On the alleged duality of the Galactic halo

Abstract

We examine the kinematics of the Galactic halo based on SDSS/SEGUE data by Carollo et al. (2007, 2010). We find that their claims of a counter-rotating halo are the result of substantial biases in distance estimates (of order 50%): the claimed retrograde component, which makes up only a tiny fraction of the entire sample, prone to contaminations, is identified as the tail of distance overestimates. The strong overestimates also result in a lift in the vertical velocity component, which explains the large altitudes those objects were claimed to reach. Errors are worst for the lowest metallicity stars, which explains the metal-poor nature of the artificial component. We also argue that measurement errors were not properly accounted for and that the use of Gaussian fitting on intrinsically non-Gaussian Galactic components invokes the identification of components that are distorted or even artificial. Our evaluation of the data leads to a revision of the estimated velocity ellipsoids and does not yield any reliable evidence for a counterrotating halo component. If a distinct counterrotating halo component exists it must be far weaker than claimed by Carollo et al. Finally we note that their revised analysis presented in Beers et al. (2011) does not alleviate our main concerns.

17 pages, 12 figures, submitted to MNRAS

References in corpus (13)

• New constraints on the chemical evolution of the solar neighbourhood and Galactic disc(s). Improved astrophysical parameters for the Geneva-Copenhagen Survey
• Cats and Dogs, Hair and A Hero: A Quintet of New Milky Way Companions
• Two Stellar Components in the Halo of the Milky Way
• The Milky Way Tomography with SDSS: II. Stellar Metallicity
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. I. Description and Initial Validation Tests
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. II. Validation with Galactic Globular and Open Clusters
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. III. Comparison with High-Resolution Spectroscopy of SDSS/SEGUE Field Stars
• The Helium abundance and Delta Y / Delta Z in Lower Main Sequence stars
• Halo Star Streams in the Solar Neighborhood
• Rotation of Halo Populations in the Milky Way and M31
• The ability of intermediate-band Stromgren photometry to correctly identify dwarf, subgiant, and giant stars and provide stellar metallicities and surface gravities
• An Examination of Recent Transformations to the BV(RI)_C Photometric System from the Perspective of Stellar Models for Old Stars
• Predicted properties of RR Lyrae stars in the SDSS photometric system

Cited by in corpus (74)

• Near-Field Cosmology with Metal-Poor Stars
• Streams, substructures and the early history of the Milky Way
• Evidence from the H3 Survey that the Stellar Halo is Entirely Comprised of Substructure
• Gaia FGK Benchmark Stars - Metallicity
• Galactic Rotation and Solar Motion from Stellar Kinematics
• The Biggest Splash
• Cosmological simulations of the formation of the stellar haloes around disc galaxies
• The large-scale structure of the halo of the Andromeda Galaxy Part I: global stellar density, morphology and metallicity properties
• Oxygen Abundances in Nearby FGK Stars and the Galactic Chemical Evolution of the Local Disk and Halo
• The Milky Way's Stellar Disk
• The Bifurcated Age-Metallicity Relation of Milky Way Globular Clusters and its Implications For the Accretion History of the Galaxy
• Gaia reveals a metal-rich in-situ component of the local stellar halo
• Kinematics of the stellar halo and the mass distribution of the Milky Way using BHB stars
• Chemical abundances of the Milky Way thick disk and stellar halo II.: sodium, iron-peak and neutron-capture elements
• The Case for the Dual Halo of the Milky Way
• Ages and kinematics of chemically selected, accreted Milky Way halo stars
• Global structure and kinematics of stellar haloes in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars in the Inner and Outer Halo Components of the Milky Way
• Bayesian analysis of ages, masses, and distances to cool stars with non-LTE spectroscopic parameters
• The Bizarre Chemical Inventory of NGC 2419, An Extreme Outer Halo Globular Cluster
• Galactic Stellar Populations in the Era of SDSS and Other Large Surveys
• The radial profile and flattening of the Milky Way's stellar halo to $80$kpc from the SEGUE K-giant Survey
• Two distinct halo populations in the solar neighborhood. III. Evidence from stellar ages and orbital parameters
• A box full of chocolates: The rich structure of the nearby stellar halo revealed by Gaia and RAVE
• The GHOSTS survey. II. The diversity of Halo Color and Metallicity Profiles of Massive Disk Galaxies
• Weighing the stellar constituents of the Galactic halo with APOGEE red giant stars
• Chemo-kinematics of the $Gaia$ RR Lyrae: the halo and the disc
• Touching The Void: A Striking Drop in Stellar Halo Density Beyond 50 kpc
• Population Studies. XIII. A New Analysis of the Bidelman-MacConnell "Weak-Metal" Stars - Confirmation of Metal-Poor Stars in the Thick Disk of the Galaxy
• In the thick of it: metal-poor disc stars in RAVE
• Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars: CEMP-s and CEMP-no Sub-Classes in the Halo System of the Milky Way
• La Silla QUEST RR Lyrae Star Survey: Region I
• Unveiling systematic biases in 1D LTE excitation-ionisation balance of Fe for FGK stars. A novel approach to determination of stellar parameters
• The Pristine survey VIII: The metallicity distribution function of the Milky Way halo down to the extremely metal-poor regime
• Characterising stellar halo populations I: An extended distribution function for halo K giants
• Anisotropy of the Milky Way's stellar halo using K giants from LAMOST and $Gaia$
• The Velocity Anisotropy of Distant Milky Way Halo Stars from Hubble Space Telescope Proper Motions
• The Fractions of Inner- and Outer-Halo Stars in the Local Volume
• Probing the shape and history of the Milky Way halo with orbital spectral analysis
• The tilt of the velocity ellipsoid in the Milky Way disk
• The Kinematic Properties of BHB and RR Lyrae stars towards the Anticentre and the North Galactic Pole: The Transition between the Inner and the Outer Halo
• A-type stars in the Canada-France Imaging Survey I. The stellar halo of the Milky Way traced to large radius by blue horizontal branch stars
• Testing galaxy formation models with the GHOSTS survey: The color profile of M81's stellar halo
• 591 high velocity stars in the Galactic halo selected from LAMOST DR7 and Gaia DR2
• Chemical Cartography. I. A Carbonicity Map of the Galactic Halo
• Deep SDSS optical spectroscopy of distant halo stars II. Iron, calcium, and magnesium abundances
• Does SEGUE/SDSS indicate a dual Galactic halo?
• The detection and treatment of distance errors in kinematic analyses of stars
• Metallicity Bias in the Kinematics of the Milky Way Stellar Halo
• 3D Extinction Mapping Using Hierarchical Bayesian Models
• Precise Radial Velocities of 2046 Nearby FGKM Stars and 131 Standards
• On the Relative Ages of the $\alpha$-Rich and $\alpha$-Poor Stellar Populations in the Galactic Halo
• A new formula for disc kinematics
• The Chemical Signature of a Relic Star Cluster in the Sextans Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy - Implications for Near-Field Cosmology
• Global Properties of M31's Stellar Halo from the SPLASH Survey: III. Measuring the Stellar Velocity Dispersion Profile
• Rotating halo traced by the K giant stars from LAMOST and Gaia
• Stellar Velocity Dispersion and Anisotropy of the Milky Way Inner Halo
• Chemical Cartography. II. The Assembly History of the Galactic Stellar Halo Traced by Carbon-Enhanced Metal-Poor Stars
• The chemodynamics of prograde and retrograde Milky Way stars
• Rotational signature of the Milky Way stellar halo
• Migration and kinematics in growing disc galaxies with thin and thick discs
• A Two-Point Correlation Function For Galactic Halo Stars
• A twisted and precessing Cepheid warp in the outer Milky Way disc
• Galactic googly: the rotation-metallicity bias in the inner stellar halo of the Milky Way
• Kinematics & Chemistry of Halo Substructures: The Vicinity of the Virgo Over-Density
• Halo orbits in cosmological disk galaxies: tracers of formation history
• Stellar science from a blue wavelength range - A possible design for the blue arm of 4MOST
• Flying far and fast: the distribution of distant hypervelocity star candidates from Gaia DR2 data
• Dependence of Galactic Halo Kinematics on the Adopted Galactic Potential
• Element abundance analysis of the metal-rich stellar halo and high-velocitythick disk in the galaxy
• Variable Stars and Galactic Structure
• Fading Features Found in the Kinematics of the Far-Reaching Milky Way Stellar Halo
• On the Use of Field RR Lyrae as Galactic Probes -- VIII. Early Formation of the Galactic Spheroid
• Understanding the Galaxy