On the Detection of Molecules in the Atmosphere of HD189733b using HST NICMOS Transmission Spectroscopy
arXiv:1401.7601 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/784/2/133
Abstract
The HST/NICMOS transmission spectrum measurements of HD 189733b that suggest the detection of methane (CH) in an exoplanet atmosphere have been a source of significant controversy. With what is probably the best analyzed exoplanet spectroscopy data set to date, different teams, using different methods, have claimed evidence both contradicting and supporting the original findings. Here, we report results from a uniform spectral retrieval analysis of the three, independent, published spectra together with null hypothesis testing. Based on Bayesian model comparison, we find that two of the three spectra show strong evidence ( 3.6) for the detection of molecular features mainly due to water and methane while the third is consistent with a weak molecular detection at the 2.2 level. We interpret the agreement in the spectral modulation established by previous authors and the atmospheric retrieval results presented here, as a confirmation of the original detection of molecular absorbers in the atmosphere of HD 189733b.
arXiv commentAccepted to ApJ
References in corpus (25)
- Clouds in the atmosphere of the super-Earth exoplanet GJ 1214b
- Infrared Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanets HD209458b and XO-1b Using the Wide Field Camera-3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
- Hubble Space Telescope Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanet HD 189733b: High-altitude atmospheric haze in the optical and near-UV with STIS
- Atmospheric Retrieval for Super-Earths: Uniquely Constraining the Atmospheric Composition with Transmission Spectroscopy
- Transmission Spectra as Diagnostics of Extrasolar Giant Planet Atmospheres
- A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra I: A Comparison of Atmospheric Retrieval Techniques
- The Flat Transmission Spectrum of the Super-Earth GJ1214b from Wide Field Camera 3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
- High C/O Ratio and Weak Thermal Inversion in the Very Hot Atmosphere of Exoplanet WASP-12b
- How to Distinguish between Cloudy Mini-Neptunes and Water/Volatile-Dominated Super-Earths
- Transmission Spectra of Three-Dimensional Hot Jupiter Model Atmospheres
- A Gaussian process framework for modelling instrumental systematics: application to transmission spectroscopy
- Strong Water Absorption in the Dayside Emission Spectrum of the Planet HD 189733b
- Water, Methane, and Carbon Dioxide Present in the Dayside Spectrum of the Exoplanet HD 209458b
- An HST Optical to Near-IR Transmission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter WASP-19b: Detection of Atmospheric Water and Likely Absence of TiO
- Optimal Estimation Retrievals of the Atmospheric Structure and Composition of HD 189733b from Secondary Eclipse Spectroscopy
- A new look at NICMOS transmission spectroscopy of HD189733, GJ-436 and XO-1: no conclusive evidence for molecular features
- Exoplanet Transit Spectroscopy Using WFC3: WASP-12 b, WASP-17 b, and WASP-19 b
- Information Content of Exoplanetary Transit Spectra: An Initial Look
- Probing the terminator region atmosphere of the Hot-Jupiter XO-1b with transmission spectroscopy
- Probing the extreme planetary atmosphere of WASP-12b
- Hubble Space Telescope hot Jupiter Transmission Spectral Survey: detection of water in HAT-P-1b from Wide Field Camera 3 near-infrared spatial scan observations
- A Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum for the Warm Saturn HAT-P-12b
- Transit infrared spectroscopy of the hot neptune around GJ 436 with the Hubble Space Telescope
- Blind extraction of an exoplanetary spectrum through Independent Component Analysis
- Transmission spectroscopy of exoplanet XO-2b observed with HST NICMOS
Cited by in corpus (35)
- Characterizing transiting exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
- Water Vapor in the Spectrum of the Extrasolar Planet HD 189733b: 1. the Transit
- Tau-REx I: A next generation retrieval code for exoplanetary atmospheres
- A Sub-Neptune Exoplanet with a Low-Metallicity Methane-Depleted Atmosphere and Mie-Scattering Clouds
- The Influence of Non-Uniform Cloud Cover on Transit Transmission Spectra
- Exoplanetary Atmospheres - Chemistry, Formation Conditions, and Habitability
- TauREx III: A fast, dynamic and extendable framework for retrievals
- No Thermal Inversion and a Solar Water Abundance for the Hot Jupiter HD209458b from HST WFC3 Emission Spectroscopy
- Uniform Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs I: Characterizing Benchmarks, Gl570D and HD3651B
- H2O abundances in the atmospheres of three hot Jupiters
- The mineral clouds on HD 209458b and HD189733b
- Water vapor in the spectrum of the extrasolar planet HD 189733b: 2. The eclipse
- A Search for Water in the Atmosphere of HAT-P-26b Using LDSS-3C
- Reliable inference of exoplanet light curve parameters using deterministic and stochastic systematics models
- A Characteristic Transmission Spectrum dominated by HO applies to the majority of HST/WFC3 exoplanet observations
- Atmospheric Characterization of 5 Hot Jupiters with Wide Field Camera 3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
- Near-infrared Thermal Emission Detections of a number of hot Jupiters and the Systematics of Ground-based Near-infrared Photometry
- Record-breaking Storm Activity on Uranus in 2014
- Information Content Analysis for Selection of Optimal JWST Observing Modes for Transiting Exoplanet Atmospheres
- Multi-band, Multi-epoch Observations of the Transiting Warm Jupiter WASP-80b
- Potassium detection in the clear atmosphere of a hot-Jupiter: FORS2 transmission spectroscopy of WASP-17b
- The Influence of Stellar Contamination on the Interpretation of Near Infrared Transmission Spectra of Sub-Neptune Worlds around M-Dwarfs
- An analytical formalism accounting for clouds and other "surfaces" for exoplanet transmission spectroscopy
- MOVES IV. Modelling the influence of stellar XUV-flux, cosmic rays, and stellar energetic particles on the atmospheric composition of the hot Jupiter HD 189733b
- A Catalogue of Exoplanet Atmospheric Retrieval Codes
- Community targets for JWST's early release science program: evaluation of WASP-63b
- Effects of refraction on transmission spectra of gas giants: decrease of the Rayleigh scattering slope and breaking of retrieval degeneracies
- Constraining Exoplanet Metallicities and Aerosols with ARIEL: An Independent Study by the Contribution to ARIEL Spectroscopy of Exoplanets (CASE) Team
- First exoplanet transit observation with the Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy: Confirmation of Rayleigh scattering in HD 189733 b with HIPO
- Near-infrared Brightness of the Galilean Satellites Eclipsed in Jovian Shadow: A New Technique to Investigate Jovian Upper Atmosphere
- The effect of spectroscopic binning on atmospheric retrievals
- Quantifying the Impact of Spectral Coverage on the Retrieval of Molecular Abundances from Exoplanet Transmission Spectra
- Radiative Transfer and Inversion codes for characterizing planetary atmospheres: an overview
- Searching for technosignatures in exoplanetary systems with current and future missions
- Precision Time-series Photometry in the Thermal Infrared with a 'Wall-Eyed' Pointing Mode at the Large Binocular Telescope