Near Earth stream decoherence revisited: the limits of orbital similarity

Abstract

Context. Orbital similarity measures, such as the D-values, have been extensively used in meteor science to identify meteoroid streams and associate meteorite falls with near-Earth objects (NEOs). However, the chaotic nature of near-Earth space challenges the long-term reliability of these measures for stream identification, and the increasing size of our fireball, meteorite fall, and NEO databases make random associations more common. Despite this, many researchers erroneously continue to use orbital similarity beyond its inherent limits. Aims. We aim to assess the statistical significance of using orbital similarity measures for identifying streams of meteoroids or asteroids and explore the implications of chaotic dynamics on the long-term coherence of these streams. Conclusions. The rapid decoherence of meteoroid streams and the chaotic dynamics of near-Earth orbits suggest that no reported stream or NEO associations of meteorites or fireballs are statistically significant according to orbital discriminates. Many are likely coincidental rather than indicative of a true physical link. However, several statistically significant clusters found within the NEO population are consistent with a tidal disruption formation. This contrast and lack of statistically significant associations amongst the impact datasets is likely due to the fireball databases being 2 orders of magnitude smaller than the NEO database and the higher intrinsic uncertainties of fireball observation derived orbits.

Accepted with revisions into A&A

References in corpus (16)

• A Global Fireball Observatory
• Data on 824 fireballs observed by the digital cameras of the European Fireball Network in 2017-2018. I. Description of the network, data reduction procedures, and the catalog
• Properties and evolution of NEO families created by tidal disruption at Earth
• The Žďár nad Sázavou meteorite fall: Fireball trajectory, photometry, dynamics, fragmentation, orbit, and meteorite recovery
• Determining fireball fates using the $\alpha$-$\beta$ criterion
• Searching for the first Near-Earth Object family
• Data on 824 fireballs observed by the digital cameras of the European Fireball Network in 2017-2018. II. Analysis of orbital and physical properties of centimeter-sized meteoroids
• Tidal disruption of near-Earth asteroids during close encounters with terrestrial planets
• Arpu Kuilpu: An H5 from the Outer Main Belt
• The orbital clusters among the near Earth asteroids
• Where Did They Come From, Where Did They Go. Grazing Fireballs
• Successful Recovery of an Observed Meteorite Fall Using Drones and Machine Learning
• Link between the Potentially Hazardous Asteroid (86039) 1999 NC43 and the Chelyabinsk meteoroid tenuous
• Comparing the dynamics of Jupiter-family Comets and comet-like fireballs
• Identification of a Minimoon Fireball
• Characterisation of chaos and mean-motion resonances in meteoroid streams -- Application to the Draconids and Leonids

Cited by in corpus (5)

• Perihelion history and atmospheric survival as primary drivers of the Earth`s meteorite record
• Decameter-sized Earth impactors -- I: Orbital properties
• Statistical significance of meteorite-asteroid pairs using geocentric parameters
• Orbit dissimilarity criteria in meteor showers: a comparative review
• A Near-Earth Object Model Calibrated to Earth Impactors