On the Consistent Use of Scale Variations in PDF Fits and Predictions

Abstract

We present an investigation of the theoretical uncertainties in parton distribution functions (PDFs) due to missing higher-order corrections in the perturbative predictions used in the fit, and their relationship to the uncertainties in subsequent predictions made using the PDFs. We consider in particular the standard approach of factorization and renormalization scale variation, and derive general results for the consistent application of these at the PDF fit stage. To do this, we use the fact that a PDF fit may be recast in a physical basis, where the PDFs themselves are bypassed entirely, and one instead relates measured observables to predicted ones. In the case of factorization scale variation we find that in various situations there is a high degree of effective correlation between the variation in the fit and in predicted observables. In particular, including such a variation in both cases can lead to an exaggerated theoretical uncertainty. More generally, a careful treatment of this correlation appears mandatory, at least within the standard scale variation paradigm. For the renormalization scale, the situation is less straightforward, but again we highlight the potential for correlations between related processes in the fit and predictions to enter at the same level as between processes in the fit or prediction alone.

18 pages. Minor updates for journal version

References in corpus (5)

• Parton distributions for the LHC
• Update of Parton Distributions at NNLO
• Study of Monte Carlo approach to experimental uncertainty propagation with MSTW 2008 PDFs
• An extensive survey of the estimation of uncertainties from missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• Absence of pi^2 terms in physical anomalous dimensions in DIS: verification and resulting predictions

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Parton distributions from LHC, HERA, Tevatron and fixed target data: MSHT20 PDFs
• Hadron structure in high-energy collisions
• Approximate N${}^3$LO Parton Distribution Functions with Theoretical Uncertainties: MSHT20aN${}^3$LO PDFs
• The transverse momentum spectrum of weak gauge bosons at N${}^3$LL+NNLO
• Publishing statistical models: Getting the most out of particle physics experiments
• Probabilistic definition of the perturbative theoretical uncertainty from missing higher orders
• Les Houches 2021: Physics at TeV Colliders: Report on the Standard Model Precision Wishlist
• Correlation of Theoretical Uncertainties in PDF Fits and Theoretical Uncertainties in Predictions
• Parton distributions with scale uncertainties: a MonteCarlo sampling approach
• High-energy QCD dynamics from bottom flavor fragmentation at the Hi-Lumi LHC
• Fully charmed tetraquarks from LHC to FCC: Natural stability from fragmentation
• Probing Proton Structure at the Large Hadron electron Collider
• Bottomoniumlike states in proton collisions: Fragmentation and resummation
• Testing parton distribution functions with t-channel single-top-quark production
• Fragmentation functions for axial-vector heavy tetraquarks: A TQ4Q1.1 update
• Proton-PDF uncertainties in extracting nuclear PDFs from $W^{\pm }$ production in p+Pb collisions
• Fragmentation of fully heavy tetraquarks: The TQ4Q1.1 functions as a case study
• Evolution of structure functions in momentum space
• Unwinding the rare $\Omega$ sector: Fragmentation of fully charmed baryons from HL-LHC to FCC
• NNLO PDFs driven by top-quark data
• Les Houches 2023 -- Physics at TeV Colliders: Report on the Standard Model Precision Wishlist
• Pseudoscalar heavy-quarkonium hadroproduction from nonrelativistic fragmentation at NLL/NLO${}^{+}$
• Tetraquark-Jet Systems at the High-Luminosity LHC
• Next-to-leading order evolution of structure functions without PDFs
• Multimodal Fragmentation of All-Heavy Pentaquarks: Uncertainty-Aware Predictions for Hadron Colliders
• All-charm tetraquarks at hadron colliders: A high-precision fragmentation perspective
• An analysis of Bayesian estimates for missing higher orders in perturbative calculations
• Heavy-flavor multimodal fragmentation to $S$-wave pentacharms at next-generation hadron colliders
• An overview of scale invariance in proton structure with holographic insights