X-ray vs. Optical Variations in the Seyfert 1 Nucleus NGC 3516: A Puzzling Disconnectedness

Abstract

We present optical broadband (B and R) observations of the Seyfert 1 nucleus NGC 3516, obtained at Wise Observatory from March 1997 to March 2002, contemporaneously with X-ray 2-10 keV measurements with RXTE. With these data we increase the temporal baseline of this dataset to 5 years, more than triple to the coverage we have previously presented for this object. Analysis of the new data does not confirm the 100-day lag of X-ray behind optical variations, tentatively reported in our previous work. Indeed, excluding the first year's data, which drive the previous result, there is no significant correlation at any lag between the X-ray and optical bands. We also find no correlation at any lag between optical flux and various X-ray hardness ratios. We conclude that the close relation observed between the bands during the first year of our program was either a fluke, or perhaps the result of the exceptionally bright state of NGC 3516 in 1997, to which it has yet to return. Reviewing the results of published joint X-ray and UV/optical Seyfert monitoring programs, we speculate that there are at least two components or mechanisms contributing to the X-ray continuum emission up to 10 keV: a soft component that is correlated with UV/optical variations on timescales >1 day, and whose presence can be detected when the source is observed at low enough energies (about 1 keV), is unabsorbed, or is in a sufficiently bright phase; and a hard component whose variations are uncorrelated with the UV/optical.

arXiv comment9 pages, AJ, in press

References in corpus (26)

• A Fundamental Relation Between Supermassive Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies
• Reverberation Measurements for 17 Quasars and the Size-Mass-Luminosity Relations in Active Galactic Nuclei
• ASCA observations of Seyfert 1 galaxies: II. Relativistic Iron K-alpha emission
• Black Hole Mass Estimates from Reverberation Mapping and from Spatially Resolved Kinematics
• X-ray Spectral Variability and Rapid Variability of the Soft X-ray Spectrum Seyfert 1 Galaxies Ark 564 and Ton S180
• X-Ray and Optical Variability in NGC 4051 and the Nature of Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxies
• Spectral evolution of magnetic flares and time lags in accreting black hole sources
• Multiwavelength observations of short time-scale variability in NGC 4151. IV. Analysis of multiwavelength continuum variability
• Revealing the Dusty Warm Absorber in MCG--6-30-15 with the Chandra HETG
• A Cutoff in the X-ray Fluctuation Power Density Spectrum of the Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 3516
• Simultaneous EUVE/ASCA/RXTE Observations of NGC 5548
• Soft X-ray emission lines from a relativistic accretion disk in MCG -6-30-15 and Mrk 766
• The Origin of the X-ray and Ultraviolet Emission in NGC 7469
• Frequency-dependent time lags in the X-ray emission of the Seyfert galaxy NGC 7469
• New constraints on the continuum-emission mechanism of AGN: Intensive monitoring of NGC 7469 in the X-ray and ultraviolet
• Multiwavelength observations of short time-scale variability in NGC 4151. II. Optical observations
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Akn 564. I. ASCA Observations and the Variability of the X-ray Spectral Components
• The continuum variability of MCG--6-30-15: A detailed analysis of the long 1999 ASCA observation
• An XMM-Newton observation of the luminous Seyfert 1 galaxy Markarian 509
• Multiwavelength observations of short time-scale variability in NGC 4151. I. Ultraviolet observations
• Intensive HST, RXTE and ASCA Monitoring of NGC 3516: Evidence Against Thermal Reprocessing
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Akn 564. II. Ultraviolet Continuum and Emission-line Variability
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Akn 564. III. Optical Observations and the Optical--UV--X-ray Connection
• Temporal characteristics of the X-ray emission of NGC 7469
• Multiwavelength observations of short time-scale variability in NGC 4151. III. X-ray and Gamma-ray observations
• A Possible 100-day X-ray-to-Optical Lag in the Variations of the Seyfert 1 Nucleus NGC 3516

Cited by in corpus (44)

• The MAXI Mission on the ISS: Science and Instruments for Monitoring All Sky X-Ray Images
• Reverberation Mapping of High-Luminosity Quasars: First Results
• Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. III. Optical Continuum Emission and Broad-Band Time Delays in NGC 5548
• On the origin of radio emission in radio quiet quasars
• Quasar Broad Absorption Line Variability on Multi-Year Time Scales
• Correlated long-term optical and X-ray variations in NGC 5548
• Long-Term X-ray Spectral Variability in Seyfert 1 Galaxies
• The multiwavelength variability of 3C 273
• Correlated X-ray/Optical Variability in the Quasar MR2251-178
• Long term optical and X-ray variability of the Seyfert galaxy Markarian 79
• Twelve years of X-ray and optical variability in the Seyfert galaxy NGC 4051
• The variable hard X-ray emission of NGC4945 as observed by NuSTAR
• Continuum Reverberation Mapping of the Accretion Disks in Two Seyfert 1 Galaxies
• Complex Optical-X-ray Correlations in the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4051
• Ultraviolet and X-ray variability of active galactic nuclei with Swift
• Tests for Standard Accretion Disk Models by Variability in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Statistical Properties of Multi-epoch Spectral Variability of SDSS Stripe82 Quasars
• X-Ray Variability of AGN and Relationship to Galactic Black Hole Binary Systems
• Correlated X-ray and Optical Variability in Mkn 509
• X-ray and Optical Correlation of Type I Seyfert NGC 3516 Studied with Suzaku and Japanese Ground-Based Telescopes
• Spectral Survey of X-Ray Bright Active Galactic Nuclei from the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer
• Multi-Wavelength Variability. Accretion and Ejection at the Fastest Timescales
• Multi-Wavelength Monitoring and Reverberation Mapping of a Changing Look Event in the Seyfert Galaxy NGC 3516
• Correlated X-ray/UV/optical variability and the nature of accretion disc in the bare Seyfert 1 galaxy Fairall~9
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Dwarf Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4395. III. Optical Variability and X-ray/UV/Optical Correlations
• X-ray to UV Variability Correlation in MCG-6-30-15
• A flare in the optical spotted in the changing-look Seyfert NGC 3516
• Fe II emission in active galactic nuclei
• Correlated X-ray/UV/optical emission and short term variability in a Seyfert 1 galaxy NGC 4593
• On the UV/optical variation in NGC 5548: new evidence against the reprocessing diagram
• New X-ray quasars behind the Small Magellanic Cloud
• The fast UV variability of the active galactic nucleus in Fairall 9
• An intrinsic link between long-term UV/optical variations and X-ray loudness in quasars
• Anomalous Broad-Line Region Responses to Continuum Variability in Active Galactic Nuclei. I. H$\beta$ Variability
• X-ray variability time scales in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Estimation of the size and structure of the broad line region using Bayesian approach
• UV to X-ray Comptonization delay in Mrk 493
• Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Dwarf Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4395. II. X-ray and Ultraviolet Continuum Variability
• A detailed analysis of the high resolution X-ray spectra of NGC 3516: Variability of the ionized absorbers
• Complex optical/UV and X-ray variability in Seyfert 1 galaxy Mrk 509
• The Relation between X-ray and Ultraviolet Variability of Quasars
• Complex Optical/UV and X-ray Variability of the Seyfert 1 galaxy 1H 0419-577
• Temperature Fluctuations in Quasar Accretion Discs from Spectroscopic Monitoring Data
• Study of the Nuclear Activity of the Seyfert Galaxy NGC 7469 over the Period of Observations 2008-2014