactic Globular Clusters
• Multiple stellar populations of globular clusters from homogeneous Ca--CN photometry. III. NGC 6752
• On the AGB stars of M 4: A robust disagreement between spectroscopic observations and theory
• Four Metal-poor Stars in the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
• Slowly cooling white dwarfs in NGC 6752
• Confirming the presence of second population stars and the iron discrepancy along the AGB of the globular cluster NGC 6752
• AGB subpopulations in the nearby globular cluster NGC 6397