The Impact of Prior Assumptions on Bayesian Estimates of Inflation Parameters and the Expected Gravitational Waves Signal from Inflation

Abstract

There has been much recent discussion, and some confusion, regarding the use of existing observational data to estimate the likelihood that next-generation cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization experiments might detect a nonzero tensor signal, possibly associated with inflation. We examine this issue in detail here in two different ways: (1) first we explore the effect of choice of different parameter priors on the estimation of the tensor-to-scalar ratio r and other parameters describing inflation, and (2) we examine the Bayesian complexity in order to determine how effectively existing data can constrain inflationary parameters. We demonstrate that existing data are not strong enough to render full inflationary parameter estimates in a parametrization- and prior-independent way and that the predicted tensor signal is particularly sensitive to different priors. For parametrizations where the Bayesian complexity is comparable to the number of free parameters we find that a flat prior on the scale of inflation (which is to be distinguished from a flat prior on the tensor-to-scalar ratio) leads us to infer a larger, and in fact slightly nonzero tensor contribution at 68% confidence level. However, no detection is claimed. Our results demonstrate that all that is statistically relevant at the current time is the (slightly enhanced) upper bound on r, and we stress that the data remain consistent with r = 0.

9 pages, 5 figures. Section added on Bayesian complexity. Matches published version

References in corpus (14)

• Cosmological Constraints from the SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies
• Measuring the effective complexity of cosmological models
• A Bayesian model selection analysis of WMAP3
• Recovering the Inflationary Potential and Primordial Power Spectrum With a Slow Roll Prior: Methodology and Application to WMAP 3 Year Data
• Slow Roll Reconstruction: Constraints on Inflation from the 3 Year WMAP Dataset
• Implications of a Running Spectral Index for Slow Roll Inflation
• A Nearly Scale Invariant Spectrum of Gravitational Radiation from Global Phase Transitions
• MCMC analysis of WMAP3 and SDSS data points to broken symmetry inflaton potentials and provides a lower bound on the tensor to scalar ratio
• New constraints on the observable inflaton potential from WMAP and SDSS
• What do WMAP and SDSS really tell about inflation?
• Impact of reionization on CMB polarization tests of slow-roll inflation
• How to constrain inflationary parameter space with minimal priors
• A Back-reaction Induced Lower Bound on the Tensor-to-Scalar Ratio
• PAPPA: Primordial Anisotropy Polarization Pathfinder Array

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Dark matter profiles and annihilation in dwarf spheroidal galaxies: prospectives for present and future gamma-ray observatories - I. The classical dSphs
• CMB Constraints on a Stochastic Background of Primordial Magnetic Fields
• Are cosmological neutrinos free-streaming?
• Evidence for extra radiation? Profile likelihood versus Bayesian posterior
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation III: Slow Roll Reconstruction Using Model Selection
• Cosmological constraints on general, single field inflation
• On the prior dependence of constraints on the tensor-to-scalar ratio
• Some remarks on the observational constraints on the self-interacting scalar field model for dark energy
• Detecting relic gravitational waves in the CMB: A statistical bias