Bayesian analysis of multiple direct detection experiments
arXiv:1310.5718
Abstract
Bayesian methods offer a coherent and efficient framework for implementing uncertainties into induction problems. In this article, we review how this approach applies to the analysis of dark matter direct detection experiments. In particular we discuss the exclusion limit of XENON100 and the debated hints of detection under the hypothesis of a WIMP signal. Within parameter inference, marginalizing consistently over uncertainties to extract robust posterior probability distributions, we find that the claimed tension between XENON100 and the other experiments can be partially alleviated in isospin violating scenario, while elastic scattering model appears to be compatible with the frequentist statistical approach. We then move to model comparison, for which Bayesian methods are particularly well suited. Firstly, we investigate the annual modulation seen in CoGeNT data, finding that there is weak evidence for a modulation. Modulation models due to other physics compare unfavorably with the WIMP models, paying the price for their excessive complexity. Secondly, we confront several coherent scattering models to determine the current best physical scenario compatible with the experimental hints. We find that exothermic and inelastic dark matter are moderatly disfavored against the elastic scenario, while the isospin violating model has a similar evidence. Lastly the Bayes' factor gives inconclusive evidence for an incompatibility between the data sets of XENON100 and the hints of detection. The same question assessed with goodness of fit would indicate a 2 sigma discrepancy. This suggests that more data are therefore needed to settle this question.
arXiv comment29 pages, 8 figures; invited review for the special issue of the journal Physics of the Dark Universe; matches the published version
References in corpus (94)
- Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
- Particle Dark Matter: Evidence, Candidates and Constraints
- Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
- Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
- First results from the LUX dark matter experiment at the Sanford Underground Research Facility
- Dark Matter Results from 225 Live Days of XENON100 Data
- Inelastic Dark Matter
- Results from the Final Exposure of the CDMS II Experiment
- Results from a Search for Light-Mass Dark Matter with a P-type Point Contact Germanium Detector
- Results from 730 kg days of the CRESST-II Dark Matter Search
- Statistics: Handle with Care, Detecting Multiple Model Components with the Likelihood Ratio Test
- Final model independent result of DAMA/LIBRA-phase1
- Search for an Annual Modulation in a P-type Point Contact Germanium Dark Matter Detector
- A search for light dark matter in XENON10 data
- Results from a Low-Energy Analysis of the CDMS II Germanium Data
- Compatibility of DAMA/LIBRA dark matter detection with other searches
- Applications of Bayesian model selection to cosmological parameters
- First dark matter search results from a 4-kg CFI bubble chamber operated in a deep underground site
- Search for dark matter annihilations in the Sun with the 79-string IceCube detector
- CDMSlite: A Search for Low-Mass WIMPs using Voltage-Assisted Calorimetric Ionization Detection in the SuperCDMS Experiment
- Final Analysis and Results of the Phase II SIMPLE Dark Matter Search
- Limits on spin-dependent WIMP-nucleon cross sections from 225 live days of XENON100 data
- Constraints on Low-Mass WIMP Interactions on 19F from PICASSO
- Dark Matter Direct Detection with Non-Maxwellian Velocity Structure
- Limits on spin-dependent WIMP-nucleon cross-sections from the XENON10 experiment
- The impact of priors and observables on parameter inferences in the Constrained MSSM
- Millicharged Atomic Dark Matter
- The Astrophysical Uncertainties Of Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
- Updated CMB constraints on Dark Matter annihilation cross-sections
- New Limits on Interactions between Weakly Interacting Massive Particles and Nucleons Obtained with CsI(Tl) Crystal Detectors
- Dark Matter Evidence, Particle Physics Candidates and Detection Methods
- Integrating Out Astrophysical Uncertainties
- Compatibility of DAMA Dark Matter Detection with Other Searches
- Magnetic Inelastic Dark Matter
- WIMP-nucleon cross-section results from the second science run of ZEPLIN-III
- Implications of CoGeNT and DAMA for Light WIMP Dark Matter
- Model Independent Form Factors for Spin Independent Neutralino-Nucleon Scattering from Elastic Electron Scattering Data
- Direct dark matter detection: the next decade
- Observations of annual modulation in direct detection of relic particles and light neutralinos
- Anapole Dark Matter
- A light scalar WIMP through the Higgs portal and CoGeNT
- Likelihood Approach to the First Dark Matter Results from XENON100
- Extending the DAMA annual-modulation region by inclusion of the uncertainties in the astrophysical velocities
- The Dark Matter at the End of the Galaxy
- A search for low-mass WIMPs with EDELWEISS-II heat-and-ionization detectors
- The unbearable lightness of being: CDMS versus XENON
- SKYNET: an efficient and robust neural network training tool for machine learning in astronomy
- XENON10/100 dark matter constraints in comparison with CoGeNT and DAMA: examining the Leff dependence
- Long-Range Forces in Direct Dark Matter Searches
- Complementarity of Dark Matter Direct Detection Targets
- Bayesian Selection of sign(mu) within mSUGRA in Global Fits Including WMAP5 Results
- Toward A Consistent Picture For CRESST, CoGeNT and DAMA
- Effect of halo modelling on WIMP exclusion limits
- Halo independent comparison of direct dark matter detection data
- Velocity distributions and annual-modulation signatures of weakly-interacting massive particles
- Quenching and Channeling of Nuclear Recoils in NaI[Tl]: Implications for Dark Matter Searches
- On the DAMA and CoGeNT Modulations
- Light Magnetic Dark Matter in Direct Detection Searches
- Astrophysics independent bounds on the annual modulation of dark matter signals
- Bayesian Calibrated Significance Levels Applied to the Spectral Tilt and Hemispherical Asymmetry
- Response of the XENON100 Dark Matter Detector to Nuclear Recoils
- Halo-independent methods for inelastic dark matter scattering
- Can CoGeNT and DAMA Modulations Be Due to Dark Matter?
- Impact of Dark Matter Microhalos on Signatures for Direct and Indirect Detection
- Determining the WIMP mass using direct detection experiments
- Xenophobic Dark Matter
- Extending the CRESST-II commissioning run limits to lower masses
- The impact of going beyond the Maxwell distribution in direct dark matter detection rates
- Identification of Dark Matter particles with LHC and direct detection data
- A Bayesian view of the current status of dark matter direct searches
- Quantifying Astrophysical Uncertainties on Dark Matter Direct Detection Results
- Search for annual modulation in low-energy CDMS-II data
- Fundamental statistical limitations of future dark matter direct detection experiments
- Connecting Direct Dark Matter Detection Experiments to Cosmologically Motivated Halo Models
- How well will ton-scale dark matter direct detection experiments constrain minimal supersymmetry?
- Taming astrophysical bias in direct dark matter searches
- Maximum Likelihood Signal Extraction Method Applied to 3.4 years of CoGeNT Data
- Improved determination of the WIMP mass from direct detection data
- A Search for the Dark Matter Annual Modulation in South Pole Ice
- Measurement of the Scintillation Yield of Low-Energy Electrons in Liquid Xenon
- Complementarity of direct and indirect Dark Matter detection experiments
- Nuclear uncertainties in the spin-dependent structure functions for direct dark matter detection
- Particle Physics Implications and Constraints on Dark Matter Interpretations of the CDMS Signal
- Direct detection experiments explained with mirror dark matter
- Using Effective Operators to Understand CoGeNT and CDMS-Silicon
- A comparison between the low-energy spectra from CoGeNT and CDMS
- A Tight Connection Between Direct and Indirect Detection of Dark Matter through Higgs Portal Couplings to a Hidden Sector
- Constraining Sommerfeld Enhanced Annihilation Cross-sections of Dark Matter via Direct Searches
- An optimistic CoGeNT analysis
- Evidence for dark matter modulation in CoGeNT?
- Chasing a consistent picture for dark matter direct searches
- Lowering the Threshold in the DAMA Dark Matter Search
- Integrating In Dark Matter Astrophysics at Direct Detection Experiments
- A New Method for Analysing Dark Matter Direct Detection Data