The flaw in the firewall argument
arXiv:1306.5488 · doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2014.05.012
Abstract
A lot of confusion surrounds the issue of black hole complementarity, because the question has been considered without discussing the mechanism which guarantees unitarity. Considering such a mechanism leads to the following: (1) The Hawking quanta with energy E of order the black hole temperature T carry information, and so only appropriate processes involving E>>T quanta can have any possible complementary description with an information-free horizon; (2) The stretched horizon describes all possible black hole states with a given mass M, and it must expand out to a distance s_{bubble} before it can accept additional infalling bits; (3) The Hawking radiation has a specific low temperature T, and infalling quanta interact significantly with it only within a distance s_{alpha} of the horizon. One finds s_{alpha} << s_{bubble} for E>>T, and this removes the argument against complementarity recently made by Almheiri et al. In particular, the condition E>>T leads to the notion of 'fuzzball complementarity', where the modes around the horizon are indeed correctly entangled in the complementary picture to give the vacuum.
arXiv comment52 pages, 13 figures, v3: comments on Rindler space added, references added
References in corpus (53)
- Gauge Theory Correlators from Non-Critical String Theory
- The World as a Hologram
- Average Entropy of a Subsystem
- Eternal Black Holes in AdS
- Building up spacetime with quantum entanglement
- The Stretched Horizon and Black Hole Complementarity
- The information paradox: A pedagogical introduction
- The fuzzball proposal for black holes: an elementary review
- AdS/CFT duality and the black hole information paradox
- Better Late than Never: Information Retrieval from Black Holes
- The fuzzball proposal for black holes
- Dual geometries for a set of 3-charge microstates
- A Model for High Energy Scattering in Quantum Gravity
- String Theory and the Principle of Black Hole Complementarity
- Gravity solutions for the D1-D5 system with angular momentum
- Black Hole Complementarity vs. Locality
- The Holographic Principle
- Non-supersymmetric smooth geometries and D1-D5-P bound states
- Logarithmic Corrections to N=2 Black Hole Entropy: An Infrared Window into the Microstates
- Adding momentum to D1-D5 system
- Comments on quantum gravity and entanglement
- Global Structure of Five-dimensional BPS Fuzzballs
- Constructing "hair" for the three charge hole
- Four Dimensional Black Hole Microstates: From D-branes to Spacetime Foam
- Radiation from the non-extremal fuzzball
- Instability of non-supersymmetric smooth geometries
- Models for unitary black hole disintegration
- Black Hole Creation in 2+1 Dimensions
- D1-D5-P microstates at the cap
- Nonviolent information transfer from black holes: a field theory parameterization
- 6D microstate geometries from 10D structures
- Deforming the D1D5 CFT away from the orbifold point
- Correlations in Hawking radiation and the infall problem
- Unitarity and fuzzball complementarity: "Alice fuzzes but may not even know it!"
- Excitations in the deformed D1D5 CFT
- New D1-D5-P geometries from string amplitudes
- Black Holes and Beyond
- Adding momentum to supersymmetric geometries
- Entangled black holes as ciphers of hidden information
- Operator mixing for string states in the D1-D5 CFT near the orbifold point
- Microstates at the boundary of AdS
- Emission rates, the Correspondence Principle and the Information Paradox
- Modave Lectures on Fuzzballs and Emission from the D1-D5 System
- Passing through the Firewall
- How fast can a black hole release its information?
- Twist-nontwist correlators in M^N/S_N orbifold CFTs
- Momentum-carrying waves on D1-D5 microstate geometries
- Adding new hair to the 3-charge black ring
- Perturbative superstrata
- Black Hole Information as Topological Qubits
- Membrane paradigm realized?
- Emergent spacetime, and a model for unitary gravitational collapse in AdS
- Qubit Models of Black Hole Evaporation
Cited by in corpus (52)
- Jerusalem Lectures on Black Holes and Quantum Information
- Transcending the ensemble: baby universes, spacetime wormholes, and the order and disorder of black hole information
- State-Dependent Bulk-Boundary Maps and Black Hole Complementarity
- The Black Hole information problem: past, present, and future
- Habemus Superstratum! A constructive proof of the existence of superstrata
- Comments on the Necessity and Implications of State-Dependence in the Black Hole Interior
- Asymptotically-flat supergravity solutions deep inside the black-hole regime
- Momentum Fractionation on Superstrata
- Gravitational echoes from macroscopic quantum gravity effects
- Unitarity and fuzzball complementarity: "Alice fuzzes but may not even know it!"
- Resolving the Structure of Black Holes: Philosophizing with a Hammer
- Holographic description of non-supersymmetric orbifolded D1-D5-P solutions
- Can we observe fuzzballs or firewalls?
- Excluding Black Hole Firewalls with Extreme Cosmic Censorship
- Integrability and Black-Hole Microstate Geometries
- Violations of the Born rule in cool state-dependent horizons
- Fuzzballs and Observations
- Black Holes: Eliminating Information or Illuminating New Physics?
- Black-Hole Entropy from Supergravity Superstrata States
- Uncertainty relation in Schwarzschild spacetime
- Little Strings, Long Strings, and Fuzzballs
- Aspects of the Papadodimas-Raju Proposal for the Black Hole Interior
- Tidal Stresses and Energy Gaps in Microstate Geometries
- Non-BPS multi-bubble microstate geometries
- An Uneventful Horizon in Two Dimensions
- Bolting Multicenter Solutions
- Operator mixing in deformed D1D5 CFT and the OPE on the cover
- Energy and Information Near Black Hole Horizons
- Smooth Causal Patches for AdS Black Holes
- Two Kissing Bolts
- What does strong subadditivity tell us about black holes?
- The fuzzball nature of two-charge black hole microstates
- Firewalls and flat mirrors: An alternative to the AMPS experiment which evades the Harlow-Hayden obstacle
- Black hole complementarity: the inside view
- Black Holes, Entropies, and Semiclassical Spacetime in Quantum Gravity
- A model with no firewall
- An equation of state in the limit of high densities
- Rescuing Complementarity With Little Drama
- Black holes, white holes, and near-horizon physics
- Are there echoes of gravitational waves?
- Entropic Entanglement: Information Prison Break
- Still No Rindler Firewalls
- Quantum Jump from Singularity to Outside of Black Hole
- The Firewall Paradox
- Nonlocal black hole evaporation and quantum metric fluctuations via inhomogeneous vacuum density
- Falling through the black hole horizon
- Black hole interior Petz map reconstruction and Papadodimas-Raju proposal
- On Some Information-geometric aspects of Hawking radiation
- Spacetime has a `thickness'
- On the Origin of Black Hole Paradoxes
- Thermomagnetic Ettingshausen-Nernst effect in tachocline, magnetic reconnection phenomenon in lower layers, axion mechanism of solar luminosity variations, coronal heating problem solution and mechanism of ADM variations around BH
- Thought Experiment to resolve the Black Hole Information Paradox