Statistical significance of meteorite-asteroid pairs using geocentric parameters

Abstract

Aims. We will test the statistical significance of meteorite-dropping fireballs and NEA clustering using the DN similarity function based on four geocentric quantities (U, theta, phi, and lambda). Methods. We calculated the cumulative similarity found between 46 meteorite falls, 535 potential meteorite-dropping fireballs, 20,516 NEAs maintained by NEODyS-2, along with 34,836 NEAs maintained by NASA/JPL HORIZONS. Statistical significance was estimated by either: (1) Kernel Density Estimation-based method to estimate the sporadic background distribution to draw random samples, or (2) applying a uniform random solar longitude (lambda). Each comparison to the synthetic sporadic population is repeated to estimate the 3-sigma region for which the cumulative similarity distribution is consistent with random association levels. Results. The observed DN cumulative similarity distribution between 46 instrumentally observed meteorite falls, 535 potential meteorite-dropping fireballs, and over 30k NEAs radiants (estimated using 6 different radiant methods) reveals no statistically significant excess of similarity between the populations consistent with streams. Conclusions. Based on nearly 600 fireball observations, there is no statistically significant clustering between meteorite falls and NEAs using geocentric impact parameters. If some meteorites arrive in streams, they make up less than ~0.1% of all falls. Recent asteroid or meteoroid physical processes could still explain features found in meteorites, but this activity is not producing distinguishable orbital streams or pairs.

Accepted for publication in A&A, 11 pages, 4 figures

References in corpus (34)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Kernel density estimation via diffusion
• Debiased orbit and absolute-magnitude distributions for near-Earth objects
• A Global Fireball Observatory
• Modeling the measurement accuracy of pre-atmosphere velocities of meteoroids
• The Maribo CM2 meteorite fall - survival of weak material at high entry speed
• Source regions of carbonaceous meteorites and NEOs
• The Sariçiçek howardite fall in Turkey: Source crater of HED meteorites on Vesta and impact risk of Vestoids
• The impact and recovery of asteroid 2018 LA
• Data on 824 fireballs observed by the digital cameras of the European Fireball Network in 2017-2018. I. Description of the network, data reduction procedures, and the catalog
• Orbital characterization of superbolides observed from space: dynamical association with near-Earth objects, meteoroid streams and identification of hyperbolic meteoroids
• The Dingle Dell meteorite: a Halloween treat from the Main Belt
• The Žďár nad Sázavou meteorite fall: Fireball trajectory, photometry, dynamics, fragmentation, orbit, and meteorite recovery
• Determining fireball fates using the $\alpha$-$\beta$ criterion
• Data on 824 fireballs observed by the digital cameras of the European Fireball Network in 2017-2018. II. Analysis of orbital and physical properties of centimeter-sized meteoroids
• Annama H chondrite - mineralogy, physical properties, cosmic ray exposure, and parent body history
• Trajectory and orbit of the unique carbonaceous meteorite Flensburg
• Atmospheric entry and fragmentation of small asteroid 2024 BX1: Bolide trajectory, orbit, dynamics, light curve, and spectrum
• Tidal disruption of near-Earth asteroids during close encounters with terrestrial planets
• On the Non-uniform Distribution of the Angular Elements of Near-Earth Objects
• The Hamburg Meteorite Fall: Fireball trajectory, orbit and dynamics
• Far from random: dynamical groupings among the NEO population
• Murrili meteorite's fall and recovery from Kati Thanda
• Supercatastrophic disruption of asteroids in the context of SOHO comet, fireball and meteor observations
• Arpu Kuilpu: An H5 from the Outer Main Belt
• Probability of coincidental similarity among the orbits of small bodies - I. Pairing
• The orbital clusters among the near Earth asteroids
• Link between the Potentially Hazardous Asteroid (86039) 1999 NC43 and the Chelyabinsk meteoroid tenuous
• Near Earth stream decoherence revisited: the limits of orbital similarity
• Catastrophic disruption of asteroid 2023 CX1 and implications for planetary defense
• Decameter-sized Earth impactors -- I: Orbital properties
• Statistical Equivalence of Metrics for Meteor Dynamical Association
• Generating realistic synthetic meteoroid orbits
• Identifying parent bodies of meteorites among near-Earth asteroids

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Orbit dissimilarity criteria in meteor showers: a comparative review
• A Near-Earth Object Model Calibrated to Earth Impactors