How flat can you get? A model comparison perspective on the curvature of the Universe
arXiv:0901.3354 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14938.x
Abstract
The question of determining the spatial geometry of the Universe is of greater relevance than ever, as precision cosmology promises to verify inflationary predictions about the curvature of the Universe. We revisit the question of what can be learnt about the spatial geometry of the Universe from the perspective of a three-way Bayesian model comparison. We show that, given current data, the probability that the Universe is spatially infinite lies between 67% and 98%, depending on the choice of priors. For the strongest prior choice, we find odds of order 50:1 (200:1) in favour of a flat Universe when compared with a closed (open) model. We also report a robust, prior-independent lower limit to the number of Hubble spheres in the Universe, N_U > 5 (at 99% confidence). We forecast the accuracy with which future CMB and BAO observations will be able to constrain curvature, finding that a cosmic variance limited CMB experiment together with an SKA-like BAO observation will constrain curvature with a precision of about sigma ~ 4.5x10^{-4}. We demonstrate that the risk of 'model confusion' (i.e., wrongly favouring a flat Universe in the presence of curvature) is much larger than might be assumed from parameter errors forecasts for future probes. We argue that a 5-sigma detection threshold guarantees a confusion- and ambiguity-free model selection. Together with inflationary arguments, this implies that the geometry of the Universe is not knowable if the value of the curvature parameter is below |Omega_curvature| ~ 10^{-4}, a bound one order of magnitude larger than the size of curvature perturbations, ~ 10^{-5}. [abridged]
arXiv commentAdded discussion on the impact of adopting (wa, w0) dark energy model, main conclusions unchanged. Version accepted by MNRAS
References in corpus (56)
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Efficient Computation of CMB anisotropies in closed FRW models
- Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation Function of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies
- Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
- Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
- A Flat Universe from High-Resolution Maps of the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
- The Supernova Legacy Survey: Measurement of Omega_M, Omega_Lambda and w from the First Year Data Set
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
- Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
- Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
- Measuring the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation scale using the SDSS and 2dFGRS
- Clustering of Luminous Red Galaxies IV: Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Line-of-Sight Direction and a Direct Measurement of H(z)
- Nonlinear Evolution of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
- A Nested Sampling Algorithm for Cosmological Model Selection
- Applications of Bayesian model selection to cosmological parameters
- How accurately can 21 cm tomography constrain cosmology?
- Observational Constraints on Dark Energy and Cosmic Curvature
- Constraining the Topology of the Universe
- What does inflation really predict?
- The essence of quintessence and the cost of compression
- Efficient Cosmological Parameter Estimation from Microwave Background Anisotropies
- Dynamical Dark Energy or Simply Cosmic Curvature?
- Measuring the effective complexity of cosmological models
- Lensed CMB simulation and parameter estimation
- Efficient Bayesian inference for multimodal problems in cosmology
- Present and future evidence for evolving dark energy
- The Impact of an Extra Background of Relativistic Particles on the Cosmological Parameters derived from Microwave Background Anisotropies
- Universal fitting formulae for baryon oscillation surveys
- Closed Universes, de Sitter Space and Inflation
- Bayesian Calibrated Significance Levels Applied to the Spectral Tilt and Hemispherical Asymmetry
- Cosmology with the Square Kilometre Array
- Distance, Growth Factor, and Dark Energy Constraints from Photometric Baryon Acoustic Oscillation and Weak Lensing Measurements
- Forecasting the Bayes factor of a future observation
- On Precision Measurement of the Mean Curvature
- Cosmic tomographies: baryon acoustic oscillations and weak lensing
- H_0 and Odds on Cosmology
- Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of Bianchi VII_h models
- WFMOS - Sounding the Dark Cosmos
- On the determination of curvature and dynamical Dark Energy
- Planck priors for dark energy surveys
- Cosmology with the Square Kilometre Array
- Fast Cosmological Parameter Estimation from Microwave Background Temperature and Polarization Power Spectra
- On using the WMAP distance priors in constraining the time evolving equation of state of dark energy
- Optimising Baryon Acoustic Oscillation Surveys - I: Testing the concordance LCDM cosmology
- Eyes Wide Open - Optimising Cosmological Surveys in a Crowded Market
- Model selection forecasts for the spectral index from the Planck satellite
- From Anisotropy to Omega
- Weighing the Universe with Photometric Redshift Surveys and the Impact on Dark Energy Forecasts
- Reconstructing the history of dark energy using maximum entropy
- The nearly flat universe
- When can the Planck satellite measure spectral index running?
- Surveying the dark side
- Nontrivial Geometries: Bounds on the Curvature of the Universe
- Introducing doubt in Bayesian model comparison
- The cosmic variance of Omega
- How Many Universes Do There Need To Be?
Cited by in corpus (46)
- The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Cosmological Implications from two Decades of Spectroscopic Surveys at the Apache Point observatory
- Curvature tension: evidence for a closed universe
- Late-time cosmology with 21cm intensity mapping experiments
- Eppur è piatto? The cosmic chronometer take on spatial curvature and cosmic concordance
- Non-parametric spatial curvature inference using late-universe cosmological probes
- The galaxy power spectrum take on spatial curvature and cosmic concordance
- Cosmology Intertwined IV: The Age of the Universe and its Curvature
- Constraints on the Dark Side of the Universe and Observational Hubble Parameter Data
- Spatial Curvature Falsifies Eternal Inflation
- What can the observation of nonzero curvature tell us?
- Curvature constraints from Large Scale Structure
- Novel null tests for the spatial curvature and homogeneity of the Universe and their machine learning reconstructions
- Imprints of the Quantum World in Classical Mechanics
- Applications of Bayesian model averaging to the curvature and size of the Universe
- A Testable Solution of the Cosmological Constant and Coincidence Problems
- Cosmology Intertwined: A Review of the Particle Physics, Astrophysics, and Cosmology Associated with the Cosmological Tensions and Anomalies
- Observable effects of anisotropic bubble nucleation
- Spatial curvature endgame: Reaching the limit of curvature determination
- Model-independent curvature determination with 21cm intensity mapping experiments
- The distribution of Omega_k from the scale-factor cutoff measure
- Testing flatness of the universe with probes of cosmic distances and growth
- What if Planck's Universe isn't flat?
- Bayesian model comparison in cosmology with Population Monte Carlo
- Optimizing baryon acoustic oscillation surveys II: curvature, redshifts, and external datasets
- Should we doubt the cosmological constant?
- Non-Gaussian Mode Coupling and the Statistical Cosmological Principle
- Constraining cosmological ultra-large scale structure using numerical relativity
- Peering beyond the horizon with standard sirens and redshift drift
- On Dark Energy and Accelerated Reference Frames
- Signatures of the Very Early Universe: Inflation, Spatial Curvature and Large Scale Anomalies
- On the question of measuring spatial curvature in an inhomogeneous universe
- A small Universe
- Bayesian Model comparison of Higgs couplings
- Exceeding Expectations: Stochastic Dominance as a General Decision Theory
- Thermodynamics of conformal fields in topologically non-trivial space-time backgrounds
- Spatial Curvature from Super-Hubble Cosmological Fluctuations
- Phenomenology of the CAH+ measure
- The five dimensional universal hypermultiplet and the cosmological constant problem
- Non-Additive Axiologies in Large Worlds
- A measure on the set of compact Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker models
- Positive curvature and scalar field tunneling in the landscape
- Comment on "Bayesian evidence: can we beat MultiNest using traditional MCMC methods", by Rutger van Haasteren (arXiv:0911.2150)
- Tensor Tilt from Primordial B-modes
- Physical Relativism as an Interpretation of Existence
- The Relativity of Existence
- A new mechanism for dark matter generation from an interacting cosmological constant