On the UV/optical variation in NGC 5548: new evidence against the reprocessing diagram

Abstract

The reprocessing scenario is widely adopted in literature to explain the observed tight inter-band correlation and short lags in the UV/optical variations of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). In this work we look into the color variability of the famous Seyfert galaxy NGC 5548 with high quality Swift multi-band UV/optical light curves. We find the color variation of NGC 5548 is clearly timescale-dependent, in a way that it is more prominent at shorter timescales. This is similar to that previously detected in quasar samples, but for the first time in an individual AGN. We show that while a reprocessing model with strict assumptions on the driving source and the disk size can apparently match the observed light curves and inter-band lags, it fails to reproduce the observed timescale dependency in the color variation. Such discrepancy raises a severe challenge to, and can hardly be reconciled under the widely accepted reprocessing diagram. It also demonstrates that the timescale dependency of the color variation is uniquely powerful in probing the physics behind AGN UV/optical variations.

arXiv comment13 pages, 5 figures; ApJ accepted

References in corpus (74)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• The Man Behind the Curtain: X-rays Drive the UV through NIR Variability in the 2013 AGN Outburst in NGC 2617
• Central Masses and Broad-Line Region Sizes of Active Galactic Nuclei. II. A Homogeneous Analysis of a Large Reverberation-Mapping Database
• Are the Variations in Quasar Optical Flux Driven by Thermal Fluctuations?
• On Uncertainties in Cross-Correlation Lags and the Reality of Wavelength-Dependent Continuum Lags in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Spectral Properties of Accretion Disks Around Galactic and Extragalactic Black Holes
• Reverberation Measurements of the Inner Radius of the Dust Torus in Nearby Seyfert 1 Galaxies
• The X-ray to optical-UV luminosity ratio of X-ray selected Type 1 AGN in XMM-COSMOS
• The Quasar Accretion Disk Size -- Black Hole Mass Relation
• The Quasar Accretion Disk Size - Black Hole Mass Relation
• An Alternative Approach To Measuring Reverberation Lags in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Is Quasar Optical Variability a Damped Random Walk?
• Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. III. Optical Continuum Emission and Broad-Band Time Delays in NGC 5548
• Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. II. Swift and HST Reverberation Mapping of the Accretion Disk of NGC 5548
• Testing thermal reprocessing in AGN accretion discs
• Modeling reverberation mapping data II: dynamical modeling of the Lick AGN Monitoring Project 2008 dataset
• The Simultaneous Optical-to-X-ray Spectral Energy Distribution of Soft X-ray Selected AGN observed by Swift
• Soft X-ray and Ultraviolet Emission Relations in Optically Selected AGN Samples
• The Sizes of the X-ray and Optical Emission Regions of RXJ1131-1231
• Quasar Accretion Disks Are Strongly Inhomogeneous
• X-Ray and Optical Flux Ratio Anomalies in Quadruply Lensed Quasars: I. Zooming in on Quasar Emission Regions
• Anatomy of the AGN in NGC 5548: I. A global model for the broadband spectral energy distribution
• Swift monitoring of NGC 5548: X-ray reprocessing and short term UV/optical variability
• Selecting Quasars by their Intrinsic Variability
• On the size and location of the X-ray emitting coronae around black holes
• Swift monitoring of NGC 4151: Evidence for a Second X-ray/UV Reprocessing
• Optimal Time-Series Selection of Quasars
• Simultaneous EUVE/ASCA/RXTE Observations of NGC 5548
• Correlated long-term optical and X-ray variations in NGC 5548
• Modelling the broad Fe Kα reverberation in the AGN NGC 4151
• The Structure of the X-ray and Optical Emitting Regions of the Lensed Quasar Q 2237+0305
• The origin of the UV/optical lags in NGC 5548
• Correlated X-ray/Optical Variability in the Quasar MR2251-178
• Further Evidence that Quasar X-Ray Emitting Regions Are Compact: X-Ray and Optical Microlensing in the Lensed Quasar Q J0158-4325
• New constraints on the continuum-emission mechanism of AGN: Intensive monitoring of NGC 7469 in the X-ray and ultraviolet
• Long term optical and X-ray variability of the Seyfert galaxy Markarian 79
• Correlation and time delays of the X-ray and optical emission of the Seyfert Galaxy NGC3783
• Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project VI: reverberating Disk Models for NGC 5548
• Quasar Selection Based on Photometric Variability
• The Color Variability of Quasars
• Steps toward determination of the size and structure of the broad-line region in active galactic nuclei. VI. Variability of NGC 3783 from ground-based data
• Twelve years of X-ray and optical variability in the Seyfert galaxy NGC 4051
• Evidence for Large Temperature Fluctuations in Quasar Accretion Disks From Spectral Variability
• A novel variability-based method for quasar selection: evidence for a rest frame ~54 day characteristic timescale
• Accretion Disc Time Lag Distributions: Applying CREAM to Simulated AGN Light Curves
• Detection of Time Lags Between Quasar Continuum Emission Bands based on Pan-STARRS Light-curves
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Akn 564. II. Ultraviolet Continuum and Emission-line Variability
• The Discovery of Timescale-Dependent Color Variability of Quasars
• X-ray vs. Optical Variations in the Seyfert 1 Nucleus NGC 3516: A Puzzling Disconnectedness
• Optical and Near-IR long-term monitoring of NGC3783 and MR2251-178: evidence for variable near-IR emission from thin accretion discs
• Characterizing the Optical Variability of Bright Blazars: Variability-Based Selection of Fermi AGN
• A DECam Search for an Optical Counterpart to the LIGO Gravitational Wave Event GW151226
• Correlated X-ray/Ultraviolet/Optical variability in the very low mass AGN NGC 4395
• EUCLIA - Exploring the UV/optical continuum lag in active galactic nuclei. I. a model without light echoing
• A High Signal-to-Noise UV Spectrum of NGC 7469: New Support for Reprocessing of Continuum Radiation
• How far is quasar UV/optical variability from damped random walk at low frequency?
• The Structure of HE 1104-1805 from Infrared to X-Ray
• The Vertical Structure and Ultraviolet Spectrum of X-Ray Irradiated Accretion Disks in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Anatomy of the AGN in NGC 5548: VII. Swift study of obscuration and broadband continuum variability
• Anatomy of the AGN in NGC 5548. VI. Long-term variability of the warm absorber
• Simulating the timescale dependent color variation in quasars with a revised inhomogeneous disk model
• X-ray and Optical Correlation of Type I Seyfert NGC 3516 Studied with Suzaku and Japanese Ground-Based Telescopes
• Correlated X-ray/UV/optical variability and the nature of accretion disc in the bare Seyfert 1 galaxy Fairall~9
• The optical variability of SDSS quasars from multi-epoch spectroscopy. II. color variation
• Constraints on the temperature inhomogeneity in quasar accretion discs from the ultraviolet-optical spectral variability
• Studying X-ray reprocessing and continuum variability in quasars: PG 1211+143
• The Effect of a Time-Varying Accretion Disk Size on Quasar Microlensing Light Curves
• Accretion Onto the Supermassive Black Hole in the High-redshift Radio-loud AGN 0957+561
• The Timescale-Dependent Color Variability of Quasars Viewed with GALEX
• A falling Corona model for the anomalous behavior of the broad emission lines in NGC 5548
• The fast UV variability of the active galactic nucleus in Fairall 9
• Spectroscopic follow-up of variability-selected active galactic nuclei in the Chandra Deep Field South
• Exploring the Variable Sky with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey

Cited by in corpus (17)

• Sciences with the 2.5-meter Wide Field Survey Telescope (WFST)
• Improving Damped Random Walk parameters for SDSS Stripe 82 Quasars with Pan-STARRS1
• Corona-Heated Accretion-disk Reprocessing (CHAR): A Physical Model to Decipher the Melody of AGN UV/optical Twinkling
• Winds Can "Blow Up" AGN Accretion Disk Sizes
• Supermassive Black Hole and Broad-line Region in NGC~5548: Results from Five-season Reverberation Mapping
• EUCLIA. II. On the puzzling large UV to X-ray lags in Seyfert galaxies
• Evolution of quasar stochastic variability along its main sequence
• Faint AGNs Favor Unexpectedly Long Inter-band Time Lags
• An intrinsic link between long-term UV/optical variations and X-ray loudness in quasars
• Time-lag between disk and corona radiation leads to hysteresis effect observed in black-hole X-ray binary MAXI J1348-630
• More than softer-when-brighter: the X-Ray powerlaw spectral variability in NGC 4051
• A new timescale-mass scaling for the optical variation of active galactic nuclei across the intermediate-mass to supermassive scales
• New Clues to Jet Launching: The inner disks in radio loud quasars may be more stable
• The Relation between X-ray and Ultraviolet Variability of Quasars
• The Host Galaxy Fluxes of Active Galaxy Nuclei Are Generally Overestimated by the Flux Variation Gradient Method
• Probing the rest-frame wavelength dependence of quasar variability : Insights from the Zwicky Transient Facility Survey
• X-ray emission of radio-loud quasar SDSS J121426.52+140258.9: independent variations between optical/UV and X-ray emission