A Bayesian model selection analysis of WMAP3

Abstract

We present a Bayesian model selection analysis of WMAP3 data using our code CosmoNest. We focus on the density perturbation spectral index $n_S$ and the tensor-to-scalar ratio $r$, which define the plane of slow-roll inflationary models. We find that while the Bayesian evidence supports the conclusion that $n_S\ne 1$, the data are not yet powerful enough to do so at a strong or decisive level. If tensors are assumed absent, the current odds are approximately 8 to 1 in favour of $n_S\ne 1$ under our assumptions, when WMAP3 data is used together with external data sets. WMAP3 data on its own is unable to distinguish between the two models. Further, inclusion of $r$ as a parameter weakens the conclusion against the Harrison-Zel'dovich case (n_S = 1, r=0), albeit in a prior-dependent way. In appendices we describe the CosmoNest code in detail, noting its ability to supply posterior samples as well as to accurately compute the Bayesian evidence. We make a first public release of CosmoNest, now available at http://www.cosmonest.org.

7 pages RevTex with 4 figures included. Updated to match PRD accepted version. Main results unchanged. CosmoNest code now version 1.0 and includes calculation of the Information. Code available at http://www.cosmonest.org

References in corpus (18)

• Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
• The 3D power spectrum of galaxies from the SDSS
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: The power spectrum and the matter content of the universe
• How many cosmological parameters?
• High Resolution Observations of the CMB Power Spectrum with ACBAR
• A Nested Sampling Algorithm for Cosmological Model Selection
• The Anisotropy of the Microwave Background to l = 3500: Mosaic Observations with the Cosmic Background Imager
• High sensitivity measurements of the CMB power spectrum with the extended Very Small Array
• The essence of quintessence and the cost of compression
• Type Ia Supernovae, Evolution, and the Cosmological Constant
• Bayesian model selection and isocurvature perturbations
• Revealing the Nature of Dark Energy Using Bayesian Evidence
• Comparison of cosmological models using Bayesian theory
• H_0 and Odds on Cosmology
• Bayesian joint analysis of cluster weak lensing and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect data
• Cosmological parameter estimation and Bayesian model comparison using VSA data
• Large-scale power in the CMB and new physics: an analysis using Bayesian model comparison
• Model selection forecasts for the spectral index from the Planck satellite

Cited by in corpus (70)

• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Information criteria for astrophysical model selection
• Cosmology and Fundamental Physics with the Euclid Satellite
• Cosmology and fundamental physics with the Euclid satellite
• Applications of Bayesian model selection to cosmological parameters
• Hemispherical power asymmetry in the three-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe sky maps
• The WiggleZ Dark Energy Survey: Final data release and cosmological results
• Markov Chain Monte Carlo Methods for Bayesian Data Analysis in Astronomy
• Inflation after WMAP3: Confronting the Slow-Roll and Exact Power Spectra with CMB Data
• Cosmic Microwave Weak lensing data as a test for the dark universe
• Confronting Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi models with Observational Cosmology
• Inflation and WMAP three year data: Features have a Future!
• Nested sampling for physical scientists
• On model selection forecasting, Dark Energy and modified gravity
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation II: Model Selection and Constraints on Reheating
• CMB polarization features from inflation versus reionization
• New Constraints on Oscillations in the Primordial Spectrum of Inflationary Perturbations
• High Dimensional Bayesian Optimisation and Bandits via Additive Models
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation: Parameter Estimation for Single Field Models
• Intermediate inflation in light of the three-year WMAP observations
• Present and future evidence for evolving dark energy
• The CMB cold spot: texture, cluster or void?
• Multi-fidelity Bayesian Optimisation with Continuous Approximations
• On Minimally-Parametric Primordial Power Spectrum Reconstruction and the Evidence for a Red Tilt
• Slow Roll Reconstruction: Constraints on Inflation from the 3 Year WMAP Dataset
• Bayesian Calibrated Significance Levels Applied to the Spectral Tilt and Hemispherical Asymmetry
• MCMC analysis of WMAP3 and SDSS data points to broken symmetry inflaton potentials and provides a lower bound on the tensor to scalar ratio
• Bayesian analysis of Friedmannless cosmologies
• Forecasting the Bayes factor of a future observation
• Cosmic microwave anisotropies from BPS semilocal strings
• AIC, BIC, Bayesian evidence against the interacting dark energy model
• Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of Bianchi VII_h models
• A Bayesian comparison between $\Lambda$CDM and phenomenologically emergent dark energy models
• How robust are inflation model and dark matter constraints from cosmological data?
• Statistical methods for cosmological parameter selection and estimation
• The Effective Theory of Inflation in the Standard Model of the Universe and the CMB+LSS data analysis
• New constraints on the observable inflaton potential from WMAP and SDSS
• WMAP 3-year primordial power spectrum
• Tuning Hyperparameters without Grad Students: Scalable and Robust Bayesian Optimisation with Dragonfly
• Cosmic acceleration from modified gravity with Palatini formalism
• Robust sampling for weak lensing and clustering analyses with the Dark Energy Survey
• Occam's razor meets WMAP
• (Lack of) Cosmological evidence for dark radiation after Planck
• Model selection forecasts for the spectral index from the Planck satellite
• A Flexible Framework for Multi-Objective Bayesian Optimization using Random Scalarizations
• Cosmological model with decaying vacuum energy law from principles of quantum mechanics
• Query Efficient Posterior Estimation in Scientific Experiments via Bayesian Active Learning
• Observational hints on the Big Bounce
• Bayesian comparison of nonstandard cosmologies using type Ia supernovae and BAO data
• Bayesian Inference from Observations of Solar-Like Oscillations
• Bayesian analysis of inflationary features in Planck and SDSS data
• Bayesian model comparison in cosmology with Population Monte Carlo
• Harrison-Z'eldovich primordial spectrum is consistent with observations
• When can the Planck satellite measure spectral index running?
• From model dynamics to oscillating dark energy parameterisation
• Is Cosmology Compatible with Blue Gravity Waves ?
• Application of Bayesian model averaging to measurements of the primordial power spectrum
• Cosmological constraints in the presence of ionizing and resonance radiation at recombination
• Planck and reionization history: a model selection view
• The Impact of Prior Assumptions on Bayesian Estimates of Inflation Parameters and the Expected Gravitational Waves Signal from Inflation
• Nontrivial Geometries: Bounds on the Curvature of the Universe
• Designing Decisive Detections
• Probing the primordial power spectra with inflationary priors
• Testing for Features in the Primordial Power Spectrum
• Probing intractable beyond-standard-model parameter spaces armed with Machine Learning
• Bayesian evidence for finite element model updating
• Noisy Blackbox Optimization with Multi-Fidelity Queries: A Tree Search Approach
• Right-Handed Sneutrino Curvaton and non-Gaussianity
• Some remarks on the observational constraints on the self-interacting scalar field model for dark energy
• Optimisation of the Population Monte Carlo algorithm: Application to constraining isocurvature models with cosmic microwave background data