Meaningful characterisation of perturbative theoretical uncertainties

Abstract

We consider the problem of assigning a meaningful degree of belief to uncertainty estimates of perturbative series. We analyse the assumptions which are implicit in the conventional estimates made using renormalisation scale variations. We then formulate a Bayesian model that, given equivalent initial hypotheses, allows one to characterise a perturbative theoretical uncertainty in a rigorous way in terms of a credibility interval for the remainder of the series. We compare its outcome to the conventional uncertainty estimates in the simple case of the calculation of QCD corrections to the e+e- -> hadrons process. We find comparable results, but with important conceptual differences. This work represents a first step in the direction of a more comprehensive and rigorous handling of theoretical uncertainties in perturbative calculations used in high energy phenomenology.

28 pages, 5 figures. Language modified in order to make it more 'bayesian'. No change in results. Version published in JHEP

References in corpus (7)

• Parton distributions for the LHC
• New parton distributions for collider physics
• A first unbiased global NLO determination of parton distributions and their uncertainties
• Giant QCD K-factors beyond NLO
• The SM and NLO multileg working group: Summary report
• Predictions for Higgs production at the Tevatron and the associated uncertainties
• Addendum to: Predictions for Higgs production at the Tevatron and the associated uncertainties

Cited by in corpus (72)

• Parton distributions for the LHC Run II
• New parton distribution functions from a global analysis of quantum chromodynamics
• Top-pair production at hadron colliders with next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic soft-gluon resummation
• Handbook of LHC Higgs Cross Sections: 2. Differential Distributions
• Medium Modifications and Production of Charmonia at LHC
• Quantifying truncation errors in effective field theory
• The Structure of the Proton in the LHC Precision Era
• 50 Years of Quantum Chromodynamics
• SusHi Bento: Beyond NNLO and the heavy-top limit
• Quantifying Correlated Truncation Errors in Effective Field Theory
• Bayesian truncation errors in chiral effective field theory: nucleon-nucleon observables
• Planck Scale Boundary Conditions and the Higgs Mass
• The PDF4LHC report on PDFs and LHC data: Results from Run I and preparation for Run II
• Uncertainty analysis and order-by-order optimization of chiral nuclear interactions
• Quantifying uncertainties and correlations in the nuclear-matter equation of state
• Dynamical scales for multi-TeV top-pair production at the LHC
• Ab-initio QCD calculations impact the inference of the neutron-star-matter equation of state
• A recipe for EFT uncertainty quantification in nuclear physics
• Hadron structure in high-energy collisions
• Approximate N^3LO Higgs-boson production cross section using physical-kernel constraints
• The Higgs Boson Lineshape
• Charged Current Drell-Yan Production at N3LO
• FLAG Review 2024
• On the Higgs cross section at N${}^3$LO+N${}^3$LL and its uncertainty
• Inclusive Production Cross Sections at N3LO
• Precision NNLO determination of alpha_s(M_Z) using an unbiased global parton set
• Higgs production at the LHC: updated cross sections at $\sqrt{s}=8$ TeV
• Precision determination of the strong coupling constant within a global PDF analysis
• May the four be with you: Novel IR-subtraction methods to tackle NNLO calculations
• Equation of State of Cold Quark Matter to $O({\alpha }_s^3\ln {\alpha }_s)$
• An extensive survey of the estimation of uncertainties from missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• Parton Shower Uncertainties with Herwig 7: Benchmarks at Leading Order
• Effective field theory for nuclear vibrations with quantified uncertainties
• Do we need N${}^3$LO Parton Distributions?
• Probabilistic definition of the perturbative theoretical uncertainty from missing higher orders
• Prospects for Higgs physics at energies up to 100 TeV
• How well can we guess theoretical uncertainties?
• Bayesian uncertainty quantification of perturbative QCD input to the neutron-star equation of state
• On the Consistent Use of Scale Variations in PDF Fits and Predictions
• Nucleon Polarisabilities at and Beyond Physical Pion Masses
• Correlation of Theoretical Uncertainties in PDF Fits and Theoretical Uncertainties in Predictions
• Decoupling Theoretical Uncertainties from Measurements of the Higgs Boson
• Parton distributions with scale uncertainties: a MonteCarlo sampling approach
• Lattice determinations of the strong coupling
• Light Nuclei from Lattice QCD: Spectrum, Structure and Reactions
• Effective field theory for vibrations in odd-mass nuclei
• Precise perturbative predictions from fixed-order calculations
• Extending the Predictive Power of Perturbative QCD Using the Principle of Maximum Conformality and Bayesian Analysis
• Novel Method to Reliably Determine the QCD Coupling from $R_{\mathrm{uds}}$ Measurements and its effects to Muon $g-2$ and $\alpha (M_Z^2)$ within the Tau-Charm Energy Region
• From chiral EFT to perturbative QCD: a Bayesian model mixing approach to symmetric nuclear matter
• Interpolating between small- and large-$g$ expansions using Bayesian Model Mixing
• Detailed Comparison of Renormalization Scale-Setting Procedures based on the Principle of Maximum Conformality
• Precision QCD phenomenology of exotic spin-2 search at the LHC
• Robust estimates of theoretical uncertainties at fixed-order in perturbation theory
• Reanalysis of the top-quark pair production via the $e^{+}{e}^{-}$ annihilation near the threshold region up to N${}^3$LO QCD corrections
• Direct nonparametric multimessenger constraints on the equation of state of cold dense nuclear matter
• Elimination of QCD Renormalization Scale and Scheme Ambiguities
• Theoretical evaluation of solar proton-proton fusion reaction rate and its uncertainties
• Approximate N${}^5$LO Higgs boson decay width $\Gamma (H\to \gamma \gamma )$
• Effective field theories for collective excitations of atomic nuclei
• Revisiting the top-quark pair production at future $e^{+}{e}^{-}$ colliders
• Ab initio models of atomic nuclei: challenges and new ideas
• An analysis of Bayesian estimates for missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• Determination of proton PDF uncertainties with Markov chain Monte Carlo
• Scale-invariant total decay width $\Gamma (H\to b\bar{b})$ using the novel method of characteristic operator
• The HiggsTools Handbook: Concepts and observables for deciphering the Nature of the Higgs Sector
• Next-to-leading order evolution of structure functions without PDFs
• Event generation at MEPS@NLO accuracy in neutral and charged current DIS at the EIC
• Les Houches study on inclusive jet production at NNLO+NNLL
• Exploring the substructure of nucleons and nuclei with machine learning
• A Precise Determination of ${\alpha }_s$ from the Heavy Jet Mass Distribution
• Estimation of uncertainties from missing higher orders in perturbative calculations