Orbit dissimilarity criteria in meteor showers: a comparative review

Abstract

In meteor science, the identification of meteor showers is a crucial and complex problem. The most common method is to perform a systematic search of a database of observed orbits using an orbit dissimilarity criterion (D-criterion) and an algorithm. D-criteria compare the result of an orbit dissimilarity function (D-function) and a threshold. These D-functions associate one value to two meteoroids orbits. If this value is lower than the threshold, the meteoroids' orbits are considered similar. Group of meteors are thus formed. However, not all D-criteria have been evaluated, and their high number makes it hard to know which should be prioritised. This paper presents a review of each D-function, the tests they passed, the threshold choice, and the algorithms they are used with. We show what methods are currently used in the search for meteor showers, presenting statistics based on papers justifying the existence of established meteor showers. We review D-functions from eight different papers. We describe how thresholds and clustering algorithms are usually chosen. We also analyse tests that were performed on D-criteria. We discover that most of those criteria were not properly tested, and that some have been criticised for their theoretical background. Thus, we recommend performing a post-search analysis of the groups found, both in a statistical sense (to make sure the groups formed could not have been formed randomly) and an orbital dynamics sense (to check whether the group could indeed come from a singular parent body), to present the findings as potential meteor showers.

References in corpus (8)

• Orbit and dynamic origin of the recently recovered Annama's H5 chondrite
• Identifying meteorite droppers among the population of bright 'sporadic' bolides imaged by the Spanish Meteor Network during the spring of 2022
• Near Earth stream decoherence revisited: the limits of orbital similarity
• Statistical Equivalence of Metrics for Meteor Dynamical Association
• A Proposed Alternative Dynamical History for 2P/Encke which Explains the Taurid Meteoroid Complex
• Towards a definition of a meteor cluster: Detection of meteor clusters from meteor orbit databases
• Characterisation of chaos in meteoroid streams. Application to the Geminids
• Statistical significance of meteorite-asteroid pairs using geocentric parameters