On Correlated-noise Analyses Applied To Exoplanet Light Curves

Abstract

Time-correlated noise is a significant source of uncertainty when modeling exoplanet light-curve data. A correct assessment of correlated noise is fundamental to determine the true statistical significance of our findings. Here we review three of the most widely used correlated-noise estimators in the exoplanet field, the time-averaging, residual-permutation, and wavelet-likelihood methods. We argue that the residual-permutation method is unsound in estimating the uncertainty of parameter estimates. We thus recommend to refrain from this method altogether. We characterize the behavior of the time averaging's rms-vs.-bin-size curves at bin sizes similar to the total observation duration, which may lead to underestimated uncertainties. For the wavelet-likelihood method, we note errors in the published equations and provide a list of corrections. We further assess the performance of these techniques by injecting and retrieving eclipse signals into synthetic and real Spitzer light curves, analyzing the results in terms of the relative-accuracy and coverage-fraction statistics. Both the time-averaging and wavelet-likelihood methods significantly improve the estimate of the eclipse depth over a white-noise analysis (a Markov-chain Monte Carlo exploration assuming uncorrelated noise). However, the corrections are not perfect, when retrieving the eclipse depth from Spitzer datasets, these methods covered the true (injected) depth within the 68\% credible region in only $\sim$45--65\% of the trials. Lastly, we present our open-source model-fitting tool, Multi-Core Markov-Chain Monte Carlo ({MC${}^3$}). This package uses Bayesian statistics to estimate the best-fitting values and the credible regions for the parameters for a (user-provided) model. {MC${}^3$} is a Python/C code, available at https://github.com/pcubillos/MCcubed.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (34)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• Analytic Lightcurves for Planetary Transit Searches
• Detection of Thermal Emission from an Extrasolar Planet
• The effect of red noise on planetary transit detection
• The 3.6-8.0 Micron Broadband Emission Spectrum of HD 209458b: Evidence for an Atmospheric Temperature Inversion
• Homogeneous studies of transiting extrasolar planets. I. Light curve analyses
• The climate of HD 189733b from fourteen transits and eclipses measured by Spitzer
• Parameter Estimation from Time-Series Data with Correlated Errors: A Wavelet-Based Method and its Application to Transit Light Curves
• The Transit Light Curve Project. IX. Evidence for a Smaller Radius of the Exoplanet XO-3b
• Possible thermochemical disequilibrium in the atmosphere of the exoplanet GJ 436b
• A Gaussian process framework for modelling instrumental systematics: application to transmission spectroscopy
• Spitzer Secondary Eclipses of the Dense, Modestly-irradiated, Giant Exoplanet HAT-P-20b Using Pixel-Level Decorrelation
• Orbital Phase Variations of the Eccentric Giant Planet HAT-P-2b
• Transit and Eclipse Analyses of Exoplanet HD 149026b Using BLISS Mapping
• The 4.5 $\mu$m full-orbit phase curve of the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• Doppler follow-up of OGLE transiting companions in the Galactic bulge
• Accurate Spitzer infrared radius measurement for the hot Neptune GJ 436b
• On the Orbit of Exoplanet WASP-12b
• Detection of Thermal Emission from a Super-Earth
• The 8 Micron Phase Variation of the Hot Saturn HD 149026b
• A uniform analysis of HD209458b Spitzer/IRAC lightcurves with Gaussian process models
• A Ground-based Optical Transmission Spectrum of WASP-6b
• The Transit Light Curve Project. VII. The Not-So-Bloated Exoplanet HAT-P-1b
• 3.6 and 4.5 $\mu$m Phase Curves of the Highly-Irradiated Eccentric Hot Jupiter WASP-14b
• Spitzer Secondary Eclipses of WASP-18b
• A Search for a Sub-Earth Sized Companion to GJ 436 and a Novel Method to Calibrate Warm Spitzer IRAC Observations
• Repeatability and Accuracy of Exoplanet Eclipse Depths Measured with Post-Cryogenic Spitzer
• WASP-8b: Characterization of a Cool and Eccentric Exoplanet with Spitzer
• Accurate radius and mass of the transiting exoplanet OGLE-TR-132b
• Reliable inference of exoplanet light curve parameters using deterministic and stochastic systematics models
• Thermal Emission of WASP-14b Revealed with Three Spitzer Eclipses
• Two nearby sub-Earth-sized exoplanet candidates in the GJ 436 system
• A blind method to detrend instrumental systematics in exoplanetary light-curves

Cited by in corpus (84)

• Markov Chain Monte Carlo Methods for Bayesian Data Analysis in Astronomy
• Hot Exoplanet Atmospheres Resolved with Transit Spectroscopy (HEARTS) - II. A broadened sodium feature on the ultra-hot giant WASP-76b
• The Transiting Exoplanet Community Early Release Science Program for JWST
• Early 2017 observations of TRAPPIST-1 with $\text{Spitzer}$
• Towards Space-like Photometric Precision from the Ground with Beam-Shaping Diffusers
• Atmospheric Regimes and Trends on Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
• Sulphur dioxide in the mid-infrared transmission spectrum of WASP-39b
• Transit detection of the long-period volatile-rich super-Earth ${\nu }^2$ Lupi d with $CHEOPS$
• CHEOPS observations of the HD 108236 planetary system: A fifth planet, improved ephemerides, and planetary radii
• A sub-Neptune sized planet transiting the M2.5-dwarf G 9-40: Validation with the Habitable-zone Planet Finder
• Diffuser-Assisted Infrared Transit Photometry for Four Dynamically Interacting \textit{Kepler} Systems
• Mass Loss from the Exoplanet WASP-12b Inferred from $\text{Spitzer}$ Phase Curves
• The Implications of 3D Thermal Structure on 1D Atmospheric Retrieval
• The Pyrat Bay Framework for Exoplanet Atmospheric Modeling: A Population Study of Hubble/WFC3 Transmission Spectra
• A pair of Sub-Neptunes transiting the bright K-dwarf TOI-1064 characterised with CHEOPS
• High atmospheric metal enrichment for a Saturn-mass planet
• Signs of strong Na and K absorption in the transmission spectrum of WASP-103b
• Precise photometric transit follow-up observations of five close-in exoplanets : update on their physical properties
• Shallow Transits - Deep Learning I: Feasibility Study of Deep Learning to Detect Periodic Transits of Exoplanets
• The TESS-Keck Survey IV: A Retrograde, Polar Orbit for the Ultra-Low-Density, Hot Super-Neptune WASP-107b
• Coupling thermal evolution of planets and hydrodynamic atmospheric escape in MESA
• The EBLM Project V. Physical properties of ten fully convective, very-low-mass stars
• Near-ultraviolet Transmission Spectroscopy of HD 209458b: Evidence of Ionized Iron Beyond the Planetary Roche Lobe
• The Transiting Multi-planet System HD15337: Two Nearly Equal-mass Planets Straddling the Radius Gap
• TOI-222: a single-transit TESS candidate revealed to be a 34-day eclipsing binary with CORALIE, EulerCam and NGTS
• The Kepler-11 system: evolution of the stellar high-energy emission and {initial planetary} atmospheric mass fractions
• Close-in sub-Neptunes reveal the past rotation history of their host stars: atmospheric evolution of planets in the HD3167 and K2-32 planetary systems
• Investigating the architecture and internal structure of the TOI-561 system planets with CHEOPS, HARPS-N and TESS
• Homogeneous search for helium in the atmosphere of 11 gas giant exoplanets with SPIRou
• Updated astrometry and masses of the LUH 16 brown dwarf binary
• Retrieval of the fluid Love number $k_2$ in exoplanetary transit curves
• $\text{PyTranSpot}$ - A tool for multiband light curve modeling of planetary transits and stellar spots
• Community targets for JWST's early release science program: evaluation of WASP-63b
• Revisiting the Iconic Spitzer Phase Curve of 55 Cancri e: Hotter Dayside, Cooler Nightside and Smaller Phase Offset
• Proxima Centauri b is not a transiting exoplanet
• Mitigating flicker noise in high-precision photometry. I -- Characterization of the noise structure, impact on the inferred transit parameters, and predictions for CHEOPS observations
• Multiple Clues for Dayside Aerosols and Temperature Gradients in WASP-69 b from a Panchromatic JWST Emission Spectrum
• AutoRegressive Planet Search: Methodology
• Diffuser-assisted Photometric Follow-up Observations of the Neptune-sized Planets K2-28b and K2-100b
• Multi-season optical modulation phased with the orbit of the super-Earth 55 Cnc e
• DREAM: III.A helium survey in exoplanets on the edge of the hot Neptune desert with GIANO-B@TNG
• The Hubble PanCET Program: A Metal-rich Atmosphere for the Inflated Hot Jupiter HAT-P-41b
• The Atmosphere and Interior Structure of HAT-P-13b from Spitzer Secondary Eclipses
• A retrieval challenge exercise for the Ariel mission
• The Dark World: A Tale of WASP-43b in Reflected Light with HST WFC3/UVIS
• Multi-band transit follow up observations of five hot-Jupiters with critical noise treatments: Improved physical properties
• ThERESA: Three-Dimensional Eclipse Mapping with Application to Synthetic JWST Data
• Constraints on Cosmological Parameters with a Sample of Type Ia Supernovae from JWST
• Ground-based follow-up observations of TRAPPIST-1 transits in the near-infrared
• The atmosphere of WASP-17b: Optical high-resolution transmission spectroscopy
• Aerosol Constraints on the Atmosphere of the Hot Saturn-mass planet WASP-49b
• Longitudinally Resolved Spectral Retrieval (ReSpect) of WASP-43b
• Thermal Phase Curves of XO-3b: an Eccentric Hot Jupiter at the Deuterium Burning Limit
• HST/STIS capability for Love number measurement of WASP-121b
• JWST-TST DREAMS: Non-Uniform Dayside Emission for WASP-17b from MIRI/LRS
• A 16 Hour Transit of Kepler-167 e Observed by the Ground-based Unistellar Telescope Network
• Seasonal Changes in the Atmosphere of HD 80606b Observed with JWST's NIRSpec/G395H
• The Hubble/STIS Near-ultraviolet Transmission Spectrum of HD 189733b
• Non-Sinusoidal Transit Timing Variations for the Exoplanet HAT-P-12b
• Scintillation-limited photometry with the 20-cm NGTS telescopes at Paranal Observatory
• On the Dayside Atmosphere of WASP-12b
• Establishing the accuracy of asteroseismic mass and radius estimates of giant stars. II. Revised stellar masses and radii for KIC 8430105
• Bayesian Methods for Joint Exoplanet Transit Detection and Systematic Noise Characterization
• The multi-planet system TOI-421 -- A warm Neptune and a super puffy mini-Neptune transiting a G9 V star in a visual binary
• fBLS -- a fast-folding BLS algorithm
• Discovery of TOI-1260d and the characterisation of the multi-planet system
• A Harsh Test of Far-Field Scrambling with the Habitable Zone Planet Finder and the Hobby Eberly Telescope
• Dark skies of the slightly eccentric WASP-18 b from its optical-to-infrared dayside emission
• Searching for Possible Exoplanet Transits from BRITE Data through a Machine Learning Technique
• Searching for orbital decay in a heartbeat star system KIC 3766353
• NGTS-13b: A hot 4.8 Jupiter-mass planet transiting a subgiant star
• TFAW: wavelet-based signal reconstruction to reduce photometric noise in time-domain surveys
• Horizontal and vertical exoplanet thermal structure from a JWST spectroscopic eclipse map
• The SPACE Program. I. The featureless spectrum of HD 86226 c challenges sub-Neptune atmosphere trends
• Simultaneous multicolour optical and near-IR transit photometry of GJ 1214b with SOFIA
• The CHEOPS view on the climate of WASP-3 b
• Validation of a Temperate Fourth Planet in the K2-133 Multi-planet System
• Global Chemistry and Thermal Structure Models for the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b and Predictions for JWST
• Gas-depleted planet formation occurred in the four-planet system around the red dwarf LHS 1903
• Modern Earth-like Chemical Disequilibrium Biosignatures Are Challenging To Constrain Through Spectroscopic Retrievals
• Improved characterization of the TOI-2141 system: a dense sub-Neptune with non-transiting inner and outer companions
• Constraining stellar rotation and planetary atmospheric evolution of a dozen systems hosting sub-Neptunes and super-Earths
• First systematic high-precision survey of bright supernovae I. Methodology for identifying early bumps
• Bayesian vs Frequentist: Comparing Bayesian model selection with a frequentist approach using the iterative smoothing method