Probabilistic definition of the perturbative theoretical uncertainty from missing higher orders

Abstract

We consider the problem of quantifying the uncertainty on theoretical predictions based on perturbation theory due to missing higher orders. The most widely used approach, scale variation, is largely arbitrary and it has no probabilistic foundation, making it not suitable for robust data analysis. In 2011, Cacciari and Houdeau proposed a model based on a Bayesian approach to provide a probabilistic definition of the theory uncertainty from missing higher orders. In this work, we propose an improved version of the Cacciari-Houdeau model, that overcomes some limitations. In particular, it performs much better in case of perturbative expansions with large high-order contributions (as it often happens in QCD). In addition, we propose an alternative model based on the same idea of scale variation, which overcomes some of the shortcomings of the canonical approach, on top of providing a probabilistically-sound result. Moreover, we address the problem of the dependence of theoretical predictions on unphysical scales (such as the renormalization scale), and propose a solution to obtain a scale-independent result within the probabilistic framework. We validate these methods on expansions with known sums, and apply them to a number of physical observables in particle physics. We also investigate some variations, improvements and combinations of the models. We believe that these methods provide a powerful tool to reliably estimate theory uncertainty from missing higher orders that can be used in any physics analysis. The results of this work are easily accessible through a public code named THunc.

arXiv comment88 pages, many figures. Version published in EPJC

References in corpus (42)

• New parton distribution functions from a global analysis of quantum chromodynamics
• Renormalons
• Higgs boson gluon-fusion production in N3LO QCD
• Five-Loop Running of the QCD coupling constant
• The Resummation of Soft Gluon in Hadronic Collisions
• Quantifying truncation errors in effective field theory
• Quark mass relations to four-loop order
• Higgs production in hadron collisions: soft and virtual QCD corrections at NNLO
• Scalar Correlator at O(alpha_s^4), Higgs Decay into b-quarks and Bounds on the Light Quark Masses
• Commensurate Scale Relations in Quantum Chromodynamics
• Higgs production in gluon fusion beyond NNLO
• Quantifying Correlated Truncation Errors in Effective Field Theory
• Systematic Scale-Setting to All Orders: The Principle of Maximum Conformality and Commensurate Scale Relations
• Bayesian truncation errors in chiral effective field theory: nucleon-nucleon observables
• Eliminating the Renormalization Scale Ambiguity for Top-Pair Production Using the Principle of Maximum Conformality
• Scale Setting Using the Extended Renormalization Group and the Principle of Maximum Conformality: the QCD Coupling Constant at Four Loops
• Setting the Renormalization Scale in QCD: The Principle of Maximum Conformality
• Adler Function, Sum Rules and Crewther Relation of Order O(alpha_s^4): the Singlet Case
• $\overline{\mathrm{MS}}$-on-shell quark mass relation up to four loops in QCD and a general SU$(N)$ gauge group
• Meaningful characterisation of perturbative theoretical uncertainties
• Resummed Higgs cross section at N${}^3$LL
• The Higgs Boson Lineshape
• On Higgs decays to hadrons and the R-ratio at N^4LO
• On the Higgs cross section at N${}^3$LO+N${}^3$LL and its uncertainty
• Precision NNLO determination of alpha_s(M_Z) using an unbiased global parton set
• Precision determination of the strong coupling constant within a global PDF analysis
• The Power of Perturbation Theory
• $\lambda {\varphi }^4$ Theory I: The Symmetric Phase Beyond NNNNNNNNLO
• Generalization of the Brodsky-Lepage-Mackenzie optimization within the $\{\beta \}$-expansion and the Principle of Maximal Conformality
• Effective field theory for nuclear vibrations with quantified uncertainties
• Do we need N${}^3$LO Parton Distributions?
• Double resummation for Higgs production
• Novel All-Orders Single-Scale Approach to QCD Renormalization Scale-Setting
• How well can we guess theoretical uncertainties?
• Small-$x$ phenomenology at the LHC and beyond: HELL 3.0 and the case of the Higgs cross section
• On the Consistent Use of Scale Variations in PDF Fits and Predictions
• Nucleon Polarisabilities at and Beyond Physical Pion Masses
• Higher-order perturbative coefficients in QCD from series acceleration by conformal mappings
• Inclusive decays of ${\eta }_c$ and ${\eta }_b$ at NNLO with large $n_f$ resummation
• Ambiguities of the principle of maximum conformality procedure for hadron collider processes
• Effective field theory for vibrations in odd-mass nuclei
• The $\{\beta \}$-expansion formalism in perturbative QCD and its extension

Cited by in corpus (30)

• 50 Years of Quantum Chromodynamics
• Approximate N${}^3$LO Parton Distribution Functions with Theoretical Uncertainties: MSHT20aN${}^3$LO PDFs
• Triphoton production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD
• Charged Current Drell-Yan Production at N3LO
• Leading-Color Two-Loop Amplitudes for Four Partons and a W Boson in QCD
• Inclusive Production Cross Sections at N3LO
• May the four be with you: Novel IR-subtraction methods to tackle NNLO calculations
• Equation of State of Cold Quark Matter to $O({\alpha }_s^3\ln {\alpha }_s)$
• Publishing statistical models: Getting the most out of particle physics experiments
• Bayesian uncertainty quantification of perturbative QCD input to the neutron-star equation of state
• Pion Fragmentation Functions at High Energy Colliders
• Correlation of Theoretical Uncertainties in PDF Fits and Theoretical Uncertainties in Predictions
• Systematizing and addressing theory uncertainties of unitarization with the Inverse Amplitude Method
• Parton distributions with scale uncertainties: a MonteCarlo sampling approach
• Precise perturbative predictions from fixed-order calculations
• Extending the Predictive Power of Perturbative QCD Using the Principle of Maximum Conformality and Bayesian Analysis
• Novel Method to Reliably Determine the QCD Coupling from $R_{\mathrm{uds}}$ Measurements and its effects to Muon $g-2$ and $\alpha (M_Z^2)$ within the Tau-Charm Energy Region
• Does Bayesian Model Averaging improve polynomial extrapolations? Two toy problems as tests
• Detailed Comparison of Renormalization Scale-Setting Procedures based on the Principle of Maximum Conformality
• Precision QCD phenomenology of exotic spin-2 search at the LHC
• Robust estimates of theoretical uncertainties at fixed-order in perturbation theory
• Achieving effective renormalization scale and scheme independence via the Principle of Observable Effective Matching
• Reanalysis of the top-quark pair production via the $e^{+}{e}^{-}$ annihilation near the threshold region up to N${}^3$LO QCD corrections
• Elimination of QCD Renormalization Scale and Scheme Ambiguities
• Approximate N${}^5$LO Higgs boson decay width $\Gamma (H\to \gamma \gamma )$
• Determination of proton PDF uncertainties with Markov chain Monte Carlo
• Scale-invariant total decay width $\Gamma (H\to b\bar{b})$ using the novel method of characteristic operator
• An analysis of Bayesian estimates for missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• A Precise Determination of ${\alpha }_s$ from the Heavy Jet Mass Distribution
• Les Houches study on inclusive jet production at NNLO+NNLL