String Theory and the Path to Unification: A Review of Recent Developments

Abstract

This is a pedagogical review article surveying the various approaches towards understanding gauge coupling unification within string theory. As is well known, one of the major problems confronting string phenomenology has been an apparent discrepancy between the scale of gauge coupling unification predicted within string theory, and the unification scale expected within the framework of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). In this article, I provide an overview of the different approaches that have been taken in recent years towards reconciling these two scales, and outline some of the major recent developments in each. These approaches include 1) string GUT models; 2) higher affine levels and non-standard hypercharge normalizations; 3) heavy string threshold corrections; 4) light supersymmetric thresholds; 5) effects from intermediate-scale gauge and matter structure beyond the MSSM; 6) strings without supersymmetry; and 7) strings at strong coupling.

104 pages, LaTeX, 21 figures, 3 tables. Substantially expanded and updated, with new material and references added. Final version to appear in Physics Reports

References in corpus (45)

• Heterotic and Type I String Dynamics from Eleven Dimensions
• Eleven-Dimensional Supergravity on a Manifold with Boundary
• Strong Coupling Expansion Of Calabi-Yau Compactification
• Evidence for Heterotic - Type I String Duality
• Couplings and Scales in Strongly Coupled Heterotic String Theory
• F-Theory at Constant Coupling
• K3 Orientifolds
• Chiral Asymmetry in Four-Dimensional Open-String Vacua
• Strings on Orientifolds
• M-Theory (the Theory Formerly Known as Strings)
• A D=4 N=1 Orbifold of Type I Strings
• Large radii and string unification
• String Duality--A Colloquium
• New Gauge Bosons from String Models
• Comments on Gepner Models and Type I Vacua in String Theory
• Universality properties of N=2 and N=1 Heterotic threshold corrections
• Threshold effects in open-string theory
• Natural gauge-coupling unification at the string scale
• Three Generations in the Fermionic Construction
• Stable Superstring Relics
• Realizing Higher-Level Gauge Symmetries in String Theory: New Embeddings for String GUTs
• String Unification, Higher-Level Gauge Symmetries, and Exotic Hypercharge Normalizations
• Orbifold and Orientifold Compactifications of F-Theory and M-Theory to Six and Four Dimensions
• Solving the Decompactification Problem in String Theory
• An Orientifold from F Theory
• The problems of unification-mismatch and low ${\alpha }_3$: A solution with light vector-like matter
• Three-Family $SO(10)$ Grand Unification in String Theory
• How to Reach the Correct sin^2θ_W and α_S in String Theory
• Asymmetric Orbifolds and Higher Level Models
• Multiple Realisations of N=1 Vacua in Six Dimensions
• Universal moduli-dependent thresholds in Z(2)xZ(2) orbifolds
• F Theory Orientifolds, M Theory Orientifolds, and Twisted Strings
• New Constraints on SO(10) Model-Building from String Theory
• A new scenario for string unification
• Three-Family SU(5) Grand Unification in String Theory
• Recent Results in String Duality
• Leptophobic Z' from Superstring Derived Models
• Supersymmetry: From the Fermi Scale to the Planck Scale
• $SU(5)\times SU(5)$ Unification, Seesaw Mechanism and R-Conservation
• The Fermion Generations Problem in the Gust in the Free World-Sheet Fermion Formulation
• Truly Strong Coupling and Large Radius in String Theory
• New dark matter candidates motivated from superstring derived unification
• Gauge Coupling Unification and the Top Mass in String Models with $SU(4)\times O(4)$ Symmetry
• String Gauge Unification and Infra-red Fixed Points in MSSM+X Models
• Gauge Coupling Constant Unification With Planck Scale Values Of Moduli

Cited by in corpus (202)

• Particle Physics Models of Inflation and the Cosmological Density Perturbation
• Tests of the Gravitational Inverse-Square Law
• Quantum Gravity and Extra Dimensions at High-Energy Colliders
• Extra Spacetime Dimensions and Unification
• Grand Unification at Intermediate Mass Scales through Extra Dimensions
• Light Neutrinos without Heavy Mass Scales: A Higher-Dimensional Seesaw Mechanism
• GUTs and Exceptional Branes in F-theory - II: Experimental Predictions
• Hunting for extra dimensions in the shadow of M87*
• TeV Scale Superstring and Extra Dimensions
• Extreme Gravity Tests with Gravitational Waves from Compact Binary Coalescences: (II) Ringdown
• Searching for realistic 4d string models with a Pati-Salam symmetry -- Orbifold grand unified theories from heterotic string compactification on a Z6 orbifold
• Fermion masses, neutrino oscillations, and proton decay in the light of SuperKamiokande
• Brane World
• Higgs Boson Mass, Sparticle Spectrum and Little Hierarchy Problem in Extended MSSM
• Relic Neutralino Densities and Detection Rates with Nonuniversal Gaugino Masses
• Gauge unification and the supersymmetric light Higgs mass
• Lepton Flavour Violation from SUSY--GUTs: Where do we stand for MEG, PRISM/PRIME and a Super Flavour factory
• Statistics on the Heterotic Landscape: Gauge Groups and Cosmological Constants of Four-Dimensional Heterotic Strings
• Gauge Kinetic Mixing and Leptophobic $Z^{\prime }$ in $E_6$ and SO(10)
• Flipped SU(5) X U(1)_X Models from F-Theory
• Strong/Weak Coupling Duality Relations for Non-Supersymmetric String Theories
• Physics Implications of Flat Directions in Free Fermionic Superstring Models I: Mass Spectrum and Couplings
• Gauge Unification in Supersymmetric Intersecting Brane Worlds
• Fermion masses in SO(10) with a single adjoint Higgs field
• Intermediate Scales, Mu Parameter, and Fermion Masses from String Models
• Unification Picture in Minimal Supersymmetric SU(5) Model with String Remnants
• New Constraints (and Motivations) for Abelian Gauge Bosons in the MeV-TeV Mass Range
• Branes with GUTs and supersymmetry breaking
• A Mechanism for Ordinary-Sterile Neutrino Mixing
• Axions and the Strong CP Problem in M-theory
• Shadow and deflection angle of rotating black hole in asymptotically safe gravity
• Testable Flipped SU(5) x U(1)_X Models
• The Status of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model and Beyond
• Natural R-Parity, μ-term, and Fermion Mass Hierarchy From Discrete Gauge Symmetries
• Magnetized Four-Dimensional $Z_2\times Z_2$ Orientifolds
• Massive quantum systems as interfaces of quantum mechanics and gravity
• On the Stability of the Classical Vacua in a Minimal SU(5) 5-D Supergravity Model
• $B\to X_s{\tau }^{+}{\tau }^{-}$ in the flipped SU(5) model
• Novel Extension of MSSM and ``TeV Scale'' Coupling Unification
• MSSM parameters from supergravity backgrounds
• Exact Standard Model Compactifications from Intersecting Branes
• Neutrinos in Warped Extra Dimensions
• Physics Implications of Flat Directions in Free Fermionic Superstring Models II: Renormalization Group Analysis
• On compatibility of string effective action with an accelerating universe
• Fermion Masses and the UV Cutoff of the Minimal Realistic SU(5)
• Relativistic deformed kinematics from momentum space geometry
• In quest of "just" the Standard Model on D-branes at a singularity
• Gauge Threshold Corrections for Local String Models
• TeV-Scale String Resonances at Hadron Colliders
• Glueball scattering cross section in lattice SU(2) Yang-Mills theory
• Spectra in Standard-like Z_3 Orbifold Models
• Solving the Hierarchy Problem without Supersymmetry or Extra Dimensions: An Alternative Approach
• String instantons, fluxes and moduli stabilization
• Landscape Cartography: A Coarse Survey of Gauge Group Rank and Stabilization of the Proton
• GUT Precursors and Entwined SUSY: The Phenomenology of Stable Non-Supersymmetric Strings
• Type IIB orientifolds on Gepner points
• TeV-scale Supersymmetric Standard Model and Brane World
• $Z^{\prime }$ bosons in supersymmetric $E_6$ models confront electroweak data
• Precision Unification in λSUSY with a 125 GeV Higgs
• Kahler Stabilized, Modular Invariant Heterotic String Models
• Constraints on Hidden Sector Gaugino Condensation
• When black holes collide: Probing the interior composition by the spectrum of ringdown modes and emitted gravitational waves
• Higher Loop Effects on Unification via Kaluza-Klein Thresholds
• Type I Vacua from Diagonal $Z_3$-Orbifolds
• Dark matter scattering cross section and dynamics in dark Yang-Mills theory
• Strings, Branes and Extra Dimensions
• Strong Unification
• A Review of Three-Family Grand Unified String Models
• Precision prediction of gauge couplings and the profile of a string theory
• Phenomenological consequences of a geometry in the cotangent bundle
• Unification predictions
• TeV physics and the Planck scale
• Gauge coupling flux thresholds, exotic matter and the unification scale in F-SU(5) GUT
• The Effects of Running Gravitational Coupling On Rotating Black Holes
• Gauge coupling unification, the GUT scale, and magic fields
• Non-Canonical Gauge Coupling Unification in High-Scale Supersymmetry Breaking
• SU(5) Unified Theories from Intersecting Branes
• String Scale Gauge Coupling Unification with Vector-like Exotics and Non-Canonical U(1)_Y Normalization
• Physical Renormalization Schemes and Grand Unification
• Adjoint Messengers and Perturbative Unification at the String Scale
• Gauge Coupling Unification with Extra Dimensions and Gravitational Scale Effects
• Implications of Canonical Gauge Coupling Unification in High-Scale Supersymmetry Breaking
• Top Quarks as a Window to String Resonances
• Towards Exotic Matter and Discrete Non-Abelian Symmetries in F-theory
• Gauge Coupling Unification without Supersymmetry
• The Internal and External Problems of String Theory - A Philosophical View
• Muon anomalous magnetic moment in supersymmetric scenarios with an intermediate scale and nonuniversality
• Anomaly-Induced Gauge Unification and Brane/Bulk Couplings in Gravity-Localized Theories
• Anti-de Sitter curvature radius constrained by quasars in brane-world scenarios
• Reconciling Grand Unification with Strings by Anisotropic Compactifications
• Extra dimensions in CERN LHC via mini-black holes: effective Kerr-Newman brane-world effects
• The effect of Yukawa couplings on Unification Predictions and the non-perturbative limit
• Geometrizing the Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations in Doubly Special Relativity
• Perturbative SO(10) Grand Unification
• Unification of gauge couplings and the tau neutrino mass in Supergravity without R-parity
• The Standard Model from String Theory: What Have We Learned?
• Gauge Coupling Unification in the Standard Model
• Anisotropic Type I String Compactification, Winding Modes and Large Extra Dimensions
• Modular Invariance, Soft Breaking, $\mu$ and $\tan \beta$ in Superstring Models
• Wilson lines corrections to gauge couplings from a field theory approach
• Flavor ``Conservation'' and Hierarchy in TeV-scale Supersymmetric Standard Model
• On the Possibility of Optical Unification in Heterotic Strings
• Casadio-Fabbri-Mazzacurati Black Strings and Braneworld-induced Quasars Luminosity Corrections
• Constraints on the deformation scale of a geometry in the cotangent bundle
• Minimal string-scale unification of gauge couplings
• Superparticle phenomenology from the natural mini-landscape
• A New Doublet-Triplet Splitting Mechanism for Supersymmetric SO(10) and Implications for Fermion Masses
• Disrupting the one-loop renormalization group invariant M/alpha in supersymmetry
• Curved momentum space, locality, and generalized space-time
• Determining Heavy Mass Parameters in Supersymmetric SO(10) Models
• Twenty-five Questions for String Theorists
• Geometry of multi-particle systems with a relativistic deformed kinematics and the relative locality principle
• A natural scenario for heavy colored and light uncolored superpartners
• Unification Without Doublet-Triplet Splitting
• Phenomenological viability of string and M-theory scenarios
• The $R$-parity Violating Decays of Charginos and Neutralinos in the B-L MSSM
• The $750$ GeV Diphoton Excesses in a Realistic D-brane Model
• Adventures in Thermal Duality (II): Towards a Duality-Covariant String Thermodynamics
• A framework for baryonic R-parity violation in grand unified theories
• The Minimal SUSY $B-L$ Model: Simultaneous Wilson Lines and String Thresholds
• Bouncing Braneworld Cosmologies and Initial Conditions to Inflation
• On the GUT scale of F-Theory SU(5)
• On the brane coupling of Unified orbifolds with gauge interactions in the bulk
• Variation in the luminosity of Kerr quasars due to extra dimension in brane Randall-Sundrum model
• The theoretical significance of G
• What QCD Tells Us About Nature -- and Why We Should Listen
• Special Grand Unification
• Could the variation in quasar luminosity, due to extra dimension 3-brane in RS model, be measurable?
• Renormalization Group and Grand Unification with 331 Models
• Unparticle Physics And Gauge Coupling Unification
• From Prototype SU(5) to Realistic SU(7) SUSY GUT
• Tidal-heating/viscous dissipation correspondence in black holes and viscous compact objects
• Optical Unification
• Scales of String Theory
• Focus Point Gauge Mediation with Incomplete Adjoint Messengers and Gauge Coupling Unification
• Modular Invariant Gaugino Condensation in the Presence of an Anomalous U(1)
• Modification of the mean free path of very high energy photons due to a relativistic deformed kinematics
• On the Running of Gauge Couplings in String Theory
• The effects of running gravitational coupling on three dimensional black holes
• Twin Peaks: A possible signal in the production of resonances beyond special relativity
• Time delays, choice of energy-momentum variables and relative locality in doubly special relativity
• GUTs and String-GUTs
• Yukawa Unification in Heterotic String Theory
• Perturbative unification of gauge couplings in supersymmetric $E_6$ models
• Fermion Masses and Mixings in GUTs with Non-Canonical U(1)_Y
• Line Bundle Hidden Sectors for Strongly Coupled Heterotic Standard Models
• Bayesian naturalness, simplicity, and testability applied to the $B-L$ MSSM GUT
• Radiative processes (tau -> mu gamma, mu -> e gamma and muon g-2) as probes of ESSM/SO(10)
• Minimal anomaly-free chiral fermion sets and gauge coupling unification
• Physics in non-fixed spatial dimensions via random networks
• Space-time thermodynamics in momentum dependent geometries
• Renormalization of the Planck mass for type II superstrings on symmetric orbifolds
• Twisting E8 Five-Branes
• Relativistic deformed kinematics: from flat to curved spacetimes
• Supergravity Resolution of the Unification to Planck Scale Hierarchy
• A new perspective on Doubly Special Relativity
• String-scale Gauge Coupling Relations in the Supersymmetric Pati-Salam Models from Intersecting D6-branes
• Comment on ``Inflation and flat directions in modular invariant superstring effective theories''
• Unification and New Particles at the LHC
• Observable n - anti-n Oscillations with New Physics at LHC
• String unification scale and the hyper-charge Kac-Moody level in the non-supersymmetric standard model
• Natural Gauge and Gravitational Coupling Unification and the Superpartner Masses
• With Neutrino Masses Revealed, Proton Decay is the Missing Link
• Successful Yukawa structures in Warped Extra Dimensions
• Neutrino Masses: Shedding Light on Unification and Our Origin
• Discrete R Symmetries and Anomalies
• Ultra high energy cosmic rays and possible signature of black strings
• Doubly special relativity as a non-local quantum field theory
• The gauge coupling evolutions of an $\mathrm{SU}(8)$ theory with the maximally symmetry breaking pattern
• General Bianchi IX dynamics in bouncing braneworld cosmology: homoclinic chaos and the BKL conjecture
• High Energy Physics and Cosmology at the Unification Frontier: Opportunities and Challenges in the coming years
• Can thermal inflation solve the monopole problem ?
• Phenomenological guide to physics beyond the Standard Model
• Seesaw scales and the steps from the Standard Model towards superstring-inspired flipped E_6
• Options for Orbifold-GUT Model Building from Five-Dimensional Supergravity
• Towards common origin of supersymmetry breaking, compositeness, and gauge mediation
• An Upper Limit on the Initial Temperature of the Radiation-Dominated Universe
• The unification in an $\widehat{\mathfrak{su}}(8{)}_{k_U=1}$ affine Lie algebra
• A Proposal for Altering the Unification Scale in String Theory
• Exploring black hole mechanics in cotangent bundle geometries
• Fermion Mass Hierarchy without Flavour Symmetry
• A Stronger Case for Superunification Post Higgs Boson Discovery
• An [SU(3)]^4 Supersymmetric grand unified model
• Tera Scale Remnants of Unification and Supersymmetry at Planck Scale
• GUT Scale Unification in Heterotic Strings
• Stability of perturbed geodesics in $nD$ axisymmetric spacetimes
• A note on two-loop effects in the DMSSM
• Universal Landau Pole and Physics below the 100 TeV Scale
• Gauge coupling unification with extra Higgs doublets
• String resonances at the Large Hadron Collider
• Gravitational Waves in Braneworld Scenarios with AdS Background
• SUSY/SUGRA/String Phenomenology
• Gauge Unification and Dynamical Supersymmetry Breaking
• The dark dimension, proton decay, and the length of the M-theory interval
• Particle physics and cosmology intertwined
• Effects of underlying topology on quantum state discrimination
• Bottom-up approach to B-parameter in minimal supersymmetric standard model
• Radiative Breaking Scenario for the GUT gauge symmetry
• Unifying gauge couplings at the string scale
• High Scale Physics Connection to LHC Data
• Search for Highly Ionizing Particles with the Pixel Detector at Belle II
• Flipped SU(6) Unification of the $SU(3{)}_c\times SU(3{)}_L\times U(1{)}_X$ Model