Evidence for extra radiation? Profile likelihood versus Bayesian posterior

Abstract

A number of recent analyses of cosmological data have reported hints for the presence of extra radiation beyond the standard model expectation. In order to test the robustness of these claims under different methods of constructing parameter constraints, we perform a Bayesian posterior-based and a likelihood profile-based analysis of current data. We confirm the presence of a slight discrepancy between posterior- and profile-based constraints, with the marginalised posterior preferring higher values of the effective number of neutrino species N_eff. This can be traced back to a volume effect occurring during the marginalisation process, and we demonstrate that the effect is related to the fact that cosmic microwave background (CMB) data constrain N_eff only indirectly via the redshift of matter-radiation equality. Once present CMB data are combined with external information about, e.g., the Hubble parameter, the difference between the methods becomes small compared to the uncertainty of N_eff. We conclude that the preference of precision cosmological data for excess radiation is "real" and not an artifact of a specific choice of credible/confidence interval construction.

10 pages, 4 figures; v2: discussion section expanded and references added, version accepted for publication by JCAP

References in corpus (8)

• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Massive neutrinos and cosmology
• Cosmology seeking friendship with sterile neutrinos
• Sterile neutrinos with eV masses in cosmology -- how disfavoured exactly?
• The Case for Dark Radiation
• Maximum Likelihood algorithm for parametric component separation in CMB experiments
• Observational bounds on the cosmic radiation density
• Are priors responsible for cosmology favoring additional neutrino species?

Cited by in corpus (39)

• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Cosmological parameters from three seasons of data
• The Phenomenology of Right Handed Neutrinos
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Dark Radiation constraints on minicharged particles in models with a hidden photon
• Updated constraints on non-standard neutrino interactions from Planck
• Converting non-relativistic dark matter to radiation
• Dark Radiation and Dark Matter in Large Volume Compactifications
• Thermalisation of light sterile neutrinos in the early universe
• Dark matter-neutrino interactions through the lens of their cosmological implications
• Asymmetric Dark Matter and Dark Radiation
• Increasing Neff with particles in thermal equilibrium with neutrinos
• Resolving the Hubble tension with Early Dark Energy
• Testing 3+1 and 3+2 neutrino mass models with cosmology and short baseline experiments
• Right-Handed Neutrinos as the Dark Radiation: Status and Forecasts for the LHC
• Vanishing effective mass of the neutrinoless double beta decay including light sterile neutrinos
• Dark Radiation and interacting scenarios
• Dark Radiation candidates after Planck
• Probing dark radiation with inflationary gravitational waves
• Planck intermediate results. XVI. Profile likelihoods for cosmological parameters
• Neutrino and Dark Radiation properties in light of latest CMB observations
• Light Sterile Neutrinos and Short Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies
• Light Higgsino from Axion Dark Radiation
• What is half a neutrino? Reviewing cosmological constraints on neutrinos and dark radiation
• Dark Radiation in extended cosmological scenarios
• Origin of Delta N_eff as a Result of an Interaction between Dark Radiation and Dark Matter
• Testing standard and non-standard neutrino physics with cosmological data
• Constraints on Neutrino Mass and Light Degrees of Freedom in Extended Cosmological Parameter Spaces
• LHC Phenomenology and Cosmology of String-Inspired Intersecting D-Brane Models
• Profile Likelihoods in Cosmology: When, Why and How illustrated with $\Lambda$CDM, Massive Neutrinos and Dark Energy
• Dark energy from dark radiation in strongly coupled cosmologies with no fine tuning
• Day-Night Asymmetries in Active-Sterile Solar Neutrino Oscillations
• Weinberg's Higgs portal confronting recent LUX and LHC results together with upper limits on B^+ and K^+ decay into invisibles
• CP-violating Phases in Active-Sterile Solar Neutrino Oscillations
• Fast and effortless computation of profile likelihoods using CONNECT
• Cosmological data and indications for new physics
• Extra relativistic degrees of freedom without extra particles using Planck data
• Comparison of results on $N_{\mathrm{eff}}$ from various Planck likelihoods
• Determination of Hubble constant from Megamaser Cosmology Project using Profile Likelihood
• Neutrino oscillations in the presence of super-light sterile neutrinos