Revisiting the Cooling Flow Problem in Galaxies, Groups, and Clusters of Galaxies
arXiv:1803.04972 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/aabace
Abstract
We present a study of 107 galaxies, groups, and clusters spanning ~3 orders of magnitude in mass, ~5 orders of magnitude in central galaxy star formation rate (SFR), ~4 orders of magnitude in the classical cooling rate (dM/dt) of the intracluster medium (ICM), and ~5 orders of magnitude in the central black hole accretion rate. For each system in this sample, we measure dM/dt using archival Chandra X-ray data and acquire the SFR and systematic uncertainty in the SFR by combining over 330 estimates from dozens of literature sources. With these data, we estimate the efficiency with which the ICM cools and forms stars, finding e_cool = SFR/(dM/dt) = 1.4 +/- 0.4% for systems with dM/dt > 30 Msun/yr. For these systems, we measure a slope in the SFR-dM/dt relation greater than unity, suggesting that the systems with the strongest cool cores are also cooling more efficiently. We propose that this may be related to, on average, higher black hole accretion rates in the strongest cool cores, which could influence the total amount (saturating near the Eddington rate) and dominant mode (mechanical vs radiative) of feedback. For systems with dM/dt < 30 Msun/yr, we find that the SFR and dM/dt are uncorrelated, and show that this is consistent with star formation being fueled at a low (but dominant) level by recycled ISM gas in these systems. We find an intrinsic log-normal scatter in SFR at fixed dM/dt of 0.52 +/- 0.06 dex, suggesting that cooling is tightly self-regulated over very long timescales, but can vary dramatically on short timescales. There is weak evidence that this scatter may be related to the feedback mechanism, with the scatter being minimized (~0.4 dex) in systems for which the mechanical feedback power is within a factor of two of the cooling luminosity.
arXiv comment16 pages, 10 figures, 6 tables. Submitted to ApJ. Comments welcome!
References in corpus (97)
- The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
- Embedded Clusters in Molecular Clouds
- Observational Evidence of AGN Feedback
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
- Heating Hot Atmospheres with Active Galactic Nuclei
- Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
- Mid-Infrared Selection of Active Galaxies
- A Systematic Study of Radio-Induced X-ray Cavities in Clusters, Groups, and Galaxies
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
- Mechanical Feedback from Active Galactic Nuclei in Galaxies, Groups, and Clusters
- Dust-Corrected Star Formation Rates of Galaxies. II. Combinations of Ultraviolet and Infrared Tracers
- A deep Chandra observation of the Perseus cluster: shocks and ripples
- The Feedback-Regulated Growth of Black Holes and Bulges through Gas Accretion and Starbursts in Cluster Central Dominant Galaxies
- Intracluster Medium Entropy Profiles for a Chandra Archival Sample of Galaxy Clusters
- High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopic Constraints on Cooling-Flow Models for Clusters of Galaxies
- Quasar Feedback: More Bang for Your Buck
- X-ray Spectroscopy of Cooling Clusters
- The Evolution of X-ray Clusters and the Entropy of the Intra Cluster Medium
- An investigation of cooling flows and general cluster properties from an X-ray image deprojection analysis of 207 clusters of galaxies
- What is a Cool-Core Cluster? A Detailed Analysis of the Cores of the X-ray Flux-Limited HIFLUGCS Cluster Sample
- The ROSAT Brightest Cluster Sample (BCS): -- III. Optical spectra of the central cluster galaxies
- GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Star Formation Rates, Stellar Masses and Dust Attenuations of 700,000 Low-redshift Galaxies
- A ROSAT study of the cores of clusters of galaxies - I. Cooling flows in an X-ray flux-limited sample
- The detection of molecular gas in the central galaxies of cooling-flow clusters
- Radiative Efficiency and Content of Extragalactic Radio Sources: Toward a Universal Scaling Relation Between Jet Power and Radio Power
- Thermal Instability in Gravitationally-Stratified Plasmas: Implications for Multi-Phase Structure in Clusters and Galaxy Halos
- Thermal Instability & the Feedback Regulation of Hot Halos in Clusters, Groups, and Galaxies
- Cause and Effect of Feedback: Multiphase Gas in Cluster Cores Heated by AGN Jets
- Filaments, Bubbles, and Weak Shocks in the Gaseous Atmosphere of M87
- Stellar mass -- halo mass relation and star formation efficiency in high-mass halos
- An Infrared Survey of Brightest Cluster Galaxies. II: Why are Some Brightest Cluster Galaxies Forming Stars?
- Stellar Masses and SFRs for 1M Galaxies from SDSS and WISE
- Supermassive Black Holes in Elliptical Galaxies: Switching from Very Bright to Very Dim
- Regulation of star formation in giant galaxies by precipitation, feedback, and conduction
- Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): Mid-Infrared Properties and Empirical Relations from
- Thermal conduction and reduced cooling flows in galaxy clusters
- Raining on black holes and massive galaxies: the top-down multiphase condensation model
- On the Origin of the Extended Halpha Filaments in Cooling Flow Clusters
- The Growth of Cool Cores and Evolution of Cooling Properties in a Sample of 83 Galaxy Clusters at 0.3 < z < 1.2 Selected from the SPT-SZ Survey
- Cooling, AGN Feedback and Star Formation in Simulated Cool-Core Galaxy Clusters
- A Massive, Cooling-Flow-Induced Starburst in the Core of a Highly Luminous Galaxy Cluster
- Radio Bubbles in Clusters
- Cold, clumpy accretion onto an active supermassive black hole
- Radiative efficiency, variability and Bondi accretion onto massive black holes: from mechanical to quasar feedback in brightest cluster galaxies
- Mechanical AGN Feedback: Controlling the Thermodynamical Evolution of Elliptical Galaxies
- Shaken Snow Globes: Kinematic Tracers of the Multiphase Condensation Cascade in Massive Galaxies, Groups, and Clusters
- A Mechanism for Stimulating AGN Feedback by Lifting Gas in Massive Galaxies
- Extreme AGN feedback in the Massive Cluster Survey (MACS): a detailed study of X-ray cavities at z > 0.3
- Every BCG with a strong radio AGN has an X-ray cool core: is the cool core - noncool core dichotomy too simple?
- X-ray cavities in a sample of 83 SPT-selected clusters of galaxies: Tracing the evolution of AGN feedback in clusters of galaxies out to z=1.2
- The Remarkable Similarity of Massive Galaxy Clusters From z~0 to z~1.9
- Unifying the micro and macro properties of AGN feeding and feedback
- Chaotic cold accretion on to black holes in rotating atmospheres
- CLASH-X: A Comparison of Lensing and X-ray Techniques for Measuring the Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters
- A survey of molecular hydrogen in the central galaxies of cooling flows
- HST Observations of Vibrationally-Excited Molecular Hydrogen in Cluster Cooling Flow Nebulae
- Aromatic Features in AGN: Star-Forming Infrared Luminosity Function of AGN Host Galaxies
- ASCA and ROSAT observations of nearby cluster cooling flows
- The duty cycle of radio-mode feedback in complete samples of clusters
- Star-Forming Brightest Cluster Galaxies at 0.25 < z < 1.25: A Transitioning Fuel Supply
- The Relation Between Cool Cluster Cores and Herschel-Detected Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- The Effect of Environment on the Formation of Halpha Filaments and Cool Cores in Galaxy Groups and Clusters
- Deep Chandra, HST-COS, and Megacam Observations of the Phoenix Cluster: Extreme Star Formation and AGN Feedback on Hundred Kiloparsec Scales
- Pahs, Ionized Gas, and Molecular Hydrogen in Brightest Cluster Galaxies of Cool Core Clusters of Galaxies
- Star Formation Efficiency in the Cool Cores of Galaxy Clusters
- Ultraviolet Morphologies and Star-Formation Rates of CLASH Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- OVI Observations of Galaxy Clusters: Evidence for Modest Cooling Flows
- Infrared and Ultraviolet Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies in the ACCEPT Sample
- A direct limit on the turbulent velocity of the intracluster medium in the core of Abell 1835 from XMM-Newton
- Star formation in z>1 3CR host galaxies as seen by Herschel
- Filamentary Star Formation in NGC 1275
- Detecting Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies with GALEX
- Solving the Cooling Flow Problem through Mechanical AGN Feedback
- A Powerful AGN Outburst in RBS 797
- The Fate of Stellar Mass Loss in Central Cluster Galaxies
- The Rarity of Star Formation in Brightest Cluster Galaxies as Measured by WISE
- A Relationship Between Halo Mass, Cooling, AGN Heating, and the Coevolution of Massive Black Holes
- A Chandra - VLA Investigation of the X-ray Cavity System and Radio Mini-Halo in the Galaxy Cluster RBS 797
- Star Formation Activity in CLASH Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Rapid Cooling of Dusty Gas in Elliptical Galaxies
- OVI in Elliptical Galaxies: Indicators of Cooling Flows
- Red but not dead : Unveiling the Star-forming Far-infrared Spectral Energy Distribution of SpARCS Brightest Cluster Galaxies at 0 < z < 1.8
- Star-Formation Bimodality in Early-Type Galaxies
- The effect of the quasar H1821+643 on the surrounding intracluster medium: revealing the underlying cooling flow
- Modeling the Infrared Emission in Cygnus A
- Constraining star formation rates in cool-core brightest cluster galaxies
- The Relationship Between Brightest Cluster Galaxy Star Formation and the Intracluster Medium in CLASH
- A Multi-Wavelength Photometric Census of AGN and Star Formation Activity in the Brightest Cluster Galaxies of X-ray Selected Clusters
- Discovery of O VII line emitting gas in elliptical galaxies
- Analysis of Spitzer-IRS spectra of hyperluminous infrared galaxies
- HST-COS Spectroscopy of the Cooling Flow in Abell 1795 - Evidence for Inefficient Star Formation in Condensing Intracluster Gas
- Where does the gas fueling star formation in BCGs originate?
- Observations of Lyman-alpha and O VI: Signatures of Cooling and Star Formation in a Massive Central Cluster Galaxy
- An Updated Ultraviolet Catalog of GALEX Nearby Galaxies
- Decoding X-ray observations from centres of galaxy clusters using MCMC
- The challenging task of determining star formation rates: the case of a massive stellar burst in the brightest cluster galaxy of Phoenix galaxy cluster
Cited by in corpus (87)
- Radio galaxies and feedback from AGN jets
- The quenching and morphological evolution of central galaxies is facilitated by the feedback-driven expulsion of circumgalactic gas
- Ubiquitous cold and massive filaments in cool core clusters
- Feedback from Active Galactic Nuclei in Galaxy Groups
- A Galaxy-Scale Fountain of Cold Molecular Gas Pumped by a Black Hole
- The X-ray Halo Scaling Relations of Supermassive Black Holes
- Cooling flow solutions for the circumgalactic medium
- Hot-mode accretion and the physics of thin-disk galaxy formation
- Enrichment of the hot intracluster medium: observations
- Thermodynamic properties, multiphase gas and AGN feedback in a large sample of giant ellipticals
- The failure of stellar feedback, magnetic fields, conduction, and morphological quenching in maintaining red galaxies
- The DIANOGA simulations of galaxy clusters: characterizing star formation in proto-clusters
- The Impact of Radio AGN Bubble Composition on the Dynamics and Thermal Balance of the Intracluster Medium
- Dissecting the turbulent weather driven by mechanical AGN feedback
- Dense gas formation and destruction in a simulated Perseus-like galaxy cluster with spin-driven black hole feedback
- Anatomy of a Cooling Flow: The Feedback Response to Pure Cooling in the Core of the Phoenix Cluster
- LOFAR Observations of X-ray Cavity Systems
- AGN feeding and feedback in Fornax A: kinematical analysis of the multi-phase ISM
- A joint SZ-Xray-optical analysis of the dynamical state of 288 massive galaxy clusters
- Pressure profiles and mass estimates using high-resolution Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect observations of Zwicky 3146 with MUSTANG-2
- Fountains and storms: The role of AGN and mergers in disrupting the cool-core in the RomulusC simulation
- An enormous molecular gas flow in the RXJ0821+0752 galaxy cluster
- A Black-Hole Feedback Valve in Massive Galaxies
- The Dust and Molecular Gas in the Brightest Cluster Galaxy in MACS 1931.8-2635
- Wide-Field Optical Spectroscopy of Abell 133: A Search for Filaments Reported in X-ray Observations
- Radio galaxies in galaxy groups: kinematics, scaling relations and AGN feedback
- The Resolved Sunyaev--Zel'dovich Profiles of Nearby Galaxy Groups
- Evidence of runaway gas cooling in the absence of supermassive black hole feedback at the epoch of cluster formation
- WISDOM project -- VIII. Multi-scale feedback cycles in the brightest cluster galaxy NGC 0708
- Cosmic rays and thermal instability in self-regulating cooling flows of massive galaxy clusters
- A Detailed Study of the Most Relaxed SPT-Selected Galaxy Clusters: Cool Core and Central Galaxy Properties
- Observational Evidence for Enhanced Black Hole Accretion in Giant Elliptical Galaxies
- Searching for cool and cooling X-ray emitting gas in 45 galaxy clusters and groups
- The Massive and Distant Clusters of WISE Survey VII: The Environments and Properties of Radio Galaxies in Clusters at z~1
- The Fate of AGB Wind in Massive Galaxies and the ICM
- Hidden Cooling Flows in Clusters of Galaxies II: A Wider Sample
- AGN feedback in the Phoenix cluster
- Multiple shock fronts in RBS 797: the Chandra window on shock heating in galaxy clusters
- Shattering and growth of cold clouds in galaxy clusters: the role of radiative cooling, magnetic fields and thermal conduction
- Molecular Flows in Contemporary Active Galaxies and the Efficacy of Radio-Mechanical Feedback
- Gas Density Perturbations in Cool Cores of CLASH Galaxy Clusters
- The complex interplay of AGN jet-inflated bubbles and the intracluster medium
- H-X-ray Surface Brightness Correlation for Filaments in Cooling Flow Clusters
- The Clusters Hiding in Plain Sight (CHiPS) survey: Complete sample of extreme BCG clusters
- Revealing a Highly-Dynamic Cluster Core in Abell 1664 with Chandra
- A z=1.85 galaxy group in CEERS: evolved, dustless, massive intra-halo light and a brightest group galaxy in the making
- The Evolution of AGN Activity in Brightest Cluster Galaxies
- Active galactic nuclei jets simulated with smoothed particle hydrodynamics
- A Multiwavelength Study of the Massive Cool Core Cluster MACS J1447.4+0827
- Very Large Array observations of the mini-halo and AGN feedback in the Phoenix cluster
- Optical emission lines in the most massive galaxies: morphology, kinematics and ionisation properties
- On the Mass Loading of AGN-Driven Outflows in Elliptical Galaxies and Clusters
- The variability of brightest cluster galaxies at high radio frequencies
- GASP XXXIX: MeerKAT hunts Jellyfish in A2626
- The Clusters Hiding in Plain Sight (CHiPS) survey: CHIPS1911+4455, a Rapidly-Cooling Core in a Merging Cluster
- Discovery of a Powerful >10^61 erg AGN Outburst in Distant Galaxy Cluster SPT-CLJ0528-5300
- The Clusters Hiding in Plain Sight (CHiPS) survey: A first discovery of a massive nearby cluster around PKS1353-341
- A Massive, Clumpy Molecular Gas Distribution and Displaced AGN in Zw 3146
- SPT-CL J2215-3537: A Massive Starburst at the Center of the Most Distant Relaxed Galaxy Cluster
- Suppressed cooling and turbulent heating in the core of X-ray luminous clusters RXCJ1504.1-0248 and Abell 1664
- How the cool-core population transitions from galaxy groups to massive clusters: A comparison of the largest Magneticum simulation with eROSITA, XMM-Newton, Chandra and LOFAR observations
- Hyenas: X-ray Bubbles and Cavities in the Intra-Group Medium
- Feedback in the merging galaxy group NGC6338
- Inquiring into the nature of the Abell 2667 Brightest Cluster Galaxy: physical properties from MUSE
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: The Nature of an Off-galaxy H Blob -- A Multi-wavelength View of Offset Cooling in a Merging Galaxy Group
- Central radio galaxies in galaxy clusters: Joint surveys by eROSITA and ASKAP
- The Evolution of Brightest Cluster Galaxies in the Nearby Universe II: The star-formation activity and the Stellar Mass from Spectral Energy Distribution
- Exploring the multiphase medium in MKW 08: from the central active galaxy up to cluster scales
- Directly Imaging the Cooling Flow in the Phoenix Cluster
- Physical cool-core condensation radius in massive galaxy clusters
- Advection by large-scale spiral flows in galaxy clusters
- Evidence for AGN-Regulated Cooling in Clusters at : A Multi-Wavelength View of SPT-CL J0607-4448
- Cooling rate and turbulence in the intracluster medium of the cool-core cluster Abell 2667
- The Case for Hot-Mode Accretion in Abell 2029
- H1821+643: The most X-ray and infrared luminous AGN in the Swift/BAT survey in the process of rapid stellar and supermassive black hole mass assembly
- Deep Chandra Observations of the z = 1.16 Relaxed, Cool-core Galaxy Cluster SPT-CL J2215-3537
- MeerKAT 21-cm HI imaging of Abell 2626 and beyond
- Cosmological evolution of gas and supermassive black holes in idealized isolated halos
- On the Assembly Bias of Cool Core Clusters Traced by H Nebulae
- Cooling+Heating Flows in Galaxy clusters: Turbulent heating, spectral modelling, and cooling efficiency
- Massive black holes and their galaxies
- Evidence of sloshing-driven mini-halo formation in the cool-core cluster RXCJ1558.3-1410
- Constraining star formation in M87 using deep HST UV data
- The contribution of non-central radio galaxies to AGN feedback in rich galaxy clusters
- High-resolution X-ray spectroscopy of clusters of galaxies
- Evidence for a moderate spin from X-ray reflection of the high-mass supermassive black hole in the cluster-hosted quasar H1821+643
- Testing the Limits of AGN Feedback and the Onset of Thermal Instability in the Most Rapidly Star Forming Brightest Cluster Galaxies