An analysis of Bayesian estimates for missing higher orders in perturbative calculations

Abstract

With current high precision collider data, the reliable estimation of theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders (MHOs) in perturbation theory has become a pressing issue for collider phenomenology. Traditionally, the size of the MHOs is estimated through scale variation, a simple but ad hoc method without probabilistic interpretation. Bayesian approaches provide a compelling alternative to estimate the size of the MHOs, but it is not clear how to interpret the perturbative scales, like the factorisation and renormalisation scales, in a Bayesian framework. Recently, it was proposed that the scales can be incorporated as hidden parameters into a Bayesian model. In this paper, we thoroughly scrutinise Bayesian approaches to MHO estimation and systematically study the performance of different models on an extensive set of high-order calculations. We extend the framework in two significant ways. First, we define a new model that allows for asymmetric probability distributions. Second, we introduce a prescription to incorporate information on perturbative scales without interpreting them as hidden model parameters. We clarify how the two scale prescriptions bias the result towards specific scale choice, and we discuss and compare different Bayesian MHO estimates among themselves and to the traditional scale variation approach. Finally, we provide a practical prescription of how existing perturbative results at the standard scale variation points can be converted to 68%/95% credibility intervals in the Bayesian approach using the new public code MiHO.

63 pages, 27 figures, for MiHO code see https://github.com/aykhuss/miho v2: updated references, other small changes, published version

References in corpus (20)

• Higgs boson gluon-fusion production in N3LO QCD
• Quark mass relations to four-loop order
• Tenth-Order Electron Anomalous Magnetic Moment --- Contribution of Diagrams without Closed Lepton Loops
• alpha_s and the tau hadronic width: fixed-order, contour-improved and higher-order perturbation theory
• Four-Loop Non-Singlet Splitting Functions in the Planar Limit and Beyond
• Complete two-loop correction to the bound-electron g factor
• Vector-Boson Fusion Higgs Pair Production at N${}^3$LO
• Large-nf Contributions to the Four-Loop Splitting Functions in QCD
• The three-loop cusp anomalous dimension in QCD
• Matter dependence of the four-loop cusp anomalous dimension
• HPro: A NLO Monte-Carlo for Higgs production via gluon fusion with finite heavy quark masses
• Quark and gluon form factors to four loop order in QCD: the $N_f^3$ contributions
• Four-loop quark form factor with quartic fundamental colour factor
• Matter dependence of the four-loop QCD cusp anomalous dimension: from small angles to all angles
• Generalization of the Brodsky-Lepage-Mackenzie optimization within the $\{\beta \}$-expansion and the Principle of Maximal Conformality
• An extensive survey of the estimation of uncertainties from missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• Two-loop binding corrections to the electron gyromagnetic factor
• Higher-order perturbative coefficients in QCD from series acceleration by conformal mappings
• One-loop binding corrections to the electron $g$ factor
• The $\{\beta \}$-expansion formalism in perturbative QCD and its extension