Reliable inference of exoplanet light curve parameters using deterministic and stochastic systematics models
arXiv:1409.5668 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stu1975
Abstract
Time-series photometry and spectroscopy of transiting exoplanets allow us to study their atmospheres. Unfortunately, the required precision to extract atmospheric information surpasses the design specifications of most general purpose instrumentation, resulting in instrumental systematics in the light curves that are typically larger than the target precision. Systematics must therefore be modelled, leaving the inference of light curve parameters conditioned on the subjective choice of models and model selection criteria. This paper aims to test the reliability of the most commonly used systematics models and model selection criteria. As we are primarily interested in recovering light curve parameters rather than the favoured systematics model, marginalisation over systematics models is introduced as a more robust alternative than simple model selection. This can incorporate uncertainties in the choice of systematics model into the error budget as well as the model parameters. Its use is demonstrated using a series of simulated transit light curves. Stochastic models, specifically Gaussian processes, are also discussed in the context of marginalisation over systematics models, and are found to reliably recover the transit parameters for a wide range of systematics functions. None of the tested model selection criteria - including the BIC - routinely recovered the correct model. This means that commonly used methods that are based on simple model selection may underestimate the uncertainties when extracting transmission and eclipse spectra from real data, and low-significance claims using such techniques should be treated with caution. In general, no systematics modelling techniques are perfect; however, marginalisation over many systematics models helps to mitigate poor model selection, and stochastic processes provide an even more flexible approach to modelling instrumental systematics.
arXiv comment15 pages, 2 figures, published in MNRAS, typo in footnote eq corrected
References in corpus (36)
- emcee: The MCMC Hammer
- Analytic Lightcurves for Planetary Transit Searches
- Detection of an Extrasolar Planet Atmosphere
- A map of the day-night contrast of the extrasolar planet HD 189733b
- Theoretical Transmission Spectra During Extrasolar Giant Planet Transits
- Detection of Thermal Emission from an Extrasolar Planet
- Infrared radiation from an extrasolar planet
- HST Time-Series Photometry of the Transiting Planet of HD 209458
- The effect of red noise on planetary transit detection
- Infrared Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanets HD209458b and XO-1b Using the Wide Field Camera-3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
- Quantifying the Uncertainty in the Orbits of Extrasolar Planets
- Hubble Space Telescope Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanet HD 189733b: High-altitude atmospheric haze in the optical and near-UV with STIS
- Transmission Spectra as Diagnostics of Extrasolar Giant Planet Atmospheres
- Efficient identification of exoplanetary transit candidates from SuperWASP light curves
- Parameter Estimation from Time-Series Data with Correlated Errors: A Wavelet-Based Method and its Application to Transit Light Curves
- The Transit Light Curve Project. IX. Evidence for a Smaller Radius of the Exoplanet XO-3b
- A simple method to estimate radial velocity variations due to stellar activity using photometry
- A Gaussian process framework for modelling instrumental systematics: application to transmission spectroscopy
- Multi-Wavelength Constraints on the Day-Night Circulation Patterns of HD 189733b
- Hubble Space Telescope times-series photometry of the planetary transit of HD189733: no moon, no rings, starspots
- The Transit Light Curve (TLC) Project. I. Four Consecutive Transits of the Exoplanet XO-1b
- HST hot Jupiter Transmission Spectral Survey: A detection of Na and strong optical absorption in HAT-P-1b
- Inverting Phase Functions to Map Exoplanets
- An HST Optical to Near-IR Transmission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter WASP-19b: Detection of Atmospheric Water and Likely Absence of TiO
- The Deep Blue Color of HD189733b: Albedo Measurements with Hubble Space Telescope/Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph at Visible Wavelengths
- A new look at NICMOS transmission spectroscopy of HD189733, GJ-436 and XO-1: no conclusive evidence for molecular features
- Accurate Spitzer infrared radius measurement for the hot Neptune GJ 436b
- A Gemini ground-based transmission spectrum of WASP-29b: a featureless spectrum from 515 to 720nm
- Probing the haze in the atmosphere of HD 189733b with HST/WFC3 transmission spectroscopy
- The optical transmission spectrum of the hot Jupiter HAT-P-32b: clouds explain the absence of broad spectral features?
- Updated parameters for the transiting exoplanet WASP-3b using RISE, a new fast camera for the Liverpool Telescope
- Warm Ice Giant GJ 3470b. I. A Flat Transmission Spectrum Indicates a Hazy, Low-methane, and/or Metal-rich Atmosphere
- Blind extraction of an exoplanetary spectrum through Independent Component Analysis
- A transit timing analysis of seven RISE light curves of the exoplanet system HAT-P-3
- Transmission spectroscopy of exoplanet XO-2b observed with HST NICMOS
- On the Detection of Molecules in the Atmosphere of HD189733b using HST NICMOS Transmission Spectroscopy
Cited by in corpus (65)
- A continuum from clear to cloudy hot-Jupiter exoplanets without primordial water depletion
- Juliet: a versatile modelling tool for transiting and non-transiting exoplanetary systems
- Early Release Science of the Exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRSpec G395H
- Detection of H2O and evidence for TiO/VO in an ultra hot exoplanet atmosphere
- A combined transmission spectrum of the Earth-sized exoplanets TRAPPIST-1 b and c
- HAT-P-26b: A Neptune-Mass Exoplanet with a Well Constrained Heavy Element Abundance
- Detection of Fe I in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b, and a new likelihood-based approach for Doppler-resolved spectroscopy
- A consistent retrieval analysis of 10 Hot Jupiters observed in transmission
- The HST PanCET Program: Exospheric Mg II and Fe II in the Near-UV transmission spectrum of WASP-121b using Jitter Decorrelation
- The Complete transmission spectrum of WASP-39b with a precise water constraint
- An optical transmission spectrum for the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b measured with the Hubble Space Telescope
- ACCESS: A featureless optical transmission spectrum for WASP-19b from Magellan/IMACS
- An absolute sodium abundance for a cloud-free 'hot Saturn' exoplanet
- On Correlated-noise Analyses Applied To Exoplanet Light Curves
- A uniform analysis of HD209458b Spitzer/IRAC lightcurves with Gaussian process models
- The Transiting Exoplanet Community Early Release Science Program for JWST
- The Near-Infrared Transmission Spectra of TRAPPIST-1 Planets b, c, d, e, f, and g and Stellar Contamination in Multi-Epoch Transit Spectra
- VLT FORS2 comparative transmission spectroscopy: Detection of Na in the atmosphere of WASP-39b from the ground
- Evidence for a Dayside Thermal Inversion and High Metallicity for the Hot Jupiter WASP-18b
- VLT/FORS2 comparative transmission spectroscopy II: confirmation of a cloud-deck and Rayleigh scattering in WASP-31b, but no potassium?
- Marginalising instrument systematics in HST WFC3 transit lightcurves
- Updated Parameters and a New Transmission Spectrum of HD 97658b
- Spi-OPS: Spitzer and CHEOPS confirm the near-polar orbit of MASCARA-1 b and reveal a hint of dayside reflection
- Into the UV: The Atmosphere of the Hot Jupiter HAT-P-41b Revealed
- Spin orbit alignment for KELT-7b and HAT-P-56b via Doppler tomography with TRES
- The GTC exoplanet transit spectroscopy survey. VI. A spectrally-resolved Rayleigh scattering slope in GJ 3470b
- An independent analysis of the Spitzer/IRAC phase curves of WASP43 b
- The HST PanCET Program: Hints of Na I & Evidence of a Cloudy Atmosphere for the Inflated Hot Jupiter WASP-52b
- Starspot occultations in infrared transit spectroscopy: the case of WASP-52b
- The First Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum of HIP 41378 f, a Low-Mass Temperate Jovian World in a Multi-Planet System
- TRAP: A temporal systematics model for improved direct detection of exoplanets at small angular separations
- Revisiting the potassium feature of WASP-31b at high-resolution
- The HST PanCET Program: An Optical to Infrared Transmission Spectrum of HAT-P-32Ab
- Simultaneous Optical Transmission Spectroscopy of a Terrestrial, Habitable-Zone Exoplanet with Two Ground-Based Multi-Object Spectrographs
- AutoRegressive Planet Search: Methodology
- Two long-period transiting exoplanets on eccentric orbits: NGTS-20 b (TOI-5152 b) and TOI-5153 b
- Solar-to-supersolar sodium and oxygen absolute abundances for a "hot Saturn" orbiting a metal-rich star
- LBT transmission spectroscopy of HAT-P-12b: confirmation of a cloudy atmosphere with no significant alkali features
- Evidence of a Clear Atmosphere for WASP-62b: the Only Known Transiting Gas Giant in the JWST Continuous Viewing Zone
- The Hubble PanCET Program: A Metal-rich Atmosphere for the Inflated Hot Jupiter HAT-P-41b
- Demonstrating High-precision, Multiband Transit Photometry with MuSCAT: A Case for HAT-P-14b
- 55 Cancri e's occultation captured with CHEOPS
- ACCESS: Confirmation of a Clear Atmosphere for WASP-96b and a Comparison of Light Curve Detrending Techniques
- ExoTiC-ISM: A Python package for marginalised exoplanet transit parameters across a grid of systematic instrument models
- Hot Rocks Survey III: A deep eclipse for LHS 1140c and a new Gaussian process method to account for correlated noise in individual pixels
- ACCESS: Confirmation of no potassium in the atmosphere of WASP-31b
- K2-287b: an Eccentric Warm Saturn transiting a G-dwarf
- A new method to measure the spectra of transiting exoplanet atmospheres using multi-object spectroscopy
- Transmission spectroscopy with VLT FORS2: a featureless spectrum for the low-density transiting exoplanet WASP-88b
- Larger and faster: revised properties and a shorter orbital period for the WASP-57 planetary system from a pro-am collaboration
- Constraints on TESS albedos for five hot Jupiters
- TESS and CHEOPS Discover Two Warm Sub-Neptunes Transiting the Bright K-dwarf HD 15906
- JWST-TST DREAMS: Non-Uniform Dayside Emission for WASP-17b from MIRI/LRS
- Detection of faculae in the transit and transmission spectrum of WASP-69b
- An old warm Jupiter orbiting the metal-poor G-dwarf TOI-5542
- Ground-Based Transmission Spectroscopy with VLT FORS2: Evidence for faculae and clouds in the optical spectrum of the warm Saturn WASP-110b
- Multi-band characterization of the hot Jupiters: WASP-5b, WASP-44b and WASP-46b
- Benchmark tests of transmission spectroscopy using transiting white dwarfs
- Discovery of a cold giant planet and mass measurement of a hot super-Earth in the multi-planetary system WASP-132
- How do wavelength correlations affect transmission spectra? Application of a new fast and flexible 2D Gaussian process framework to transiting exoplanet spectroscopy
- Characterization of an Instrument Model for Exoplanet Transit Spectrum Estimation through Wide Scale Analysis on HST Data
- A Transmission Spectrum Of HD 189733b From Multiple Broadband Filter Observations
- Detection and characterisation of a 106-day transiting Jupiter : TOI-2449 b / NGTS-36 b
- An improved correction of radial-velocity systematic for the SOPHIE spectrograph
- gallifrey: JAX-based Gaussian process structure learning for astronomical time series