Measuring black hole spins with x-ray reflection spectroscopy: A GRMHD outlook
arXiv:2507.02583 · doi:10.1103/4sth-rnwv
Abstract
X-ray reflection spectroscopy has evolved as one of the leading methods to measure black hole spins. However, the question is whether its measurements are subjected to systematic biases, especially considering the possible discrepancy between the spin measurements inferred with this technique and those from gravitational wave observations. In this work, we use general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations of thin accretion disks around spinning black holes for modeling the accretion process, and then we simulate NuSTAR observations to test the capability of modern reflection models in recovering the input spins. For the first time, we model the electron density and ionization profiles from GRMHD-simulated disks. Our study reveals that current reflection models work well only for fast-rotating black holes. We model the corona as the base of the jet and we find that reflection models with lamppost emissivity profiles fail to recover the correct black hole spins. Reflection models with broken power-law emissivity profiles perform better. As we increase the complexity of the simulated models, it is more difficult to recover the correct input spins, pointing toward the need to update our current reflection models with more advanced accretion disks and coronal geometries.
arXiv comment21 pages, 12 figures. v2: refereed version. Supplemental material available at http://link.aps.org/supplemental/10.1103/4sth-rnwv
References in corpus (94)
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- On the Absorption of X-rays in the Interstellar Medium
- GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
- GWTC-2: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
- The Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR) Mission
- GWTC-3: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the Second Part of the Third Observing Run
- The Supernova -- Gamma-Ray Burst Connection
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. V. Physical Origin of the Asymmetric Ring
- Broad-band gamma-ray and X-ray spectra of NGC 4151 and their implications for physical processes and geometry
- Improved Reflection Models of Black-Hole Accretion Disks: Treating the Angular Distribution of X-rays
- An XMM-Newton survey of broad iron lines in Seyfert galaxies
- Going with the flow: can the base of jets subsume the role of compact accretion disk coronae?
- The May 1989 outburst of the Soft X-ray Transient GS 2023+338 (V404 Cyg)
- Taiji Program: Gravitational-Wave Sources
- The Athena++ Adaptive Mesh Refinement Framework: Design and Magnetohydrodynamic Solvers
- First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. V. Testing Astrophysical Models of the Galactic Center Black Hole
- X-ray reflected spectra from accretion disk models. III. A complete grid of ionized reflection calculations
- Single star progenitors of long gamma-ray bursts I: Model grids and redshift dependent GRB rate
- Measuring Black Hole Spin using X-ray Reflection Spectroscopy
- Irradiation of an Accretion Disc by a Jet: General Properties and Implications for Spin Measurements of Black Holes
- On the formation and evolution of black-hole binaries
- On the Dynamical Foundations of Alpha Disks
- The Event Horizon General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic Code Comparison Project
- Black Hole Spin via Continuum Fitting and the Role of Spin in Powering Transient Jets
- Simulations of Magnetized Disks Around Black Holes: Effects of Black Hole Spin, Disk Thickness, and Magnetic Field Geometry
- The Constant Inner-Disk Radius of LMC X-3: A Basis for Measuring Black Hole Spin
- An extended scheme for fitting X-ray data with accretion disk spectra in the strong gravity regime
- Stellar-mass Black Hole Spin Constraints from Disk Reflection and Continuum Modeling
- Direct calculation of the radiative efficiency of an accretion disk around a black hole
- Broad iron K-alpha emission lines as a diagnostic of black hole spin
- MHD simulations of jet acceleration from Keplerian accretion disks: the effects of disk resistivity
- Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
- Towards precision measurements of accreting black holes using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
- Accretion Discs with Strong Toroidal Magnetic Fields
- The Origin of Black Hole Spin in Galactic Low-Mass X-ray Binaries
- Science with the TianQin observatory: Preliminary results on massive black hole binaries
- Measuring Black Hole Spin by the Continuum-Fitting Method: Effect of Deviations from the Novikov-Thorne Disc Model
- On the Origin of Black Hole Spin in High-mass X-Ray Binaries
- On the Thermal Stability of Radiation Dominated Accretion Disks
- The evolution of black-hole mass and angular momentum
- On the determination of the spin and disc truncation of accreting black holes using X-ray reflection
- A public relativistic transfer function model for X-ray reverberation mapping of accreting black holes
- Broadband Multi-wavelength Properties of M87 during the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope Campaign
- Constraining X-ray Binary Jet Models via Reflection
- Understanding Compact Object Formation and Natal Kicks. III. The case of Cygnus X-1
- Formation of Magnetically Truncated Accretion Disks in 3D Radiation-Transport Two-Temperature GRMHD Simulations
- Efficiency of Thin Magnetically-Arrested Disks Around Black Holes
- Insight-HXMT observations of jet-like corona in a black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1820+070
- Analysis of NuSTAR and Suzaku observations of Cyg X-1 in the hard state: evidence for a truncated disc geometry
- Spectral analysis of the XMM-Newton data of GX 339-4 in the low/hard state: disc truncation and reflection
- Exploring The Effects Of Disk Thickness On The Black Hole Reflection Spectrum
- Public Release of RELXILL_NK: A Relativistic Reflection Model for Testing Einstein's Gravity
- Apples and Oranges: Comparing black holes in X-ray binaries and gravitational-wave sources
- Accretion Geometry in the Hard State of the Black-Hole X-Ray Binary MAXI J1820+070
- The evolution of GX 339-4 in the low-hard state as seen by NuSTAR and Swift
- Formation of the black-hole binary M33 X-7 via mass-exchange in a tight massive system
- Puffy accretion disks: sub-Eddington, optically thick, and stable
- Reverberation Reveals the Truncated Disc in the Hard State of GX 339-4
- The Effect of Returning Radiation on Relativistic Reflection
- Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and a thin disk model with finite thickness
- Gravitational Wave Astronomy With TianQin
- Testing General Relativity with NuSTAR data of Galactic Black Holes
- Improved spectral models for relativistic reflection
- Reflection Modeling of the Black Hole Binary 4U~163047: the Disk Density and Returning Radiation
- Disk Emission from Magneto-hydrodynamic Simulations of Spinning Black Holes
- Reflection spectra of thick accretion disks
- Jets, disc-winds and oscillations in general relativistic, magnetically driven flows around black hole
- Systematically Revisiting All NuSTAR Spins of Black Holes in X-Ray Binaries
- Modelling correlated variability in accreting black holes: the effect of high density and variable ionisation on reverberation lags
- GRMHD Simulations and Modeling for Jet Formation and Acceleration Region in AGNs
- Observational properties of puffy disks: radiative GRMHD spectra of mildly sub-Eddington accretion
- Hybrid Comptonization and Electron-Positron Pair Production in the Black-Hole X-Ray Binary MAXI J1820+070
- Implementation of a radial disk ionization profile in the RELXILL_NK model
- Fe K Profiles from Simulations of Accreting Black Holes
- Modeling uncertainties in X-ray reflection spectroscopy measurements II: Impact of the radiation from the plunging region
- Spin and Accretion Rate Dependence of Black Hole X-Ray Spectra
- Black hole Spin Measurement Based on Time-domain VLBI Observations of Infalling Gas Cloud
- Reflection spectra of accretion disks illuminated by disk-like coronae
- Modeling the X-ray Contribution of X-ray Binary Jets
- Phase-resolved spectroscopic analysis of the eclipsing black hole X-ray binary M33 X-7: System properties, accretion, and evolution
- Modeling uncertainties in X-ray reflection spectroscopy measurements I: Impact of higher order disk images
- High-density reflection spectroscopy of black hole X-ray binaries in the hard state
- Testing relativistic reflection models with GRMHD simulations of accreting black holes
- Comprehensive UV and Optical spectral analysis of Cygnus X-1: Stellar and wind parameters, abundances, and evolutionary implications
- X-ray spectra of black hole X-ray binaries with returning radiation
- Towards more accurate synthetic reflection spectra: improving the calculations of returning radiation
- Truncated accretion discs in black hole X-ray binaries: dynamics and variability signatures
- Testing the Keplerian disk hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
- Modeling Multiple X-Ray Reflection in Super-Eddington Winds
- The 2018 outburst of MAXI J1820+070 as seen by Insight-HXMT
- Spectra of Puffy Accretion Discs: the kynbb Fit
- About the accuracy of the relxill/relxill_nk models in view of the next generation of X-ray missions
- Reflection Spectra of Accretion Disks Illuminated by an Off-Axis Corona
- X-ray reflection spectroscopy with improved calculations of the emission angle