Bayesian Calibrated Significance Levels Applied to the Spectral Tilt and Hemispherical Asymmetry

Abstract

Bayesian model selection provides a formal method of determining the level of support for new parameters in a model. However, if there is not a specific enough underlying physical motivation for the new parameters it can be hard to assign them meaningful priors, an essential ingredient of Bayesian model selection. Here we look at methods maximizing the prior so as to work out what is the maximum support the data could give for the new parameters. If the maximum support is not high enough then one can confidently conclude that the new parameters are unnecessary without needing to worry that some other prior may make them significant. We discuss a computationally efficient means of doing this which involves mapping p-values onto upper bounds of the Bayes factor (or odds) for the new parameters. A p-value of 0.05 ($1.96\sigma$) corresponds to odds less than or equal to 5:2 which is below the `weak' support at best threshold. A p-value of 0.0003 ($3.6\sigma$) corresponds to odds of less than or equal to 150:1 which is the `strong' support at best threshold. Applying this method we find that the odds on the scalar spectral index being different from one are 49:1 at best. We also find that the odds that there is primordial hemispherical asymmetry in the cosmic microwave background are 9:1 at best.

arXiv comment5 pages. V2: clarifying comments added in response to referee report. Matches version to appear in MNRAS

References in corpus (20)

• Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
• Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
• Information criteria for astrophysical model selection
• Statistics: Handle with Care, Detecting Multiple Model Components with the Likelihood Ratio Test
• Hilltop Inflation
• A Nested Sampling Algorithm for Cosmological Model Selection
• Applications of Bayesian model selection to cosmological parameters
• Testing the cosmological principle of isotropy: local power spectrum estimates of the WMAP data
• Hemispherical power asymmetry in the three-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe sky maps
• Local Voids as the Origin of Large-angle Cosmic Microwave Background Anomalies I
• Measuring the effective complexity of cosmological models
• Fast-Roll Inflation
• A Bayesian model selection analysis of WMAP3
• Slow Roll Reconstruction: Constraints on Inflation from the 3 Year WMAP Dataset
• A re-analysis of the three-year WMAP temperature power spectrum and likelihood
• Broken Isotropy from a Linear Modulation of the Primordial Perturbations
• Forecasting the Bayes factor of a future observation
• The isocurvature fraction after WMAP 3-year data
• Occam's razor meets WMAP
• Point-Source Power in 3 Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe Data

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• The Best Inflationary Models After Planck
• A broadband flux scale for low frequency radio telescopes
• Observing the Inflationary Reheating
• Is the Jeffreys' scale a reliable tool for Bayesian model comparison in cosmology?
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation: Parameter Estimation for Single Field Models
• Bayesian Selection of sign(mu) within mSUGRA in Global Fits Including WMAP5 Results
• Detection of Cosmological 21 cm Emission with the Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment
• Inflation after Planck: Judgment Day
• Hunting Down the Best Model of Inflation with Bayesian Evidence
• Testable polarization predictions for models of CMB isotropy anomalies
• How flat can you get? A model comparison perspective on the curvature of the Universe
• On Minimally-Parametric Primordial Power Spectrum Reconstruction and the Evidence for a Red Tilt
• Reconstruction of the Dark Energy equation of state
• Ground- and Space-based Detection of the Thermal Emission Spectrum of the Transiting Hot Jupiter KELT-2Ab
• A pair of Sub-Neptunes transiting the bright K-dwarf TOI-1064 characterised with CHEOPS
• Measurement of the charged pion mass using X-ray spectroscopy of exotic atoms
• Constraints on modified gravity from the BOSS galaxy survey
• 2D Retrieval Frameworks for Hot Jupiter Phase Curves
• Fingerprinting Dark Energy II: weak lensing and galaxy clustering tests
• Large-scale anomalies in the cosmic microwave background as signatures of non-Gaussianity
• Cosmic Inflation at the Crossroads
• Bayesian evidence for $\alpha$-attractor dark energy models
• Bayesian data analysis tools for atomic physics
• Model selection for spectro-polarimetric inversions
• Variational Inference as an alternative to MCMC for parameter estimation and model selection
• New Test of Modulated Electron Capture Decay of Hydrogen-Like ${}^{142}$Pm Ions: Precision Measurement of Purely Exponential Decay
• Direction dependence of cosmological parameters due to cosmic hemispherical asymmetry
• Should we doubt the cosmological constant?
• Testing protoplanetary disc dispersal with radio emission
• Evidence for dark matter modulation in CoGeNT?
• Chasing a consistent picture for dark matter direct searches
• Denser Sampling of the Rosette Nebula with Faraday Rotation Measurements: Improved Estimates of Magnetic Fields in HII Regions
• Determining the motion of the solar system relative to the cosmic microwave background using type Ia supernovae
• Limitations of Bayesian Evidence Applied to Cosmology
• Flat Tree-level Inflationary Potentials in Light of CMB and LSS Data
• Mean shift cluster recognition method implementation in the nested sampling algorithm
• Constraining f(R) gravity with cross-correlation of galaxies and cosmic microwave background lensing
• Cosmological constraints on a unified dark matter-energy scalar field model with fast transition
• A Framework for Optimizing Exoplanet Target Selection for the James Webb Space Telescope
• Designing Decisive Detections
• A joint analysis of AMI and CARMA observations of the recently discovered SZ galaxy cluster system AMI-CL J0300+2613
• A blind detection of a large, complex, Sunyaev--Zel'dovich structure
• SZ observations with AMI of the hottest galaxy clusters detected in the XMM-Newton Cluster Survey
• Probing the primordial power spectra with inflationary priors
• Global Bayesian Analysis of $\mathrm{J}/\psi$ Photoproduction on Proton and Lead Targets
• Euclid preparation LXXI. Simulations and nonlinearities beyond $\mathsf{\Lambda }$CDM. 3. Constraints on $f(R)$ models from the photometric primary probes
• Cosmological constrains on fast transition Unified Dark Energy/Matter models
• Signal detection for spectroscopy and polarimetry
• Measurement of the charged pion mass using a low-density target of light atoms
• Bayesian Model Selection and Uncertainty Propagation for Beam Energy Scan Heavy-Ion Collisions
• Bayesian analysis of multiple direct detection experiments
• Primary Velocity and Orbital Phase Effects on Planetary Detectability from Small Epoch Number Data Sets
• The Virtues of Frugality - Why cosmological observers should release their data slowly
• Bayesian leave-one-out cross-validation for astrophysical model comparison using gravitational-wave background data
• A Bayesian Approach for Strong Field QED Tests with He-like Ions