Solar Chromospheric Temperature Diagnostics: a joint ALMA-H$\alpha$ analysis

Abstract

We present the first high-resolution, simultaneous observations of the solar chromosphere in the optical and millimeter wavelength ranges, obtained with ALMA and the IBIS instrument at the Dunn Solar Telescope. In this paper we concentrate on the comparison between the brightness temperature observed in ALMA Band 3 (3 mm; 100 GHz) and the core width of the H$\alpha$ 656.3 nm line, previously identified as a possible diagnostic of the chromospheric temperature. We find that in the area of plage, network and fibrils covered by our FOV the two diagnostics are well correlated, with similar spatial structures observed in both. The strength of the correlation is remarkable, given that the source function of the mm-radiation obeys local thermodynamic equilibrium, while the H$\alpha$ line has a source function that deviates significantly from the local Planck function. The observed range of ALMA brightness temperatures is sensibly smaller than the temperature range that was previously invoked to explain the observed width variations in H$\alpha$. We employ analysis from forward modeling with the RH code to argue that the strong correlation between H$\alpha$ width and ALMA brightness temperature is caused by their shared dependence on the population number $n_2$ of the first excited level of hydrogen. This population number drives millimeter opacity through hydrogen ionization via the Balmer continuum, and H$\alpha$ width through a curve-of-growth-like opacity effect. Ultimately, the $n_2$ population is regulated by the enhancement or lack of downward Ly$\alpha$ flux, which coherently shifts the formation height of both diagnostics to regions with different temperature, respectively.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (21)

• The Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph (IRIS)
• The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array
• The stellar atmosphere simulation code Bifrost
• The formation of the Halpha line in the solar chromosphere
• Dynamic Hydrogen Ionization
• A publicly available simulation of an enhanced network region of the Sun
• An Open Source, Massively Parallel Code for Non-LTE Synthesis and Inversion of Spectral Lines and Zeeman-induced Stokes Profiles
• STiC -- A multi-atom non-LTE PRD inversion code for full-Stokes solar observations
• Solar science with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array - A new view of our Sun
• ROSA: a high cadence, synchronized multi-camera solar imaging system
• Observing the Sun with the Atacama Large Millimeter-submillimeter Array (ALMA): Fast-Scan Single-Dish Mapping
• The solar chromosphere at high resolution with IBIS. IV. Dual-line evidence of heating in chromospheric network
• Three-dimensional non-LTE radiative transfer computation of the Ca 8542 infrared line from a radiation-MHD simulation
• Spectropolarimetric NLTE inversion code SNAPI
• Millimeter radiation from a 3D model of the solar atmosphere I. Diagnosing chromospheric thermal structure
• A First Comparison of Millimeter Continuum and Mg II Ultraviolet Line Emission from the Solar Chromosphere
• First analysis of solar structures in 1.21 mm full-disc ALMA image of the Sun
• H-alpha features with hot onsets III. Fibrils in Lyman-alpha and with ALMA
• Chromospheric backradiation in ultraviolet continua and Halpha
• First high-resolution look at the quiet Sun with ALMA at 3 mm
• ALMA Observations of the Solar Chromosphere on the Polar Limb

Cited by in corpus (35)

• Waves in the lower solar atmosphere: the dawn of next-generation solar telescopes
• The Sun at millimeter wavelengths I. Introduction to ALMA Band 3 observations
• Sunrise III: Overview of Observatory and Instruments
• Observations of solar chromospheric oscillations at 3 mm with ALMA
• A comparative study of two X2.2 and X9.3 solar flares observed with HARPS-N: Reconciling Sun-as-a-star spectroscopy and high-spatial resolution solar observations in the context of the solar-stellar connection
• Physical properties of bright Ca II K fibrils in the solar chromosphere
• The Formation Height of Millimeter-wavelength Emission in the Solar Chromosphere
• Transient brightenings in the quiet Sun detected by ALMA at 3 mm
• High-frequency wave power observed in the solar chromosphere with IBIS and ALMA
• An overall view of temperature oscillations in the solar chromosphere with ALMA
• ALMA observations of transient heating in a solar active region
• Understanding Sun-as-a-star variability of solar Balmer lines
• ALMA observations of the variability of the quiet Sun at millimeter wavelengths
• Spectral variations within solar flare ribbons
• The Sun at millimeter wavelengths. III. Impact of the spatial resolution on solar ALMA observations
• A study of sunspot 3 minute oscillations using ALMA and GST
• A first look at the submillimeter Sun with ALMA
• IBIS-A: The IBIS data Archive. High resolution observations of the solar photosphere and chromosphere with contextual data
• Evaluating Non-LTE Spectral Inversions with ALMA and IBIS
• Physical properties of a fan-shaped jet backlit by an X9.3 flare
• Constraining the systematics of (acoustic) wave heating estimates in the solar chromosphere
• Propagation of transverse waves in the solar chromosphere probed at different heights with ALMA sub-bands
• Unveiling the True Nature of Plasma Dynamics from the Reference Frame of a Super-penumbral Fibril
• Temperature inversion in a gravitationally bound plasma: Case of the solar corona
• Flares detected in ALMA single-dish images of the Sun
• Temperature inversion in a confined plasma atmosphere: coarse-grained effect of temperature fluctuations at its base
• Temperature diagnostics of chromospheric fibrils
• Temperature and density profiles in the corona of main-sequence stars induced by stochastic heating in the chromosphere
• The Sun at millimeter wavelengths IV. Magnetohydrodynamic waves in small-scale bright features
• Comparison of chromospheric diagnostics in a 3D model atmosphere: H$\alpha$ linewidth and mm continua
• Active region upflows in various coronal structures and their coupling to the lower atmosphere
• EMISSA: Exploring millimetre indicators of solar-stellar activity III. Comparison of Ca II indices and millimetre continua in a 3D model atmosphere
• The Solar ALMA Science Archive (SALSA)
• The Sun at millimeter wavelengths V. Magnetohydrodynamic waves in a fibrillar structure
• A publicly available multi-observatory data set of an enhanced network patch from the Photosphere to Corona