The angular momentum controversy: What's it all about and does it matter?

Abstract

The general question, crucial to an understanding of the internal structure of the nucleon, of how to split the total angular momentum of a photon or gluon into spin and orbital contributions is one of the most important and interesting challenges faced by gauge theories like Quantum Electrodynamics and Quantum Chromodynamics. This is particularly challenging since all QED textbooks state that such an splitting cannot be done for a photon (and a fortiori for a gluon) in a gauge-invariant way, yet experimentalists around the world are engaged in measuring what they believe is the gluon spin! This question has been a subject of intense debate and controversy, ever since, in 2008, it was claimed that such a gauge-invariant split was, in fact, possible. We explain in what sense this claim is true and how it turns out that one of the main problems is that such a decomposition is not unique and therefore raises the question of what is the most natural or physical choice. The essential requirement of measurability does not solve the ambiguities and leads us to the conclusion that the choice of a particular decomposition is essentially a matter of taste and convenience. In this review, we provide a pedagogical introduction to the question of angular momentum decomposition in a gauge theory, present the main relevant decompositions and discuss in detail several aspects of the controversies regarding the question of gauge invariance, frame dependence, uniqueness and measurability. We stress the physical implications of the recent developments and collect into a separate section all the sum rules and relations which we think experimentally relevant. We hope that such a review will make the matter amenable to a broader community and will help to clarify the present situation.

96 pages, 11 figures, 5 tables, review prepared for Physics Reports

References in corpus (60)

• Generalized Parton Distributions
• Parton Physics on Euclidean Lattice
• Impact Parameter Space Interpretation for Generalized Parton Distributions
• The Stueckelberg Field
• Generalized parton distributions and strong forces inside nucleons and nuclei
• Pinch Technique: Theory and Applications
• Light-Cone Representation of the Spin and Orbital Angular Momentum of Relativistic Composite Systems
• The Deuteron Spin-dependent Structure Function g1d and its First Moment
• Generalized parton correlation functions for a spin-1/2 hadron
• Spin and orbital angular momentum in gauge theories: Nucleon spin structure and multipole radiation revisited
• Reply to the Comment on "Spin and orbital angular momentum in gauge theories: Nucleon spin structure and multipole radiation revisited" [PRL 100:232002 (2008)]
• Viewing the Proton Through "Color"-Filters
• Spin and orbital angular momentum in gauge theories (II): QCD and nucleon spin structure
• Notes on the orbital angular momentum of quarks in the nucleon
• The Spin Structure of the Nucleon
• Spin Structure of the Nucleon - Status and Recent Results
• Spin densities in the transverse plane and generalized transversity distributions
• Proton Spin Structure from Measurable Parton Distributions
• Measurement of the Spin Structure of the Deuteron in the DIS Region
• Structure analysis of the generalized correlator of quark and gluon for a spin-1/2 target
• Unified framework for generalized and transverse-momentum dependent parton distributions within a 3Q light-cone picture of the nucleon
• Why Gauge?
• Interplay of Spin and Orbital Angular Momentum in the Proton
• Chromodynamic Lensing and Transverse Single Spin Asymmetries
• Quantum Mechanical Properties of Bessel Beams
• On Gauge-Invariant Decomposition of Nucleon Spin
• DVCS amplitude in the parton model
• Gauge invariance and background field formalism in the exact renormalisation group
• Do gluons carry half of the nucleon momentum?
• Constraining quark angular momentum through semi-inclusive measurements
• Angular momentum of non-paraxial light beam: Dependence of orbital angular momentum on polarization
• Twist analysis of the nucleon spin in QCD
• Wilson lines and orbital angular momentum
• Physics of Gluon Helicity Contribution to Proton Spin
• Measurement of Dijet Production at Low Q^2 at HERA
• On the controversy concerning the definition of quark and gluon angular momentum
• Transverse Polarization of the Nucleon in Parton Picture
• Pretzelosity TMD and Quark Orbital Angular Momentum
• The Gauge-Invariant Angular Momentum Sum-Rule for the Proton
• Gauge invariant composite fields out of connections, with examples
• The role of orbital angular momentum in the proton spin
• Twist-three relations of gluonic correlators for the transversely polarized nucleon
• Proper identification of the gluon spin
• Covariantized Noether identities and conservation laws for perturbations in metric theories of gravity
• Spin in relativistic quantum theory
• A critical assessment of the angular momentum sum rules
• On transverse spin sum rules
• Transverse Spin in QCD and Transverse Polarized Deep Inelastic Scattering
• Gluon Spin, Canonical Momentum, and Gauge Symmetry
• Gauge links for transverse momentum dependent correlators at tree-level
• New relation between transverse angular momentum and generalized parton distributions
• Comments on Background Independence and Gauge Redundancies
• A relativistic study of Bessel beams
• On gauge invariant nucleon spin decomposition
• Gauge symmetry and background independence: Should the proton spin decomposition be path independent?
• Nucleon Spin in QCD: Old Crisis and New Resolution
• Decomposing the SU(N) Connection and the Wu-Yang Potential
• Physical Degrees of Freedom for Gauge Fields and the Issue of Spin
• The proton spin decomposition : path dependence and gauge symmetry
• Some Problems Concerning Interchange of Order of Integration in Functional Integral Formalism of U(1) Gauge Field Theories

Cited by in corpus (257)

• Transverse and longitudinal angular momenta of light
• An updated review of the new hadron states
• Theory and applications of free-electron vortex states
• Forces inside hadrons: pressure, surface tension, mechanical radius, and all that
• Parton distributions and lattice QCD calculations: a community white paper
• Large-Momentum Effective Theory
• Direct measurements of the extraordinary optical momentum and transverse spin-dependent force using a nano-cantilever
• Revisiting the mechanical properties of the nucleon
• Optical Momentum, Spin, and Angular Momentum in Dispersive Media
• 50 Years of Quantum Chromodynamics
• GPD phenomenology and DVCS fitting - Entering the high-precision era
• Polarization and Vorticity in the Quark Gluon Plasma
• Relativistic hydrodynamics for spin-polarized fluids
• Parton distributions and lattice QCD calculations: toward 3D structure
• Generating spin polarization from vorticity through nonlocal collisions
• Conservation of the spin and orbital angular momenta in electromagnetism
• Iterative Monte Carlo analysis of spin-dependent parton distributions
• Spin and orbital angular momenta of acoustic beams
• Spin tensor and its role in non-equilibrium thermodynamics
• Spin Hydrodynamics and Symmetric Energy-Momentum Tensors -- A current induced by the spin vorticity --
• Optical momentum and angular momentum in complex media: From the Abraham-Minkowski debate to unusual properties of surface plasmon-polaritons
• Relativistic spin hydrodynamics with torsion and linear response theory for spin relaxation
• Parton Distributions in Nucleons and Nuclei
• On the hadron mass decomposition
• The Spin Structure of the Nucleon
• Acoustic Radiation Force and Torque on Small Particles as Measures of the Canonical Momentum and Spin Densities
• Spin tensor and pseudo-gauges: from nuclear collisions to gravitational physics
• Effective quantum kinetic theory for spin transport of fermions with collsional effects
• Spatial distribution of angular momentum inside the nucleon
• Promises and challenges of high-energy vortex states collisions
• Spin Polarizations in a Covariant Angular-Momentum-Conserved Chiral Transport Model
• Small-$x$ Helicity Evolution: an Operator Treatment
• Forces within hadrons on the light front
• Small-$x$ asymptotics of the quark helicity distribution
• A Lattice Study of Quark and Glue Momenta and Angular Momenta in the Nucleon
• Diffractive Dijet Production and Wigner Distributions from the Color Glass Condensate
• Small-$x$ Asymptotics of the Gluon Helicity Distribution
• Gravitational form factors of light mesons
• Spacetime algebra as a powerful tool for electromagnetism
• Spin and polarization: a new direction in relativistic heavy ion physics
• Phenomenological assessment of proton mechanical properties from deeply virtual Compton scattering
• Covariant multipole expansion of local currents for massive states of any spin
• Spin-orbit correlations in the nucleon
• Nucleon gravitational form factors from instantons: forces between quark and gluon subsystems
• Acoustic versus electromagnetic field theory: scalar, vector, spinor representations and the emergence of acoustic spin
• Energy momentum tensor and the D-term in the bag model
• The energy-momentum tensor of spin-1 hadrons: formalism
• Side-Jump Induced Spin-Orbit Interaction of Chiral Fluids from Kinetic Theory
• Unified formalism for electromagnetic and gravitational probes: densities
• The light-front gauge-invariant energy-momentum tensor
• Wigner Distributions for Gluons in Light-front Dressed Quark Model
• A Fixed-Target Programme at the LHC: Physics Case and Projected Performances for Heavy-Ion, Hadron, Spin and Astroparticle Studies
• Nucleon generalized form factors from two-flavor lattice QCD
• Polarized Antimatter in the Proton from Global QCD Analysis
• Constructing phase space distributions with internal symmetries
• Gauge Symmetries, Symmetry Breaking, and Gauge-Invariant Approaches
• Calculating TMDs of a Large Nucleus: Quasi-Classical Approximation and Quantum Evolution
• Gluon Gravitational Form Factors at Large Momentum Transfer
• How well do we know the gluon polarization in the proton?
• The Parton Orbital Angular Momentum: Status and Prospects
• Quark and Gluon Helicity Evolution at Small $x$: Revised and Updated
• Helicity at Small $x$: Oscillations Generated by Bringing Back the Quarks
• The relativistic center of mass in field theory with spin
• Transverse spin effects in hard semi-inclusive collisions
• Perturbative Calculations of Gravitational Form Factors at Large Momentum Transfer
• Resolution of a conflict between Laser and Elementary Particle Physics
• Constraints on spin-dependent parton distributions at large x from global QCD analysis
• Pseudo-gauges and relativistic spin hydrodynamics for interacting Dirac and Proca fields
• Mass-polariton theory of sharing the total angular momentum of light between the field and matter
• New explicit expressions for Dirac bilinears
• Quark orbital dynamics in the proton from Lattice QCD -- from Ji to Jaffe-Manohar orbital angular momentum
• Wigner functions and quantum kinetic theory of polarized photons
• Helicity Evolution at Small $x$: the Single-Logarithmic Contribution
• Orbital Angular Momentum at Small $x$
• Rigorous constraints on the matrix elements of the energy-momentum tensor
• The issue of gauge choice in the Landau problem and the physics of canonical and mechanical orbital angular momenta
• Angular momentum and generalized parton distributions for the proton with basis light-front quantization
• Unveiling the Proton Spin Decomposition at a Future Electron-Ion Collider
• Where do we stand with a 3-D picture of the proton?
• Relativistic Spin-Orbit Interactions of Photons and Electrons
• Transverse Spin Structure of the Nucleon
• Quantum field theory for spin operator of the photon
• Canonical and Poynting currents in propagation and diffraction of structured light: tutorial
• Loop spin effects in intense background fields
• Analytic Solution for the Revised Helicity Evolution at Small $x$ and Large $N_c$: New Resummed Gluon-Gluon Polarized Anomalous Dimension and Intercept
• Twist-3 GPDs in Deeply-Virtual Compton Scattering
• Gravitational form factors and angular momentum densities in light-front quark-diquark model
• Lorentz Invariance and QCD Equation of Motion Relations for Generalized Parton Distributions and the Dynamical Origin of Proton Orbital Angular Momentum
• Noether's theorems and the energy-momentum tensor in quantum gauge theories
• An introductory lecture on Generalised Parton Distributions
• Dilaton and Massive Hadrons in a Conformal Phase
• 2D energy-momentum tensor distributions of nucleon in a large-$N_c$ quark model from ultra-relativistic to non-relativistic limit
• Pseudo-gauge dependence of quantum fluctuations of energy in a hot relativistic gas of fermions
• Gluon distributions and their applications to Ioffe-time distributions
• Bundle geometry of the connection space, covariant Hamiltonian formalism, the problem of boundaries in gauge theories, and the dressing field method
• Pion gravitational form factors in a relativistic theory of composite particles
• Genuine empirical pressure within the proton
• Vortex $\gamma$ photon generation via spin-to-orbital angular momentum transfer in nonlinear Compton scattering
• Novel twist-three transverse-spin sum rule for the proton and related generalized parton distributions
• Quark spin and orbital angular momentum from proton GPDs
• Nucleon relativistic polarization and magnetization distributions
• Relativistic spin sum rules and the role of the pivot
• Pseudogauge freedom and the SO(3) algebra of spin operators
• The dressing field method of gauge symmetry reduction, a review with examples
• From Ji to Jaffe-Manohar orbital angular momentum in Lattice QCD using a direct derivative method
• Universality of the Poincaré gravitational form factor constraints
• Monopole and quadrupole contributions to the angular momentum density
• Angular Momentum Conservation Law in Light-Front Quantum Field Theory
• The gravitational form factors of the electron in quantum electrodynamics
• Momentum, angular momentum, and spin of waves in an isotropic collisionless plasma
• Orbital Angular Momentum and Generalized Transverse Momentum Distribution
• Helicity Evolution at Small $x$: Revised Asymptotic Results at Large $N_c\&N_f$
• Impact of DCSB and dynamical diquark correlations on proton GPDs
• Nucleon spin decomposition and differential geometry
• Pre-Town Meeting on Spin Physics at an Electron-Ion Collider
• Tractors and Twistors from conformal Cartan geometry: a gauge theoretic approach I. Tractors
• The physics of helical electron beam in a uniform magnetic field as a testing ground of gauge principle
• Twisted particle collisions: a new tool for spin physics
• Spin and momentum of the light fields in inhomogeneous dispersive media with application to surface plasmon-polariton waves
• Quark transverse spin-orbit correlations
• Gluon transversity in polarized proton-deuteron Drell-Yan process
• Spin and Orbital Angular Momentum of Coherent Photons in a Waveguide
• Tractors and Twistors from conformal Cartan geometry: a gauge theoretic approach II. Twistors
• The role of electron orbital angular momentum in the Aharonov-Bohm effect revisited
• Spatial densities of momentum and forces in spin-one hadrons
• QCD angular momentum in $N\to \Delta$ transitions
• Statistical description of the proton spin with a large gluon helicity distribution
• The Spin Budget of the Proton at NNLO and Beyond
• Relativistic composite-particle theory of the gravitational form factors of pion: quantitative results
• Light-front representation of chiral dynamics with Delta isobar and large-N_c relations
• Global analysis of polarized DIS & SIDIS data with improved small-$x$ helicity evolution
• Angular Momentum Distribution in the Transverse Plane
• Transverse spin sum rule of the proton
• Light-front representation of chiral dynamics in peripheral transverse densities
• Quantum Commutation Relationship for Photonic Orbital Angular Momentum
• Special Theory of Relativity for a Graded Index Fibre
• Angular momentum decomposition from a QED example
• Physical symmetries and gauge choices in the Landau problem
• Partonic angular momentum in the nucleon's chiral periphery
• Emergent Canonical Spin Tensor in the Chiral-Symmetric Hot QCD
• Deuteron polarizations in the proton-deuteron Drell-Yan process for finding the gluon transversity
• Anomalous Geometric Spin Hall Effect of Light?
• On the canonical formulation of gauge field theories and Poincare transformations
• Gauge Is More Than Mathematical Redundancy
• Boundary terms in quantum field theory and the spin structure of QCD
• Unravelling the physical meaning of the Jaffe-Manohar decomposition of the nucleon spin
• Towards three-dimensional nucleon structures at the Electron-Ion Collider in China: A study of the Sivers function
• Unpolarized generalized parton distributions of light and heavy vector mesons
• Measurement of Optical Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum: Implications for Photon Angular Momentum
• Gravitational transverse-momentum distributions
• Generation of Ultrarelativistic Vortex Leptons with Large Orbital Angular Momenta
• Superkicks and the photon angular and linear momentum density
• Spatial densities of the photon on the light front
• Flavor structure of the energy-momentum tensor form factors of the proton
• Baryons and Chiral Symmetry
• Quantum stresses in the hydrogen atom
• Classical Emergence of Intrinsic Spin-Orbit Interaction of Light at the Nanoscale
• Bound states -- from QED to QCD
• Quark spin-orbit correlations in the pion meson in light-cone quark model
• Scalar gauge fields
• Exploring Baryon Resonances with Transition Generalized Parton Distributions: Status and Perspectives
• On the two remaning issues in the gauge-invariant decomposition problem of the nucleon spin
• Relativistic decomposition of the orbital and the spin angular momentum in chiral physics and Feynman's angular momentum paradox
• Proton spin after 30 years: what we know and what we don't?
• Regularization dependence of pion generalised parton distributions
• Quark spin-orbit correlations in spin-0 and spin-1 mesons using the light-front quark model
• Momentum, spin, and orbital angular momentum of electromagnetic, acoustic, and water waves
• Dynamical constraints on pseudo-gauge transformations
• Collective dynamics of polarized spin-half fermions in relativistic heavy-ion collisions
• Quark Orbital Angular Momentum in the MIT Bag Model
• Radiation forces and torques in optics and acoustics
• Revisiting the compatibility problem between the gauge principle and the observability of the canonical orbital angular momentum in the Landau problem
• Role of guiding center in Landau level system and mechanical and pseudo orbital angular momenta
• Photonic Quantum Chromo-Dynamics
• Mechanical form factors and densities of non-relativistic fermions
• Pion gravitational form factors at large momentum transfer in the instant-form relativistic impulse approximation approach
• Graviton topology
• The role of the GPD E in the determination of the parton angular momenta
• Relativistic energy-momentum tensor distributions in a polarized nucleon
• Quark angular momentum in a spectator model
• Recent developments in chiral and spin polarization effects in heavy-ion collisions
• Light front synchronization and rest frame densities of the proton: Electromagnetic densities
• Spin-orbit correlation and spatial distributions for spin-0 hadrons
• Mean free path of photons in relativistic heavy ion collisions
• On the role of the subsidiary fields in the momentum and angular momentum in covariantly quantized QED and QCD
• A still unsettled issue in the nucleon spin decomposition problem : On the role of surface terms and gluon topology
• On energy-momentum and spin/helicity of quark and gluon fields
• Proton spin: a topological invariant
• Gluon Generalized TMDs and Wigner Distributions in boost invariant longitudinal space
• Quark and Glue Components of the Proton Spin from Lattice Calculation
• The axial charges of proton within an extended chiral constituent quark model
• Impact of gauge fixing on angular momentum operators of the covariantly quantized electromagnetic field
• Elementary quantum mechanics of the neutron with an electric dipole moment
• Electromagnetic gauge-freedom and work
• Spin of Photons: Nature of Polarisation
• Gluon generalized transverse momentum dependent parton distributions and Wigner functions of the Proton
• Orbital angular momentum of the proton and intrinsic five-quark Fock states
• Investigations on the flavor-dependent axial charges of the octet baryons
• Helicity is a topological invariant of massless particles: C=-2h
• Mapping the transverse spin sum rule in position space
• Unconventional Supersymmetry via the Dressing Field Method
• On the decomposition theorem for gluons
• Potential linear and angular momentum in the scalar diquark model
• Electromagnetic angular momentum of the electron: One-loop studies
• Parton Decomposition of Nucleon Spin and Momentum: Gluons from Dressed Quarks
• Mass decomposition of the pion in the 't Hooft model
• Basis transformation properties of anomalous dimensions for hard exclusive processes
• Dirac Equation for Photons: Origin of Polarisation
• Pseudogauge ambiguity in the distributions of energy density, pressure, and shear force inside the nucleon
• Zero curvature is a necessary and sufficient condition for a spin-orbital decomposition
• Can sea quark asymmetry shed light on the orbital angular momentum of the proton?
• Electric field-based quantization of the gauge invariant Proca theory
• Angular momentum of the electron: One-loop studies
• Mass sum rules of the electron in quantum electrodynamics
• On the Angular Momentum and Spin of Generalized Electromagnetic Field for $r$-Vectors in $(k,n)$ Space-Time Dimensions
• Quantum stress and torsion distributions in the deuteron
• Energy, angular momentum and pressure force distributions inside nucleons
• Preponderant Orbital Polarization in Relativistic Magnetovortical Matter
• Spin Angular Momentum of Proton Spin Puzzle in Complex Octonion Spaces
• Gauge invariant gluon spin operator for spinless non-linear wave solutions
• Four no-go theorems on the existence of spin and orbital angular momentum of massless bosons
• Unified treatment of the total angular momentum of single photons via generalized quantum observables
• Quark and gluon orbital angular momentum: Where are we?
• Reformulations of Yang-Mills Theories with Space-time Tensor Fields
• Achievements and open issues in the determination of polarized parton distribution functions
• Equivalence of helicity and Euclidean self-duality for gauge fields
• Quark spin-orbit correlations
• Confinement with Perturbation Theory, after All?
• Spacetime geometry of acoustics and electromagnetism
• Energy-momentum tensor form factors and spin density distribution in the nucleon calculated in a quantized Skyrme model with vector mesons
• The quark orbital angular momentum of ground state octet baryons
• Neutron DVCS Measurements with BONuS12 in CLAS12
• On the non-uniqueness of the energy-momentum and spin currents
• The gauge-invariant canonical energy-momentum tensor
• Single-Transverse-Spin-Asymmetry studies with a fixed-target experiment using the LHC beams (AFTER@LHC)
• Orbital angular momentum in the nucleons
• Viscoelastic response and anisotropic hydrodynamics in Weyl semimetals
• Macroscopic Singlet, Triplet, and Colour-Charged States of Coherent Photons
• Symmetry of Dirac two-oscillator system, gauge-invariance, and Landau problem
• Non-manifest symmetries in quantum field theory
• Neutron Spin Structure from e-3He Scattering with Double Spectator Tagging at the Electron-Ion Collider
• Extended Conformal Symmetry in $d\ne 4$: Conformal Symmetry of Abelian Gauge Theory in the Physical Sector
• Gravitational formfactors of the $\rho$ meson in QCD sum rules
• Accessing the Gluon Momentum Fraction of Nucleons through the Gradient Flow
• Proton spin from small-$x$ with constraints from the valence quark model
• Conference Summary of QNP2018
• Mechanical properties of proton in the momentum space
• Transverse-spin gluon distribution function
• Transverse energy-momentum tensor distributions in polarized nucleons
• Spin structure of the nucleon on the light front
• Accessing baryon-antibaryon generalized distribution amplitudes in $e^{\pm }\gamma \to e^{\pm }B\bar{B}$
• Gravitational form-factors of the $\pi$ and $K$ mesons in QCD sum rules
• Deformed angular momentum algebra within the real Hilbert space
• Physical Angular Momentum Separation for QED
• Some remarks on the current issues in nucleon spin structure study
• Quantum statistical fluctuation of energy and its novel pseudo-gauge dependence
• A New Improved Energy-Momentum Tensor and Its Possible Role in Gravity