Recovering Stellar Population Properties and Redshifts from Broad-Band Photometry of Simulated Galaxies: Lessons for SED Modeling

Abstract

We present a detailed analysis of our ability to determine stellar masses, ages, reddening and extinction values, and star formation rates of high-redshift galaxies by modeling broad-band SEDs with stellar population synthesis. In order to do so, we computed synthetic optical-to-NIR SEDs for model galaxies taken from hydrodynamical merger simulations placed at redshifts 1.5 < z < 3. Viewed under different angles and during different evolutionary phases, the simulations represent a wide variety of galaxy types (disks, mergers, spheroids). We show that simulated galaxies span a wide range in SEDs and color, comparable to these of observed galaxies. In all star-forming phases, dust attenuation has a large effect on colors, SEDs, and fluxes. The broad-band SEDs were then fed to a standard SED modeling procedure and resulting stellar population parameters were compared to their true values. Disk galaxies generally show a decent median correspondence between the true and estimated mass and age, but suffer from large uncertainties. During the merger itself, we find larger offsets (e.g., log M_recovered - log M_true = -0.13^{+0.10}_{-0.14}). E(B-V) values are generally recovered well, but the estimated total visual absorption Av is consistently too low, increasingly so for larger optical depths. Since the largest optical depths occur during the phases of most intense star formation, it is for the highest SFRs that we find the largest underestimates. The masses, ages, E(B-V), Av, and SFR of merger remnants (spheroids) are very well reproduced. We discuss possible biases in SED modeling results caused by mismatch between the true and template star formation history, dust distribution, metallicity variations and AGN contribution.

Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal, 24 pages, 19 figures

References in corpus (21)

• EAZY: A Fast, Public Photometric Redshift Code
• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• Multiwavelength study of massive galaxies at z~2. I. Star formation and galaxy growth
• An Observational Determination of the Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation at z~2
• AMAZE. I. The evolution of the mass-metallicity relation at z>3
• The Stellar, Gas and Dynamical Masses of Star-Forming Galaxies at z~2
• H-alpha Observations of a Large Sample of Galaxies at z~2: Implications for Star Formation in High Redshift Galaxies
• Evidence for TP-AGB stars in high redshift galaxies, and their effect on deriving stellar population parameters
• Kinematic Structure of Merger Remnants
• What do we learn from IRAC observations of galaxies at 2 < z < 3.5?
• Multiwavelength study of massive galaxies at z~2. II. Widespread Compton thick AGN and the concurrent growth of black holes and bulges
• Sunrise: Polychromatic Dust Radiative Transfer in Arbitrary Geometries
• Modelling the Pan-Spectral Energy Distribution of Starburst Galaxies: IV The Controlling Parameters of the Starburst SED
• On Sizes, Kinematics, M/L Gradients, and Light Profiles of Massive Compact Galaxies at z~2
• Spitzer Mid-to-Far-Infrared Flux Densities of Distant Galaxies
• Direct Measurements of the Stellar Continua and Balmer/4000 Angstrom Breaks of Red z>2 Galaxies: Redshifts and Improved Constraints on Stellar Populations
• The Origin of Line Emission in Massive z~2.3 Galaxies: Evidence for Cosmic Downsizing of AGN Host Galaxies
• SPITZER Observations of z~3 Lyman Break Galaxies: stellar masses and mid-infrared properties
• Dust Attenuation in Hydrodynamic Simulations of Spiral Galaxies
• Photometric Properties of the Most Massive High-Redshift Galaxies

Cited by in corpus (83)

• Modeling the Panchromatic Spectral Energy Distributions of Galaxies
• The Growth of Massive Galaxies Since z=2
• Galaxy Structure and Mode of Star Formation in the SFR-Mass Plane from z ~ 2.5 to z ~ 0.1
• The Atlas3D project - XX. Mass-size and mass-sigma distributions of early-type galaxies: bulge fraction drives kinematics, mass-to-light ratio, molecular gas fraction and stellar initial mass function
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly: Stellar Mass Estimates
• Deriving Physical Properties from Broadband Photometry with Prospector: Description of the Model and a Demonstration of its Accuracy Using 129 Galaxies in the Local Universe
• On Star Formation Rates and Star Formation Histories of Galaxies out to z ~ 3
• A deep ALMA image of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field
• Fitting the integrated Spectral Energy Distributions of Galaxies
• The Relation Between SFR and Stellar Mass for Galaxies at 3.5 $\le z\le$ 6.5 in CANDELS
• Star formation rates and masses of z ~ 2 galaxies from multicolour photometry
• How to measure galaxy star-formation histories I: Parametric models
• A CANDELS - 3D-HST Synergy: Resolved Star Formation Patterns at 0.7 < z < 1.5
• Compact High-Redshift Galaxies Are the Cores of the Most Massive Present-Day Spheroids
• Constraining the properties of AGN host galaxies with Spectral Energy Distribution modeling
• Recovering galaxy stellar population properties from broad-band spectral energy distribution fitting
• An Older, More Quiescent Universe from Panchromatic SED Fitting of the 3D-HST Survey
• Discriminating Between the Physical Processes that Drive Spheroid Size Evolution
• A Large Population of Massive Compact Post-Starburst Galaxies at z>1: Implications for the Size Evolution and Quenching Mechanism of Quiescent Galaxies
• Fast, Slow, Early, Late: Quenching Massive Galaxies at z~0.8
• How well can we really estimate the stellar masses of galaxies from broadband photometry?
• On Sizes, Kinematics, M/L Gradients, and Light Profiles of Massive Compact Galaxies at z~2
• On the Last 10 Billion Years of Stellar Mass Growth in Star-Forming Galaxies
• Properties of $z\sim 3-6$ Lyman Break Galaxies. II. Impact of nebular emission at high redshift
• Synthetic Galaxy Images and Spectra from the Illustris Simulation
• SHARDS: an optical spectro-photometric survey of distant galaxies
• Relative merits of different types of rest-frame optical observations to constrain galaxy physical parameters
• K+A Galaxies as the Aftermath of Gas-Rich Mergers: Simulating the Evolution of Galaxies as Seen by Spectroscopic Surveys
• KMOS^3D: Dynamical constraints on the mass budget in early star-forming disks
• Should we believe the results of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling?
• Stellar mass-to-light ratios from galaxy spectra: how accurate can they be?
• The evolution of the Tully-Fisher relation between z~2.3 and z~0.9 with KMOS^3D
• Impact of star formation history on the measurement of star formation rates
• MOSFIRE Spectroscopy of Quiescent Galaxies at 1.5 < z < 2.5. I - Evolution of Structural and Dynamical Properties
• Hot dust in Panchromatic SED Fitting: Identification of AGN and improved galaxy properties
• Determining the stellar masses of submillimetre galaxies: the critical importance of star formation histories
• Dark matters on the scale of galaxies
• Evidence for a correlation between the sizes of quiescent galaxies and local environment to z ~ 2
• Properties of z~3-6 Lyman break galaxies. II. Testing star formation histories and the SFR-mass relation with ALMA and near-IR spectroscopy
• The rise and fall of the star formation histories of blue galaxies at redshifts 0.2<z<1.4
• Abundance matching with the mean star formation rate: there is no missing satellites problem in the Milky Way above ${\mathbf{M}}_{200}\sim 10^9{\mathbf{M}}_{\odot }$
• Ultraviolet to infrared emission of z>1 galaxies: Can we derive reliable star formation rates and stellar masses?
• Population synthesis modelling of luminous infrared galaxies at intermediate redshift
• Ultra-deep Spitzer Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy of LIRGs and ULIRGs at z ~ 1-2
• The intrinsic characteristics of galaxies on the SFR-stellar mass plane at 1.2<z<4: I. the correlation between stellar age, central density and position relative to the main sequence
• Dissecting the size-mass and ${\Sigma }_1$-mass relations at 1.0 < z < 2.5: galaxy mass profiles and color gradients as a function of spectral shape
• The Impact of Star Formation Histories on Stellar Mass Estimation: Implications from the Local Group Dwarf Galaxies
• Recovering stellar population parameters via two full-spectrum fitting algorithms in the absence of model uncertainties
• Evolution of Quiescent and Star-Forming Galaxies Since z~1.5 as a Function of Their Velocity Dispersions
• Detailed Cluster Mass and Light profiles of A1703, A370 and RXJ1347-11 from Deep Subaru Imaging
• The dependence of the galaxy stellar-to-halo mass relation on galaxy morphology
• Color Distributions, Number and Mass Densities of Massive Galaxies at 1.5 < z < 3: Comparing Observations with Merger Simulations
• Halpha Imaging of the Herschel Reference Survey. The star formation properties of a volume-limited, K-band-selected sample of nearby late-type galaxies
• The high redshift SFR-M* relation is sensitive to the employed star formation rate and stellar mass indicators: Towards addressing the tension between observations and simulations
• Characterizing hydrostatic mass bias with Mock-X
• Galaxies in the Illustris simulation as seen by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - I: Bulge+disc decompositions, methods, and biases
• A bright, spatially extended lensed galaxy at z = 1.7 behind the cluster RCS2 032727-132623
• Mergers and Star Formation: The environment and Stellar Mass Growth of the Progenitors of Ultra-Massive Galaxies since z = 2
• Recovering galaxy stellar population properties from broad-band spectral energy distribution fitting II. The case with unknown redshift
• Beyond UVJ: Color Selection of Galaxies in the JWST Era
• MAGAZ3NE: High Stellar Velocity Dispersions for Ultra-Massive Quiescent Galaxies at $z\gtrsim 3$
• A New Empirical Method to Infer the Starburst History of the Universe from Local Galaxy Properties
• The complex physics of dusty star-forming galaxies at high redshifts as revealed by Herschel and Spitzer
• Herschel observations of gamma-ray burst host galaxies: implications for the topology of the dusty interstellar medium
• Selection of massive evolved galaxies at $3\le z\le 4.5$ in the CANDELS fields
• The extended epoch of galaxy formation: age dating of ~3600 galaxies with 2<z<6.5 in the VIMOS Ultra-Deep Survey
• A decrease of the gas exchanges between galaxies and the IGM, from 12 to 6 billion years ago
• DEVILS: Cosmic evolution of SED-derived metallicities and their connection to star-formation histories
• Using the 1.6um Bump to Study Rest-frame NIR Selected Galaxies at Redshift 2
• Euclid: Early Release Observations -- Overview of the Perseus cluster and analysis of its luminosity and stellar mass functions
• Evidence for Reduced Specific Star Formation Rates in the Centers of Massive Galaxies at z = 4
• Physical properties of galaxies: toward a consistent comparison between hydrodynamical simulations and SDSS
• Energy balance SED modelling can be effective at high redshifts regardless of UV-FIR offsets
• Dust attenuation, dust content and geometry of star-forming galaxies
• The physical properties of local (U)LIRGs: a comparison with nearby early- and late-type galaxies
• Galaxy properties from J-PAS narrow-band photometry
• What Regulates Galaxy Evolution? Open Questions in Our Understanding of Galaxy Formation and Evolution
• The MOSDEF Survey: Stellar Continuum Spectra and Star Formation Histories of Active, Transitional, and Quiescent Galaxies at 1.4$<$\lowercase{z}$<$2.6
• Physical and Morphological Properties of [O II] Emitting Galaxies in the HETDEX Pilot Survey
• Systematics in the SED Fitting Parameter Estimation of Composite Galaxies
• 3D intrinsic shapes of quiescent galaxies in observations and simulations
• SE3D: Building a radiative transfer emulator to fit panchromatic resolved galaxy observations with 3D models of dust and stars
• A multiwavelength study of near- and mid-infrared selected galaxies at high redshift: ERGs, AGN-identification and the contribution from dust