A comparative study of two X2.2 and X9.3 solar flares observed with HARPS-N: Reconciling Sun-as-a-star spectroscopy and high-spatial resolution solar observations in the context of the solar-stellar connection

Abstract

Stellar flares cannot be spatially resolved, which complicates ascertaining the physical processes behind particular spectral signatures. Due to their proximity to Earth, solar flares can serve as a stepping stone for understanding their stellar counterparts, especially when using a Sun-as-a-star instrument and in combination with spatially resolved observations. We aim to understand the disk-integrated spectral behaviors of a confined X2.2 solar flare and its eruptive X9.3 successor as measured by HARPS-N. The behavior of multiple photospheric and chromospheric spectral lines are investigated by means of activity indices and contrast profiles. A number of different photospheric lines were also investigated by means of equivalent widths, and radial velocity measures, which are then related to physical processes directly observed in high-resolution observations made with the Swedish 1-meter Solar Telescope and SDO Our findings suggest a relationship between the evolving shapes of contrast profile time and the flare locations, which assists in constraining flare locations in disk-integrated observations. In addition, an upward bias was found in flare statistics based on activity indices derived from the Ca II H & K lines. In this case, much smaller flares cause a similar increase in the activity index as that produced by larger flares. H$\alpha$-based activity indices do not show this bias and are therefore less susceptible to activity jitter. Sodium line profiles show a strongly asymmetric response during flare activity, which is best captured with a newly defined asymmetrical sodium activity index. A strong flare response was detected in Mn I line profiles, which is unexpected and calls for further exploration. Intensity increases in H$\alpha$, H$\beta$, and certain spectral windows of AIA before the flare onset suggest their potential use as short-term flare predictors.

arXiv commentPublished in A&A; Volume 682, A46 (20 pages, 14 figures) doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202347895

References in corpus (169)

• The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite
• No planet for HD 166435
• The CORALIE survey for southern extra-solar planets VII. Two short-period Saturnian companions to HD108147 and HD168746
• ESPRESSO@VLT -- On-sky performance and first results
• CRISP Spectropolarimetric Imaging of Penumbral Fine Structure
• The LCES HIRES/Keck Precision Radial Velocity Exoplanet Survey
• Non-LTE calculations for neutral Na in late-type stars using improved atomic data
• Using the Sun to estimate Earth-like planets detection capabilities II. Impact of plages
• Planetary detection limits taking into account stellar noise. I. Observational strategies to reduce stellar oscillation and granulation effects
• The formation of the Halpha line in the solar chromosphere
• SOAP 2.0: A tool to estimate the photometric and radial velocity variations induced by stellar spots and plages
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets. X. A m sin i = 11 Mearth planet around the nearby spotted M dwarf GJ 674
• A Unified Computational Model for Solar and Stellar Flares
• Comprehensive Analysis of Coronal Mass Ejection Mass and Energy Properties Over a Full Solar Cycle
• Impact of Space Weather on Climate and Habitability of Terrestrial Type Exoplanets
• CRISPRED: A data pipeline for the CRISP imaging spectropolarimeter
• Can Superflares Occur on Our Sun?
• TW Hydrae: evidence of stellar spots instead of a Hot Jupiter
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics II. The formation of the Mg II h&k lines in the solar atmosphere
• Stellar activity of planetary host star HD 189733
• Long-term magnetic activity of a sample of M-dwarf stars from the HARPS program I. Comparison of activity indices
• ARES v2 - new features and improved performance
• The Solar Twin Planet Search. I. Fundamental parameters of the stellar sample
• Measuring precise radial velocities on individual spectral lines. I. Validation of the method and application to mitigate stellar activity
• A Comparative Study Between Eruptive X-class Flares Associated with Coronal Mass Ejections and Confined X-class Flares
• Sun-as-a-star Observation of White-Light Flares
• Fluxes in Hαand Ca II H and K for a sample of Southern stars
• Suppression of Coronal Mass Ejections in active stars by an overlying large-scale magnetic field: A numerical study
• STiC -- A multi-atom non-LTE PRD inversion code for full-Stokes solar observations
• The Confined X-class Flares of Solar Active Region 2192
• The MUSCLES Treasury Survey. V. FUV Flares on Active and Inactive M Dwarfs
• The Chinese Hα Solar Explorer (CHASE) mission: An overview
• Ellerman Bombs at high resolution: I. Morphological evidence for photospheric reconnection
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. I. 3D NLTE formation of Mn lines in late-type stars
• Probable detection of an eruptive filament from a superflare on a solar-type star
• Implications of mass and energy loss due to coronal mass ejections on magnetically-active stars
• A candidate super-Earth planet orbiting near the snow line of Barnard's star
• Flocculent flows in the chromospheric canopy of a sunspot
• Indications of stellar coronal mass ejections through coronal dimmings
• New Observational Constraints on the Winds of M Dwarf Stars
• The Stellar CME-flare relation: What do historic observations reveal?
• Sun-as-a-Star Spectrum Variations 1974-2006
• Three Years of HARPS-N High-Resolution Spectroscopy and Precise Radial Velocity Data for the Sun
• HARPS-N observes the Sun as a star
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXV. The interesting case of HD41248: stellar activity, no planets?
• A stellar flare-coronal mass ejection event revealed by X-ray plasma motions
• Two planets around Kapteyn's star : a cold and a temperate super-Earth orbiting the nearest halo red-dwarf
• Stellar activity mimics a habitable-zone planet around Kapteyn's star
• The quest for stellar coronal mass ejections in late-type stars: I. Investigating Balmer-line asymmetries of single stars in Virtual Observatory data
• CME-CME Interactions as Sources of CME Geo-effectiveness: The Formation of the Complex Ejecta and Intense Geomagnetic Storm in Early September 2017
• Measuring precise radial velocities on individual spectral lines : II. Dependance of stellar activity signal on line depth
• Statistical Properties of Superflares on Solar-type Stars: Results Using All of the Kepler Primary Mission Data
• DELO-Bezier formal solutions of the polarized radiative transfer equation
• Block-induced complex structures building the flare-productive solar active region 12673
• Halpha line profile asymmetries and the chromospheric flare velocity field
• The Evolution of Flare Activity with Stellar Age
• Soft X-ray Pulsations in Solar Flares
• Solar oxygen abundance
• PEPSI deep spectra. I. The Sun-as-a-star
• HAZMAT. IV. Flares and Superflares on Young M Stars in the Far Ultraviolet
• Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections I. Estimating occurrence frequencies and mass-loss rates
• SSTRED: Data- and metadata-processing pipeline for CHROMIS and CRISP
• HARPS-N Solar Radial-Velocity Variations Are Dominated By Large, Bright Magnetic Regions
• Eruption of a multi-flux-rope system in solar active region 12673 leading to the two largest flares in Solar Cycle 24
• Constraining Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections Through Multi-Wavelength Analysis of the Active M Dwarf EQ Peg
• On fibrils and field lines: The nature of H$\alpha$ fibrils in the solar chromosphere
• Three-dimensional modeling of the Ca II H&K lines in the solar atmosphere
• Discovery of an Extremely Short Duration Flare from Proxima Centauri Using Millimeter through FUV Observations
• YARARA: Significant improvement of RV precision through post-processing of spectral time-series
• Detection and high-resolution spectroscopy of a huge flare on the old M9 dwarf DENIS 104814.7-395606.1
• The quiet solar atmosphere observed and simulated in NaD1
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: a new approach to chemically characterising young open clusters
• Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of the X9.3 Flare on 2017 September 6: Evolving Magnetic Topology
• Variability of stellar granulation and convective blueshift with spectral type and magnetic activity. I. K and G main sequence stars
• Activity-induced radial velocity jitter in a flaring M dwarf
• Probability of CME Impact on Exoplanets Orbiting M Dwarfs and Solar-Like Stars
• How magnetic activity alters what we learn from stellar spectra
• Flares in Open Clusters with K2. I. M45 (Pleiades), M44 (Praesepe) and M67
• RASSINE: Interactive tool for normalising stellar spectra I. Description and performance of the code
• Successive flux rope eruptions from $\delta$-Sunspots region of NOAA 12673 and associated X-class eruptive flares on 2017 September 6
• The effect of flares on total solar irradiance
• The spectral content of SDO/AIA 1600 and 1700 Å filters from flare and plage observations
• High-resolution spectroscopy of flares and CMES on AD Leo*
• On the origin of two X-class flares in active region NOAA 12673 - Shear flows and head-on collision of new and pre-existing flux
• Magnetohydrodynamic Modeling of a Solar Eruption Associated with X9.3 Flare Observed in Active Region 12673
• Coronal response to magnetically-suppressed CME events in M-dwarf stars
• Statistical Analysis of Stellar Flares from the First Three Years of TESS Observations
• Agatha: disentangling periodic signals from correlated noise in a periodogram framework
• A Monster CME Obscuring A Demon Star Flare
• The effect of stellar activity on the spectroscopic stellar parameters of the young solar twin HIP 36515
• Solar cycle indices from the photosphere to the corona: measurements and underlying physics
• Two Super-Earths Orbiting the Solar Analogue HD41248 on the edge of a 7:5 Mean Motion Resonance
• Solar Chromospheric Temperature Diagnostics: a joint ALMA-H$\alpha$ analysis
• The Search for Signatures Of Transient Mass Loss in Active Stars
• On the correlation between Ca and Halpha solar emission and consequences for stellar activity observations
• Rapid buildup of a magnetic flux rope during a confined X2.2 class flare in NOAA AR 12673
• The Chromospheric Telescope
• Sun-as-a-star Analyses of Various Solar Active Events Using H$\alpha$ Spectral Images Taken by SMART/SDDI
• Properties of flares and CMEs on EV Lac: Possible erupting filament
• Three-dimensional modeling of chromospheric spectral lines in a simulated active region
• Horizontal flow fields observed in Hinode G-band images II. Flow fields in the final stages of sunspot decay
• Search for flares and associated CMEs on late-type main-sequence stars in optical SDSS spectra
• Persistent starspot signals on M dwarfs: multi-wavelength Doppler observations with the Habitable-zone Planet Finder and Keck/HIRES
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: A new approach to chemically characterising young open clusters II. Abundances of the neutron-capture elements Cu, Sr, Y, Zr, Ba, La, and Ce
• Spectropolarimetric inversions of the Ca ii 8542 Å line in a M-class solar flare
• Tuning the Exo-Space Weather Radio for Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections
• Observing the Sun as a star: Design and early results from the NEID solar feed
• Giant white-light flares on fully convective stars occur at high latitudes
• Decoding the radial velocity variations of HD41248 with ESPRESSO
• Temporal evolution and correlations of optical activity indicators measured in Sun-as-a-star observations
• Activity and Magnetic Field Structure of the Sun-Like Planet Hosting Star HD 1237
• Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections
• Stellar activity correction using PCA decomposition of shells
• Chi Values for Blue Emission Lines in M Dwarfs
• Stellar signal components seen in HARPS and HARPS-N solar radial velocities
• Simultaneous Kepler/K2 and XMM-Netwon observations of superflares in the Pleiades
• Solar twins and the Barium puzzle
• A Two-Step Magnetic Reconnection in a Confined X-class Flare in Solar Active Region 12673
• Detection Limits of Low-mass, Long-period Exoplanets Using Gaussian Processes Applied to HARPS-N Solar RVs
• Inference of the chromospheric magnetic field configuration of solar plage using the Ca II 8542 Å line
• Stellar energetic particles in the magnetically turbulent habitable zones of TRAPPIST-1-like planetary systems
• Torus-Stable Zone Above Starspots
• Quiet-Sun imaging asymmetries in NaI D1 compared with other strong Fraunhofer lines
• Homologous white light solar flares driven by photosperic shear motions
• Frequency of Coronal Mass Ejection Impacts with Early Terrestrial Planets and Exoplanets Around Active Solar-like Stars
• Characteristic time of stellar flares on Sun-like stars
• Continuous Null-Point Magnetic Reconnection Builds Up a Torus Unstable Magnetic Flux Rope Triggering the X9.3 Flare in Solar Active Region~12673
• Explanation of the activity sensitivity of Mn I 5394.7 Å
• The curious case of HD41248. A pair of static signals buried behind red-noise
• Center-to-limb variation of spectral lines and continua observed with SST/CRISP and SST/CHROMIS
• Non-LTE Calculations of the Fe I 6173 Å Line in a Flaring Atmosphere
• Physical properties of bright Ca II K fibrils in the solar chromosphere
• SOAP-GPU: Efficient Spectral Modelling of Stellar Activity Using Graphical Processing Units
• Non-LTE inversions of a confined X2.2 flare: I. Vector magnetic field in the photosphere and chromosphere
• The GAPS Programme at TNG -- XXV. Stellar atmospheric parameters and chemical composition through GIARPS optical and near-infrared spectra
• A Superflare on YZ Canis Minoris Observed by Seimei Telescope and TESS: Red Asymmetry of H$\alpha$ Emission Associated with White-Light Emission
• Understanding the HMI pseudocontinuum in white-light solar flares
• The spectroscopic binary system Gl 375. I. Orbital parameters and chromospheric activity
• The spectral impact of magnetic activity on disk-integrated HARPS-N solar observations: exploring new activity indicators
• Observations and simulations of the Na I D1 line profiles in an M-class solar flare
• Optimising the H$\alpha$ index for the identification of activity signals in FGK stars. Improvement of the correlation between H$\alpha$ and CaII H&K
• Diagnostic potential of the Ca II 8542A line for solar filaments
• H$\alpha$ and H$\beta$ emission in a C3.3 solar flare: comparison between observations and simulations
• A Helicity-Based Method to Infer the CME Magnetic Field Magnitude in Sun and Geospace: Generalization and Extension to Sun-Like and M-Dwarf Stars and Implications for Exoplanet Habitability
• The New 2018 Version of the Meudon Spectroheliograph
• Improvements in the determination of ISS Ca II K parameters
• The Neupert Effect of Flare UltraViolet and Soft X-ray Emissions
• Solar oxygen abundance using SST/CRISP center-to-limb observations of the O I 7772 Å line
• Flare Kernels May be Smaller than You Think: Modelling the Radiative Response of Chromospheric Plasma Adjacent to a Solar Flare
• An MHD Modeling of Successive X2.2 and X9.3 Solar Flares of 2017 September 6
• Far beyond the Sun: I. The beating magnetic heart in Horologium
• Christian Horrebow's Sunspot Observations -- I. Life and Published Writings
• Flare Induced Photospheric Velocity Diagnostics
• Testing the Spectroscopic Extraction of Suppression of Convective Blueshift
• Spectral diagnostics of cool flare loops observed by SST: I. Inversion of the Ca II 8542 Å and H$\beta$ lines
• Estimating Magnetic Filling Factors From Simultaneous Spectroscopy and Photometry: Disentangling Spots, Plage, and Network
• The Chromospheric Response to the Sunquake generated by the X9.3 Flare of NOAA 12673
• Intrusion of Magnetic Peninsula toward the Neighboring Opposite-polarity Region That Triggers the Largest Solar Flare in Solar Cycle 24
• Statistical Properties of Soft X-ray emission of solar flares
• On the Possibilities of Detecting Helium D${}_3$ Line Polarization with Metis
• Small-scale loops heated to transition region temperatures and their chromospheric signatures in the simulated solar atmosphere
• The Mg I b triplet and the 4571 Å line as diagnostics of stellar chromospheric activity
• The wings of Ca II H and K as photospheric diagnostics and the reliability of one-dimensional photosphere modeling
• Far beyond the Sun: II. Probing the stellar magnetism of the young Sun ι Horologii from the photosphere to its corona
• The SunPy Project: An Interoperable Ecosystem for Solar Data Analysis
• Stellar Energetic Particle Transport in the Turbulent and CME-disrupted Stellar Wind of AU~Microscopii
• Physical properties of a fan-shaped jet backlit by an X9.3 flare
• Background-subtracted Solar Activity Maps
• Formation of H$\epsilon$ in the solar atmosphere

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Spectral variations within solar flare ribbons
• Synthesizing Sun-as-a-star flare spectra from high-resolution solar observations
• The extremely strong non-neutralized electric currents of the unique solar active region NOAA 13664
• Probing Na in giant exoplanets with ESPRESSO and 3D NLTE stellar spectra
• Solar active region evolution and imminent flaring activity through a color-coded visualization of photospheric vector magnetograms
• Discovery of multi-temperature coronal mass ejection signatures from a young solar analogue
• Solar Flux Atlases: The new HARPS-N Quiet Sun Benchmark and Ca II H & K Lines Continuum Normalisation
• Does the solar oxygen abundance change over the solar cycle? An investigation into activity-induced variations of the O I infrared triplet