Excluding Black Hole Firewalls with Extreme Cosmic Censorship
arXiv:1306.0562 · doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2014/06/051
Abstract
The AMPS argument for black hole firewalls seems to arise not only from the assumption of local effective field theory outside the stretched horizon but also from an overcounting of internal black hole states that include states that are singular in the past. Here I propose to exclude such singular states by Extreme Cosmic Censorship (the conjectured principle that the universe is entirely nonsingular, except for transient singularities inside black and/or white holes). I argue that the remaining set of nonsingular realistic states do not have firewalls but yet preserve information in Hawking radiation from black holes that form from nonsingular initial states.
arXiv comment23 pages, LaTeX, more minor revisions, quotes from Hawking, references added in response to comments by referees and colleagues and from new citations to AMPS, and additions to the acknowledgments
References in corpus (128)
- Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
- Black holes and the butterfly effect
- Black Holes: Complementarity or Firewalls?
- Cool horizons for entangled black holes
- Time Evolution of Entanglement Entropy from Black Hole Interiors
- Multiple Shocks
- Better Late than Never: Information Retrieval from Black Holes
- Quantum Gravity In De Sitter Space
- An Apologia for Firewalls
- Time Dependence of Hawking Radiation Entropy
- An Infalling Observer in AdS/CFT
- State-Dependent Bulk-Boundary Maps and Black Hole Complementarity
- Positive vacuum energy and the N-bound
- Gauge/Gravity Duality and the Black Hole Interior
- Loop quantization of the Schwarzschild black hole
- Quantum Computation vs. Firewalls
- The Black Hole Interior in AdS/CFT and the Information Paradox
- Information Preservation and Weather Forecasting for Black Holes
- Black holes, quantum information, and unitary evolution
- Complementarity Is Not Enough
- Nonviolent nonlocality
- Models for unitary black hole disintegration
- Comments on black holes I: The possibility of complementarity
- Search for a heavy top-quark partner in final states with two leptons with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
- Nonviolent information transfer from black holes: a field theory parameterization
- Non-extremal Black Hole Microstates: Fuzzballs of Fire or Fuzzballs of Fuzz ?
- Black Holes, Information, and Hilbert Space for Quantum Gravity
- The Transfer of Entanglement: The Case for Firewalls
- Is the firewall consistent?: Gedanken experiments on black hole complementarity and firewall proposal
- The Value of Singularities
- Complementarity Endures: No Firewall for an Infalling Observer
- Unitarity and fuzzball complementarity: "Alice fuzzes but may not even know it!"
- Unbounded entropy in spacetimes with positive cosmological constant
- Resolving the Structure of Black Holes: Philosophizing with a Hammer
- Black Hole Complementarity and the Harlow-Hayden Conjecture
- The flaw in the firewall argument
- A global picture of quantum de Sitter space
- Entangled black holes as ciphers of hidden information
- String Theory Versus Black Hole Complementarity
- Firewalls From Double Purity
- Singularities, Firewalls, and Complementarity
- Evaporating Firewalls
- Black hole entropy, curved space and monsters
- Black hole complementarity and firewall in two dimensions
- Passing through the Firewall
- Thin-shell bubbles and information loss problem in anti de Sitter background
- String theory at the tip of the cigar
- Boundary unitarity and the black hole information paradox
- The Born Rule Dies
- Sensible Quantum Mechanics: Are Probabilities only in the Mind?
- Modulated Hawking radiation and a nonviolent channel for information release
- Entropic N-bound and Maximal Mass Conjecture Violations in Four Dimensional Taub-Bolt(NUT)-dS Spacetimes
- Is Alice burning or fuzzing?
- Holographic Space-Time Does Not Predict Firewalls
- Effective field theory models for nonviolent information transfer from black holes
- Measurement of the hadronic activity in events with a Z and two jets and extraction of the cross section for the electroweak production of a Z with two jets in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV
- Black holes without firewalls
- An Uneventful Horizon in Two Dimensions
- Restoring predictability in semiclassical gravitational collapse
- Pure states and black hole complementarity
- Sensible Quantum Mechanics: Are Only Perceptions Probabilistic?
- Backdraft: String Creation in an Old Schwarzschild Black Hole
- A Note on (No) Firewalls: The Entropy Argument
- Butterflies on the Stretched Horizon
- Behind the Horizon in AdS/CFT
- Comment on the black hole firewall
- Measurements without Probabilities in the Final State Proposal
- Holographic Space-time and Black Holes: Mirages As Alternate Reality
- Statistical physics of black holes as quantum-mechanical systems
- Black Holes or Firewalls: A Theory of Horizons
- Semiclassical black holes expose forbidden charges and censor divergent densities
- The Entropy of a Vacuum: What Does the Covariant Entropy Count?
- Black Hole Information as Topological Qubits
- New Concepts for Old Black Holes
- Sketches of emergent geometry in the gauge/gravity duality
- Low Energy Description of Quantum Gravity and Complementarity
- Energy and Information Near Black Hole Horizons
- Computational Complexity and Black Hole Horizons
- Firewalls in AdS/CFT
- Remarks on Black Hole Evolution a la Firewalls and Fuzzballs
- A Rotating Black Hole Solution for Shape Dynamics
- Monsters, black holes and the statistical mechanics of gravity
- Status report: black hole complementarity controversy
- What does strong subadditivity tell us about black holes?
- Unitarity and the Hilbert space of quantum gravity
- Phases of information release during black hole evaporation
- Hyper-Entropic Gravitational Fireballs (Grireballs) with Firewalls
- Consciousness and the Quantum
- Indication for unsmooth horizon induced by quantum gravity interaction
- Mass of a Black Hole Firewall
- Macroscopic superpositions and black hole unitarity
- Black hole complementarity: the inside view
- On the pattern of black hole information release
- Lobotomy of Flux Compactifications
- A Review of the N-bound and the Maximal Mass Conjectures Using NUT-Charged dS Spacetimes
- Insufficiency of the Quantum State for Deducing Observational Probabilities
- Disentangling the Black Hole Vacuum
- Causal Patch Complementarity: The Inside Story for Old Black Holes
- Numerical Evidence for Firewalls
- No Holography for Eternal AdS Black Holes
- Black Hole Firewalls Require Huge Energy of Measurement
- On-shell actions with lightlike boundary data
- Typicality Derived
- Symmetric-Bounce Quantum State of the Universe
- On the many saddle points description of quantum black holes
- No Firewalls in Holographic Space-Time or Matrix Theory
- Cool horizons lead to information loss
- Black holes vs. firewalls and thermo-field dynamics
- Black Hole Formation at the Correspondence Point
- The Fate of Monsters in Anti-de Sitter Spacetime
- Freely Falling Observer and Black Hole Radiation
- Factorization of unitarity and black hole firewalls
- Unitary S Matrices With Long-Range Correlations and the Quantum Black Hole
- Complementarity + Back-reaction is enough
- No-Bang Quantum State of the Cosmos
- What happens at the horizon?
- Firewalls, smoke and mirrors
- Karlhede's invariant and the black hole firewall proposal
- Evaporating black holes have leaky horizons or exotic atmospheres
- The two faces of Hawking radiation
- Finite Canonical Measure for Nonsingular Cosmologies
- Thermal duality and gravitational collapse in heterotic string theories
- Still No Rindler Firewalls
- Stochastic Quantum Gravity, Gravitational Collapse and Grey Holes
- Brick Walls for Black Holes in AdS/CFT
- Multi-particle correlations, many particle systems, and entropy in effective field theories
- Semi-Classical Field Theory as Decoherence Free Subspaces
- Comment on "Empty Black Holes, Firewalls, and the Origin of Bekenstein-Hawking Entropy"
Cited by in corpus (48)
- State-Dependent Bulk-Boundary Maps and Black Hole Complementarity
- Entanglement entropy and nonabelian gauge symmetry
- Comments on the Necessity and Implications of State-Dependence in the Black Hole Interior
- The Typical-State Paradox: Diagnosing Horizons with Complexity
- Evaporating Firewalls
- Black Hole Complementarity in Gravity's Rainbow
- Black hole evaporation without an event horizon
- An Uneventful Horizon in Two Dimensions
- Butterflies on the Stretched Horizon
- Holographic Space-time and Black Holes: Mirages As Alternate Reality
- Statistical physics of black holes as quantum-mechanical systems
- Unruh-DeWitt detector response across a Rindler firewall is finite
- Lagrangian constraints and renormalization of 4D gravity
- Distinguishing Brans-Dicke-Kerr type naked singularities and black holes with their thin disk electromagnetic radiation properties
- Computational Complexity and Black Hole Horizons
- Smooth Causal Patches for AdS Black Holes
- Icezones instead of firewalls: extended entanglement beyond the event horizon and unitary evaporation of a black hole
- Qubit Transport Model for Unitary Black Hole Evaporation without Firewalls
- (1+1)D Calculation provides evidence that quantum entanglement survives a firewall
- Black Hole Firewalls Require Huge Energy of Measurement
- How can we erase states inside a black hole?
- The semi-classical stress-energy tensor in a Schwarzschild background, the information paradox, and the fate of an evaporating black hole
- Smooth and sharp creation of a Dirichlet wall in 1+1 quantum field theory: how singular is the sharp creation limit?
- Black Holes, Entropies, and Semiclassical Spacetime in Quantum Gravity
- Page curves for tripartite systems
- Something special at the event horizon
- Black holes, white holes, and near-horizon physics
- Schrödinger evolution of two-dimensional black holes
- Models for the nonsingular transition of an evaporating black hole into a white hole
- Firewalls, smoke and mirrors
- Interpreting the semi-classical stress-energy tensor in a Schwarzschild background, implications for the information paradox
- Classifying self-gravitating radiations
- Firewalls as artefacts of inconsistent truncations of quantum geometries
- Before the Page time: maximum entanglements or the return of the monster?
- Black Hole Information Loss: Some Food for Thoughts
- Still No Rindler Firewalls
- Resolution to the firewall paradox: The black hole information paradox and highly squeezed interior quantum fluctuations
- The effective Tolman temperature in curved spacetimes
- Quantum Jump from Singularity to Outside of Black Hole
- The Firewall Paradox
- Black holes to white holes I. A complete quasi-classical model
- Falling through the black hole horizon
- Semiclassical approach for the evaporating black hole revisited
- Free-fall energy density and flux in the Schwarzschild black hole
- Heat capacity of a self-gravitating spherical shell of radiations
- On the Origin of Black Hole Paradoxes
- Thought Experiment to resolve the Black Hole Information Paradox
- Note on Localized Objects as Constrained States of Holographic Variables