The Dynamics of Crowd Disasters: An Empirical Study
arXiv:physics/0701203 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.75.046109
Abstract
Many observations in the dynamics of pedestrian crowds, including various self-organization phenomena, have been successfully described by simple many-particle models. For ethical reasons, however, there is a serious lack of experimental data regarding crowd panic. Therefore, we have analyzed video recordings of the crowd disaster in Mina/Makkah during the Hajj in 1426H on January 12, 2006. They reveal two subsequent, sudden transitions from laminar to stop-and-go and ``turbulent'' flows, which question many previous simulation models. While the transition from laminar to stop-and-go flows supports a recent model of bottleneck flows [D. Helbing et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 168001 (2006)], the subsequent transition to turbulent flow is not yet well understood. It is responsible for sudden eruptions of pressure release comparable to earthquakes, which cause sudden displacements and the falling and trampling of people. The insights of this study into the reasons for critical crowd conditions are important for the organization of safer mass events. In particularly, they allow one to understand where and when crowd accidents tend to occur. They have also led to organizational changes, which have ensured a safe Hajj in 1427H.
References in corpus (15)
- Social Force Model for Pedestrian Dynamics
- Simulating Dynamical Features of Escape Panic
- Traffic and Related Self-Driven Many-Particle Systems
- Simulation of pedestrian dynamics using a 2-dimensional cellular automaton
- Jamming, Force Chains and Fragile Matter
- Unified Scaling Law for Earthquakes
- Friction effects and clogging in a cellular automaton model for pedestrian dynamics
- The Fundamental Diagram of Pedestrian Movement Revisited
- Experimental study of pedestrian flow through a bottleneck
- Many-particle simulation of the evacuation process from a room without visibility
- Turbulent-like fluctuations in quasistatic flow of granular media
- Experimental study of pedestrian counterflow in a corridor
- Analytical Approach to Continuous and Intermittent Bottleneck Flows
- Density waves of granular flow in a pipe using lattice gas automata
- Analytical investigation of oscillations in intersecting flows of pedestrian and vehicle traffic
Cited by in corpus (106)
- Statistical physics of social dynamics
- How simple rules determine pedestrian behavior and crowd disasters
- The walking behaviour of pedestrian social groups and its impact on crowd dynamics
- Human Mobility: Models and Applications
- Saving Human Lives: What Complexity Science and Information Systems can Contribute
- Transitions in pedestrian fundamental diagrams of straight corridors and T-junctions
- Active Jamming: Self-propelled soft particles at high density
- Universal power law governing pedestrian interactions
- Crowd Behaviour during High-Stress Evacuations in an Immersive Virtual Environment
- Collective Motion of Moshers at Heavy Metal Concerts
- Traffic Instabilities in Self-Organized Pedestrian Crowds
- Modeling Crowd Turbulence by Many-Particle Simulations
- Properties of pedestrians walking in line - Fundamental diagrams
- Time-evolving measures and macroscopic modeling of pedestrian flow
- Crowd Behavior Analysis: A Review where Physics meets Biology
- Mesoscopic Turbulence and Local Order in Janus Particles Self-Propelling under an AC Electric Field
- Pedestrian flows in bounded domains with obstacles
- Challenges in Complex Systems Science
- Properties of pedestrians walking in line: Stepping behavior
- Dynamic Stride Length Adaptation According to Utility And Personal Space
- Constant net-time headway as key mechanism behind pedestrian flow dynamics
- Gradient Navigation Model for Pedestrian Dynamics
- Non-local first-order modelling of crowd dynamics: a multidimensional framework with applications
- Empirical characteristics of different types of pedestrian streams
- Social Force Model parameter testing and optimization using a high stress real-life situation
- Modeling rationality to control self-organization of crowds: An environmental approach
- Mechanical response of dense pedestrian crowds to the crossing of intruders
- Emergent Structural Mechanisms for High-Density Collective Motion Inspired by Human Crowds
- Fluctuations around mean walking behaviours in diluted pedestrian flows
- Simulation of counter flow pedestrian dynamics in hallways using spheropolygons
- Investigation of Pedestrian Dynamics in Circle Antipode Experiments
- Collective dynamics of pedestrians interacting with attractions
- Pedestrian Models based on Rational Behaviour
- Experimental study of pedestrian flow through a T-junction
- Estimation of crowd density applying wavelet transform and machine learning
- Evacuation time estimate for a total pedestrian evacuation using queuing network model and volunteered geographic information
- Pattern Formation, Social Forces, and Diffusion Instability in Games with Success-Driven Motion
- Experimental study on the elderly pedestrians passing through bottlenecks
- Crowd dynamics - being stuck
- Inside a Life-Threatening Crowd: Analysis of the Love Parade Disaster from the Perspective of Eyewitnesses
- Analysis of emergent patterns in crossing flows of pedestrians reveals an invariant of `stripe' formation in human data
- Sparse game changers restore collective motion in panicked human crowds
- A generalized residual technique for analyzing complex movement models using earth mover's distance
- Phase transitions in crowd dynamics of resource allocation
- How crowd accidents are reported in the news media: Lexical and sentiment analysis
- Pedestrians in static crowds are not grains, but game players
- Forward propagation of a push through a row of people
- Body and mind: Decoding the dynamics of pedestrians and the effect of smartphone distraction by coupling mechanical and decisional processes
- An all-densities pedestrian simulator based on a dynamic evaluation of the interpersonal distances
- On the emergence of an "intention field" for socially cohesive agents
- Jamming transitions induced by an attraction in pedestrian flow
- Inflow process of pedestrians to a confined space
- Kernel Estimates as General Concept for the Measuring of Pedestrian Density
- A continuum model for nematic alignment of self-propelled particles
- Generic modes of consensus formation in stochastic language dynamics
- A Simple and Realistic Pedestrian Model for Crowd Simulation and Application
- Walkers on the circle
- Position-Based Multi-Agent Dynamics for Real-Time Crowd Simulation (MiG paper)
- The effect of obstacles near a silo outlet on the discharge of soft spheres
- Influence of Pre-bottleneck Diversion Devices on Pedestrian Flow
- Membranes for spontaneous separation of pedestrian counter flows
- Microscopic dynamics of escaping groups through an exit and a corridor
- Exploring crowd persistent dynamism from pedestrian crossing perspective: An empirical study
- Nonreciprocal interactions in crowd dynamics: investigating the impact of moving threats on pedestrian speed preferences
- A Comprehensive Study on Pedestrians' Evacuation
- Experimental studies of pedestrian flows under different boundary conditions
- Conservation laws in the modeling of moving crowds
- A dynamic state-based model of crowds
- Can high-density human collective motion be forecasted by spatiotemporal fluctuations?
- From Crowd Dynamics to Crowd Safety: A Video-Based Analysis
- A kinetic theory approach for 2D crowd dynamics with emotional contagion
- First Order Models of Human Crowds with Behavioral-Social Dynamics
- Continuous agent-based modeling of adult-child pairs based on a pseudo-energy: Relevance for public safety and egress efficiency
- An early warning method for crush
- Eulerian vs. Lagrangian analyses of pedestrian dynamics asymmetries in a staircase landing
- A comparative study on the bottleneck flow between preschool children and adults under different movement motivations
- Norm breaking in a queue -- athermal phase transition
- Two dimensional outflows for cellular automata with shuffle updates
- Bicycle flow dynamics on wide roads: Experiment and modeling
- Quaternions in collective dynamics
- Crowd Congestion and Stampede Management through Multi Robotic Agents
- Existence and uniqueness of measure solutions for a system of continuity equations with non-local flow
- Eliminating Bias in Pedestrian Density Estimation: A Voronoi Cell Perspective
- Understanding Crowd Flow Movements Using Active-Langevin Model
- Sequential evacuation strategy for multiple rooms toward the same means of egress
- Deterministic particle approximation of the Hughes model in one space dimension
- Dynamics of Panic Pedestrians in Evacuation
- The Impact of Position Errors on Crowd Simulation
- Ordering leads to multiple fast tracks in simulated collective escape of human crowds
- Discrepancies in Pedestrian Crossing of Static vs. Dynamic Crowds: An Experimental Study
- Impact of Impulse Stops on Pedestrian Flow
- Gender-specific behavior change following terror attacks
- Go left or right? Explore the side preference behavior with circle antipode experiments
- Continuum dynamics of the intention field under weakly cohesive social interactions
- Patterns of cooperation during collective emergencies in the help-or-escape social dilemma
- A re-examination of the role of friction in the original Social Force Model
- Collective patterns of pedestrians interacting with attractions
- Turbulence and Shock-Waves in Crowd Dynamics
- Target-density formation in swarms with stochastic sensing and dynamics
- Qualitative behaviour and numerical approximation of solutions to conservation laws with non-local point constraints on the flux and modeling of crowd dynamics at the bottlenecks
- Quantification of bottleneck effects for different types of facilities
- A macroscopic pedestrian model with variable maximal density
- From the Micro-scale to Collective Crowd Dynamics
- Improving competitive evacuations with a vestibule structure designed from panel-like obstacles
- Modelling Crowd Dynamics: a Multiscale, Measure-theoretical Approach
- Crowd Behavior Dynamics: Entropic Path-Integral Model