A Comparative Study Between Eruptive X-class Flares Associated with Coronal Mass Ejections and Confined X-class Flares
arXiv:0808.2976 · doi:10.1086/519765
Abstract
We examine the two kinds of major energetic phenomena that occur in the solar atmosphere: eruptive and confined events. The former describes flares with associated coronal mass ejections (CMEs), while the latter denotes flares without associated CMEs. We find that about 90% of X-class flares are eruptive, but the remaining 10% are confined. To probe why the largest energy releases could be either eruptive or confined, we investigate four X-class events from each of the two types. Both sets of events are selected to have very similar intensities (X1.0 to X3.6) and duration (rise time under 13 minutes and decay time not over 9 minutes) in soft X-ray observations, to reduce any bias due to flare size on CME occurrence. We find that the occurrence of eruption (or confinement) is sensitive to the displacement of the location of the energy release, defined as the distance between the flare site and the flux-weighted magnetic center of the source active region. The displacement is 6 - 17 Mm for confined events but as large as 22 - 37 Mm for eruptive events. This means that confined events occur closer to the magnetic center, while the eruptive events tend to occur close to the edge of active regions. We use the potential field source-surface model to infer the coronal magnetic field above the source active regions and calculate the flux ratio of low (<1.1 Rs) to high (>1.1 Rs) corona. We find that the confined events have a lower ratio (<5.7) than the eruptive events (>7.1). These results imply that a stronger overlying arcade field may prevent energy releases in the low corona from being eruptive, resulting in flares, but without CMEs.
References in corpus (3)
Cited by in corpus (92)
- An Observational Overview of Solar Flares
- Driving major solar flares and eruptions: a review
- Why Is the Great Solar Active Region 12192 Flare-Rich But CME-Poor?
- Magnetic Properties of Solar Active Regions that Govern Large Solar Flares and Eruptions
- Electric current in flares ribbons: observations and 3D standard model
- Global Properties of Solar Flares
- From coronal observations to MHD simulations, the building blocks for 3D models of solar flares
- Extreme solar events
- Acceleration and propagation of Solar Energetic Particles
- Microflares and the Statistics of X-ray Flares
- The Confined X-class Flares of Solar Active Region 2192
- Quantitative Analysis of CME Deflections in the Corona
- Origin and Structures of Solar Eruptions I: Magnetic Flux Rope (Invited Review)
- A Comparative Study of Confined and Eruptive Flares in NOAA AR 10720
- Statistical Study of Coronal Mass Ejection Source Locations: Understanding CMEs Viewed in Coronagraphs
- Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections I. Estimating occurrence frequencies and mass-loss rates
- Constraining Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections Through Multi-Wavelength Analysis of the Active M Dwarf EQ Peg
- Hooked flare ribbons and flux-rope related QSL footprints
- Confined Flares in Solar Active Region 12192 from 2014 October 18 to 29
- Helical Kink Instability in a Confined Solar Eruption
- Why is a flare-rich active region CME-poor?
- An Unorthodox X-Class Long-Duration Confined Flare
- Critical Height of the Torus Instability in Two-Ribbon Solar Flares
- Temperature evolution of magnetic flux rope in a failed solar eruption
- The Sun and Space Weather
- On the factors determining the eruptive character of solar flares
- Reconnection fluxes in eruptive and confined flares and implications for superflares on the Sun
- Magnetic helicity and energy budget around large confined and eruptive solar flares
- Fine Structures and Overlying Loops of Confined Solar Flares
- A Quantitative Model of Energy Release and Heating by Time-dependent, Localized Reconnection in a Flare with a Thermal Loop-top X-ray Source
- Coronal Quasi-periodic Fast-mode Propagating Wave Trains
- Magnetic Flux and Magnetic Non-potentiality of Active Regions in Eruptive and Confined Solar Flares
- Statistical study of magnetic non-potential measures in confined and eruptive flares
- Sources of Solar Energetic Particles
- Magnetic Reconnection Rates and Energy Release in a Confined X-class Flare
- A Study of Fast Flareless Coronal Mass Ejections
- A Two-Step Magnetic Reconnection in a Confined X-class Flare in Solar Active Region 12673
- A Statistical Study of Solar Filament Eruptions That Forms High-Speed Coronal Mass Ejections
- Torus-Stable Zone Above Starspots
- Mini-filament Eruptions Triggering Confined Solar Flares Observed by ONSET and SDO
- Failed Eruption of a Filament as a Driver for Vertical Oscillations of Coronal Loops
- A Comparative Study of the Eruptive and Non-Eruptive Flares Produced by the Largest Active Region of Solar Cycle 24
- Continuous Null-Point Magnetic Reconnection Builds Up a Torus Unstable Magnetic Flux Rope Triggering the X9.3 Flare in Solar Active Region~12673
- A comparative study of two X2.2 and X9.3 solar flares observed with HARPS-N: Reconciling Sun-as-a-star spectroscopy and high-spatial resolution solar observations in the context of the solar-stellar connection
- The Association of Solar Flares with Coronal Mass Ejections During the Extended Solar Minimum
- Statistical Properties of Ribbon Evolution and Reconnection Electric Fields in Eruptive and Confined Flares
- Thermodynamic Spectrum of Solar Flares Based on SDO/EVE Observations: Techniques and Statistical Results
- Cosmic Ray Intensity Variation Lags Sunspot number: Implications of Late Opening of Solar Magnetic Field
- A Study of a Compound Solar Eruption with Two Consecutive Erupting Magnetic Structures
- A New Magnetic Parameter of Active Regions Distinguishing Large Eruptive and Confined Solar Flares
- A comparative study between a failed and a successful eruption initiated from the same polarity inversion line in AR 11387
- A Model for Confined Solar Eruptions Including External Reconnection
- Waiting Times of Quasi-homologous Coronal Mass Ejections from Super Active Regions
- EUV and HXR Signatures of Electron Acceleration During the Failed Eruption of a Filament
- Two-stage energy release process of a confined flare with double HXR peaks
- The causes of quasi-homologous CMEs
- Solar Energetic Particle Forecasting Algorithms and Associated False Alarms
- Degree of electric current neutralization and the activity in solar Active Regions
- Three-dimensional Magnetic Reconnection Triggering an X-class Confined Flare in Active Region 12192
- Impulsive energy release and non-thermal emission in a confined M4.0 flare triggered by rapidly evolving magnetic structures
- The Roles of Reconnected Flux and Overlying Fields in CME Speeds
- Energy partition in two M-class circular-ribbon flares
- Does Nearby Open Flux Affect the Eruptivity of Solar Active Regions?
- A reconnection-driven model of the hard X-ray loop-top source from flare 2004-Feb-26
- Mass of prominences experiencing failed eruptions
- Multi-Wavelength Observations of the Spatio-Temporal Evolution of Solar Flares with AIA/SDO: I. Universal Scaling Laws of Space and Time Parameters
- Pseudostreamer influence on flux rope evolution
- Where and how does a decay-index profile become saddle-like?
- Low geo-effectiveness of fast halo CMEs related to the 12 X-class flares in 2002
- Two-step evolution of a rising flux rope resulting in a confined solar flare
- Are complex magnetic field structures responsible for the confined X-class flares in super active region 12192?
- An investigation of flare emissions at multiple wavelengths
- Temporal Offsets between Maximum CME Speed Index and Solar, Geomagnetic, and Interplanetary Indicators during Solar Cycle 23 and the Ascending Phase of Cycle 24
- The Kinematic Evolution of Erupting Structures in Confined Solar Flares
- Global energetics of solar powerful events on 6 September 2017
- H and EUV observations of a partial CME
- A Catalogue of Solar X-ray Plasma Ejections observed by the Soft X-ray Telescope onboard YOHKOH
- A Solar Magnetic-fan Flaring Arch Heated by Non-thermal Particles and Hot Plasma from an X-ray Jet Eruption
- Space weather: the solar perspective -- an update to Schwenn (2006)
- Energy and spectral analysis of confined solar flares from radio and X-ray observations
- Are Decaying Magnetic Fields Above Active Regions Related to Coronal Mass Ejection Onset?
- Energy partition in a confined flare with an extreme-ultraviolet late phase
- Dynamic Property and Magnetic Nonpotentiality of Two Types of Confined Solar Flares
- Homologous compact major blowout-eruption solar flares and their production of broad CMEs
- Confinedness of an X3.1 class solar flare occurred in NOAA 12192: Analysis from multi-instruments observations
- Multi-Viewpoint Observation of a Failed Prominence Eruption on the Sun
- Characterising Solar Magnetic Reconnection in Confined and Eruptive Flares
- Extremely Large EUV Late Phase of Solar Flares
- Investigation of a confined C-class flare in an arch filament system close to a regular sunspot
- The Exceptional Aspects of the Confined X-class Flares of Solar Active Region 2192
- Aditya-L1 and SDO Observations of a Confined X-Class Flare with an EUV Late Phase: Thermal and Nonthermal Emission, Magnetic Topology, and Flux Rope Confinement
- Why could a new-born active region produce coronal mass ejections?