A Comprehensive Comparative Test of Seven Widely-Used Spectral Synthesis Models Against Multi-Band Photometry of Young Massive Star Clusters
arXiv:1601.03850 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stw150
Abstract
We test the predictions of spectral synthesis models based on seven different massive-star prescriptions against Legacy ExtraGalactic UV Survey (LEGUS) observations of eight young massive clusters in two local galaxies, NGC 1566 and NGC 5253, chosen because predictions of all seven models are available at the published galactic metallicities. The high angular resolution, extensive cluster inventory and full near-ultraviolet to near-infrared photometric coverage make the LEGUS dataset excellent for this study. We account for both stellar and nebular emission in the models and try two different prescriptions for attenuation by dust. From Bayesian fits of model libraries to the observations, we find remarkably low dispersion in the median E(B-V) (~0.03 mag), stellar masses (~10^4 M_\odot) and ages (~1 Myr) derived for individual clusters using different models, although maximum discrepancies in these quantities can reach 0.09 mag and factors of 2.8 and 2.5, respectively. This is for ranges in median properties of 0.05-0.54 mag, 1.8-10x10^4 M_\odot and 1.6-40 Myr spanned by the clusters in our sample. In terms of best fit, the observations are slightly better reproduced by models with interacting binaries and least well reproduced by models with single rotating stars. Our study provides a first quantitative estimate of the accuracies and uncertainties of the most recent spectral synthesis models of young stellar populations, demonstrates the good progress of models in fitting high-quality observations, and highlights the needs for a larger cluster sample and more extensive tests of the model parameter space.
arXiv commentAccepted for publication in MNRAS (14 Jan. 2016). 30 pages, 16 figures, 9 tables
References in corpus (77)
- Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
- The chemical composition of the Sun
- Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
- The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
- PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
- Starburst99: Synthesis Models for Galaxies with Active Star Formation
- Correcting for the Effects of Interstellar Extinction
- Binary interaction dominates the evolution of massive stars
- Stellar mass-to-light ratios and the Tully-Fisher relation
- Mass-loss predictions for O and B stars as a function of metallicity
- Grids of stellar models with rotation - I. Models from 0.8 to 120 Msun at solar metallicity (Z = 0.014)
- MILES: A Medium resolution INT Library of Empirical Spectra
- A Quantitative Comparison of SMC, LMC, and Milky Way UV to NIR Extinction Curves
- Young massive star clusters
- Pre-Supernova Evolution of Massive Single and Binary Stars
- An updated MILES stellar library and stellar population models
- A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: I. Calibration of theoretical spectra
- Metallicities of 0.3<z<1.0 Galaxies in the GOODS-North Field
- PARSEC evolutionary tracks of massive stars up to at metallicities 0.00010.04
- The R136 star cluster hosts several stars whose individual masses greatly exceed the accepted 150 Msun stellar mass limit
- The rotation rates of massive stars: the role of binary interaction through tides, mass transfer and mergers
- Comparison of H-alpha and UV Star Formation Rates in the Local Volume: Systematic Discrepancies for Dwarf Galaxies
- Optical Spectroscopy and Nebular Oxygen Abundances of the Spitzer/SINGS Galaxies
- The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey VIII. Multiplicity properties of the O-type star population
- The effect of massive binaries on stellar populations and supernova progenitors
- New PARSEC evolutionary tracks of massive stars at low metallicity: testing canonical stellar evolution in nearby star forming dwarf galaxies
- Nebular Emission from Star-Forming Galaxies
- Optimization of Starburst99 for Intermediate-Age and Old Stellar Populations
- Present-day cosmic abundances. A comprehensive study of nearby early B-type stars and implications for stellar and Galactic evolution and interstellar dust models
- The 2013 Release of Cloudy
- The Effects of Stellar Rotation. II. A Comprehensive Set of Starburst99 Models
- Realistic Ionizing Fluxes for Young Stellar Populations from 0.05 to twice solar metallicity
- Grids of stellar models with rotation - III. Models from 0.8 to 120 Msun at a metallicity Z = 0.002
- The incidence of stellar mergers and mass gainers among massive stars
- Spectral and Photometric Evolution of Young Stellar Populations: the Impact of Gaseous Emission at Various Metallicities
- A spectroscopic survey on the multiplicity of high-mass stars
- Spectral synthesis including massive binaries
- The spectral evolution of the first galaxies. I. James Webb Space Telescope detection limits and color criteria for population III galaxies
- Cluster Mass Functions in the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds: Fading and Size of Sample Effects
- The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars: constraints on stellar evolution from the chemical compositions of rapidly rotating Galactic and Magellanic Cloud B-type stars
- The Luminosity Function of Star Clusters in Spiral Galaxies
- Legacy ExtraGalactic UV Survey (LEGUS) with The Hubble Space Telescope. I. Survey Description
- Empirical determination of the shape of dust attenuation curves in star-forming galaxies
- The mass function of young star clusters in spiral galaxies
- Probing the role of the galactic environment in the formation of stellar clusters; using M83 as a test bench
- Ages and Luminosities of Young SMC/LMC Star Clusters and the recent Star Formation History of the Clouds
- The ages of young star clusters, massive blue stragglers and the upper mass limit of stars: analysing age dependent stellar mass functions
- Stellar Clusters in M83: Formation, evolution, disruption and the influence of environment
- ALMA reveals the feeding of the Seyfert 1 nucleus in NGC 1566
- UVBLUE: a new high-resolution theoretical library of ultraviolet stellar spectra
- The effect of stellar evolution uncertainties on the rest-frame ultraviolet stellar lines of CIV and HeII in high-redshift Lyman-break galaxies
- Physical limits to the validity of synthesis models: The Lowest Luminosity Limit
- Super star clusters in Haro 11: Properties of a very young starburst and evidence for a near-infrared flux excess
- Dust and Nebular Emission. I. Models for Normal Galaxies
- Wolf-Rayet stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud: I. Analysis of the single WN stars
- The star cluster formation history of the LMC
- Similarities in Populations of Star Clusters
- On the Interstellar Medium and Star Formation Demographics of Galaxies in the Local Universe
- The very massive binary NGC3603-A1
- The Physical Properties and Effective Temperature Scale of O-type Stars as a Function of Metallicity. III. More Results from the Magellanic Clouds
- The Importance of Nebular Continuum and Line Emission in Observations of Young Massive Star Clusters
- Hubble Tarantula Treasury Project: Unraveling Tarantula's Web. II. Optical and Near Infrared Star Formation History of the Starburst Cluster NGC 2070 in 30 Doradus
- A model of spectral galaxy evolution including the effects of nebular emission
- The Brightest Young Star Clusters in NGC 5253
- Stochasticity, a variable stellar upper-mass limit, binaries and star-formation rate indicators
- Evolutionary Population Synthesis for Binary Stellar Populations
- The Link Between the Formation Rates of Clusters and Stars in Galaxies
- The temporal and spatial evolution of the starburst in ESO 338-IG04 as probed by its star clusters
- Revisiting the abundance gradient in the maser host galaxy NGC 4258
- The Age Distribution of Clusters in M83
- The ionized gas in the central region of NGC 5253: 2D mapping of the physical and chemical properties
- Piecing together the puzzle of NGC 5253: abundances, kinematics and WR stars
- A first orbital solution for the very massive 30 Dor main-sequence WN6h+O binary R145
- Star Cluster Mass and Age Distributions of Two Fields in M83 Based on HST/WFC3 Observations
- Evolutionary Population Synthesis for Binary Stellar Population at High Spectral Resolution: Integrated Spectral Energy Distributions and Absorption-feature Indices
- A Rare Encounter with Very Massive Stars in NGC 3125-A1
- Ultraviolet Spectroscopy of Circumnuclear Star Clusters in M83
Cited by in corpus (53)
- Binary Population and Spectral Synthesis Version 2.1: construction, observational verification and new results
- Reevaluating Old Stellar Populations
- Modelling the nebular emission from primeval to present-day star-forming galaxies
- BPASS predictions for Binary Black-Hole Mergers
- Delay-time distribution of core-collapse supernovae with late events resulting from binary interaction
- Ultraviolet spectra of extreme nearby star-forming regions --- approaching a local reference sample for JWST
- Legacy ExtraGalactic UV Survey with The Hubble Space Telescope. Stellar cluster catalogues and first insights into cluster formation and evolution in NGC 628
- Ionizing spectra of stars that lose their envelope through interaction with a binary companion: role of metallicity
- JWST/NIRCam Probes Young Star Clusters in the Reionization Era Sunrise Arc
- The GREATS H+[OIII] Luminosity Function and Galaxy Properties at : Walking the Way of JWST
- New Insights into the Evolution of Massive Stars and Their Effects on Our Understanding of Early Galaxies
- Photoionization Models for the Semi-Forbidden C III] 1909 Emission in Star-Forming Galaxies
- The impact of stars stripped in binaries on the integrated spectra of stellar populations
- The disappearance of the helium-giant progenitor of the type Ib supernova iPTF13bvn and constraints on its companion
- Neutron Star Kicks and their Relationship to Supernovae Ejecta Mass
- A VLT/FORS2 view at : Lyman- emitter fraction and galaxy physical properties at the edge of the epoch of cosmic reionization
- The Very Massive Star Content of the Nuclear Star Clusters in NGC 5253
- Modelling ultraviolet-line diagnostics of stars, the ionized and the neutral interstellar medium in star-forming galaxies
- The spectral evolution of the first Galaxies. III. Simulated James Webb Space Telescope spectra of reionization-epoch galaxies with Lyman continuum leakage
- Understanding the high-mass binary black hole population from stable mass transfer and super-Eddington accretion in BPASS
- Initial Mass Function Variations Cannot Explain the Ionizing Spectrum of Low Metallicity Starbursts
- Exploring HeII1640 emission line properties at
- Ultraviolet spectra of extreme nearby star-forming regions: evidence for an overabundance of very massive stars
- Rapidly evolving faint transients from stripped-envelope electron-capture supernovae
- Weighing in on black hole binaries with BPASS: LB-1 does not contain a 70M black hole
- The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey: XII. MgII emission and absorption in star-forming galaxies
- Hierarchical star formation across the grand design spiral NGC1566
- The HDUV Survey: Six Lyman Continuum Emitter Candidates at z~2 Revealed by HST UV Imaging
- H Morphologies of Star Clusters in 16 LEGUS Galaxies: Constraints on HII region evolution timescales
- Simultaneous analysis of SDSS spectra and GALEX photometry with STARLIGHT: Method and early results
- Explaining the differences in massive star models from various simulations
- Comparison of Theoretical Starburst Photoionisation Models for Optical Diagnostics
- From kpcs to the central parsec of NGC 1097: feeding star formation and a black hole at the same time
- Bright, Relatively Isolated Star Clusters in PHANGS-HST Galaxies: Aperture Corrections, Quantitative Morphologies, and Comparison with Synthetic Stellar Population Models
- What Drives the Redshift Evolution of Strong Emission Line Ratios?
- Revisiting Attenuation Curves: the Case of NGC 3351
- A novel method to automatically detect and measure the ages of star clusters in nearby galaxies: Application to the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Synthetic photometry of OB star clusters with stochastically sampled IMFs: analysis of models and HST observations
- On the Simultaneous Modelling of Dust and Stellar Populations for Interpretation of Galaxy Properties
- Empirical SED Templates for Star Clusters Observed with HST and JWST: No Strong PAH or IR Dust Emission after Five Myr
- HST viewing of spectacular star-forming trails behind ESO 137-001
- A machine-learning approach to measuring the escape of ionizing radiation from galaxies in the reionization epoch
- Constraining the LyC escape fraction from LEGUS star clusters with SIGNALS HII region observations: A pilot study of NGC 628
- Ages and Masses of Star Clusters in M33: a Multi-wavelength Study
- Dust Emission as a Function of Stellar Population Age in the Nearby Galaxy M33
- Gravitational wave spectral synthesis
- Blue galaxies: modelling nebular He II emission in high redshift galaxies
- Effects of binary stellar populations on direct collapse black hole formation
- What can distant galaxies teach us about massive stars?
- PAH Marks the Spot: Digging for Buried Clusters in Nearby Star-forming Galaxies
- The significant contribution of supersoft X-ray Sources to the nebular HeII line emission
- Interpreting Galaxy Properties with Improved Modelling
- Challenges and Techniques for Simulating Line Emission